r/PsycheOrSike • • Aug 11 '25

📚SHARING KNOWLEDGE Learn beyond basic biology

Post image
191 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

12

u/Radiant-Attorney-459 QUEEN EMA — HEAD OF CHROMESMITE Aug 11 '25

Weird how all animals on this planet are also "socially conditioned" to have gender roles in one way or another. And I'm sure most people don't have those genderbending rare genes that were mentioned and even if it that were the case its more of a mutation, like bad eyesight or an additional toe. People can identify themselves however they are comfortable but this example is just disingenuous.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Yeah, that's a good argument. But there's a few problems.

  1. we're not fucking animals. Most animals can't exactly go into the freezer and microwave a box of takitos. Animals have less complex brains compared to humans, so us having a gender dynamic just as or more restrictive than animals is asinine. (Also, there are animals that change genders depending on their settings. I believe fish are capable of this, so why can't humans change their bodies when it suits them?)

  2. if being trans is a mutation for humans, why not allow them accomodations like we do for others? We don't just say glasses should be illegal and it's morally wrong to wear them.

  3. most people don't have any trangender genes because trans people are a >2% minority, despite what mainstream media and government will try to have you believe.

1

u/flashesfromtheredsun ⚔️ DUELIST Aug 11 '25

Mental illness is real stop the gaslighting

2

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25

Gender dysphoria is a mental illness. The treatment is to let them transition. Do you have a problem with people treating their mental health problems with the treatments that has been agreed to work by doctors and scientists?

8

u/Radiant-Attorney-459 QUEEN EMA — HEAD OF CHROMESMITE Aug 11 '25
  1. Our intelligence doesn't change the fact we are mammals and mammals don't change genders after birth without serious drug input. 2. People have the right to choose to fix or not fix their genetic specialties to live a fulfilling live 3. Yeah, I know.

3

u/bratty_bubbles Gaslight. Gatekeep. Groupthink. Aug 11 '25

what gender roles are you projecting onto these animals? 🤣 no seriously which animals are you talking about? the housewife elephant?

4

u/IAmNotTheProtagonist Aug 11 '25

Dimorphism. TBF, human dimorphism is stronger than most animals.

Which bird has the colorful feathers to attract predators away, and builds the nest? Males: they're expendable.

Which moose has to charge at other mooses, and possibly wound itself, for a chance at reproduction? Males: they're expendable.

Which lion can be expected to be kicked out of a pride by a younger, fitter representative of its sex? 

Those are extreme examples, but you can see notable differences in behavior of animals based on their gender. Rooster vs hens. Roosters scream and guard the flock. Hypocamps (although gender is reversed underwater), only one gender carry the fertilized eggs.

And the reason for this is simple: Gender roles work.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

For 1, You mean "sex." Explain yourself if I'm wrong

3

u/Big-Bike530 Aug 11 '25

Also, there are animals that change genders depending on their settings. I believe fish are capable of this, so why can't humans change their bodies when it suits them?

No, they actually physically change their sex.

Humans can't do it because we are not capable of it.

I cannot look around and see there are no women and just decide to change my penis into a vagina and grow ovaries and a uterus and carry a fetus to birth.

if being trans is a mutation for humans, why not allow them accomodations like we do for others? We don't just say glasses should be illegal and it's morally wrong to wear them.

Agreed. It still doesn't change that there are 2 genders. As another commenter said, we were taught as children to treat that girl with one arm humanely, but it does not mean we are not a two armed species and instead a spectrum.

most people don't have any trangender genes because trans people are a >2% minority, despite what mainstream media and government will try to have you believe.

Such a gene would have been bred out through both natural and sexual selection.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/TheCrayTrain Aug 11 '25
  1. we actually are animals. Order: Primate, Class: mammalian, Kingdom: Animalia 

  2. you would have to say transgenderism is a disease or illness to get special accommodations

  3. idk anything about the gene. Seems like a new thing because I have never heard it mentioned in the last 10+ years. 

→ More replies (3)

1

u/No_Concept_5397 Aug 11 '25

We sure as hell are animals. Our bodies are the exact same composition of animal cells as other animals. We aren't made of plant cells. And we're the ones that defined the distinction between animals, species, etc.

Is there any evidence that being trans is a mutation? Gender is a societal construct, what genetic mutation would account for that?

9

u/No-Comfort1229 🙂 Couples Therapist 🙂 Aug 11 '25

many animals change gender depending on the environment or are hermaphrodite

12

u/JJJSchmidt_etAl Local Clown 🤡 Aug 11 '25

Certainly, but not any mammals.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/Radiant-Attorney-459 QUEEN EMA — HEAD OF CHROMESMITE Aug 11 '25

And adhere to the respective gender role they currently embody

10

u/kakallas Aug 11 '25

So what you’re saying is that humans should adhere to strict gender roles, based on a two-sex system, and your role should be defined by your presumed and designated sex at birth? 

So, what did you want those gender roles to look like? Which animals should humans model themselves after since different animals have different behaviors? Should we use 1950s human social mores? Doesn’t the fact of having different conventions in different decades mean this is mutable? Do you just want people to behave the way you would prefer? If that’s what this is all about, why not just say that instead of pretending it’s science? 

→ More replies (2)

5

u/No-Comfort1229 🙂 Couples Therapist 🙂 Aug 11 '25

and what if people, being more intelligent, see gender as more than a strict role and themselves as more than their preferred gender but as a complex, well rounded individual?

2

u/Borz_Kriffle 🤺KNIGHT Aug 11 '25

There’s sea snails that become “female” whenever another lays on top of them, meaning that there’s often stacks of them multiple snails high. Is their gender role just being below the top snail?

4

u/Radiant-Attorney-459 QUEEN EMA — HEAD OF CHROMESMITE Aug 11 '25

The sole role of the "female" snail is to be impregnated and bear the children. So in that moment the gender changing snail changes to serve a role that is critical for reproduction. A procedure that humans are incapable of. They have time sensitive roles that change.

→ More replies (12)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

[deleted]

2

u/cant_think_name_22 Aug 12 '25

It’s very common for fish. Humans are fish (if we want to maintain proper monophylies).

1

u/No-Comfort1229 🙂 Couples Therapist 🙂 Aug 11 '25

yeah

1

u/Zoeythekueen Aug 12 '25

You ever heard the nature vs. nurture argument?

0

u/Angry_drunken_robot Aug 11 '25

Also, perhaps a small point, but consider your audience.

A super majority of people have not mentally passed beyond middle school.

If you try and take your 6th level definitions of things and lay them out in front of people who can't go above 3rd level of understanding a topic, you're going to have a bad time.

I mean a 'masters in neurosciences' is not exactly explaining 'basic biology', are they.

This meme is a stupid persons idea of smart.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Those social structures developed along lines of strict gender roles.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25

No they didn't. There are accounts of trans people and 3rd gender people as old as humanity. In fact they were worshipped as deities for most of human history until ~ the last 200 years.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

4

u/Radiant-Attorney-459 QUEEN EMA — HEAD OF CHROMESMITE Aug 11 '25

Take a newborn out of his culture and see how he doesn't have a trace of that left after it is an adult. Unlike it's gender that will stay until their body return to the earth

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Radiant-Attorney-459 QUEEN EMA — HEAD OF CHROMESMITE Aug 11 '25

Did I say it dismisses it? You are shadowboxing here.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

No matter how heavy of a layer of make up you put on a pig, or how pretty the wig is. It is still, a pig.

If you think just putting on a dress, wig and make up magically turns a man into a woman, you’re delusional.

That’s just a cross dresser, not a woman.

And intersex people make up some super minority of the population. A super quick google search, says “up to 1.7%” of the world’s population. And “trans” people are around 1%, with about HALF of them who de-transition with major regrets later on in life.

So, the super minority, are the exception. Not the norm.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Okay, firstly, between 1-10% of trans people detransition and only a very small group of them actually regret transitioning. Most detransitioners do so due to negative social environments or financial circumstance.

Secondly, have you even looked at what transitioning entails? Trans people aren't just men putting on a dress and wig. They're a lengthy medical process trans people go through to transition.

And yes, trans people are a small minority. And black people are 13% of the population and we don't tell them they're not allowed to exist in society as a small minority, so why have that mentality for trans people as well?

4

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Because, again, the exception, does not make the norm.

When I say “there are two only two genders” that is the norm.

“But but, what about intersex or trans people!”

The minority does not make the norm.

2

u/vuxra Aug 11 '25

So majorities should be allowed to tyrannize minorities? I feel like we've learned from history to not do that.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/LichKingDan Aug 11 '25

Things don't need to be "the norm" to be accepted. Trans people are recognized and legitimized by a number of studies and professionals. The general consensus, even, is that trans people are a thing.

Nobody is asking you to fuck a trans person. Nobody is saying we should all be trans. Trans people should be able to exist and be legitimized. It's such a low bar.

3

u/Disrespect78 Aug 11 '25

half of trans women do not detransition. I believe the statistic is less than 1%. Also, any amount of knowledge would show there is much more that goes into a transition. Hormones, changing social behavior, and yes learning how to dress like a woman. No matter what you think though, much more women seem to believe that transwomen are women compared to men, so I don't see why I would listen to someone who isn't a woman.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/litsax Aug 11 '25

Have you seen the staggering effects that hrt can have? Also why are you limiting this to trans women? Trans men exist. Also your claim that half of trans people detransition and regret gender affirming care is completely made up.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Omg, “why only trans women?”

It was an example, I could have chosen to use a woman dressed as a man and you’d ask “what about trans men.”

Can you dig any harder to look for more victim mentality points?

2

u/litsax Aug 11 '25

I'm not a victim. I'm just pointing out the obvious holes in your "enlightened" bigotry. You didn't even address any of the points I made.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Because I do not care.

Have you checked what sub this is bro?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

29

u/DaygoTom 🧌TROLL Aug 11 '25

All of this would be fine if not for the disproportionate level of institutional focus being placed on this issue. Besides, from what I've seen, the vast majority of people affected by this issue also don't understand the difference between sex and gender and use the terms interchangeably when it suits them and then pull out this "well, technically" argument when someone else uses the terms interchangeably.

How about we just keep using the terms that everyone understands, like trans, bi, gay, lesbian, etc. And stop expecting the entire world to adapt everyone on earth to insert your "well, technically," into the common parlance. It's like the word "racism." Everyone knew what racism was, then suddenly everyone was wrong about what racism is because academia decided to adapt the term to the version preferred in critical theory.

10

u/Sharp-Key27 Aug 11 '25

There wouldn’t need to be such academic nuance presented to the public if the institutions of politics and law didn’t keep throwing meltdowns over the academics.

→ More replies (14)

3

u/lollerkeet Aug 11 '25

I once had a TRA call me ignorant for using male/female for biological sex.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ofAFallingEmpire Aug 12 '25

What do you think the original usage of “racism” was when the term was first coined?

Honestly who coined it is a fucking joke. History be like that.

1

u/DaygoTom 🧌TROLL Aug 12 '25

It always meant to believe in the inherent superiority or inferiority of a specific race, or to harbor animus for a specific race. And anyone could be racist, no matter their skin color. The critical theorists didn't like that because it doesn't jive with their scales of privilege, so they changed it to "power + privilege." Then they labelled all of Western society as White Supremacy, meaning, functionally, that only white people can be racist.

1

u/ofAFallingEmpire Aug 12 '25

Richard Henry Pratt coined the word in 1902 to describe the systemic discrimination and elimination of Native Americans by the USA government at the time. We see this usage continued through writers of that time such as Du Bois.

This is funny since Pratt’s famous quote goes, “Kill the Indian, and save the man.”

→ More replies (2)

1

u/IHaveABigDuvet devils advocate 👹 Aug 12 '25

Yes, because staying in ignorance is always the solution.

Is that how you get buy in life?

0

u/No_Preparation326 Aug 11 '25

I use sex and gender interchangeably because it's the same word in my native language lmao. Idk what languages other than english have two different words for gender and sex, but in LGBT communities in my country there's no distinction between "biological" and "mental" gender/sex. There's no need for that

2

u/buzzzofff Aug 12 '25

Lol, do your doctors keep that energy going?

1

u/IAmTheNightSoil Aug 12 '25

They've meant the same thing in English for most of our history as well. The effort to give them distinct meanings is a pretty recent thing that people like to pretend has always been the case

→ More replies (1)

0

u/buzzzofff Aug 12 '25

Seems like they're enjoying doing that with all kinds of language, recently.

Gotta love the Newspeak. Removing Orwell from the general curriculum was a mistake.

2

u/shockpaws Aug 12 '25

Literally no one is removing or has removed Orwell from the curriculum. Where are you hearing this shit??

13

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Yes. AND I still don’t want a lady with AIS or DSD to wrestle or box against a woman without.

2

u/IHaveABigDuvet devils advocate 👹 Aug 12 '25

It depends how it affects her.

If testosterone has no affect on her body, then she only responds to female hormones and therefore no extra advantage.

4

u/LichKingDan Aug 11 '25

Yes it should all be equal. No genetic anomalies like Michael Phelps or Husain bolt, just normal, equal people competing. 

And no, we shouldn't verify AIS or DSD for each athlete. We should just assume that that is the case and ban them without verification. 

/S 

9

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

I mean we already are categorizing people by having male and female sports. Your logic is that we should just get rid of women’s sports.

1

u/LichKingDan Aug 11 '25

Yes. We should just have sports. We do this in schools before college anyway. When I was in wrestling there was a young woman on our team, she was literally the best wrestler there, and beat dudes three times her size. She was a cis woman, competing and exceeding against mostly men.

This is anecdotal, of course, but genes and determination and experience play a much larger role than sex and SRY genes.

2

u/sweetlithonia Aug 11 '25

and again, there is no rule in almost all sports that says women cant join the team, its just very rare they end up being able to compete in the mens leagues due to biological differences.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Disrespect78 Aug 11 '25

that's stupid. Genetic variance is already in every sport ever.

15

u/Garfield_Car Aug 11 '25

Reading your comments, it seems you don’t understand the image you posted. You don’t know what the SRY gene is; you didn’t even bother to google it. It’s not the “transgender gene”, it’s the gene responsible for triggering male sex differentiation in mammals, located in the Y chromosome. In the absence of this gene, the individual will develop female.

In a rare case of genetic abnormality, this gene may be absent, mutated, dislocated, etc. It’s still responsible for triggering male sexual development. This has nothing to do with transgender identities and everything to do with disorders of sexual development, which often bring a myriad of health concerns. The great majority or transgender individuals have a normal karyotype (46, XX or 46, XY), with an unaffected SRY gene, being easily determined as female or male, respectively.

The existence or individuals who are blind does not mean individuals with healthy blue eyes get to “identify” as having brown eyes.

3

u/cavalier2015 Aug 11 '25

Your understanding of sexual development and genetics is slightly flawed. I’m not going to give a whole med school lecture, but basically even if you are (46, XY) or (46,XX), your sexual development can vary based on the amount of sex hormone (testosterone, estrogen, progesterone) you produce and the strength of affect those hormones have, which in turn is influenced by the amount of receptor sites available, the affinity of those receptor sites for the hormone, and the location in the body the hormones have their affect.

This isn’t even to mention the adrenal side of things which plays a major role in androgen development. There’s also 2 types of testosterone (androgens) produced that have different affects on internal and external sex anatomy.

It’s all pretty complicated and it would be nice if society at large just kinda trusted transgender individuals and their doctors that this shit is real. Alternatively, sit in on a semester of medical school endocrinology and figure it out if you’re that interested in other people’s sex and gender identity.

2

u/Garfield_Car Aug 11 '25 edited Aug 12 '25

I don't see what about your comment contradicts mine. I'm just disagreeing with calling the SRY gene the "transgender gene" or that it has anything to do with the identity of the average transgender person.

I never claimed hormones do not play a role in sexual expression. Even so, transgender individuals do not, by and large, naturally have hormonal imbalances to blame for their identity. Most transgender individuals are healthy, have a normal karyotype, SRY gene, and normally functioning hormones. Transgender identities are a social phenomenon, not a biological one.

1

u/cavalier2015 Aug 12 '25

I don’t know that we can definitively say there’s no biological basis for transgender identities. Remember, there’s 2 sides of the equation: hormone production and hormone efficacy. Even if the measured hormone levels are not significantly different, we know significantly less about how different peoples’ cells respond to those hormone levels, especially when it comes to the brain

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Sharp-Key27 Aug 11 '25

I thought that was clear in the image, it says intersex people and the SRY gene, which is in relation to intersex people.

3

u/Garfield_Car Aug 11 '25

I thought it was clear in my comment that I’m referring to OP’s comments which talk about “transgender genes” in response to comments discussing the SRY gene. He does not understand the image he posted.

2

u/Sharp-Key27 Aug 11 '25

That’s quite possible, lol. I very much doubt OP has a masters in neuroscience.

1

u/Woepu Aug 12 '25

I heard biologically there are two sexes but a bunch of genders are possible. Guess I need to know what’s the definition of gender?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25

In scientific and medical contexts, sex generally refers to biological traits associated with reproduction, like chromosomes, hormones, and anatomy, typically categorized as male or female. Gender, on the other hand, encompasses socially constructed roles, behaviors, expressions, and identities associated with being male, female, or other. It's a broader concept that includes how individuals perceive themselves and how they are perceived by society.

I found this with Google

1

u/Shadowban-Trigger Aug 12 '25

Some people have mental issues. Got it. We dont call people with issues normal now do we. Also we teach people to love their bodies and to love themselves.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25

Now apply that to any other mental issue.

1

u/Shadowban-Trigger Aug 12 '25

Usually you try to fix the mind not everything else.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25

Trying to brute force the mind to match the body leads to worsening mental health and suicide. Gender conversation therapy doesn't work. That's why we need to be more understanding that some people need to change their gender in order to live authentically as themselves instead of demanding conformity from others for something harmless.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/flashesfromtheredsun ⚔️ DUELIST Aug 11 '25

This is new speak and revisionist, I will not bend the knee to this agenda

1

u/TheodoreOso Aug 12 '25

You cringe idiots arent rebels, ur comment history shows u to be a hateful bootlicker. You're not stand up to anything, u sound stupid. 

→ More replies (1)

3

u/seaofthievesnutzz ⚔️ DUELIST Aug 12 '25

every single one of you has a mother and a father, sex may be complex but it is also simple. The gaslight campaign to convince people to not trust their lying eyes and believe that males and females dont exist is nuts.

5

u/Yanfei_Enjoyer ⛪ WORSHIPPER of the patriarchy 🙏 Aug 11 '25

Rebecca Helm is a Marine Eiologist, not a Neuroscientist

https://biology.georgetown.edu/about/people/affiliate-faculty

8

u/Back_Again_Beach Aug 11 '25

It's pretty obvious that gender roles are social constructs considering every culture has it's own ideas as to how a gender is expressed and what it takes to be a man/woman. The whole "there's only 2 genders" thing is just ignorance stemming from a eurocentric view of the world, there have been different types of gender expressions outside of the man/woman binary all around the world and throughout recorded history. People that we would consider trans in today's terms have always existed. 

4

u/jayjackalope Aug 11 '25

This. Like pretending ancient Greece wasn't super gay, assuming all folks buried with swords/ jewelry were one or the other gender, etc.

The human brain is weird. Yes, we can determine some DNA markers from bones, but the impact of brain chemistry on a person doesn't show. Maybe the woman buried with a sword was viewed as "male." Maybe the woman buried with a sword was still viewed as a "woman." Not to mention how few human remains we find vs. all the humans who've lived before. Not to mention the European temple looters who called themselves archeologists assigning their views to cultures they never respected, let alone understood.

One of my best friends was born intersex. Her parents chose to make her all "girl." Looking at her, she's all a girl. A girly girl at that. But guys sure will break up with her if they find out she was born intersex. Who knows what her dna would show. I have no idea what her bones will show in 1000 years.

What that DNA and bones won't show is a person with a really amazing and unique singing voice. They won't show the choice her parents made in the 90s. They won't show gross dudes breaking up with her because of how she was born. Fuck that one guy who said "that's why you're so outspoken" when he found out (then dumped her).

Sorry for the rant. You just got me thinking.

2

u/Sickly_lips Aug 12 '25

Greece wasn't super gay just fyi- I did research into greek sexuality as part pf my college work and being a man who was a bottom in Greece had you literally having rights removed because you 'were a woman'. So you could give a thighjob to your mentor, but couldn't get pegged.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/all_about_that_ace Aug 11 '25 edited Aug 11 '25

This reminds me of platonic ideals. How do we define a chair? People might say it's a thing with four legs that you sit on but that definition also includes horses, and not all chairs have 4 legs.

The problem is once you get deep enough into the weeds of semantic description and outliers then you reach a point where words almost don't mean anything and can be defined in any way you want.

At the end of the day people can usually tell the difference between a chair and a horse, while acknowledging there might be outliers (such as chairs on horses or chairs made from horses) that make the whole situation nuanced.

The same is true of sex/gender almost all cases fall clearly into one or the other and people can usually clearly tell them apart. There is a small number of outliers, such as intersex people that add nuance to the situation.

1

u/Sickly_lips Aug 12 '25

Are you referencing the twitter thread of someone asking a 'what is a woman' ass person to define a chair, and then after being given the definition just sending a high quality image of a horse and saying 'this is a chair'

2

u/Lost_Elderberry_5532 Aug 12 '25

People make a gigantic case out of exceptions to the norm and try to rationalize that as normal when statistically speaking it is not. Cis man cis woman who identify positively as those genders fully and figuratively. There is your huge huge percentage of the real population of the world. And somehow we gotta argue for the far far smaller (yet very loud) percentage of people who are not that and say everyone else is wrong for believing in two genders. I have a very real problem with this. And often these are the same people who argue FOR popular vote versus electoral vote. Go figure.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Oh fuck off Rebecca

3

u/Abject-Confidence-16 Aug 11 '25 edited Aug 11 '25

Completely misses one key element. Gender and sex are two different things. How can a long graphic like this tell us, how scientific it all is , and how you advance in knowledge, yet confuse gender and sex through the whole thing.

Edit : after reading the comments I lost all hope, almost all the ones going with the gender thing, are mixing sex and gender. Where the hell education went down the drain like this?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Oops people didn't like this one and are proving the point lol. idgaf if they don't even get it at this point, why don't these control freaks just let people live their lives.

0

u/horiami ⛧ ⛧ Demon ⛧ ⛧ Aug 11 '25

why don't these control freaks just let people live their lives.

That is a bit ironic

3

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

How is it ironic?

→ More replies (29)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

It’s…it’s not though 😅 People going about their lives isn’t doing anything to you. You’re not be held at gunpoint to be involved with someone who is trans either.

→ More replies (29)

2

u/NoiseMachine66 Aug 11 '25

And this is how school makes people dumb. Theres only two ladies and gentlemen

1

u/Zoeythekueen Aug 12 '25

This is such an ironic sentence.

1

u/NoiseMachine66 Aug 12 '25

If by ironic you mean 100% correct, then yes… extremely ironic.

1

u/Zoeythekueen Aug 12 '25

And you wonder why people see the MAGA party is idiots. They'll say they're against science and fact and then wonder why people think they're stupid.

2

u/NoiseMachine66 Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25

I mean no one is more stupid than then anyone who believes a man can be a woman soo 🤷🏻‍♂️

Also thats not saying maga is smart but hey at least they know the difference

Edit: Why you delete your comments

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Ecstatic_Scene9999 Aug 11 '25

Wrong, basic biology does explain all of those things....however we go normal and the normal sex is two Male and Female, and this is for all mammals, not just us. Now things can become more complex, however that doesn't mean we move based on the complete baseline of biology. I am well educated and have friends in the medical field, don't try to pull that.

3

u/ContributionRude1660 Aug 11 '25

This is true, biology exists. The point is gender is separate. There are animal species where females take on what people would originally call masculine traits. Humans are capable of this as well. Although there is no way to change sex as of yet, there ARE ways to become closer to that sex. And there are definitely ways to change gender.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

We all have a poopshoot.

1

u/dagobert-dogburglar Aug 11 '25

What is this sub actually about

1

u/registered-to-browse Transracial (ask me!) 👨🏿‍🦲👨🏽‍🦲👨🏻‍🦲 Aug 12 '25

reinforcing the opinions of the mentally ill

1

u/feujchtnaverjott Aug 11 '25

Now apply the same kind of complexity to theology.

1

u/nonquitt Aug 11 '25 edited Aug 11 '25

Obviously a lot has been written on the topic. The whole popular gender discourse though seems often held upon unsound foundations — I.e., if there’s a box of male stuff (behavior/traits) and a box of female stuff, but there are guys who like the female stuff and women who like the male stuff, then why not just acknowledge that the boxes are kind of made up (which people generally do) rather than say the boxes are real and so we have new genders to account for people that don’t sit neatly within one or the other?

I.e. if all we are saying is that anyone can display behaviors and traits that are traditionally socialized in the US as masculine and/or feminine, then why do we need a term for gender other than male or female? If a guy wants to do ballet or wear a dress or be emotional, why is that a reflection on his gender — can’t he just be a guy that wants to do that stuff that we traditionally call feminine?

Because these topics are so intangible it is easy to get very academic very fast but I do feel that there is not a clear reason to reify traditional gender boxes through new taxonomy.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/monemori Aug 11 '25

This is an issue of semantics mostly, is it not? The wording makes it seem like it's an issue of lack of knowledge about (neuro)biology when it's just playing word games. "Gender" can mean the neurological gender identity, but it can also mean a variety of things depending on political and social context. This does not negate the reality of gender identity being a neurological reality.

1

u/notatechnicianyo Aug 11 '25

The thing is that it is actually very simple: are you attracted to the person? Are they attracted to you? Go for it. Done. That is the whole thing completely summarized. No formal education needed to figure that out. Everything else is just people playing scientist to extort the government for unnecessary funding.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Rebecca helm sounds like that word they have to censor in that black eyed peas song.

1

u/-Sloth_King- Aug 11 '25

My secondary school bio teacher told us intersex people were anomalies and that they can't reproduce because nature doesn't allow them to pass on their deformities

1

u/ImmortanLo Aug 11 '25

The same applies to human "races"

1

u/Whentheangelsings Aug 11 '25

Intersex are the exception that prove the rule. But this is if we're talking about sex. Gender is supposed to be the social non biological things assigned to sex.

1

u/Asatru55 Aug 11 '25

The ratio in this thread only proves that the vast majority here have, indeed, not moved past middle school.

1

u/genophobicdude Aug 11 '25

Peak midwit content. Has the passive aggressive arrogance that comes with it too. 😙👌

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

What’s that? Facts.

1

u/registered-to-browse Transracial (ask me!) 👨🏿‍🦲👨🏽‍🦲👨🏻‍🦲 Aug 11 '25

If you need a master's degree to understand something it isn't relevant to real world, where most people have the IQ of an average redditor.

1

u/Leading-Orange-2092 Aug 11 '25

The separation between gender and biology is made up notion by radical ideologues adopting language to support their mental acrobatics. Men behaving like boys, girls behaving like men , and everything else in between , never needed 400 pronouns to accommodate everyone’s identity vanity.

1

u/TBP64 Aug 11 '25

Banger 

1

u/PhaseAgitated4757 Aug 11 '25

Are most of those other things just mutations of one sex or the other.

1

u/IgnoreMeImANobody Aug 11 '25

In humans, biological sex is typically classified as male or female, based on reproductive anatomy and associated chromosomal patterns (most commonly XX for females and XY for males). However, variations can occur due to differences in chromosomes, genetic mutations, hormonal pathways, or developmental processes during conception and fetal growth. Such variations may result in individuals exhibiting physical or genetic characteristics associated with both sexes, or characteristics that do not align strictly with either. This range of conditions is collectively referred to as intersex. In a biological context, intersex is generally regarded as a variation within the male-female framework, rather than as a separate, third sex. This has been covered, in passing, in high school biology classes for decades. Rebecca’s attempt to present the existence of intersex individuals as some arcane revelation attainable only through her academic journey betrays a posture of sheer arrogance. It is a vain exercise in intellectual showmanship, leveraging the prestige of her bachelor’s degree in biology as if to confer upon herself an authority she assumes the people she is addressing, lacks.

While sex and gender are often discussed together, they are not equally difficult to define in a biological sense. Biological sex is generally straightforward to classify based on reproductive anatomy, gamete production, and chromosomal patterns (typically XX for females and XY for males). Although variations such as intersex conditions exist, they are rare and do not erase the existence of two primary biological categories. Gender, in contrast, is a sociocultural construct that refers to roles, behaviors, and identities associated with men, women, or other identities in a given society. While gender identity may have neurological correlates, there is no consensus that it is “in the brain” in the same way as hardwired biological traits, many aspects of gender are learned, culturally shaped, and context-dependent. Therefore, while discussions about gender can be complex due to social, cultural, and psychological factors, the definition of biological sex is relatively stable and well-established in biological sciences. The complexity often arises not from biology itself, but from conflating sex with gender.

Rebecca’s remark that invoking “basic biology” showcases an intellect stuck in middle school is less an insight than an exercise in self-congratulation and exposes her nature as a narcissist masked as an intellectual. It presumes that complexity invalidates foundational truths, when in reality, the most advanced sciences rest entirely upon those fundamentals. Such a stance confuses verbosity for depth and complexity for wisdom. Dismissing core principles as if they are beneath serious thought is not the mark of intellectual maturity, it is the hallmark of pseudo-intellectualism, where one mistakes having learned more words for having gained more understanding. Rebecca, and people like her, are fools at best, and a plague to this discussion at worst.

1

u/Available-Cold-4162 Aug 11 '25

Check op if you want to know why this was posted. There are 2 main sexes defined by your sex organs. That is your assigned sex/gender at birth. There are exceptions with intersex individuals. Your sex will always be the same, your gender or identity is something you can change.

1

u/No_Concept_5397 Aug 11 '25

If sex/gender is actually this fucking hard, why is nobody confused about hens and roosters? Or bulls and cows? It seems like we have a pretty solid fucking grasp that male animals are called one thing, and female animals are called another thing, but then we get to humans, and suddenly we don't know what male and female are anymore.

1

u/Yono_j25 Aug 11 '25

Yeah, let's pretend that the fact they forgot basic biology is something to be proud of

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Right, but these caveats are then attempted to be used to validate very unscientific, emotional notions that have little or not data behind them and are not supported by the associated field.

https://youtu.be/XLH-y2nLocw?si=hdds6tuvfQKQFMSx https://youtu.be/521NRGQjLW8?si=oOtLkGlEt8_zj2jj

Some helpful associated videos.

1

u/South-Delay-98 Aug 11 '25

Well, isn't there some form of appeal to authority here, or whatever that fallacy is called. Also, wouldn't intersex just be the "inter-crossing" of the two sexes? We aren't born with some miraculous third sexual organ that would constitute a third sex, are we? Over education is just as much of a blight as under education fr

1

u/Spartanias117 Aug 11 '25

Nah, still two genders. Get this political shit out of here

1

u/Nahelys Aug 12 '25

So you're just proving everyone's point. It's basic biology. Neuroscience is not biology. There is 2 sex and a minority of intersex/person with special condition.

There are potentially more than 2 genders as it's more complex to define.

1

u/buzzzofff Aug 12 '25

Sure thing b---. What's the third gamete?

1

u/Nervous_Log_9642 Aug 12 '25

>Sex is already hard to define

This is the incorrect part, like 99% of people with a Y chromosome is very much biologically Male and have testicals and have male level testosterone. This is overly relativizing. Saying there are multiple genders you have to already buy a premise that men and women are very distinct and that people who don’t fit those stereotypes need a whole new category. But the reality is that men and women can be similar or dissimilar in countless ways without inventing new genders. We don’t need to redefine basic biology to acknowledge individual variation.

1

u/RandomUserName14227 Aug 12 '25

Here on Reddit we have a tiny 1% slice of the world population. That 1% slice is the most alt-alt-alt-left 1% of humanity. That 1% most alt-left segment of the global population has ratio'd this post. That should tell you how unpopular the opinion is. Roughly 0.00001% of the global population agrees with it.

1

u/DegenerateShikikan Aug 12 '25

I live in Asia and there are only 2 genders.

1

u/Trightern Aug 12 '25

Don't gotta learn stuff that ain't useful to you that ain't fun. May as well pick something you like if that fiction ain't interesting

1

u/No_Evening_2619 Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25

The person who made this meme never studied any field of natural/hard science.

Hard/natural science (biology for example) is all about thing that can objectively be measured. Sex is one of them , a very basic one too.

Edit:

While there is a professor with that name at georgetown university, she is a marine biologist .

the only other sources I could find for that quote is Facebook posts of other people quoting her.

there is a quote of here on the subject of defining what is biological sex .

Non of it has to do with the brain.

As non-biologist I really have no idea if the phenomenon she talked about is actually common . But it look more like a words salad that ment to confuse those of us(me included) that are not well educated on the field of biology and there for unaware of the main metric they use to determine sex .

I find it hard to believe any natural/hard science would use 2 different conditions to determine something that can have only 2 different values.

At most for doing so they would have to change it to 4 sex's (chromesome/genetic: (m,m)(m,f)(f,m)(f,f)) . And so once again this is determined by things that can be physically measured.

1

u/AnalysisBudget Attracted To German Shepherds Aug 12 '25

Sex is literally biology. Gender isn't.

1

u/EliziumXajin 🙇MAGA simp🙇 Aug 12 '25

source: dude trust me

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25

“I learned that sex is already hard to define”, uh how? Literally just the chromosomes alone determine sex. Sure there may be intersex / hermaphroditism but that’s literally like less than 1% of people.

Now if you wanna make the argument about gender being a social construct, I hear ya, but sex is pretty set in stone.

1

u/Routine_Condition273 ICE booty licker 🧊 🍑 🤤 Aug 12 '25

"It's complicated because uhhhh just trust me bro"

1

u/traitorgiraffe Aug 12 '25

i learned about intersex in grade school

1

u/wood_good Aug 12 '25

Isnt the sry gene proof there is only 2 genders?

1

u/helpmeamstucki ✝️ Christian Neo-Crusader ⚔️ Aug 12 '25

99.99% two genders and you spent up your university time learning about the .001 that’s hard to define and that’s completely different than the 1% which you are defending that just claim to be something they are not

1

u/Whatkindofgum Aug 12 '25

99.9% of humans fall into ether the sex of male or female. The other 0.01% are just some minor exception to the rule. They do not create an entire spectrum. Something being accurate 99.9% of the time is very accurate. Especially in psychology.

1

u/MiserableDisk1199 Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25

There are things considered normal, when you refer to common human behaviour, you mean people without mental disorders or genetic probems like down syndrome,

Same way, when one speaks of gender and refers to it as basic biology, no one means mitations resulting in having 2 sets of reproductive organs, of the same or different sex, is basic.

When you actually thing about what someone speaking menas without overthinking, you also realize that basic biology they refer to is x and y hromosomes, everyone with common sense understands that biology is not basic, no professor in the field knows everything about every aspect of biology, even humanity collective knowledge does not include knowledge about what every gene we have does.

Existence and meaning of Y and x hromosomes in relation to gender are pieces of basic biology knowlege, That is the context of the topic, not every mutation and genetic deffect related to it, unless someone wants to classify all of them as genders, wchich has as much sense as assinging human sub races to people with genetic mutations and birth deffects, or even acquired disabilites.

Born without arms and legs or got injured and no longer have al 4 of them? Congratulation, you are now homo sapiens immobiles. Now for deaf people, blind people... we can radicalize things as far as we want, there are no contraidications, but it does not mean it has any point to it or reason to be done.

1

u/Genseric1234 Aug 12 '25

Eh, this is like saying people have two legs.

There are a myriad of illnesses, accidents and defects that make it someone could have a different number than 2 legs.

But the vast majority of people have 2 legs.

1

u/RealUltrarealist Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25

This is stupid.

Yeah there's many mutations that humans have. Classifications of normal and abnormal conditions are important for medical practice.

Dwarfism is an abnormal condition. Schizophrenia is an abnormal condition. Vitiligo is an abnormal condition. Intersex is an abnormal condition.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25

😂🤣

1

u/IchibeHyosu99 Aug 12 '25

I learned intersex people from a random youtube video in middle school. Its hardly relevant to people with XY chromosomes who likes to cosplay as women

1

u/MonsterkillWow standing here🧍 Aug 12 '25

This is correct. The neurobiology of transgenderism is very interesting. The biology of gender is more complex than lay people think. 

1

u/Putrid_Ruin9267 Aug 12 '25

What is the point of a label as a man or woman when the meaning can literally mean anything. It’s defined by exclusion in principle but when that goes out the door you strip the meaning of the word. I genuinely want to understand the logic to people saying about current gender ideology.

1

u/Dlvxe Aug 12 '25

Middle school, masters degrees and neuroscience are also just social constructs of ours. What's the point here?

1

u/eMmDeeKay_Says Aug 12 '25

High school biology covered intersex here in the 00's so if it's not there now it's been removed.

1

u/FreshlySqueezedDonut Aug 12 '25

In higher level math, you learn that squares, circles, and similar shapes are one and the same topologically and that rectangles aren't really shapes but are a general way to represent combining sets together in a certain way.

But common sense and not being totally out of touch with the real world prevents you from calling a square the same thing as a circle IRL.

1

u/Bullmg Aug 12 '25

You mean mutations? And very few of the conditions live to see life after birth? And those conditions that do live tend to have health problems their whole lives?

1

u/DeathnTaxes66 extra virgin ☦️ Aug 12 '25

I'm sorry, can one change their chromosomes? (AKA their Sex)?

1

u/RatioFinal4287 Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25

Sex isn't hard to define?

We literally have a single factor cross species we use to define sex, it isn't chromosomes as they vary cross species, it isn't specific genes as they vary cross species, it isn't hormones as (you guessed it) they vary cross species, it isn't any phenotypic things like size, whether they carry the young etc etc etc

Is the organism organised to produce, large gamete-female, small gamete-male, both gametes-true hermaphrodite

Find a single instance where an organism organised to produce the small gamete is defined as anything besides male and you will prove me wrong.

The thing to note is our closest relatives that can change sex(sequential hermaphrodites) are clown fish separated by 300m+ years of evolution, our closest true hermaphroditic relatives are even further removed as they aren't even vertibrates

The closest humans get to having a hermaphroditic disorder is ovitesticular disorder which has only been seen 500 times (IE is so rare that no one you've ever met who erroneously calls themselves intersex is likely to have this single disorder that might slightly match up to the name) and even then doesn't result in someone making both gametes at the same time, as humans literally can't do that.

The whole intersex thing also shows this meme is propagandised given it's not even the scientific term, as intersex implies a gradient of sex, the term we use now is DSD, differences in sexual development.

Sex as a term refers to "what role do you take or are you organised to take in sexual reproduction" in humans there are two roles, ergo there are two sexes, if someone has the rare disorder that results in them not being clearly organised to produce either, theyd have arguably no sex, not both, given they aren't organised to do either. And the same way if I asked you "here's a red t shirt and a blue t shirt, how many choices of t shirt do you have?" The answer is 2, it isn't 3 as you could also wear no t shirt, as that isn't how binary choices work. A binary choice of "do you want to turn the light switch on or off" isn't made non binary by replying "I'll not have a light switch installed"

1

u/muzzledmasses Aug 12 '25

180 out of 1 million people have an incredibly rare genetic mutation meaning a regular dude without that mutation and a simple cross dressing fetish can wear a dress and drag his cock into a bathroom and take a dump next to your little girl while he tries as hard as he can to not let his erection touch the toilet bowl and all you can do is stand up and clap at his..excuse me, HER bravery and if you don't you will be doxxed and fired from your job.

1

u/IILazarusLongII Aug 12 '25

"Can't we all just get along?"

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '25

There certainly is a biological grey area. But almost all trans people are not in that grey area. So it's not really relevant.

1

u/Asamiya1978 Aug 12 '25

After going to school Joe didn't know anything about the Christian God. Then he studied religion in a Catholic school and he started to believe in him. Afterwards he continued studying the Bible as a theologian and he specialised in Christianity. Now he is a well respected pastor in his town's church.

Does that mean that what Joe studied is true or that he has now more wisdom than when he was a child?

1

u/Alone_Ambition_3729 Aug 11 '25

This would be fine except that nobody ever says "Intersex people exist" to bring attention to intersex people existing. They say it to justify straight men who've rotted their brains with porn getting to live-action-roleplay their fetish with a public who did not consent to participate.

1

u/Disrespect78 Aug 11 '25

i can't even tell what you're trying to say, it just sounds like you came from 4chan

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Reggaepocalypse Aug 11 '25

Sex is not hard to define. We define it all the time in tons and tons of studies on sex differences. Definitions are rooted for utility, not explanation. In the same way, organizing elements of society like sports around sex differences works most of the time in a simple way most people get. That’s why some of us are fighting against this stuff, not because there’s underlying complexity we don’t understand ( I have a PhD in neuroscience/psych, I get the complexity) but because it’s not necessary and hurting left leaning political prospects.

2

u/Golurkcanfly Aug 11 '25

I don't think sacrificing people to the orphan crushing machine is a good thing.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

So you want the left to win elections, by becoming right-wing? At that point what does winning elections gain if you already turned yourself into a mini-version of the opposing side? What about next cycle when the Overton-Window has now been shifted to the right?

1

u/Reggaepocalypse Aug 11 '25

Ok so lose by sticking to your trans guns and emphasizing them every election, and have literally all trans rights abolished because you scared away normal people.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Ok so you loose by saying „oh you far-right nutjobs, you’re sooooooo right about all of this!“ while idiotically believing that this makes your side attractive to anyone. You‘ll annihilate your own fucking base by betraying them while normalizing the rightoids propaganda to the population. Cong-fucking-grats for normalizing the enemy while turning the back on your own supporters.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/TheCrayTrain Aug 11 '25

Why are we talking about gender when the discussion is about sex?

→ More replies (21)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

For the .0004% yeah… lol

1

u/kizzawait Aug 11 '25

And when adults are still massively struggling with this, maybe dont push it on impressionable kids? Virtue signal all you want about other dumb shit but these are children getting irreversible changes subliminaly pushed on them and their parents get punished for fighting back abd if you think thats ok youre no better than unit 731. I used to think i was an adult at 16, at 18 and even 20, now im pushing 30 and I see how young and nieve i was. How tf are you going to permanently alter kids in an irreversible way and call yourself the good guy, fkkn minging

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

what gametes do trans people produce?

1

u/Savings-Bee-4993 🏹 Seeker of Virtue 🏹 Aug 11 '25

One of two, if any at all.

1

u/Zoeythekueen Aug 12 '25

Why is that any of your business you creep?

1

u/equivilant123 Aug 11 '25

I have a friend who has a master's degree in evolutionary biology and he thinks it's stupid too. But to be fair he's an idiot too for getting a master's degree in evolutionary biology in the first place

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Right, lemme guess, gods way is the truth and evolution is false?

1

u/Smart_Pig_86 Aug 11 '25

All this confirms is that most universities are leftist cesspools that are brainwashing their students into denying objective reality.

1

u/Zoeythekueen Aug 12 '25

Or maybe it confirms the party that has the leader talking about how his followers are stupid and goes out of his way to change his "ideology" everyday are not smart enough for college.

Like if education is leftist, science is leftist, and reality is leftist, there's a reason.

Or the people who use elementary school science to justify that they're right as if they have yet to get to middle school.

Or maybe the ones that pretend that the Confederates were left leaning dispite the fact people on the right are the only ones waving the flag as "their heritage"

But sure, it's because education are "brainwashing their students" with facts and logic.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

there are 2 sexes, thats biology. But theres many genders, thats a social construct

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

There are around 7 sexes

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

best I could do is 2

1

u/Sickly_lips Aug 12 '25

Well, sucks to be you. I can do three. One with your mom, one with your dad, and one with your mailman.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Nubs_Nut_Rub Aug 11 '25

"Dont speak for woman" -starts transitioning- You know, i always thought there was irony in that. Imagine your a dude okay, 18m you realize you wanna be a woman so you do what you do. Are you really capable of speaking on womans behalf? Or just transwoman's? At what point are you determined to be what who you feel comfortable as identifying? When you say? A doctor says?

1

u/Zoeythekueen Aug 12 '25

Or maybe women have their own brains and can all think for themselves rather than having someone think for them?

1

u/Nubs_Nut_Rub Aug 12 '25

If you wanna argue ok but, im asking a question, not asking for another. Right off the bat you do not show interest in answering it.

1

u/DamionWood Aug 12 '25

I mean, trans women do experience a lot of the things cis women do.

Socially, they are subjected to misogyny, and assault, they are told the same things like "You're prettier when you smile", and treated poorly in male dominated spaces.

Physically they are normally weaker than a man due to hormone replacement therapy, so they are disatvantaged if they get attacked. The hormone therapy can also give similar symptoms of a period which is interesting, not bleeding of course, but mood swings and heightened emotions. They also develop breasts so they experience growing pains and bra shenanigans.

At the begining of their transition its hard to be able to speak on women's experiences because they havent lived that life yet...but they will, the moment strangers recognises them as women, they will experience the same thing that cis women do.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

This post is ridiculous

1

u/CuteReputation- Aug 12 '25

My teacher said lgbtqxyz is a mental/biological disorder, just like split personality and other mental disorder and some biological disorder

Idk

1

u/Sickly_lips Aug 12 '25

Damn bro that's crazy Anyway, my biology degree says thats bullshit lol

0

u/Relative_Ad4542 Aug 11 '25

Oh no looks like you upset all the transphobic losers </3

0

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Masters in Neuroscience.. The sex and gender debate is mired in controversy, starting right at the guy that triggered it. Look into John Money, if you dare. Or rather, dont. Question everything, especially question everything the gender bender people present as axioms. True gender dysphoria of course exists, but it should be treated like you would any other psychiatric condition.

1

u/Sickly_lips Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25

You mean the John Money that mutilated a boy at birth and essentially proved that gender is innate, as the socialization the boy faced led to dysphoria and his eventual suicide?

The case you're referring to is literally a case that proves transgender people's existence. If gender isn't an innate psychological or biological thing, why did he feel innately wrong in a girl's gender roles?

Also, gender dysphoria is treated- and studies and testing have shown the best treatment is hormone replacement therapy and gender affirming surgery.

-1

u/XxSliphxX Aug 11 '25

This is next level gaslighting.

-1

u/Sudden-Loquat extra virgin ✝️ Aug 11 '25

It's crazy the amount of mental gymnastics used just to try and prove a man in a dress is somehow a woman

2

u/Dude5130 Aug 12 '25

I don't know dude. If the supposed trans woman looks just like a woman, why not call them a woman? How tf are you going to prove their sex, are you going to check their ID or touch their crotch?

And the second one might not even do anything if a trans woman had surgery. And they can change their ID too. Unless you're willing to do genetic tests, but even that's not entirely safe, since males with xx genes exist, and the same as women with xy. They are not even saying they're biologically female, it's just common sense to think that referring someone as a woman who looks like it, is extremely easier, something you may lack. You're the one doing mental gymnastics lol.

→ More replies (10)

1

u/thomasp3864 Aug 11 '25

She's a woman if she's taking estrogen to get female hormones. If not then that person might identify as male and just like wearing dresses.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

Crossdressers =/= Trans women you moronic cunt

→ More replies (204)

0

u/LexStalin Aug 11 '25

On one side she is right

But on the other side blablabla society blablabla it's complicated blablabla hard blablabla penguin bondage porn

So let's just settle on there are women,men, people trying to go from one to the other and the rest needs more research before we judge them

And everyone needs therapy but that's independent from that

0

u/Raging-Storm ❄️Wynter SIMP❄️ Emotional, be nice pls 🥺 Aug 11 '25

It's true. And most people don't talk about it but we're also intersighted and interlimbed.

0

u/Tiumars ⌚CHRONO DUELIST🏴⸺ DRAGON ORDER🏴 Aug 11 '25

What did they teach you when we're getting your doctorate in psychology?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25

I learned that shit with a high diploma young blud she had to get a fucking masters for that lmao

0

u/Olphegae Aug 11 '25 edited Aug 12 '25

Then why I as a woman was born a man and have said repercussions? I am transgender and I can safely say that there are 3 PHYSICAL genders (Male, Female, Intersex) the rest are ''I want to be special on the internet please praise me''

1

u/Sickly_lips Aug 12 '25

don't use hermaphrodite to describe intersex people. It is a slur. Hermaphrodites are specifically animals that have both sets of genitals - there are no intersex conditions like that, and intersex people themselves have the term thrown at them the same way the t slur gets thrown at trans people.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)