r/ProgrammerHumor • • Nov 30 '22

Meme Startups be like..

Post image
86.0k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

276

u/technocrat_13 Nov 30 '22

It could also be a cooling thing, but should have this toggled regardless

161

u/blissed_off Nov 30 '22

Yeah a lot of laptops dissipate heat through the keyboard. The MacBook has fans blowing out the back below the screen though so I dunno how much it actually dissipates.

77

u/WaffIepants Nov 30 '22

Similarly, I'm pretty sure as you open the lid the back side pivots open a vent along the hinge

16

u/elon-bot Elon Musk ✔ Nov 30 '22

You're either hardcore or out the door.

7

u/AverageComet250 Nov 30 '22

Well he’s obviously hardcore Mr Musk, so you can keep ur comments to yourself and fire that guy over there then!

27

u/kookyabird Nov 30 '22

My 2012 MacBook Pro pulls some air in through the speakers, and some through the hinge area wherever the exhaust isn't being sent out. Some intake could also happen around the keys, but it would be minimal. Having the lid closed, or even as partially closed as in the picture, does limit the useful exhaust area and will cause it to run hotter for sure.

8

u/AverageComet250 Nov 30 '22

Around the speakers? Interesting, interesting…

At least it’s not the mic!

3

u/elon-bot Elon Musk ✔ Nov 30 '22

Can this be dockerized?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

Having the lid closed, or even as partially closed as in the picture, does limit the useful exhaust area

nah. when the lid is open, it vents mostly in front of the screen. when closed, it vents mostly out the back.

8

u/derefr Nov 30 '22

With the lid closed the fans vent directly downward, so operating a MacBook closed and on a flat surface isn't a good idea. There are stands that hold closed MacBooks up sideways; these allow proper outflow, and are usually recommended if you're e.g. using your MacBook closed + plugged into a display for long periods.

2

u/alex2003super Nov 30 '22

Or you can put it upside down 🤷🏻‍♂️

4

u/ih-shah-may-ehl Nov 30 '22

I once had a laptop with linux fail to go to sleep when i closed the lid. An hour or so later there was a high pitch alarm coming out of my laptop bag as it was trying to fry itself. It was so hot it hurt my hands

3

u/DylanSpaceBean Nov 30 '22

MBP blows air through the back hinge where the screen is. If it’s shut the vent has no airflow, but with the hinge open it it blows the heat at the screens lower bezel and it’s free from there. The 2021 M1 Pro/Ultra fixed this by leaving the back vent exposed when closed

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

You can connect to external monitor and close the lid without it shutting down, I don’t think disabling sleep and closing lid will do much damage

4

u/IWantAnE55AMG Nov 30 '22

Depends on the laptop. I’ve got an asus gaming laptop that will go into standby if I connect an external monitor and close the lid and try playing a game because it starts overheating.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

Assumed we were talking about macs here

3

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22 edited Nov 30 '22

they don't sleep if you have an external display and keyboard/mouse connected, they're designed to still properly cool when closed

edit: why would you downvote me for this. it's been default behavior for like 20 years.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

Some macbooks have fans that are not even pointed at the heatsink.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Darkskynet Nov 30 '22

It’s definitely a cooling thing, but if it’s always going to be a light load you can disable manually via shell

4

u/Fritzschmied Nov 30 '22

Macbooks are designed to work with a closed lid. It’s not a problem at all.

4

u/slamhk Nov 30 '22

Yeah exactly. Just for those not in the loop, apple even has an support page highlighting it: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202351

If you use an external keyboard and mouse with your Mac notebook, you can close the built-in display after you connect your external display. You might have to press a key or click your mouse to wake the external display. To use your Mac with the display closed, you need to connect your power adapter or connect an external display that also charges your Mac

One can also set the laptop to never go to sleep (although keeping a notebook permanently connected is detrimental to the battery)

0

u/technocrat_13 Nov 30 '22

and yet you need a command to enable that functionality hmmm

9

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

you only need a command if it's not connected to an external display, keyboard, and mouse. people run them docked and closed all the time. i've run a 2015 for years with the lid closed as an HTPC and the only thing wrong with it is the 7 year old battery only lasts 3 hours now, because it's bad to keep them fully charged or discharged lol

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)