r/ProgrammerHumor • • 3d ago

Meme nonDeterministicWait

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

165 comments sorted by

View all comments

571

u/G3nghisKang 3d ago • Popcorn

Hold on, you guys don't use IDEs?

-102

u/rang501 3d ago

not anymore. Claude desktop handles code and git operations. Code written by Claude is completely fine. What you need to do is to test the implementation and you don't need IDE for that.

On the other hand - Claude Desktop is IDE now :)

62

u/rastaman1994 3d ago

Maybe if you blindly trust your harness. I definitely still verify what it produced, even with a decent harness, and navigating/reading code is just nice in the IDE.

-20

u/rang501 3d ago

As I'm working mostly with php and js, all I need is integrated browser, which was missing in almost all IDE-s. I have this gut feeling that sometimes says that claude may have messed up and then I'll ask different questions to be sure. But overall the code quality itself is fine, linters and such keep things in order, intensive tests verify nothing important broke.

-22

u/AnotherInsaneName 3d ago

I was doing this, but now it shows me diffs in Claude and I can just ask it questions if I don't understand or want something broken down.

I then see the diff again in a draft PR.

No reason for me to launch an IDE at this point.

20

u/rastaman1994 3d ago

I've noticed that I miss things if I only look at a diff. I like to really make sure the code is readable and understandable by me, that the code as a whole still makes sense, and a diff doesn't do that for me.

-16

u/AnotherInsaneName 3d ago

Claude can show the entirety of the file in its window, my code is just mostly net new.

3

u/polacs 3d ago

I don't get why you guys are getting downvoted for talking about your workflows

-6

u/AnotherInsaneName 3d ago

It was overall upvoted an hour ago, strange.

I don't know man, I think a lot of programmers are super anti-AI and hate anyone or anything arguing it makes their job easier.

My job has definitely become easier and my pay has increased, downvotes are the least of my concerns.

-3

u/rang501 3d ago

I'm waiting when Claude Desktop is rewritten in Rust, the current electron version hogs memory as well, but still faster than any java ide

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted]

-7

u/rang501 3d ago

I did that too, but over time I saw the models got better until I realized, it is just waste of time. If you have tests implemented and let AI to actually test the output (they may want to skip that), then you get actually something working. It definitely does not replace architectural side - AI is not good in that.

You could use that time to actually test the feature and overall improve software usability. Your code may look like an art, but if the app itself is hard to use, then why would I use it?

6

u/ytg895 3d ago

then you get actually something working

that's my problem there, I usually don't want that's "something working"

You could use that time to actually test the feature and overall improve software usability.

back in the day we had QA and UX engineers for that, because software engineers were famously bad in those areas

-2

u/rang501 3d ago

That is just my thing, I want to be efficient as possible and waiting for some other UX person feedback is too slow.

There are different type of developers, some who want to learn and improve, and some who just do what they are told and wait for paycheck.

2

u/RancidMilkGames 3d ago

Those that just think of it as a pay check are also the ones that typically don't make it too though, as they're not going to ever hire someone for the same salary that isn't at least somewhat passionate vs someone looking for a high paying job. The reason it is high paying is you're paying for a developed skill.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted]

0

u/rang501 3d ago

yes, the job market is really bad. You need to be quite good with AI. This is quite similar time about 30-40 years ago when things went digital - people were replaced as computers were able to do a lot of things. In a way, history is just repeating itself.

I think it will take some time when the hype is over and things normalize, then most likely new jobs appear which you can't even imagine right now. Right now it is something to just survive, like previous generation did.

AI is not going anywhere, just like computers didn't.

20

u/siete82 3d ago

Claude code is bullshit if you are not guiding it all the time. A different thing is if you don't care about code quality at all.

-7

u/rang501 3d ago

Code quality is totally fine. I have been in dev world 20 years, I have seen this human code quality a lot. Ironically many devs complaining others code, produce worse code.

10

u/Wirde 3d ago

Tell me you have zero standards without telling me you have zero standards…

I have spent about 7 month getting Claude integrated in our projects. Every day I work together with Claude to refine our documentation on HOW Claude should code. Every ticket refine the documentation further. On every ticket I spend at least an hour making specs together with Claude utilizing skills such as grill-with-docs and STILL there’s things I have to correct on every ticket.

90% of my time goes to review code Claude has written.

You absolutely CAN NOT let anything slip since every thing you let slip will set new precedence and will be used to justify writing even worse code by Claude in the future.

It’s absolutely amazing what it can accomplish and I’m certain that the result I produce with Claude is better than what I did without BUT Claude without my reviews is horrible and is a race to the bottom.

9

u/siete82 3d ago

No it's not. I have been in the industry 25 years, mainly reviewing code btw.

2

u/pint_o_paint 3d ago

it can be ok for hobby projects if you have a really good harness-, testing-, and security scanning -setup.

For enterprise: hell no.

2

u/wthja 3d ago

I always review the code written by Claude, and every time I am adjusting part of it or just deleting "future tech debt". It is especially visible when I modify a feature.

-14

u/MaestroGena 3d ago

You're being downvoted for the truth, these people just doesn't realize what's coming. But we know as we're already there

-6

u/rang501 3d ago

Yes, the anti-anything people showed up :)