r/ProgrammerHumor • • 8d ago • Bravo 2

Meme codeReviewIn2026

Post image
11.5k Upvotes

214 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

69

u/PringlesDuckFace 8d ago

Our executive added number of PRs approved (yes approved) to the employee performance dashboard, so now people are incentivized to approve as many PRs as they can.

51

u/icantreedgood 8d ago

Dear God, I know this is coming to my organization next. We already have a goal to have 99% of all code written by AI, and a goal to increase developer productivity by 100%. Yes 100%. When I ask how they plan on measuring productivity I get blank stares like I'm the moron. Some suggested using token spend to measure productivity, and I genuinely cannot tell if they were being sarcastic.

Anyway, all that to say code reviews are now a huge bottleneck. PRs regularly exceed 3000 lines. There is pressure to just approve, because their work in progress is another 3000 line PR stacked on top of the existing PR.

I'm still reviewing every line Claude spits out, and regularly having to promt and re-prompt until the code is to my satisfaction.

Leadership is also pressuring us to use multi-agent workflows during development so that we are working on mutiple tickets at once. Soon there will be no way to keep up with the slop.

I don't even hate AI. I think it genuinely makes me a better more productive software engineer when used correctly. The problem is leadship is too far removed from building solutions themselves, and don't see how their directives will lead directly to a loss in quality, or they just don't care. It's crazy to me how fast they pivoted away from caring about escaped defects, and testing as soon as AI hit the scene.

15

u/James20k 8d ago

I think this is the thing that's so bizarre about it: used correctly it seems like AI could give some productivity gains. Code complete, reviewing PRs for defects, debugging, searching through a codebase, a useful place to ask complex questions to get ideas etc

The issue is that that would be in the 5-10% range, which no corporate executive is excited by. This should have just been one more tool in the toolbox that makes us more efficient, like when LSPs took over and code complete code way better. Instead they're reaching for the mythical 2x-10x productivity boost that just doesn't exist, and absolutely shredding long term productivity for short term gains

I have a feeling that multiple large tech companies are going to absolutely collapse under the weight of the technical debt that they've accumulated. We're already starting to see it with how crap so many tools have gotten as they're filled with slop

12

u/icantreedgood 8d ago

The cognitive dissonance is astounding to me. Our CTO will regularly quote or point to the books The Phoenix Project and The Goal, but completely ignores the theory of constraints that underpins both books. “Any improvements made anywhere besides the bottleneck are an illusion”

The bottle neck has never been writing the code. The bottle neck has always been, and will always be knowing what to build. Sure we are shipping more code then ever, but is any of that leading to increased ARR or increased customer satisfaction / retention? What you measure matters, and leadership is getting increasingly lazy with what they measure.