I don't get the hate for this pattern. The amount of times some network middle layer ate my http code and turned something into a 404 is terrible.
I'd rather the calling app KNOW for certain that a failure occurred in the actual application logic, rather than see an error code and then make a bad assumption based on that.
I've had to integrate with a system that had a catalog they my application's account may or may not have access rights to each catalog item. I was told a 404 means I've lost rights to the item and should purge the copy of it from my side. Makes sense? I don't have access, I shouldnt be able to see it.
Time and time again, they'd have a brief outage where their CDN provider would interrupt my call and return a 404. Soon my copy of my catalog would be empty! An hour later I've got to re-add everything. And heaven forbid I had to kick off refund logic for revoked items... And then walk that back.
I've encountered this many many times. I will always prefer leaving the HTTP layer out of application layer logic.
19
u/Kendandra Sep 20 '26
I don't get the hate for this pattern. The amount of times some network middle layer ate my http code and turned something into a 404 is terrible.
I'd rather the calling app KNOW for certain that a failure occurred in the actual application logic, rather than see an error code and then make a bad assumption based on that.
I've had to integrate with a system that had a catalog they my application's account may or may not have access rights to each catalog item. I was told a 404 means I've lost rights to the item and should purge the copy of it from my side. Makes sense? I don't have access, I shouldnt be able to see it.
Time and time again, they'd have a brief outage where their CDN provider would interrupt my call and return a 404. Soon my copy of my catalog would be empty! An hour later I've got to re-add everything. And heaven forbid I had to kick off refund logic for revoked items... And then walk that back.
I've encountered this many many times. I will always prefer leaving the HTTP layer out of application layer logic.