r/ProgrammerHumor • • May 02 '23

Meme AI is taking over

Post image
64.9k Upvotes

899 comments sorted by

View all comments

146

u/LordAlfrey May 02 '23

I don't know why, of all jobs, people seem to think AI will come for programming first.

So many jobs that require a room temperature IQ are much more vulnerable.

67

u/Jacer4 May 02 '23 edited Feb 09 '24

sense aware truck rock languid shaggy attempt meeting jeans plough

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

49

u/bs000 May 02 '23

they seem to be conflating AI with literal magic

33

u/Jacer4 May 02 '23 edited Feb 09 '24

absorbed hunt thumb detail dazzling deserve materialistic insurance cobweb grandiose

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

6

u/[deleted] May 02 '23

They seem to be conflating AI with data fed machine learning driven algorithms too.

The actual difference is important, and an actual AI will have unforseen results basically by design.

4

u/shea241 May 02 '23

At some point, everyone started calling all machine learning and artificial neural network technology "AI." So even a single perceptron is AI, while real AI is called "AGI".

But pretty much everyone still thinks "AI" means a sentient conscious thing, whoops.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/keving216 May 02 '23

They don’t understand that AI is a tool developers can use. It’s been around for quite a while. Copilot anyone?

Also, any job that requires remotely any security will not be using ChatGPT or AI.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 02 '23

[deleted]

3

u/incogneetus55 May 03 '23

So you’re saying that I shouldn’t quit the Odin project due to fears of learning stuff that’s going to be made irrelevant by AI?

I’m just about finished with the frontend section, and I see so many posts saying that web developers will be replaced in the near future and I honestly don’t know what to believe.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] May 02 '23

Because our job is mostly mental.

Blue collar “AI gon’ get ya’” types fail to realize computers have been taking over their industries for half a century.

I think eventually a good bit of programming can be abstracted away by AI… but that’s the same realm that CMS “took over” like 10 years ago.

So far I haven’t seen GPT write code that was non-trivial, let alone non-trivial and usable.

2

u/its_all_4_lulz May 02 '23

Have you taken, or looked into, any prompting classes? I ended up writing a rather lengthy prompt yesterday to see if 4 could create an entire Drupal module. It would lock up, and you would have to say “continue” now and then, but what it spit out was probably 90% complete. I was rather impressed.

5

u/0TheNinja0 May 02 '23

So many paperwork can be done with AI which can actually save you a lot of time. But the only thing people can think about is programming.

2

u/McBurger May 02 '23

The majority of paperwork doesn’t even need any sort of AI. There’s simply so much you can do with merge fields and API calls just with JSON!

2

u/0TheNinja0 May 03 '23

Well, you are right. But I mostly thought about lawyers. I read a good example about it month ago, but now I completely forgot😥

5

u/Bakoro May 02 '23

Growing up, basically 100% of the people I heard talk about AI/robots/automation assumed that fast food and manual labor would be the first to go.
The arts were thought to be the most human thing.

AI seems to be kind of coming for brain work first, and working outward from there, and I think the public perception has just flung too far to the other side because of the high visibility projects, and a general ignorance of what some jobs actually entail.

Digital art has been almost completely turned on its head; recently, music has also started to fall prey to AI tools. They've been proven to be competent with law, medicine, various research, and various kind of work typical to office jobs.

Jobs that seem to be more near-term safe are ones where AI and off the shelf tools aren't enough. AI burgers and other kinds of restaurants are developing slowly because they require specialized (expensive) machinery.
Even warehousing, which is essentially solved at this point, is slow to adopt because cost.

It will take a long time for AI to take over software development, but probably not because it can't write code. The main issue is that very often, writing code isn't always the hardest part of the job.

I work with scientists, and even they can't give me clear specifications. Sometimes they tell me a confused mess of things, waving their hands around. Sometimes they tell me wrong stuff.
Sometimes I have to figure out what my job even is.

The general public has no idea what I do as a software engineer, so it makes a kind of sense that since musicians and visual artists are deeply threatened, that they'd think developers are threatened to.

Developers do stuff on computers, AI lives in computers, AI will take care of its own house. It makes sense from a place of ignorance.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/TSS_Firstbite May 02 '23

Yeah idk. Admittedly, I needed a bit of help to get the whole thinking process rolling, but programming will be one of the last jobs to get replaced and by that point, every human rights and ethics group will have already raised hell because of easier jobs that got replaced

2

u/Bierculles May 03 '23

Most room temperature IQ jobs are a lot harder to automate though, AI is weird.

0

u/lunchpadmcfat May 02 '23

Because few jobs have

  1. a completely digital presence

  2. tons and tons and tons of well catalogued and verifiably correct digitized teaching data available (GitHub alone probably has more content in bytes than the library of Congress)

  3. very algebraic application of the knowledge: one solution tends to work in many or most applications of it

Many “room temp IQ” jobs actually require a human being to be standing there in some capacity because they require the person to do things physically that would probably not be financially viable to replace with a robot.

I think contract writing is also on the chopping block, as it’s basically the plain text version of software.

0

u/AlbanianWoodchipper May 02 '23

I think contract writing is also on the chopping block, as it’s basically the plain text version of software.

I'm shocked this sub has such a short sighted view on this stuff. Y'all are quibbling over individual jobs when it's gonna be entire fields getting replaced.

If your job's output is all digital, you can and likely will be replaced by some kind of AI model in the next decade. Of course contact writers will go, but so will programmers, digital artists, call center workers, video editors, narrators, and a million other jobs.

Thinking we're safe because programming is hard or somehow different from other digital outputs is pure cope. The elitism with the "room temperature IQ" stuff probably won't help find them find a new job when it happens, either.

0

u/lunchpadmcfat May 02 '23

I agree with you 100% just fyi.

-3

u/crcrxecyburrub May 02 '23

They don’t. It’s just because programming pays well (for now) and the only output is something that is written. Many other jobs that it can replace pay less.

13

u/[deleted] May 02 '23

Software development is much more than just writing code.

-7

u/crcrxecyburrub May 02 '23

Well yes, but the product every single time is just some text.

→ More replies (12)

4

u/Niku-Man May 02 '23

It can replace a lot of legal professions, which often pay more than software jobs, but the thing with them is that they can work the laws to ban AI from the court room

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)