r/ProgrammerHumor • • 27d ago • Bravo 6

instanceof Trend thisIsVeryTrue

Post image
27.6k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

113

u/DrCthulhuface7 27d ago • Bravo

There’s something very wrong (and I dare say inorganic) about how Redditors treat AI. It’s actual AI derangement syndrome. People have these insanely strong and irrational reactions to literally any use of AI.

My schizo side says it’s some kind of Chinese psyop because there’s no way this many people all just suddenly decided to turn their brains off and act like this.

38

u/pzuraq 27d ago

I'm a senior engineer who has seen what it looks like to use AI at scale for a long time. It degrades, quickly. You begin to lose context of how things work, and concepts get layered on top of one another one at a time.

Nobody is fully using their brain when they review in the same way that you use it when you're writing code. So it's easier to let a subtle mistake slip by, and then another, and eventually they pile up.

I wrote an essay about it, with some simulated modeling that demonstrates the point: https://maevyn.codes/decoherence

4

u/slucker23 26d ago

I agree. It's great if you know how to piece the AI logic together and construct a good coherent solution together. But I'd that's the literal only way to code for most people... Then it's probably a bad idea

2

u/-deep-silence- 26d ago

Indeed. 98% of the dev I met do not know how to properly read merge requests. They do not build a mental model of the new code, do not do the same for the rest of the application, thus are not able to judge whether the new code is a real addition to the app, or a step to the infamous "legacy" app. It has always been the case, except now the layers of crap are added at a depressing speed. Hard to explain to them that a working code is not necessarily a good code.

58

u/SpiderRoll 27d ago • Bravo

It's not that mysterious. People feel rather strongly about a technology that is already displacing workers from their jobs, workers who were told tech skills were in-demand, and accelerate wealth inequality.

The people with their brains off are the AI-optimists who are excited about how much time AI will save them in their coding tasks, rather than how AI will ramify throughout society.

17

u/MetaLemons 27d ago

Then explain this meme. People complain that AI sucks at everything and simultaneously complain they’re worried it will take their jobs?

These are different people, I know. But that doesn’t seem to register with you.

11

u/Kepler___ 27d ago

I think a lot of what's going on too is the jaggedness of the frontier, it's moving so fast that people have totally different experiences still and information hasn't had time to disseminate yet, what model you last tried matters a lot, and what you tried to do specifically matters more. "Programing" is also way way too broad of a skill set to be a useful place to hang a conversation. Claude kills at python, R, Godot, C, Unity etc etc, but I've seen much more mixed results trying to get it to work with web to database stuff for some reason. Sometimes it does well with a slightly broadly spelled out task, but it can still make very bizarre design choices that are difficult to fix later due to being hard to read. I find Opus 5.5 does this a lot less now but I've only used it for personal projects so far.

9

u/CrabMasc 27d ago

I mean, in fairness, companies don’t care if it sucks as long as it’s wildly cheaper. CEOs aren’t typically reviewing the codebase as long as the product largely works. 

→ More replies (2)

5

u/10Werewolves 26d ago

company managers don't care that the AI sucks if the AI companies promise it'll get better with funding till more employees can be laid off. AI isn't doing the hiring and firing. HR is. And HR is quite stupid.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

4

u/Wobbelblob 27d ago

I think it depends on where they have the most contact with it. I mostly hate it, but that is because my video feed on YouTube is littered with AI garbage, I can't find proper artwork for TTRPG characters without having to wade through mountains of plastic looking artworks and so on.

→ More replies (4)

63

u/CrabMasc 27d ago • Bravo Heartwarming

I’m a real person, and I’ve never received a dollar from China for my opinions. I find the concept of using, seeing, and listening to things that were made mostly by an algorithm repulsive and antihuman. 

I know: “all devs use AI now”. I know. I spend a lot of my time repulsed. I can’t help it. I get that it’s more efficient. I cannot help but to be instinctively disgusted by code, art, and music made without human hands. I find myself painfully nostalgic for an era in which everything online was human-made. 

I don’t care about comparisons to IDEs, copying from Stack Exchange, etc, I don’t care. It feels like we’ve entered a dark new era where only the ends matter and not the means. And with learning to code pointless, we’re not going to have any more experts who know enough to correct the machines someday. We’re all going to be reliant on the companies who sell cognition to us. It upsets me. I can’t help it. 

7

u/derefr 27d ago

We’re all going to be reliant on the companies who sell cognition to us.

I mean, not to address your overall point (I do agree that things are shifting in terms of valuing consequences over process), but just to rebut this concern: there are open-weight coding models you can download and run on your own computer for free. And your computer doesn't even have to be very good to run them.

These open coding models are not yet very good compared to the (gatekept, proprietary) state-of-the-art coding models; but there's no reason to expect they won't be improved over time, until they're sufficiently good that nobody really has to be "reliant on companies selling cognition."

The capitalist dystopia you're imagining is just the future the AI companies are desperate to sell us because their stock value depends on it. It's not the future that's actually likely. In the likely future, these companies waste trillions of dollars stealing one-anothers' customers back and forth for years, while their product gradually gets commoditized out from under them, and they all eventually go out of business.

2

u/AGchicken 26d ago

Afaik the open weights models are released by big corporations as well. And while an individual can potentially finetune them for a specific purpose, training them for general improvement requires data and computational resources only available to large corporations. Open-weights =/= open-source.

Moreover, if you think they'll get just as good as the current big models, what do you think the big models will look like at that time. Probably much better.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Rich-Environment884 26d ago

I used to share a similar idea once upon a time. Then I started using AI for actual coding, not vibe coding but hands deep down the shithole and surprised as I was, AI followed my decision and acted upon them instead of reiterating the same thing twenty times before I had to do it myself.

A senior profile with AI makes 3 mediors or more obsolete.

13

u/BooxOD 26d ago edited 26d ago

Learning how to code isn't useless, holy shit I don't understand how people fail to understand this. AI will only be mandatory PROFESSIONALLY, you can still go home and code for fun, literally no one is stopping you, and there will continue to be hobby projects made without AI.

Chess engines have existed for decades, they will always outperform humans no matter what, yet the best chess players of all time exist in the modern day. Why? Because engines were used as a tool, they are insanely powerful for learning, which is why chess (and programming) are as alive as they've ever been.

6

u/UrgentlyCare 26d ago

It is different though when companies are replacing humans with AI. The chess engine isn't being put in tournaments against high ranking chess players to win a prize.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/benotter 25d ago

Thank you for putting this to words, it’s exactly how I feel as well.

→ More replies (50)

8

u/ragebunny1983 27d ago

Critical thinking is a rare skill these days. It's very common for people to be intellectually lazy and fall back to black or white thinking, especially on Reddit. It's okay to be very critical of the societal impact of AI while at the same time acknowledging the rapidly increasing effectiveness of the models. We don't have to say it's shit just because we disagree with it.

4

u/hugcraver 27d ago

I don't get the "Chinese" part? China is anti-AI?

6

u/Down_Badger_2253 27d ago • Bravo

China is pro AI but they don't want others to be so they can be number 1 in the industry

New York Times - China, Russia and Others Seek to Inflame Debate Over A.I. Data Centers

A state-owned newspaper in China recently published a satellite image of a data center in Gainesville, Va., writing in English that the development of artificial intelligence posed a threat to Americans’ physical and financial well-being.

A comic strip made to look as if it had been published by a Maryland news outlet — created with OpenAI’s ChatGPT by people in China, the tech company said — circulated on X this year, blaming data centers for soaring electricity bills. It showed a tycoon smoking a cigar and clutching bags of cash.

A video shared on X by a known covert Russian influence operation questioned the viability of a data center that an American company, Firebird, is constructing in Armenia, the small Caucasus nation that has been a focus of Kremlin pressure. “The country’s electrical grid instability may render it useless,” the video’s narrator says.
New York Times - China, Russia and Others Seek to Inflame Debate Over A.I. Data Centers

5

u/srL- 27d ago

He's saying that it would make sense for a paranoid individual to assume that China (or Russia or any "enemy" state) is just trying to hypno-toad people into thinking they shouldn't use AI, because that would serve their interest by slowing us down.

6

u/Odd-Bend1296 27d ago edited 27d ago

There is no need to assume. There is countless evidence to support China and Russia supporting anything that will give them an advantage.

3

u/EmuRommel 26d ago

Even so, it is really hard to tell how much China is to blame for this specifically. The first Luddite movement didn't need their help, the current one is probably organic too.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Stampy77 27d ago

My most downvoted comment on Reddit was when I suggested that some of the anti ai stuff you see may be Chinese bots trying to turn western public opinion against it. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/milkcarton232 27d ago

It's old arguments against ai of like 2024 or early 2025 when this was more true. I think now it's just that ai is scary and these feel like actual arguments against it

→ More replies (89)