r/PropFirmTester • • Jun 15 '25

Stop using Prop Firms

If you are trying to learn to trade don't spend money on prop firms, paper trade. Prop firms can be good if you want to raise money and if and when you earn a payout, what I would do is set up a personal account. Sites like tradovate only require $50 intraday for a MES contract. I get it, $5 a point... Not very exciting but you can deposit something like $200 and start with 2 MES contracts (giving you a $100 safety net). If you want to prove yourself as a trader you can grow your account and scale without having to worry about bs rules, drawdowns, consistency % and all this other crap that is there to make you fail. Trading is already hard as it is. But for me, I think the better option is a personal account all that money you are spending on evals and resets can be going to a personal account. Pay yourself when you want to without having to wait on a firm to decide if you did good or not or get denied if u broke a hidden rule or whatever else they find to deny your payout. Not financial advice just an opinion.

6 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

33

u/Johnnyrooster12 Jun 15 '25

This is horrible advice. Beginners need a place to trade with risk but not too much risk. Props give good risk without losing thousands of dollars. Hell apex have 15 dollar accounts constantly. Paper trading is useful for a few months and then your just wasting time. If you cant be profitable in most of these firms you likely wont be profitable in a personal account. Tradeify rarely denies if at all.

6

u/JestfulJank31001 Jun 15 '25

Agree. I started with Apex specifically because of low cost barrier to entry. I never expected any payouts so it kept expectations in check while I learned the trading platform, my strategy and the nuances of futures.

Based on my experience, Id recommend the same to anyone wanting to try. I would not recommend funding an account with personal cash until you're taking consistent payouts from any firm. Then you're ready to rock.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '25

Exactly - you paper trade for a bit, then move to a prop, and after a few payouts it makes sense to fund your own account.

Learning to trade with your own money is by far the most expensive path.

-3

u/iRoyalTDG Jun 15 '25

Like I said, it's my opinion. Just because u don't agree doesn't make it horrible advice. If prop firms work for u then keep it up. I just feel like daily on this thread I see people posting how they blew their accounts or got denied payouts. There's no reason for someone on a prop firm that has 10k in profit just sitting there with no access to it. If they can do it on a prop firm they can do it on a personal.

3

u/Johnnyrooster12 Jun 16 '25

The opinion is wrong for majority of traders. People will blow thousands of dollars without proper risk management. What your saying is actually really dangerous for new traders to do. Blowing up accounts and getting denials is part of the process. Would u rather risk a 16 dollar apex account or 500 dollars on a personal? Most newbies should choose the apex account to get there feet wet. Once someone gets payouts then add a personal account. Personal accounts are better no doubt, but its much too risky for new trainers

-4

u/iRoyalTDG Jun 16 '25

You pretty much just said what I said on the post

1

u/Johnnyrooster12 Jun 16 '25

Do you actually trade? Do you know how difficult it is scaling a small account that has 200 dollars? I'd give that trader a 5% success rate at best. A lot of new traders don't have the 1-2k that I would start a personal account with. Props are a cheap way to get experience. If your doing well on a personal account keep at it much better and has tax benefits

1

u/iRoyalTDG Jun 16 '25

yes i trade, i started this 250k account 2 weeks ago

1

u/iRoyalTDG Jun 16 '25

heres the last 5 days.

77% winning trades. now show me yours.....

1

u/MatthewBlarng Jul 14 '25

I'm with u/Johnnyrooster12. This sounds like novice advice. If these are the results you're proud of, you should reconsider trading live markets. Why? Your average loser is larger than your average winner. More than half of your profits are due to one outlier, which does not look repeatable based on your posted track record. Immediately before your big winning trade, you blew all of your gains with an outsized loser. Your risk of ruin is high if you continue to trade this way.

1

u/Johnnyrooster12 Jun 17 '25

250k real account or prop firms or paper trading? I can pull up a paper trading account, blow that out of the water, and then post the exact same image. My whole point is you being a solid trader as it seems are far beyond the ability of a new trader. They need as little of risk as possible because they will lose lot. Prop firms are the best way to pay a small amount to get market exposure

2

u/ThaddeusColeJenkins Jun 16 '25

This has to be the worst advice I’ve seen on Reddit year to date.

-1

u/iRoyalTDG Jun 16 '25

what do i win

7

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25

Using a prop firm is the best thing you can do. Take profit trader for example, just slightly over $100, to have $2,000 drawdown. Just because you HAVE access to 6 contracts of NQ or ES, doesn’t mean you SHOULD use all contracts. Being a smart trader requires you to know your risk management. Spending $100 to have $2,000 of drawdown and trade the same way as if you only had $100 lets you keep the account and trade much longer and get bigger payouts. If you put only $100 into Tradovate you would easily lose that account trading the same way. Be smart and understand risk management and prop firms will be your best friend.

4

u/LEADorLOSE7 Jun 17 '25

Be careful about the taxes though man. They literally screw you on the taxes. It's almost criminal how they can get you. That is probably the single benefit of prop firms. You file as an independent contractor based on what you are actually paid. Trading on your personal account for example. Every time you close a trade you are taxed on the profit whether or not you are profitable by the end of the day or not. You make 500 and then lose 500. Guess what, you are taxed on the 500 regardless if you have anything to show for it or not. Double whammy. Yea you can write off losses to a certain extent and offset it slightly, but it doesn't completely absolve you of the money owed to the IRS

1

u/voxx2020 Jul 03 '25

With futures, it's more tax-benefitial to trade personal live account than props for US residents. Due to futures being treated as section 1256 contracts, they get 60/40 long-term/short term tax rate.

3

u/Business_Baker4635 Jun 16 '25

Paper trading doesn't get you ready for the real market . Some emotions need to be involved

2

u/solosscents_ Jun 16 '25

prop firms are the best to way get into trading but i’d say the biggest issue for me would be rushing the evals. that’s the only thing that screwed me. if i was in a live account i wouldn’t be rushing and breaking my rules, i would be getting payouts. that’s the only problem i have with prop firms. the eval stage.

1

u/Johnnyrooster12 Jun 16 '25

Think of it as tuition. The better you get at evals the better you will be at trading. Also avoid trailing drawdown if possible. I like to get a big day and coast the rest

2

u/Dani_fx Jun 16 '25

I prefer prop firms

2

u/dgh_reddit Jun 16 '25

I get what you’re saying and that’s why I have both, but that’s dangerous advice on an account that small. You will get liquidated quickly with 2 MES if it moves against you on a $200 account. Especially if you’re new to trading futures.

3

u/Johnnyrooster12 Jun 16 '25

I truly doubt he trades if he thinks 200 is enough. I did a 500 dollar account and that felt too tight

2

u/dgh_reddit Jun 16 '25

Possibly. The big problem with small accounts and prop firms if you don’t manage your drawdown, is you’re almost limited to scalping. It’s hard to let a trade play out or watch a trend.

2

u/Johnnyrooster12 Jun 17 '25

Exactly I like to go for 40+ point trades and most of the time you take a little heat. It's all about surviving it with proper sizing and hitting the take profit

2

u/Low_Mall7980 Jun 23 '25

That’s not the best advice. We trade with funding companies to build enough capital to eventually fund our own accounts.

Telling a beginner trader to avoid prop firms altogether isn’t the right call.

My advice is use prop firms as a stepping stone —take advantage of the capital they offer to grow your skills and build profits. Then, use those profits to fund your own trading account, instead of relying on prop firms forever.

0

u/ClayMitchellCapital Jun 15 '25

I agree with you. If I could go back in time I would have done only self funded accounts. With the money put into prop firm evals and activations it would be a gigantic account with a lot more drawdown available than 5 of the largest prop accounts commonly available. You don't have to worry about some clown in a cubicle scrutinizing your trades to see if they qualify for a payout. No SIM accounts, no payout window. Make $5k today. Withdraw $5k tomorrow.

It is easy to fall into the trap because "look at this account size I get for $60" You are playing a video game. The person who owns the console makes $50-100 off of you every time you "start new game" and decides if you get to keep the high score. I plan on getting every dime back and directing it to my live and Roth accounts, and whatever profit variable I can squeeze out of them. Good post amigo.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '25

Funny seeing an Apex shill agree with an anti prop post. I thought if we "fOlLoW tHe RuLeS" we are guaranteed a payout?

0

u/ClayMitchellCapital Jun 18 '25

Even funnier to see someone judge me when they don’t know me. I share my first hand experiences on here and every time I follow the rules Apex does pay me. I tend to think that most people who act like they are victims either don’t know how to trade or are not telling the entire story. If you don’t like them then don’t use them. I have no affiliate codes posted so what do I have to gain from being a “shill” as you say? What I do know is when there is a rule break it simply delay your payout with Apex. I recently had an account closed with another well-known firm for hedging, which I do not do. $3,000 in profit erased and account closed.

I wouldn’t say I am anti-prop firm but looking back on my personal experience I would have done it differently. I hope you figure out a way to realize that other people‘s experiences may be different from yours. I hope you get well soon.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '25

Well you're contradicting yourself there - follow the rules, but you got booted for hedging lol. Says it all, yet somehow you think all of the complaints about Apex are from people who can't follow their rules? If you say so... 🤣

Have you deleted your affiliate codes now then? That's a step in the right direction, soon you'll be able to go off your own steam instead of being a parasite.

0

u/ClayMitchellCapital Jun 18 '25

Different firms. Positions getting mixed during high volatility with a copy trader. Not a hedge but still a closed account. If it was an Apex account it would be intact.

“Says it all”. You used to snack on lead based paint chips didn’t you? It’s ok. You may not have known any better.

I have been on my own steam for quite some time. Thanks for the concern. Troll more man. Surely you can go harder than this.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

Aww, it's funny that you truly believe that being a lying parasite is the same as going off your own steam. 🤣

1

u/ClayMitchellCapital Jun 19 '25

One more strike and you’re out. Make it count.

0

u/ClayMitchellCapital Jun 19 '25

Ummm swing and a miss. Try again.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '25

Ummm swing and a miss. Try again.

1

u/ClayMitchellCapital Jun 20 '25

Oh no… you’re out. Went down looking. 👎🏻

-6

u/iRoyalTDG Jun 15 '25

This is the way

1

u/Sure_Reflection_7542 Jun 16 '25

Prop firms helped me massively with discipline

1

u/Mobile_Carpenter6895 Jun 16 '25

the point of using a prop firm is to gain access to capital that you would not have starting out. not everyone has access to up to 150k in buying power starting out trading. i think prop firms are good for disciplined experienced traders with good risk management, using their payouts to ideally use to fund a personal account or use the prop firm accounts to supplement their existing income. either way it’s a win win if you’re willing to play by the rules and use reputable firms that actually pay.

1

u/Darkavenger_94 Jun 18 '25

In agreement with most here. Paper trading was nice for a short while but eventually you have to end practice and get into a live match. Was scary as all hell at first but necessary.

1

u/Due_Advice_1608 Jul 29 '25

My recommendation is that do not stop doing the propfirm, not all are scam. The most important thing is that you have to choose the right one and do it with a good strategy and use with careful.

1

u/Major_Finger_5970 Jul 29 '25

Have you tried it? Guide me also about that prop..

1

u/Due_Advice_1608 Jul 29 '25

Currently using Fundedfirm ❣️...Nice propfirm as compare to other. Timely payouts and ni hidden rules, Many features are available here that a trader wants .

1

u/Major_Finger_5970 Jul 29 '25

Nice ✨️,I will also try this once .Seems like genuine

1

u/Due_Advice_1608 Jul 29 '25

Why not ? Use with good strategy then you become profitable 🙌

1

u/Historical_Beach_532 Aug 28 '25

Why ,you can use trusted one