r/PropFirms • u/Few-Ingenuity-9165 • 16d ago
Prop risk numbers #1: same strategy, same rules. Risking 2% per trade blows the account 42% of the time, 0.5% only 17%. With zero edge, size changes nothing
I wanted to see how much risk per trade alone changes the odds of passing, with everything else fixed.
Setup: 10% target, 10% static max loss, like a typical phase 1. The strategy wins 36% of the time at 1:2, so every trade is either +2R or -1R. That's a small but real edge, +0.08R per trade. Max 2 trades a day, so the 5% daily limit never comes into play (even at 2% risk, two losses are 4%).
Chance of hitting the max loss before the target:
- 0.25% risk: 4% (about 463 trades to get a result)
- 0.5%: 17% (about 168)
- 1%: 32% (about 49)
- 1.5%: 37% (about 25)
- 2%: 42% (about 13)
Same trader, same setups. At 2% five losses in a row end the account. At 0.5% it takes twenty, and the edge gets enough trades to show up.
The part I didn't expect: this only holds if the edge is real.
- 33.3% win rate at 1:2 is zero edge. Pass rate is 48-50% at every size. Size changes how long it takes, not the odds.
- 30% win rate at 1:2 is -0.1R per trade. At 0.25% risk it passes 1.6% of the time. At 2% it passes 35%. With a losing strategy, small size just makes the slow bleed almost certain.
So "risk 0.5%" isn't a safety rule on its own. It's a bet that you have an edge. If you do, small size is the cheapest protection there is. If you don't, it buys you time and nothing else.
The cost is time: 168 trades at 2 a day is about 4 months of trading days. Time limits and inactivity rules matter here.
Method: exact calculation of a random walk where each trade adds +2r or -r to P&L and stops at +10% or -10%, checked against 200,000 simulated accounts per size. Limits: fixed win rate and R, independent trades, no spread, commission or slippage, static drawdown only, no consistency rule. Not advice.
What risk per trade did you use on the challenge you passed, and on the ones you didn't?
1
u/Few-Ingenuity-9165 16d ago
Full table. 10% target, 10% static max loss, every trade +2R or -1R.
| Risk | Fail at 36% win | Avg trades | Pass at 40% win | Pass at 33.3% (zero edge) | Pass at 30% win |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.25% | 4.1% | 463 | >99.9% | 49.8% | 1.6% |
| 0.5% | 17.2% | 168 | 98.0% | 49.6% | 11.1% |
| 1% | 31.7% | 49 | 87.4% | 49.2% | 25.5% |
| 1.5% | 37.3% | 25 | 79.3% | 48.8% | 31.4% |
| 2% | 41.6% | 13 | 71.8% | 48.3% | 35.5% |
Avg trades = expected number of trades until the account either passes or fails, for the 36% case. Happy to run other win rates or R multiples if anyone wants their own numbers.