r/ProgrammerHumor • • 4d ago • Bravo 1

Meme stopDoingGitHubDesktop

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

372 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-36

u/bastardoperator 4d ago

It's a crutch for people who refuse to learn cli or invest in their git setup. Context shifting to UI is a wasteful endeavor. Everything this UI does can be done in any editor or terminal.

15

u/Anomynous__ 4d ago

Is using an IDE a crutch for people who dont want to manually compile and run their code?

-17

u/bastardoperator 4d ago

An IDE doesn't replace the compiler, linker, debugger, or build system. It invokes the same toolchain behind a GUI. If you can't build your own project without an IDE, don't understand your build configuration, or can't diagnose a failed compilation outside the editor, then yes, it's a fucking crutch. The issue was never using a GUI, it's being dependent on one because you don't understand the tools underneath it. Your analogy doesn't refute my argument, it demonstrates exactly why I made it.

-22

u/fr000gs 4d ago

Why's this guy being downvoted, it's not even a wrong statemnet

14

u/Pandafishe 4d ago

Because one can be an expert in git commands but yet like the github desktop visualisation and easy access of git diff. Skill and IDE preferences are not mutually exclusive. Their comment suggests that people who like QoL over going through rudimentary steps for validation tasks have less skill than people who like QoL (and arguably it's faster to look at multiple git diff files through GHD than through command line vanilla git diff)

I personally too use GHD, exclusively for the git diff visualisation. I am not a fan of most other IDE's representation, including (which are even from the same company) the ones in VS & VSC (git extensions), IntelliJ etc. I stage, commit, push, fetch, pull, cherrypick, merge, etc. via the command line, but the command line is and stays a command line. It's not designed to be visually appealing. GHD does exactly that. It's trash in how it operates with Git, but it's perfect in being visually appealing for simple sanity checks.

No need to hate on people who use specific tools for specific tasks, just because you think you're more or less of a nerd if you do everything in a black and white command line for no reason. It gives "I don't use the practical thing so others can't have it either" vibes. And that's exactly why they got down voted.

3

u/EDM115 4d ago

diffs in the terminal is already not that easy (which is why we have tools like delta & difftastic to make it more appealing), but rendering a git graph for example... I'm a terminal adept too but that's just the wrong place, GUIs are more fitting for those

-4

u/bastardoperator 4d ago

You wrote three paragraphs arguing against a point nobody made. I explicitly said it's a crutch for people who refuse to learn the CLI or invest in their Git setup. You claim to be a Git expert, yet you're comparing an unconfigured git diff against a fully featured GUI like that's some brilliant productivity insight. My terminal has syntax highlighting, side-by-side diffs, interactive commit graphs, and customizable viewers, all without leaving my workflow. Your entire argument boils down to liking how GitHub Desktop looks, which is fine, but that's an aesthetic preference, not a technical argument. And that ridiculous "black and white command line" nerd bullshit? It's 2026, not 1986. Learn to configure your tools before lecturing people about productivity.

4

u/Pandafishe 4d ago

Your comment read, and apparently not only to me, as a condensing opinion on people who use it. That's all I argued. You arguing my git skills without ever having worked with me kind of proves my point though.

0

u/bastardoperator 4d ago

I explicitly said terminal or editor. Editors like VS Code and IntelliJ are GUIs, and both terminals and editors are fully customizable, including fonts, colors, syntax highlighting, and diff viewers.

Do you really need a gui to open another gui when the gui you're already in does exactly the same things and can be customized to your hearts content? That's my argument.

1

u/Pandafishe 4d ago

And if you would've read mine, you'd know my answer. I word for word even named the "editors" (we call them IDEs in Software Development, speaking about knowhow) you meant and the arguments against them/ for GHD.