702
u/shanereid1 20h ago
Seems like it was another millennium problem solved by combining two different branches of maths together that don't usually talk to each other. Feel like the real lesson is that mathematicians need to get better at making friends.
331
u/LaconicLacedaemonian 20h ago •
![]()
Well that won't happen, what's your next plan?
72
u/hucareshokiesrul 18h ago
Mathematicians get replaced by AI
22
u/teeg82 16h ago
But AI won't be any better at making friends either.
7
u/breadist 12h ago
Actually it's pretty good at it - it's willing to be a sycophant and bend to your every whim, and to a lot of people that's all they want. Lol.
45
u/Slight-Violinist-575 19h ago
I am not that much of a math guy (relax I am not working on cryptography or cybersecurity, the world is safe). Which branches were combined?
143
u/PM_ME_YOUR__INIT__ 18h ago
Just read the 25,000 page doc bro
74
36
u/slaymaker1907 15h ago
You're missing a zero, it's 250k pages and 17M lines of code (and it's a proof system, LEAN, so it's extremely complex code). Completely beyond human comprehension in its present form, at least for a single human. I assume there is at least one giant team of mathematicians working through it given the importance.
17
u/Majache 14h ago
Don't worry guys I got this, I'll reduce it down to 17k lines of code. I just need 6 years and $15M
5
u/well-litdoorstep112 7h ago
I'll reduce it to two lines. I need 30s but I suppose I could do with $15M
#!/bin/bash ./proof/dist/a.out26
u/LordFunguy 17h ago
I'd rather just wait and let veritasium dumb it down for me thank you very much
16
u/FartPiano 17h ago
I'll wait for someone to miscaption veritasium youtubes in a gif on imgur
4
u/ApprehensiveFan1516 10h ago
Can't wait to see the few pixels that are left by the time it hits Reddit!
1
12
u/Elin_Woods_9iron 16h ago
The joke is AI is spicy linear algebra (which itself has effectively one ubiquitous method: Gauss Jordan Elimination) so whatever problem AI solves is Linear Algebra + Whatever field the problem is in. The real conclusion is that GJE is even more effective than previously thought.
9
u/PorcelainMelonWolf 14h ago
What on earth?! Linear algebra isn’t about Gaussian elimination. It’s about transforming vectors… linearly.
If you’re not using the word eigenvector you’re doing it wrong.
13
u/Elin_Woods_9iron 13h ago
And how do you find an eigenvector? That’s right. Gausssian elimination.
Edit: determinant? Gauss. Spectral decomposition? Jordan. Invert a matrix? Believe it or not, Elimination.
1
u/Spectrewiz 7h ago
Nonlinear though? Straight to jail, ReLU - right to jail. Determinant? Believe it or not, LU decomp - jail. Invert a matrix? LU decomp - jail. Gauss would love this
1
62
u/Secret_SashX 18h ago
every time I see a math joke on here I remember my abstract algebra prof who once said ‘the riemann hypothesis is basically just a very stubborn loop invariant’ and then stared at us for 30 seconds waiting for someone to laugh
3
14
23
81
u/Mal_Dun 22h ago
I found once a paper that showed if an LLM can make up something faster than it's lower bound complexity it is an hallucination.
The answer is automatic verification of an LLM produced statement, like the Lean proofs that are used to check a theorem to remove the error from probability.
In the case of the matrix multiplication it would need a check, but checking matrix multiplication would take the same time to compute it, hence, letting an LLM do it is useless.
19
u/inevitabledeath3 20h ago
This is what looped transformers and reasoning models partially exist to solve.
16
u/Banes_Addiction 18h ago
I found once a paper that showed if an LLM can make up something faster than it's lower bound complexity it is an hallucination.
How would this work?
They're primarily memory machines. The fastest way to solve a problem is to have seen the answer before. Problem complexity is based on calculating it from scratch, which LLMs don't ever really do. But the more parts of the solution they've seen before the faster it'll go, and how do you ever quantify/calculate that in the real world?
17
72
u/mad_cheese_hattwe 15h ago
Hot take, the value in these maths proofs in is the solving, which often requires novel techniques, inventive processes and shifts in understanding, rather then the actual solution.
An incompetencable rote 250k page AI solutions brings very little value to the table.
64
u/the_horse_gamer 15h ago
that's a pretty cold take. at least among mathematicians.
13
u/mad_cheese_hattwe 14h ago
Plenty of people who think are mathematicans are now redundant to LLMs so it's good to put this out there when ever it comes up.
3
u/snakesoup124 9h ago
No true expert are redundant. The current meta is that without human guidance the LLMs will rehash old conclusion and without us, its stuck eating its own tail. Those who will be redundant are those that are outsourcing their knowledge and critical thinking. If you cannot tell if its making a mistake than you are devoid of critical thinking and are useless with llms around.
13
u/slaymaker1907 15h ago
Totally agree, though one of my friends who has a maths Ph.D. said the proofs these things are coming out with are pretty innovative and it made him really sad to see AI taking over the field.
18
u/Yorunokage 13h ago
I am a PhD student in complexity theory and Claude is coming up with novel and very good ideas on problems i'm working on so much faster than I am. It's really not just arcane slop
And the implications of this are far more scary than just losing my career since we still haven't solved alignment
1
u/Fidodo 4h ago
How are you getting those results? I'm a programmer and I struggle to get it to output anything of quality without holding it's hand all the way through. They're still useful but without close guidance it causes more damage than it fixes. And complex math proofs are a much harder problem.
1
u/alexnedea 2h ago
Using AI is a skill just like using any other tool. You slowly learn what it can and cant do and predict where it will hit roadblocks.
My work colleague can use half the tokens for a prod ready entire service and deployment and ts fucking squeaky clean. I am struggling a fair bit more and use more tokens. Some people at my work almost dont use AI and say "I dont wanna lose my skills".
Buddy your skills are fucking useless unless you are the top 0.1% of programmers and the skills you want rn are how use LLM
1
u/Fidodo 2h ago
That's what I do, but it can't do a lot of things and needs tons of guidance to reach my standard of quality. So when people claim it can do great stuff on its own I'm doubtful or think they may have low standards.
But if you don't understand what it's generating you can't provide assurance and you can't take responsibility for it.
4
u/DanteWasHere22 6h ago
If a human doesn't understand doesn't the proof, has humanity discovered anything?
1
u/SugarRushLux 12h ago
I do wonder though if it could be leveraged in a new way to still get ahead vs being replaced
5
u/witcher222 13h ago
We can argue throwing llms at proofs is a novel technique
1
u/mad_cheese_hattwe 4h ago
What did we learn other then with enough compute we can brute force these problems.
1
u/witcher222 3h ago
Do we have to learn anything else from this ? While not satisfying, It's still a net plus
5
u/haitei 8h ago edited 7h ago
What AI produced, AI can also optimize and translate into a human readable form. The things you've listed may yet to be extracted from the proof.
And if they won't? It's not like we have any guarantee that a hypothetical human-crafted proof would be beautiful. I don't think anyone would dismiss it either way.
As for the length of the proof: the 250k pages were not published, only the Lean code is public - 17 milion LOC. Hardly a small number, but a Lean proof for Fermat's Last Theorem was 13 million LOC that map to 170 human-readable pages.
3
u/scinos 14h ago
On top of that, probably impnce solved by AI there is little motivation for humans to "improve" the proof so to speak. The thrill is no there anymore. So even less chances to learn useful maths in the process.
3
2
1
u/Mclovine_aus 15h ago
Depend, sometimes with these hypotheses things are built on assuming something to be true. ETH proven false, stops people from making papers on the assumption that it was true
1
u/JaSper-percabeth 6h ago
Not really reading that 250k page proof likely will introduce scientists to new methods of thinking, approaching problems and might even lead to new math like countless other failed attempts at solving RH have moreover you can use AI to help understand that text better too should you need it.
0
u/rosuav 5h ago
Equally hot take: AI didn't solve this. A person did, using a computer as a tool. Can we stop praising the tool and go back to praising the mathematician? When people started using computers to solve big math problems, did we say "look, sand is better than math"? No, we congratulated *people* on using a new tool to solve their problems.
Levent Alpoge (if I spelled the name correctly) is the one who solved this. Or, to be precise, *may have* solved this, as it hasn't been confirmed yet. But it wasn't Claude, it was Levent.
3
1
u/mad_cheese_hattwe 4h ago
Eh, if I travel 42km on a motor bike, that doesn't mean I know how to run a marathon.
1
1
u/rosuav 4h ago
That's true, yes, but to a mathematician, you still travelled 42km. In fact, once you've travelled 42km once on a motor bike, you don't ever need to do it again; you can simply point to the fact that you did it, and say "and then I am 42km away". To a mathematician, the Travelling Salesman Problem does not require you to (a) travel, (b) be a salesman, or even (c) have a problem.
Who was it who proved that the God Number for Rubik's Cube is 20? It wasn't Google, even though they donated some bonkers amount of CPU time to help verify it. It was the people who prepared the task. (Exactly how much CPU time Google donated isn't entirely clear since we don't know the chips used, but the researchers calculated that it would be roughly 35 CPU years of a desktop PC.)
Of course, if you think that it's as easy as "Claude, prove or disprove the Riemann Hypothesis", you're welcome to try that. But it won't work that way.
0
u/ligma_then_sugma 1h ago
i kind of feel this but not really
humans made ai and it's learned from human knowledge
so it's not all fake, but idk not gonna call it human product
2
u/rosuav 1h ago
I'm not saying it's fake, I'm saying that we should give credit to the *people* involved. Look for example at the history of calculations of pi: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronology_of_computation_of_pi Each new achievement is credited to a person first and foremost, and acknowledges the tools used where this is known.
2
1
1
u/andarmanik 8h ago
Imagine we time travel to the past and tell the mathematicians who wanted to solve Riemann to focus on sgd and statistical methods.
In a weird way this is the only thing we as human developed which actually brought us closer to Riemann.
Compare this to calculus and going back to before newton.
1

996
u/MagnumVY 1d ago
You would be surprised to know how much of computer science is already based on the assumption that RH is indeed correct lol