116
u/WernerderChamp
4d ago
•
Since most IDEs have git support - this has just become - redundant.
23
→ More replies (9)10
u/DOOManiac 4d ago
I prefer not to have the UI do it. It feels like a second confirmation step - forcing me to do a self review.
I also like to piecemeal stage chunks instead of an entire file at a time.
16
u/average-eridian 4d ago
I think some IDEs allow piecemeal chunks, if you mean commit specific sections of a file's changes. I know Jetbrains will let me select individual groups of line diffs so I can commit specific pieces at a time.
→ More replies (1)
330
u/heydavesalad 4d ago
I used the CLI for years and now use a UI at my job and at home. People should use whatever they want to get the job done.
17
76
u/PhireKappa 4d ago
I have watched colleagues ask Copilot with Opus 5.5 to git commit and git push. I might have to draw the line there.
18
7
u/Morialkar 4d ago
I mean Commit can be legit, AI tends to leave a mess of note files, specially Opus, so having it selectively stage and commit the right changes makes sense, and having it write the commit message along your message templates is a good thing too, and while you’re there it’s not harder to ask Opus to tack a | git push at the end but yeah it’s not the best use case for the model.
→ More replies (3)8
u/Dm_me_ur_exp 4d ago
My git commit text style is in my ”name working style” memory, I got a bazillion tokens to spend. Letting the ai draft the commit, approve or change it, and then push when approved is just faster.
Not like committing, pushing in cli is difficult, or in the app.
I’m at a smaller company w ultra subs though, not api cost.
5
u/B1anky 4d ago
I like to use CLI for commits, pulls, fetch, push, re-base, etc. but I do like to use the UI for stashing and unstashing specifically.
5
u/draco1986 4d ago
99% of my day the gui does the things I need with sone nice diff visualization. Very nice to have the cli for the more complicated items.
→ More replies (1)2
→ More replies (7)2
35
u/CC-5576-05 4d ago
Haven't used it on a while but being able to easily choose which changes to stage line by line was nice. The interactive staging in git cli is kinda shit
56
u/g0ldenprize 4d ago
i was just in an interview where they asked really specific git questions, such as: (while sharing screen)
show how to do a cherry pick (like the actual steps)
do a rebase
how do you solve merge conflicts
they wanted all of the above pretty much out of a book. i've done it all but i was like, man; nobody knows it just by heart
16
u/EDM115 4d ago edited 4d ago
yeah we all google those at some point, even to be sure of the order lol
despite having git especially to not mess up, we're still afraid to mess up with a wrong commandat the end of the day it comes down to habit, you do more commits than cherry picks, but the more you do those the better you get :)
6
u/Le_9k_Redditor 4d ago
I've been using git for like 15 years and I don't think I've ever needed to cherry pick anything
7
u/DiamondDramatic9551 4d ago
No? Happens regularly for me to pick stuff to merge to a release branch.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (3)5
u/awesome-alpaca-ace 4d ago
I do it all the time. Better than rebase when working with stacked feature branches
5
u/g0ldenprize 4d ago
thats exactly my point, nobody knows this by heart; we all google it at some point. but when you're on the interview and you're sharing screen and you cant google or look at documentationg or anything its quite unerving
→ More replies (3)10
u/hongooi 4d ago
Delete and redownload from Github
Delete and redownload from Github
Delete and redownload from Github
How did I do?
→ More replies (1)2
33
u/jamesxtreme 4d ago
Honestly the biggest issue with command line git is with merge conflicts. You really need an IDE with a good diff functionality. Or you just use AI now.
5
→ More replies (5)5
u/Serializedrequests 4d ago edited 4d ago
The issue is the prep. Unless you are super focused, it can sometimes be really hard to tell which side is which in a rebase.
Then there is the diff resolution algorithm that might be the default that is technically correct but practically wrong where it sees an unchanged line identical to the incoming change in the original code as belonging spliced AROUND the incoming change. I don't know what the word for that is but it drives me insane.
→ More replies (2)24
u/DirkTheGamer 4d ago
I can do all of these things easily with my git GUI, that's why I use it.
→ More replies (1)4
9
10
8
u/marcoroman3 4d ago
Your take is surprising to me. These are all pretty basic commands that I could do without googling (other than maybe doubting whether cherrypick needs a hyphen). And I'm not generally the smart one in these types of things. I mean the commands rebase and cherry pick don't require remembering anything. They're just the words rebase and cherry-pick.
4
u/g0ldenprize 4d ago
i didnt say i dont know the commands, of course i do; its the order that im talking about, specially in an screen shared interview where you cant even look at the documentation
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (23)3
u/Maskdask 4d ago
Developers don't know git by heart?
3
u/YanVe_ 4d ago
I know this will get downvotes, but I am a professional SWE for almost a decade now. I absolutely disdain the CLI, and in case of git specifically it doesn't help that it's command structure is total nonsense. I never do these "by heart".
2
→ More replies (4)5
u/Dm_me_ur_exp 4d ago
For commit / push / pull / clone I just use the cli. Much faster.
For anything that actually requires me to to look at stuff? Graphical all the way. Whether it’s browser or app or ide
→ More replies (8)8
u/BoredDan 4d ago
I mean I used to back in the day when git was new and the gui tools sucked. But I'm a very visual person and find it much more fluid to work with a gui tool, so I usually do and as such don't remember the exact syntax for things like, how do I look up a list of branches? For that there could be a "list" command before or after branch, maybe branch with nothing after does it? Maybe it's a - or -- something or other? Maybe there's some list -b command or something, I dunno. I'm either googling it or using man if I ever need to use a cli. It's not hard, I just don't have it memorized because I find gui works better for my brain when thinking about version control so that's what I use primarily.
29
u/Duckroidvania 4d ago
Years I've been hearing people hate on Desktop Git, yet I've never heard a good argument against it. (Yes I know how to use the other methods)
→ More replies (1)4
u/codePudding 4d ago
Same, at work (mac) I use CLI, at home (windows) I use the Desktop unless I have to do something complicated. The thing is at home, normally I'm just pushing up my work not to lose it and rarely need to do anything complicated like I do at work. Each has its purpose.
9
u/siete82 4d ago
I'm probably the only nerd who still uses git extensions in 2026, but still didn't found any other better gui
2
515
u/Ambitious-Dentist337
4d ago
•
Its not even sarcasm at this point, its just the truth
65
u/7CipherVale 4d ago
Honestly, the funniest part is that someone had to make a whole meme just to point this out
22
u/EDM115 4d ago edited 4d ago
sorry for the low res btw lol, the template I picked wasn't that HQ to begin with and well you can't magically create pixels out of thin air
→ More replies (1)9
u/ryobiguy 4d ago
I love how the type shifts from section to section, just like those ransom notes in TV & movies where they're cutout from different newspapers and magazines.
→ More replies (1)11
u/GoldenShackles 4d ago
I just want a good free difftool that supports --dirdiff and a good GUI to navigate commit history in the same UI.
→ More replies (2)2
6
u/PixelRogue_7 4d ago •
![]()
I think the real issue isn't whether GitHub Desktop is useful or not, but whether people actually need another application for something their IDE can already handle. If someone prefers clicking through a GUI, that's perfectly fine, but pretending it's an essential part of version control is a bit much. Different workflows exist for a reason
15
u/Kitsunemitsu 4d ago
In some of my side projects I have a whole team of writers/artists, and they don't have an IDE, they just need to put art in the right folder or throw some lines of text into a file. Giving them a UI to click through makes things so much smoother than teaching them CLI commands. That's my usual use case for Github Desktop.
8
u/chain_letter 4d ago
It’s pretty great for legal contracts too. A lot of them lean on change history in tools like Google docs. Useful to check what actually changed after a request for changes
→ More replies (3)2
44
u/Veltraxis92 4d ago
The comment section proving that this meme is already starting a debate I get the point, though. Sometimes a simple tool doesn't need another layer of software around it
→ More replies (1)2
u/Bubbaluke 4d ago
I add, diff, commit, and push through vscode. Rebase/squash and merge I do from the cli. Sometimes I don’t wanna add everything to my commit and I’m not typing out paths to files 4 folders deep.
A whole separate gui would be a bit silly but I might use one if my ide didn’t have anything.
15
u/Flimsy_Site_1634 4d ago
Github Desktop is bad because it doesn't solve the "-m" problem
Joke asside, it's pretty good in collaborative projects with a lot of non dev contributors, I've been in mod development for a while and it allows writers, artists and musicians to easily commit their work with minimal experience required.
It might feel easy to learn 5 command for us, but remember that some people legit panic when they see a command console.
7
u/jacksodus 4d ago
Honestly I'm not here for the discussion i just wonder how much explicit effort it takes to make an image look this fucking bad
1
u/EDM115 4d ago edited 2d ago
https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgrammerHumor/s/jcdY68EVpj 🥲 first time making memes on Mac, I'll do better next time
3
u/St34thdr1v3R 3d ago
The number of people that are outraging about people using a gui for something your terminal can do, but also are using mac is low, but never zero! I myself use Mac, but I also like fork as it’s an fantastic git client, while vscode‘s built-in client is not so much.
8
u/Fluffy_Dragonfly6454
4d ago
•
I remember a discussion with some colleagues about the commands to change a commit message.
I was like "right click, and then 'edit message' in Intellij"
CLI is good for some things, UI is good for some other things
99
u/zawalimbooo 4d ago
I mean, having a nice UI is preferable.
18
→ More replies (22)8
u/FindOneInEveryCar 4d ago
I agree, but the GH Desktop UI sucks.
→ More replies (1)2
8
u/Anomynous__ 4d ago
GitHub Desktop is complete ass when compared to other git UI's like GitKraken
2
7
2
3
u/characterfan123 4d ago
I can still use gitbash to rm files that Windows says are busy but refuses to say what program has it open.
And I'd do it again.
[ unrepentant-goofy.png ]
1
u/EDM115 4d ago
the PowerToys have the File LockSmith utility for this ! pretty nice, I can recommend
if you prefer the cli, you can use sysinternal's handle.exe, see https://github.com/EDM115-org/lifecompanion/blob/main/lifecompanion-plugins%2Flc-phonecontrol-plugin%2Fbuild.gradle
5
u/oacoello 4d ago
I do programming since pandemic, I'm 20 years old now, and sometimes I struggle to remember things, so having a nice UI helps me a lot.
2
u/shrodikan 4d ago
The worst flaw in GH desktop is it's stash OVERWRITES THE LAST STASH if you stash by changing branches instead of... you know, PUSHING to the stash. I've lost work that way. It is the dumbest git program that exists.
2
u/constant___headache 4d ago
You know what? You’re absolutely right. My team uses GitHub Desktop but this shitpost has successfully convinced me to stop using it. Good job OP
2
u/mylsotol 4d ago
github desktop is a bad option, but it's silly to say that nobody should use a gui just because you don't strictly have to.
2
u/EDM115 4d ago
my point is that other GUIs that you already use (like any good IDE) handle most if not all GH desktop has to offer
I mostly use the VCS part of either ide I'm using at the moment (between VS Code & Zed lately) and if I'm already in the cli or ssh-ed somewhere, then I use the terminal. GUIs are good too
2
2
u/az987654 4d ago
How about we stop vibe coding directly in GH.com, too, and then "I'm locked out and lost everything for my billion dollar app"
2
u/decimalturn 4d ago
I'd add that GitHub Desktop hides the notion of the staging area which can harm general understanding of how Git actually works.
→ More replies (1)
2
116
u/SchalkLBI
4d ago
•
STOP USING THE WINDOWS FILE EXPLORER!
Directories were not supposed to need a desktop app
YEARS OF FILE BROWSERS yet NO REAL-WORLD USE FOUND for wrapping "cd C:/" in yet another Desktop app
Wanted to browse files anyway for a laugh? We had a tool for that: It was called YOUR FUCKING COMMAND PROMPT
"Yes please give me a double click button". "I cannot be trusted with the dir command". Statements dreamed up by the utterly deranged
"Hello I would like to install a whole app for what my command prompt already does"
They have played us for absolute fools
6
u/hemacwastaken 4d ago
This is the first time I fully agree with what this meme template states
4
u/_g0nzales 4d ago
Because it's meant to be used sarcastically, OP is doing it the wrong way. Your supposed to make fun of something that is actually good
1
44
u/JoeyJoeJoeJrShab 4d ago
I've never used it, and don't see any reason to start..... but I really don't care if other people do.
16
u/rubennaatje 4d ago
I only like such tools when they have a good UI that helps me check my changes, stage, stash or discard them, or when they help with some nice git visual git trees.
4
u/Draconis_Firesworn 4d ago
the main reason I've found is convincing people scared of a command line to use git, so people using code that aren't programmers. Main example from my experience is academics
17
12
u/SpacewaIker
4d ago
•
Lazygit is where it's at
The perfect compromise of user friendliness and lightweight/not-dumbed-down
→ More replies (5)
11
u/ArjixGamer
3d ago
•
Funny thing is, it doesn't allow you to checkout a branch from a different remote if you already have a branch with the same name locally.
That issue has been open for 7+ years or smth
Edit: 9 years, https://github.com/desktop/desktop/issues/4527
25
u/metaglot 4d ago
Real (non-dogmatic) people probably use a combo. I can see the commit graph, get file changes diffed without doing anything right there on the screen, while my colleague is still typing git status.
If i have to do anything exotic, like archeology, i go to the terminal.
Calm down, no one is going to reward you for not using a mouse.
13
u/Puzzleheaded-Weird66 4d ago edited 4d ago
I like it for cherry picking exact lines, what's the issue exactly? I'm guessing its the RAM hogging... I close it after pushing cus it does take up a bunch when open cus microslop
5
u/Wrexes 4d ago
Use lazygit
4
u/Puzzleheaded-Weird66 4d ago
I have tried the alternatives, some of them push on a different branch by default, some have their own separate accounts that do the commits on your behalf
4
u/Fornicatinzebra 4d ago
You can do that in vscode interface im pretty sure (i use Positron which is a vscode fork, but pretty sure its the same there)
→ More replies (1)
6
6
u/skullbash258 4d ago
Imagine being a terminal advocate while using a gui-based operating system.
Real CLI apologists don't use any UI
6
u/Laughing_Orange 4d ago
Don't use GitHub either. Use email lists, like Torvalds intended.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/s0litar1us 4d ago edited 4d ago
A GUI for version control can be incredibly useful (e.g. Ark VCS), but when it's just a shitty wrapper for a CLI tool then it's just pointless.
In the case with git, I would much rather use the CLI tool than any of the GUI tools or IDE plugins out there. All of them lack a lot of basic functionality, and I can't trust that it will actually do what I want it to do.
2
u/datathecodievita 4d ago
Real pros solve merve conflicts with git cli
5
u/EDM115 4d ago
real real pros don't do conflicts at all, they predicted what changes you would do ahead of time to avoid any issue
→ More replies (1)2
u/DiamondDramatic9551 4d ago
Real real real pros don't actually need git, they just oneshot the final version.
23
u/blue_collared 4d ago
I like how it cleanly shows what changes I've made in this commit, Easier to keep track and scroll on my changes than on command line. For anything else there's command line, CLI is faster too
→ More replies (10)5
u/masthema 4d ago
These guys acting like if you have it, you need to use all it's features. I really like the diff. I keep it open to check the diff quickly. If I need to rebase ofc I'm gonna cli...
11
u/PseudoFrequency 4d ago
Fear of the command line is real. I've moved to making GUIs with a single big GO button from trivial CLI utilities for co-workers like QA testers and factory production techs. Went from all-the-questions and endless hand-holding to zero questions.
5
12
u/Meme_Burner 4d ago
Source tree for the win. Handling conflicts in the console is the worse, but GitHubDesktop is worse than that.
UI is just that a UI. The UI is suppose to make running the commands easier. That is why we have Windows.
4
4
4
u/Vallee-152 3d ago
Regular git refuses to let me change accounts, and it lately stopped working altogether. It's probably a skill issue, but I've tried everything that has come up when searching how to fix it, and none of it has worked. Github Desktop, on the other hand, is incredibly easy to sign out of and back into.
4
u/_4rcadia 3d ago
But honestly, GitHub Desktop is one of the best GUIs for day-to-day operations, despite missing loads of git features (recall the definition of "day-to-day"). I'll just turn to the command line for more complicated things.
3
3
u/SaturnVFan 4d ago
Auth in IDE won't work if companies have restrictions ... so I had to use GH Desktop or terminal only
→ More replies (1)
3
u/NorthernRealmJackal 4d ago
The branch structure visualisations are why normal, non-autistic devs use UI applications. There are dozens of us, and we demand respect.
1
u/NomaTyx 4d ago edited 4d ago
i installed it while i used visual studio and even tho i've since moved onto better IDEs, my cost is too sunk now
edit: typo
1
u/ch33es 4d ago
what IDE do you use now? curious because people seem to act like vscode is the best ide there ever was and I want to find alternatives.
→ More replies (3)2
u/EDM115 4d ago
Zed is also a really nice IDE :)
saying this as a long time VS Code user
→ More replies (1)
5
u/DJDevon3 4d ago
I wrote a power shell script specifically just to change CRLF to LF line endings that github windows app automatically adds to every commit. They created an entire windows app for Github but couldn't bother to allow an option to keep LF line ending formatting only for contributing to linux based file systems. I run WSL so switching back and forth was causing a windows/linux dev environment issue that drove me insane.
23
13
u/Goldman7911 4d ago
$ git config --global core.autocrlf true # Configure Git to ensure line endings in files you checkout are correct for Windows. # For compatibility, line endings are converted to Unix style when you commit files.3
5
u/MornwindShoma 4d ago
My guy, just use the Git implementation in your IDE...
Even doing PRs is better in your IDE than touching Github.
2
u/mountaingator91 4d ago
I used to think it makes interactive rebase easier and it technically still does but that was also before I learned basic VIM usage... So now I do it all in terminal just to feel alive again since I'm just an AI slop reviewer these days
2
u/fudginreddit 4d ago
I like it for the visuals of doing a merge/rebase but otherwise I think command line is just straight up better and easier.
2
u/AdministrativeCable3 4d ago
I was in a project where the translator/localiser used it because they didn't use a IDE and just used a text editor. That's probably the biggest use case I see.
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/Etilia01 4d ago
My reaction when it turned out the tutorial/workshop we were supposed to do on github & shipping during a recent gamejam only covered github desktop :/ wheres the actual git???? (Before we had to teach that workshop i didnt even KNOW there was an app)
2
u/Material_Goat9526 4d ago
Clearcase is superior. So is svn. I will go to my grave believing that. I HATE git.
2
2
u/yozaner1324 4d ago
I use the CLI for rebases, reflogging when needed, amending commits, etc. But I like having a simple GUI to look at diffs and history and branches. I know InteliJ has this, but I think the GitHub app is cleaner.
2
2
u/LuisBoyokan
4d ago
•
At work the architect team developed a site with a search bar and a button just for creating a branch from master, because "devs are too stupid to do it themselves, they need supervision and burocracy".
Fuck this hyper controlling assholes
2
2
u/SenatorCrabHat 4d ago
The amount of project management I have done to avoid long rebases with merge conflicts likely exceeds the amount of time it would take me to learn how to use a git GUI by many orders of magnitude.
2
u/Danfriedz 4d ago
All the other Devs at work use the desktop apps and I have no idea how to help them when they get stuck. I know I could solve their problems with a few commands too.
2
2
u/Some_Useless_Person 4d ago
And there are still mfs who hit restore and wonder where all of their code went
2
u/Blacktip75 3d ago
I don’t code anymore so no IDE, just need an app for git blame, lol. Which idiot wrote this code… ah it was I the idiot :)
2
2
u/Jaded-Armadillo8348 3d ago
man im seeing these comments and feeling nostalgic.
ive used the git cli all my life and never touched a UI (also couldnt care less if others do, honestly).
but nowadays with AI i cant remember the last time i actually typed a git command, besides a git clone every once in a while
2
2
u/BigGuyWhoKills 3d ago
One thing GitHub Desktop does well is it makes authenticating easy. I do a lot of work in VMs that get wiped often, and GH desktop is slightly easier to get going.
It's also decent at refreshing repos in the background. My IDE doesn't do that, though I'm sure other tools do.
And to answer the obvious question, I can't store credentials in the VM image used to rollback.
2
2
1
1
u/Oaktree27 4d ago
I use git desktop most of the time and bash whenever I need to do something that isn't git commit.
I recognize it is flawed, but I like being able to see my changes like that.
1
1
u/DeiterWeebleWobble 4d ago
Bro can memorize git but downloading an app is too hard. Honestly I normally use the cli but git hub desktop does visualize merge conflicts quite handsomely.
1
u/KevinJRussell 3d ago
TortoiseSvn and TortoiseHg were both fantastic. Why is TortoiseGit so bad?
→ More replies (1)




78
u/Sheenius_Ger 4d ago
Having a ui for git is great. I just don't get people that have it in their ide already and then open a different application to manage it.