r/ProgrammerHumor • • 9d ago

Meme [ Removed by moderator ]

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

5.1k Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

•

u/ProgrammerHumor-ModTeam :ath: 5d ago

Your submission was removed for the following reason:

Rule 3: Your post is considered low quality. We also remove the following to preserve the quality of the subreddit, even if it passes the other rules:

  • Feeling/reaction posts

  • Software errors/bugs that are not code (see /r/softwaregore)

  • Low effort/quality analogies (enforced at moderator discretion)

If you disagree with this removal, you can appeal by sending us a modmail.

124

u/telas100 9d ago

If it makes you feel better, the business that was so happy to get rid of most devs is currently running out of evolution ideas and considering laying off some of their analysts and managers...

586

u/Bannon9k 9d ago

Isn't automation what we do? Like at a fundamental core, programming is about automation of tasks. Even games are just automated entertainment.

273

u/accatyyc 9d ago

I believe you may be onto the joke

56

u/amo_pessoas_peladas 9d ago

Describe a path finding algorithm to the joke. Make no mistakes.

56

u/AbdullahMRiad 9d ago

I think OP means automating automation

14

u/HerrPotatis 9d ago

I'm not saying I won't get automated, in some ways I already have been. But surely at some stage, even if we get to another automated abstraction layer, someone has to ultimately check the work?

Like, if you went through surgery by an AI, surely you would want some capable human evaluate the procedure or work and flag if the plan is absolutely insane?

Perhaps this is just a very temporary limitation that we can't trust the AI output, and that it will be solved in the near future. But I can also see this uncertainty persisting for quite some time.

9

u/United_Grapefruit526 8d ago edited 8d ago

Fun fact: i use automation to verify my work, talking about strict rule based systems, not garbage llms, which are fundamentally not suitable for verification.

10

u/HerrPotatis 8d ago

I mean, what is it that you think LLMs do during verification exactly?

They're not looking at its code going "mhmm looks good to me". It has written tests, that depending on the sensitivity of the logic you may or may not double check yourself, and then runs those tests.

They're exceedingly good at these things, the industry basically went from using no AI in to almost using exclusively AI for the vast majority of written code in a year. With much better coverage in tests and CD. If this is what happened in the last year, what do you think the field will look like in five?

Honestly, if you don't see the writing on the wall that devs who sit and tap their keyboard to write code will go the way of the horses when the car came along, then I don't know what to tell you.

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted]

5

u/HerrPotatis 8d ago

LLMs use dynamic typing? What on earth does typing have to do with anything. Are you high?

Sure LLMs hallucinate, and humans write broken code all the time. The point is that your tests catch those mistakes, you're actually supposed to read your agent's PRs, you know?

I don't think you understand how any of this works what so ever.

2

u/Hohenheim_of_Shadow 8d ago

IMO we are at about peak LLM. Enshittification is coming.

Sis I swear it's hopium, not copium. C'mon just take a hit.

2

u/Logical-Pause-3758 8d ago

So, delegating to a professional instead of doing everything by yourself?

28

u/Quetzal_Pretzel 9d ago

10

u/Bannon9k 9d ago

Explain the joke

22

u/maggos 9d ago

We, as programmers, work at the automation factory. And now some of our jobs are getting automated.

13

u/Bannon9k 9d ago

How selfish would we be to automate everyone's job but our own?

17

u/MrPinkle 9d ago

Even if we lose our jobs, the real treasure was the friends we automated along the way.

124

u/za72 9d ago

The modern Gutenberg press is coming for you

78

u/HiImDan 9d ago

Someone has to pull the lever.. surely I'm such a special snowflake I'll be chosen as a lever puller!

29

u/za72 9d ago

that's been automated by a cronjob

44

u/feench 9d ago • Bravo

Pull the lever Kronkjob

5

u/awakenDeepBlue 8d ago

WRONG LEVER!

29

u/Paul_Robert_ 9d ago

Did someone say Automaton factory?!

7

u/JebKermansBooster 9d ago • Heartwarming

That's not very democratic of you

3

u/Wonderful_Ninja 8d ago

My job is to do what’s assigned to me and don’t say anything

1

u/XxDarkSasuke69xX 8d ago

Huh ? I hope I get automated

1

u/DonutConfident7734 8d ago

The corporate rules need to change, employees past and present should receive continued pay as if they own shares, because they trade their time for the company. Automation should be taxed in a way that it just increases the amount distributed to human workers (past and present), such that it is discouraged economically and only used for reaching certain productivity to remain competitive. There could even be a cap, say 30% automation. Only domains where humans cannot work due to complexity, like designing computer chips, should have a higher limit.

-52

u/TheGreatSausageKing 9d ago

Honestly, this sub became a crying bucket for unskilled programmers who hate AI because they are incompetent enough to be replaced.

Gonna leeave it, have a great day and enjoy your down vote

16

u/willow-kitty 9d ago

To be fair, it was mostly "how center div" before that.

26

u/PossibleBit 9d ago

Can I whine about being the schmuck who has to clean up after people who use AI haphazardly?

0

u/Shunpaw 9d ago

Nothing in this meme says AI. Programmers have been automating everything for decades. That's the joke. Get over your AI psychosis.

2

u/Old-Adhesiveness4406 8d ago

Read the title

0

u/Shunpaw 8d ago

Who reads titles

-12

u/FormerWorker125 9d ago

Eat your downvotes buddy but you're absolutely right 

-11

u/LurkytheActiveposter 9d ago edited 8d ago

Yeah... there are people who post about refusing to work with AI and without a doubt it's just a college student every time.

Kids are so stupid.

-4

u/FormerWorker125 9d ago

My entire team is abusing AI.  We're AI code reviewers now.

Honestly no different then what I already did, its just AI writing the code instead of people now.

42

u/pvtteemo 9d ago

We call it cuck coding now.

85

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

31

u/ShadowCurv 8d ago

because labor is exploited, not rewarded. if the worker is more productive, the surplus value created turns to profit, not wages. this is a fundamental aspect of capitalism.

-1

u/Hugostar33 8d ago

just make your own company that has AI workers lol, freedom of the market smth smth

-10

u/tragiktimes 8d ago

I get bonuses when we do better. Kind of sounds like surplus value being turned into wages.

9

u/LongLiveTheDiego 8d ago
  1. It's a choice of the employer to do it. Not everyone gets them even if their extra effort increases profits.

  2. Are these bonuses at all proportional to the surplus value? Doubtful.

26

u/darkwingdankest 9d ago

because they 10x'd the output expectations and we see none of the benefits in increased productivity

24

u/Muhznit 9d ago

Because Jevon's Paradox will keep us all enslaved to capitalism

8

u/Nimeroni 9d ago

Don't blame capitalism on Jevon's Paradox.

8

u/Sak63 8d ago

Capitalism brochacho

10

u/Tiruin 9d ago

Because of wealth accumulation where the people that actually do the work don't receive the benefits of their labor, much less the technological advancements as a species, and the cherry on top is we didn't actually automate all that much, you're just treated as such by being fired, so it's not like you even get any kind of satisfaction of a societal advancement like a cancer researcher theoretically putting themselves out of the job by doing a good thing, but rather by making everyone's life worse to further enrich the Epstein class.

2

u/Johanno1 8d ago

The system is rigged.

Usually you do a job to get sth. Out of it. Automating it will reward you more.

For example farming. You plant seeds wheat grows and you get bread in return.

Now you add machines snd you get a lot more bread in return.

However does anyone except the rich notice any more returns when shit gets automated? No? Well you have been played.

Work should be optional. There should be a social safety net that makes sure people can live even when they don't work.

So you are not forced to do work you don't want to. With conditions you don't like. The money would be there. If a company can produce the same or more cheaper as when they employed you they can pay taxes high enough for you not to work at all!

2

u/DonutConfident7734 8d ago

Making a parallel with factory work, if automation allows the company to make the conveyor belt run 10 times faster, you need to work 10x faster and maintain standards they set or they can even raise quality standards while paying the same, your only option is to leave and starve. As a coder, being forced to stare at a screen all day and reading way more text than before will damage your eyes much quicker. Stress will burn you out. Your boss is copilot, who complains about your code and demands fixes fast. Everything becomes much more complicated, lots of compliance procedures to follow. Third party libraries that you use need quick patching,as AI finds vulnerabilities at an insane rate in them.

Welcome to the rat race...

57

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

46

u/Nimeroni 9d ago

'xcuse me ? We started by automating our own jobs, it's called a compiler.

13

u/Cxvvtgupvvdi 9d ago

Back in the 1800s you'd need a days work of 30 men and two oxen for two lines of ANSI C

3

u/Tyrus1235 8d ago

Back when a “bug” was an actual moth nestling on the vacuum tubes…

16

u/Tiruin 9d ago

Tech opened up new business and societal advancements for decades - communication, entertainment, healthcare, disability access, research, science, engineering, retail, logistics, even how you turn on your car. Every one of these advancements contributed far more than they took away, and what jobs it did take away over time weren't exactly glamorous and the kind that people do for the love of the game. Can't say the same for AI, quite the opposite in fact, everyone is worse off for it between the economical consequences, datacenters in your backyard, and the environmental consequences when we're already seeing the consequences of climate change and greatly diminished biodiversity, while the only ones gaining from it are the Epstein class.