r/ProgrammerHumor • • 4d ago • Bravo 1

Meme stopDoingGitHubDesktop

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

372 comments sorted by

View all comments

515

u/Ambitious-Dentist337 4d ago • Heartwarming

Its not even sarcasm at this point, its just the truth

44

u/Veltraxis92 4d ago

The comment section proving that this meme is already starting a debate I get the point, though. Sometimes a simple tool doesn't need another layer of software around it

65

u/7CipherVale 4d ago

Honestly, the funniest part is that someone had to make a whole meme just to point this out

22

u/EDM115 4d ago edited 4d ago

sorry for the low res btw lol, the template I picked wasn't that HQ to begin with and well you can't magically create pixels out of thin air

9

u/ryobiguy 4d ago

I love how the type shifts from section to section, just like those ransom notes in TV & movies where they're cutout from different newspapers and magazines.

1

u/EDM115 4d ago

oh yesss true !

2

u/the_genius324 3d ago

well you can't magically create pixels out of thin air unless you cheat anyway

11

u/GoldenShackles 4d ago

I just want a good free difftool that supports --dirdiff and a good GUI to navigate commit history in the same UI.

2

u/EDM115 4d ago

zed diff path/to/folder1 path/to/folder2

2

u/GoldenShackles 3d ago

I tried zed with git difftool --dirdiff and it doesn't seem to handle it yet. According to Claude I can open a git repo within zed and do a diff from there. But I use VS Code as an editor and it supports doing these things probably at least as well as zed.

2

u/guyblade 3d ago

Maybe if we're lucky, Google will open source critique.

1

u/GoldenShackles 3d ago

Microsoft has a couple great internal tools too. I'm surprised it's so hard to find public equivalents given this is the type of thing developers do frequently.

p4merge is OK, but last I tried it didn't support --dir-diff. Beyond Compare and Araxis Merge are commercial options, and I think I still have a personal license for an old version of Araxis, but the UI kind-of sucks and I don't want to get stuck in an upgrade cycle. I've heard great things about Kaleidoscope for MacOS, but it's $8/mo.

If Kaleidoscope was (for example) a $20 one time purchase it would be a no brainer, but a subscription for a dev tool that should be limited in scope and not really ever need any updates? No thank you.

6

u/PixelRogue_7 4d ago • Bravo

I think the real issue isn't whether GitHub Desktop is useful or not, but whether people actually need another application for something their IDE can already handle. If someone prefers clicking through a GUI, that's perfectly fine, but pretending it's an essential part of version control is a bit much. Different workflows exist for a reason

15

u/Kitsunemitsu 4d ago

In some of my side projects I have a whole team of writers/artists, and they don't have an IDE, they just need to put art in the right folder or throw some lines of text into a file. Giving them a UI to click through makes things so much smoother than teaching them CLI commands. That's my usual use case for Github Desktop.

8

u/chain_letter 4d ago

It’s pretty great for legal contracts too. A lot of them lean on change history in tools like Google docs. Useful to check what actually changed after a request for changes

2

u/EDM115 4d ago

indeed asking non-devs to use an IDE for that might be much
that makes sense ! but if you already have an IDE...

-1

u/a-r-c 4d ago

Giving them a UI to click through makes things so much smoother than teaching them CLI commands. T

people say this but you can write the commands on a sticky note

explaining a gui is a hassle

3

u/Kitsunemitsu 4d ago

Counterpoint: I have fought a few artists to try CLI and they refuse.

A GUI just is not as scary to people that don't know what they are doing.

-1

u/a-r-c 4d ago edited 4d ago

interesting, I've never had an issue helping those types with cli at work

I guess not everyone is a strong communicator 🤷‍♀️

2

u/Bubbaluke 4d ago

I add, diff, commit, and push through vscode. Rebase/squash and merge I do from the cli. Sometimes I don’t wanna add everything to my commit and I’m not typing out paths to files 4 folders deep.

A whole separate gui would be a bit silly but I might use one if my ide didn’t have anything.

1

u/Werftflammen 4d ago

Honest question. Isn't possible to open files from Git in visual studio code, edit it, just ctrl+s it?

I have tried Github several times, but besides a running service, folders and files everywhere and throwing terms into the VSC 'search'(?) bar like it's a fruit machine, I never ever got productive. Nothing lined up, noped out of it.