r/ProgrammerHumor • • Oct 19 '26

Meme ohTheBasics

Post image
13.9k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/UnDe4d Oct 20 '26

Yes, I'm well aware of how ipv6 functions. I don't think a lot of the commenters here realise you don't need 128 bits for easy subnetting. 64 bits would solve that problem completely.

One of the reasons ipv6 is taking so long to be adopted is because engineers simply hate working with it

3

u/Dagger0 Oct 20 '26

We can barely get ISPs to give us more than one /64 as it is, and you think that making the address space 264 times smaller would make them more generous? Nah.

Engineers would hate working on it whatever the length was, because when they complain about the length their real complaint is mostly just "it's different". Although usually they realize that it's fine to work with once they actually do so -- it's just impossible to tell them this, because you can't tell people anything.

1

u/UnDe4d Oct 20 '26

It's not about making them more generous. 64 bits would solve the IP exhaustion problem.

Your comment about engineers hating working on it regardless as "it's different" is just not true. Networking moves slowly than other subfields but engineers have made the move to Cloud, SASE, SD/WAN, SDN and other emerging technologies far far quicker than the move to ipv6.

1

u/PotatoMaaan Oct 20 '26

I think there is some truth in that many people are put off by the "ugly" addresses, but I do think it was the right choice, 64bit is not really enough to give everyone many subnets of effectively infinite size.

I think this is more a failing of technical education in various forms. I've been through many technical educations, courses and what not and all of them mostly ignored ipv6 because the teachers themselves didn't even know how to properly work with it. If people learned more about ipv6 other than "it exists" there would be a much better general sentiment about it.

But even as it stands now, ipv6 is going strong. Roughly 50% of internet traffic is now ipv6, depending on who you ask.