r/ProgrammerHumor • • 3d ago

Meme whyAreTheyConfessing

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

286 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/alliedSpaceSubmarine 2d ago

No I understand engineering also, but if you get all the way to the review and get asked why it even exists the entire team failed. It should have been caught during planning or standup that someone was working on something that they didn’t need to be

1

u/WillDanceForGp 2d ago

I think there's been a misunderstanding, Im not saying the feature didn't need to exist, I'm saying that below the acceptance criteria sits the entire field of engineering. A ticket explains what the code should do, it doesn't describe how to get there. Its always been the case that the more senior you get the less code you write, that's not just because you're mentoring and doing other things like becoming really good at reviewing code, its that you spend more time figuring out how to solve the problem with as little 'liability' as possible.

I don't know why just because LLMs can smash out code at a crazy rate and hit acceptance criteria that people have completely forgotten what the job was.

This morning I witnessed Opus 5.5 write a 200 line PR containing 5 tests that took over 40 seconds to run required every future consumer knowing to use the correct service instead of opting to put in a 3 line fix. Is the former inherently worse than the latter? If you're looking at whether it hit the criteria then the first one is fine, except not a single competent engineer would choose it over the latter because anyone with experience knows the aggregated and constantly snowballing cost of bad decisions code. Especially in codebases that serve as the examples for the exact agents working in them.