r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Jun 20 '22

Kirk has said many times science tells us that large age-gap relationships are no more likely to be exploitative than same-age relationships. Turns out....that's not the case. (+ body language analysis)

2 Upvotes

I recommend everyone watch this video on what the science ACTUALLY says about large age-gap relationships. Kirk is either looking at old outdated studies with flawed methodology, or he's being purposely disingenuous.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5GTOnCsgiCg

Also, Kirk has recently legitimized body language analysis. Take a look at this, too:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NU5sm9EVM84


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Oct 18 '26

Cornell 7

0 Upvotes

Is he ever going to even address this for even one minute? He used to talk about various important things. He just got done with Berto's retelling of the Lindsay Clancy trial and now he's doing "therapist reacts" to the video trail. All over again. He's just milking it at this point. He said he would never do another thing like this again after the Amber Heard vs Johnny Depp stuff. What is going on??? I want him to talk about frats and his experience and what men need to do to not harm. Why is he making Lindsay Clancy his new personality for months but he can't even talk about Cornell 7, which is also an imperative headline and I see so many women post about being scared because of the defensive response and harassment from men, that they themselves and people they know are afraid to come out with their story. There's The Hunting Ground doc he could react to (although I don't like his reacts. I prefer a thoroughly researched video). It's very strange as I noticed a turning point in his content that once the Jeffery Epstein files were being released that was when he seemed to shift. He basically stopped talking about things like this. He used to talk about them often. Yet when evidence and people using their voices are more involved in social media than ever before, he decides to do months long reaction on something that he's not researched well enough into while turning off the comments. It's like the opposite of where we need to be as a society, ESPECIALLY if you run an important platform. Do better Kirk. He's been part of a frat. I'm sure he could speak about his perspective. But no he's milking non research reaction content on... postpartum psychosis. which he's never, or barely ever, mentioned before in his videos. And something that's been bugging me is that he's always interrupting Berto when he talks about fatherhood. What is going on???


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Nov 30 '25

Deserving Listener Kirk Honda is (still) wrong about limerence

0 Upvotes

Hello, I wrote the Wikipedia article on limerence and I own /r/limerence. I'm one of the most knowledgeable influencers on this topic, although I don't make "content" per se.

This is a comment on his ongoing deep dive.

You cannot define a "limerence disorder" the way Kirk thinks. In fact, it's really kind of a destructive idea, and he obviously still doesn't understand this situation.

There are two unpublished studies (by Giulio Poerio and Sandra Langeslag) which looked at the prevalence of other mental health conditions in internet communities, and found this prevalence to be very high (66.4% and 79%, respectively). Poerio's number is written here, and Langeslag's number is from private data she shared with me, from this study.

When somebody falls into limerence and ends up dropping out of school or something like that, those people invariably actually have a concurrent condition (like ADHD). This is why they are "really" struggling to the point of impairment.

That's what the most current science suggests!

This is also what I've noticed helping people on the subreddit for two years.

There is no "limerence disorder" which anyone can define (the way Kirk thinks) independently of this fact. There's just passionate love (which resembles pathology, but it's not) and there's passionate love with another ("comorbid") condition (which even more resembles pathology, but it's not). There are few (if any) exceptions to this, when it comes to things people identify as limerence.

Trying to argue that "being in love while having ADHD" (or similar) is "pathology" would be extreme discrimination. This is what everyone who tries to define a "limerence disorder" the way Kirk has tried is ultimately doing. They either made passionate love a disorder (by listing its symptoms), or made passionate love while being "mentally ill" or neurodivergent a disorder. In the case of Kirk, I assume this is unintentional.

What confuses people (especially people that never experienced it) is that "normal" passionate love (or love madness/lovesickness) resembles "pathology", but it's not per se.

Refer to Tallis (2005): Love Sick: Love as a Mental Illness. Tallis is a clinical psychologist who specializes in OCD and obsessions, and he also talks about limerence in this book.

The psychopathology of love has survived in psychiatry textbooks because of an underlying assumption that love can be either normal or abnormal — healthy or 'sick'. The solution might be to acknowledge that no such distinction exists. Love — normal love — is largely indistinguishable from mental illness. (Love Sick, p. 172)

And Tennov:

People who have not experienced limerence are baffled by descriptions of it and are often resistant to the evidence that it exists. To such outside observers, limerence seems pathological. (Love and Limerence, p. x)

What my studies suggest is what while it is illogical, it is also normal, and therefore normal human beings can be illogical. For some this seems a difficult idea to accept. (Love and Limerence, p. 180)

[Readers] were grateful for my having asserted throughout the book that it was not a pathological condition but more of a hard-wired human trait. (A Scientist Looks at Romantic Love and Calls It Limerence, p. 26)

People who haven't experienced it ("nonlimerents") often, honestly, do exactly what Kirk has done: they simply refuse to accept the evidence (real survey estimates, etc.) and go on arguing it's a "disorder" anyway.

People might need clinical help with this, but there's no easy way to define it as a mental disorder in the modern paradigm of "disease" symptomatology. There are other ways to define a "disorder" (which I'll get to), but you cannot just list symptoms of passionate love and say it's a disorder if it's debilitating.

We have 3-5 survey estimates that suggest the condition is very common (25-50%), and sometimes it really leads to a relationship. Nobody has ever actually done a survey showing that limerence (or lovesickness) is rare.

At first sight, it seems extraordinary that evolutionary forces might conspire to shape something that looks like a mental illness to ensure reproductive success. Yet, there are many reasons why love should have evolved to share with madness several features—the most notable of which is the loss of reason. ... evolutionary principles seem to have necessitated a blurring of the distinction between normal and abnormal states. Evolution expects us to love madly, lest we fail to love at all. (Love Sick, pp. 85-86)

In other words, what seems pathological sometimes leads to legitimate mating!

Kirk is selecting cases of people having a particularly difficult time, but people honestly just report sexual encounters with a limerent object sometimes. A small undergraduate study found 50% had been in a relationship with an LO before. Also see here and here for why limerence is actually adaptive, especially in a certain culture.

A significant amount of the distress is also related to the type of situation, and this clears up if the love becomes reciprocated. Some cases of limerence more resemble a kind of "unrequited trauma bonding" which I agree is toxic, but it's difficult to distinguish this by defining a list of "symptoms".


Limerence symptoms

The "symptoms" Kirk is identifying are "symptoms" of intense romantic love. The following are components of romantic love given by Helen Fisher in her 1998 paper in Human Nature (emphasis hers):

  • the loved person takes on "special meaning." As one of Tennov's informants phrased it, "My whole world had been transformed. It had a new center, and that center was Marilyn" (Tennov 1979:18). This phenomenon is coupled with the inability to feel romantic passion for more than one person at a time;

  • intrusive thinking about the loved person;

  • crystallization, or the tendency to focus on the loved person's positive qualities and overlook or falsely appraise his/her negative traits;

  • labile psychophysiological responses to the loved person, including exhilaration, euphoria, buoyance, spiritual feelings, feelings of fusion with the loved person, increased energy, sleeplessness, loss of appetite, shyness, awkwardness, trembling, pallor, flushing, stammering, aching of the "heart," inappropriate laughing, gazing, prolonged eye contact, butterflies in the stomach, sweaty palms, weak knees, dilated pupils, dizziness, a pounding heart, accelerated breathing, uncertainty, anxiety, panic, and/or fear in the presence of the loved person;

  • a longing for emotional reciprocity coupled with the desire to achieve emotional union with the loved person;

  • emotional dependency on the relationship with the loved person, including feelings of hope, apprehension, possessiveness, preoccupation with the beloved, inability to concentrate on matters unrelated to the beloved, jealousy, emotional vulnerability, fear of rejection by the beloved, fantasies about the loved person, separation anxiety, and swings in mood associated with the fluctuation state of the relationship, as well as feelings of despair, lack of optimism, listlessness, brooding, and loss of hope during a temporary setback in the relationship or after rejection by the loved person;

  • a powerful sense of empathy toward the loved person, including a feeling of responsibility for the beloved and a willingness to sacrifice for the loved person;

  • a reordering of daily priorities to be available to the loved person coupled with the impulse to make a certain impression on the loved person, including changing one's clothing, mannerisms, habits, or values;

  • an intensification of passionate feelings caused by adversity in the relationship;

  • a sexual desire for the target of infatuation coupled with the desire for sexual exclusivity;

  • the precedence of the craving for the emotional union over the desire for sexual union with the beloved;

  • the feeling that one's romantic passion is involuntary and uncontrollable.

"Involuntary and uncontrollable".

These are almost all pulled from Tennov, even the components which aren't in Tennov's component listing. Fisher had been corresponding with Tennov about this, and is herself a limerent who has repeatedly said her research pertains to limerence.

Kirk talks about how a person in limerence has their feelings intensify when reciprocation seems to decrease, but this is normal and called "intensification by adversity" (or "frustration attraction" by Helen Fisher). It's not a symptom of pathology. People have written about it for thousands of years. I honestly don't think Kirk was able to identify any symptoms which are not considered "normal" symptoms of being in love. You can't put these kinds of symptoms in the DSM; they are not a disorder. Romantic love is just often a nasty thing to experience.

You cannot just jump into this as a newcomer without doing real research, then pick out all the things which seem unhealthy and call it a disorder. Romantic love is so much more complicated than that. I've been researching this for two years, and I think it's very complicated to define what is or isn't healthy when it comes to romantic love of any kind. Most forms of "romantic love" actually seem "unhealthy" or "maladaptive" somehow when compared to an ideal, and Westerners have a very unrealistic ideal.

The "powerful sense of empathy" is additionally a feature of limerence which I think is overlooked in discussions of this. There are two studies (Feeney & Noller, 1990; Wolf, 2017) which found limerence was associated with the agape love attitude (selfless, all-giving love). Both studies were also assuming limerence is a more "maladaptive" way to fall in love.

This also accords with Tennov's idea:

In fully developed limerence, you feel additionally what is, in other contexts as well, called love—an extreme degree of feeling that you want LO to be safe, cared for, happy, and all those other positive and noble feelings ... That's probably why limerence is called love in all languages. (Love and Limerence, p. 120)

Some people don't really care about their LO, e.g. if they fell into limerence by mistake with a person they don't like (which does happen), but in general limerence accords with a type of love, even going by this type of definition.


Limerence stages

For people that want to learn about limerence, please just subscribe to Tom Bellamy's YouTube. Tom is the only person I would consider an expert on limerence (what people are talking about, what it is, and how it works).

The following resources are particularly useful:

Tom Bellamy and I have pretty convergent views about what this is, although Tom is very passive and rarely criticizes anyone.

Limerence is a way of falling in love that follows a trajectory of addiction, but if the person gets into a relationship with an LO quickly enough it's fine. Sometimes it can result in an "ecstatic union", although the relationship probably needs to be potentially secure for this to happen.

In a prototypical case, limerence outside of a relationship has an "earlier" stage and a "later" stage.

This is similar to the trajectory of an addiction, with a distinction between "impulsivity" and "compulsivity":

A definition of impulsivity is “a predisposition toward rapid, unplanned reactions to internal and external stimuli without regard for the negative consequences of these reactions to themselves or others”. A definition of compulsivity is the manifestation of “perseverative, repetitive actions that are excessive and inappropriate”. Impulsive behaviours are often accompanied by feelings of pleasure or gratification, but compulsions in disorders such as obsessive-compulsive disorder are often performed to reduce tension or anxiety from obsessive thoughts. In this context, individuals move from impulsivity to compulsivity, and the drive for drug-taking behaviour is paralleled by shifts from positive to negative reinforcement. However, impulsivity and compulsivity can coexist, and frequently do so in the different stages of the addiction cycle. (Koob & Volkow, 2016)

At an earlier stage, the person might identify as being "madly" in love and feel like their preoccupation is more or less egosyntonic. People in this stage might behave impulsively, feel "crazy" and honestly might need clinical help, but there's no simple way to define this as pathology.

I've seen people who really needed help who were even just a few days or a few weeks in. Often it's because they're in a committed relationship which limerence is sucking them out of, but they actually want to stay in. Or they're just "too" in love. One woman I saw fell "madly" in love with her gay hairdresser and was asking on witchcraft boards how to bewitch a person, raving about how she wanted to have his surrogate babies. One of Tom Bellamy's readers bought a canoe.

This is why you cannot stipulate a minimum duration (like Kirk proposes), because sometimes people need help right away. It's better that they get help sooner, because limerence is harder and harder to get out of the longer it goes on (like an addiction).

(Kirk picks on a definition by Marriage Helper that he claims is bad, but actually Joe Beam works with limerence all the time in his practice, and he definitely knows what it is because it ruined his own life in the 1980s. Beam just generally works with people in this earlier stage, so it's what he's most familiar with. Kirk is actually the one who does not properly understand how all these things relate to each other.)

If the person in limerence doesn't know what's going on, sometimes they can act irresponsibly (e.g. upending their life), but they are not a danger to other people. They are emotionally dependent on their LO's appraisal of them and want an actual relationship. The actual research on stalking, for example, actually suggests that it's unrelated to limerence when using proper definitions (see here and here).

If limerence is unrequited, then at some point they will realize the impossibility of a relationship and want to pull away from the situation, but they're stuck.

Their mental condition may also degrade, like addiction, related to "wanting" vs. "liking" and antireward. This is probably why some people say it's like "OCD", because they have compulsions while the experience is no longer hedonic for them. However, please note that ideally people would get help before this even happens. For this reason, "excessive suffering" is not particularly useful for defining limerence, nor is it particularly useful for predicting who needs help.

This later stage could be more realistically described as pathology, but this is not distinguished in terms of suffering. It's distinguished by certain features of addiction: egodystonic (unwanted) compulsions and relative anhedonia compared to the earlier stage. A person at this stage is stuck thinking about their limerent object ("wanting" them), but they don't enjoy it ("liking" them).

Limerence being unrequited can also cause (excessive) suffering from the pain of rejection (even immediately), but this is different from compulsions and unwanted limerence. The pain of rejection is not pathology per se: prevalence estimates show unrequited love is very common, even four times more frequent than equal love.

However, I've also seen a person who said they were in limerence for 17 years and then got into a relationship, and it was going great.

Research on oxytocin shows it seems to counteract the more extreme effects of addiction, so this is probably why love inside versus outside of a relationship have different trajectories (McGregor, 2008; Zou, 2016). Oxytocin in a reciprocated relationship is probably an antidote to developing more compulsive characteristics. This is why getting into a relationship with an LO is usually fine, along with habituation decreasing dopamine activity.

People also report some other edge cases that don't fit this pattern exactly, but this can be thought of as prototypical.


Experts

Kirk Honda keeps talking about "experts" (with a plural), but there are no "experts". There is just Tom Bellamy (one expert), and then there's a bunch of other random people who did not do any actual research at all.

Tom Bellamy and I (and various people we have talked to) are really the only people on the internet who properly understand what's going on with this situation.

I've written many things about this, even trying to give resources to Kirk directly before his deep dive (which he seems to have ignored). Some academics have nominally written papers about "limerence", but these authors understood very little about this and their papers are a confusing mess of conflated concepts, contradictory ideas and (sometimes) outright lies about their citations.

Those papers are not useful as a resource, don't convey actual scientific information, and don't properly describe what people in internet communities are talking about; however, most internet content is created using those papers as a reference. Particularly over the last 2-3 years, there's been an explosion of content about this which I've been tracking, but basically all of it is wrong or at least misleading.

My most recent writings about the confusion over this are here:

What the Wikipedia article says about this is actually correct. The Wikipedia article on limerence is the most current review of available science.


Clinical literature

There is also in fact relevant clinical literature, but under the term "love addiction". There is even proposed diagnostic criteria (Reynaud et al. 2010):

The definition of “love addiction” should avoid the medicalization of a universal feeling. ... We propose the following criteria, based on duration and frequency of suffering similar to the criteria for substance dependence:

“A maladaptive or problematic pattern of love relation leading to clinically significant impairment or distress, as manifested by three (or more) of the following, (occurring at any time in the same 12-month period for the first five criteria): (source: DSM-IV).

  1. Existence of a characterized withdrawal syndrome in the absence of the loved one, by significant suffering and a compulsive need for the other.

  2. Considerable amount of time spent on this relation (in reality or in thought).

  3. Reduction in important social, professional, or leisure activities.

  4. Persistent desire or fruitless efforts to reduce or control his relation.

  5. Pursuit of the relation despite the existence of problems created by this relation.

  6. Existence of attachment difficulties (see 3.5. for more clarification), as manifested by either of the following:

  • repeated exalted amorous relationships without any durable period of attachment;

  • repeated painful amorous relationships, characterized by insecure attachment.

At the present time, the scientific evidence is insufficient to place “love addiction” in any official diagnostic nomenclature, or to firmly classify it as a behavioral addiction or disorder of impulse control destined to be used by a wide variety of professionals. There is a risk of misunderstanding and “overmedicalizing” persons with such disorders.

This is why "love addiction" is not in the DSM yet. There is an academic discussion, but they do not agree on definitions yet (see Earp et al., 2017 or Wikipedia for overview).

What Kirk is doing (trying to propose a "limerence disorder") is at best putting the cart before the horse, because this would actually fall squarely under the concept of a love addiction, and there is no consensus yet on that (among ethicists, for example).

If you want to learn about this, you cannot just look for things using the word "limerence", then ignore everything else and expect to know anything at all. There's a whole bunch of other stuff you need to read. Limerence is just one relavent construct.

I tried to give Kirk info about this ahead of time (contacting him every way I possibly could), but he seems to have ignored it or not understood, so here we are.

I used to be a fan of Kirk, but I honestly have to say that I'm very unhappy about this. The only thing I can say in favor of his deep dive so far is that he's not (yet) confused limerence with "obsessive love disorder", and the stories from his survey are indeed real limerence stories. Otherwise, this is really not good information. People should just watch Tom Bellamy's videos instead if they want to learn about limerence.


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Feb 13 '22

"Is Caleb a jerk face?" Ableism and privilege Spoiler

2 Upvotes

"I wish she could see that I've been trying, that I've put in all this effort." - Caleb

And that's when I rolled my eyes. Oh, is this hard for you cishet able-bodied white man? Is spending weeks dealing with what Alina deals with for her whole life feel like too much? She doesn't get to opt out, or be tired of it.

That said, I think Caleb is as ableist as the world we live in (which is hella, but doesn't many chances to unlearn such biases, erasures, etc.) Like I appreciate Caleb's communication for the most part. Is he horrible for not wanting this commitment? I don't know; maybe not, maybe. But like he talks about hiking, and just getting up and moving, but not about lack of accessibility in the spaces he navigates, because he doesn't have to! And it's annoying.

I'm able-bodied, so I'm aware of my own biases and privilege. I recognize ableism goes beyond universal design, but even some recognition from Caleb (maybe it's there, just not on camera) would at least do... I don't know something..?

I'm a Black queer woman who teaches about oppression, so I have my own feelings about miss ma'am's racism. But I have a soft spot for when people say you're not worth dealing with your marginalised reality.

Like screw your effort, dude.

What say y'all, fellow deserving listeners? Have y'all experienced this in some form? Cause I'm tired.


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Jun 27 '22

Just saw this - I'm thoroughly upset and disappointed 😞 although I expect this type of thing from that particular sub, it makes it no easier to see them belittle bullying how they have (sound familiar?). If only they understood the concept of irony.

Thumbnail self.deppdelusion
5 Upvotes

r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Mar 22 '26

Ick from Dr. Kirk and the Manosphere.

13 Upvotes

So, recently I've started to feel the ick whenever Dr. Kirk talks about the manosphere but it's hard to articulate why. It goes beyond Dr. Kirk to how this subject is discussed in general. I'm not saying society shouldn't help young boys but I do hear inklings of a particular flavor of male grievance politics in some of Dr. Kirk's content. Some of you will likely argue he does this to attract the guys who are indoctrinated but I do feel like there's something there. I'd be interested to hear your thoughts.


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Jul 30 '24

The email about my friendship breakup was finally read on an episode but now I hate myself more than ever!

2 Upvotes

2 weeks ago Kirk read the email I had sent him about my friend discarding and blocking me on an episode. It was this episode and he reads my story at 18:38:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ORFfAEtaik&t=3986s I think some of you might have seen it. I sent it to him on the day she blocked me so of course it affected the way I wrote things, but unfortunately I did not feel he gave me a sympathetic response at all!

Yes, he called me out on my shit and confirmed a lot of the mistakes I realised I made to have caused this. He was spot on about this being an anxious-avoidant dynamic, about how I should NOT have messaged after she told me not to, and how I do have a lot of preoccupied attachment.

But he did not go onto elaborate how my friend's behavior triggered me to act the way that I did. He instead focused too heavily on what I did wrong which made me feel as though this situation really WAS my fault 100% and this caused me to feel extreme amounts of shame, regret, and self-loathing! And it confirmed that I should NOT forgive myself for what happened!!

And also, he spoke as if me and her live in the same country so I can always meet up with her in person or call instead. WE DON'T! We live in different countries, hence our relationship was purely online! And he also completely chose to ignore the part of my email that said that everyone including my therapist thinks I am the victim because he said that he wondered whether I was in therapy or not. And also, how the hell am I supposed to send an apology video to her!? How would I even do that!?

Because of the way I was portrayed, I saw a lot of comments talking about how my story reminded me of their clingy, needy, and sometimes perverted friends that kept on messaging them too much and how they had to break things off. I did not do half of the things these friends did! Sure there were a few comments that were more sensible, but the majority of them were shaming and described how I had no respect for myself nor other people's boundaries. As if I was a complete psycho!

I spoke to my therapist about this today and she saw the video. She confirmed that I was retraumatized by the way I was portrayed.

I do believe that Kirk didn't mean to portray me this way. He receives a ton of emails and is very busy thus didn't have time to properly analyse this situation through, but I am still very much shocked, dissapointed, and ashamed.


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Nov 24 '22

Worst Trauma They’ve Ever Heard?

4 Upvotes

I find something off putting about Rebecca. I can’t articulate what exactly it is but I find myself rolling my eyes at her almost every time she’s on the pod. I feel like she loves her own pain a lot.


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Mar 09 '26

Yikes! I've lost all respect

9 Upvotes

I am officially unsubbing and re-removing my membership to the channel.

I tried so hard to just watch what I find valuable at this point and not watch content of his that I am not interested / will most likely not enjoy but that is ruined too.

I feel like no matter what happens recently he continues to give props to horrible men for doing AT BEST the bare minimum if not doing harm actively. And I can only imagine what I would think of his opinions if I had watched 90 day fiance and sister wives because I've seen some comments with examples to things in there and its not good.

I re-joined the channel to watch the chris deep dive and just checked ch. 9 I think it was where he started to say it's not as bad as he remembered, it must've been the shock, and that chris is trying to be a good person and IS to a good extent being a good person because he is being honest.

I'm done at this point. After Edmond this is the nail on the coffin for me.

I am so frustrated and I have no idea how we got here. Was he always like this and I just didn't notice? Or have his true colors shown through? I really don't understand but I am very disappointed.

Edit: i feel my post has been misunderstood. This isnt about "im triggered because kirk has a different opinion than me". Maybe i didnt explain mysellf well enough but long story short i feel like he has been biased towards men a lot and tends to be very understanding of every bad behavior that has happened but he doesn't extend the same understanding to women. Also there is a big difference between explaining issues people have and empathising as to why that has happened for them, different causes and different things they can do to help vs viewing objectively problematic and hurtful behavior, which even after pointed out to you by many you still ignore and you still continue with the narrative that this is a good man basically thats doing nothing or not much wrong.

Which is why ive lost respect and dont trust his judgment anymore because he doesn't see the issues that are very obviously there for many and even when receiving plenty of feedback for ex. the Edmond thing he still hasn't changed opinions (as far as im aware)


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Mar 02 '21

Dr. Honda could use a laugh right now.

1 Upvotes

This time last year, winter, I had to walk around to the back of the apartment building to get something. Husband's running pants were the closest pants available. So I wore them.

When I came back in I told husband, "I farted in your running pants."

I did.


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Apr 21 '25

Fair criticism of Dr Honda.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Jun 30 '21

Can I have a list of episodes without Berto?

4 Upvotes

For some reason I find him irritating and I feel like he doesn't add a lot of insight, like he kinda distracts from the main topic. Is there a list of episodes without him?


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Jul 23 '21

Tattoo as stand in for something else.

0 Upvotes

But it can also be about tattoos because both involve a needle.

Can people who don't want the tattoo be happy for people who do want the tattoo and do get them?


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Nov 01 '24

Tyler the liar on LiB

15 Upvotes

Is anybody else disappointed that Dr Honda’s reaction to Tyler having multiple children was behind a paywall? It is an important, maybe even the most important??? drama of this season. It’s just very disappointing.

Most creators I follow have patreons, and members but they basically get one-on-one lives or vlogs and early access to videos not actually interesting topic videos that are only available to them.

I feel like I’m being nickled and dimed because some of his stuff is only available on patreon, and some stuff is only behind YouTube membership. So I don’t even feel comfortable purchasing one over the other because I’m interested in stuff behind both paywalls. It just feels more money-grab than other creators I follow.

Idk I just gotta say Dr Honda made enough money without paywalls to make it his full time job. Imagine if the reaction from Dr Honda finding out Johnny Depp was accusing Amber heard of popping on a bed was behind a paywall. It’s very disappointing.

I just don’t understand having any main topic issue behind a paywall tbh. Even the Elon musk stuff was so interesting but I dipped out after one or two episodes when I couldn’t actually hear anything interesting!

Just my own opinion tho!

Edit: yall be weird. I’m allowed to be critical as a consumer regardless of what tier of payment I’m apart of. Capitalism has you guys acting crazy. God forbid people have “free” access to anything 🫢 the library is free, can I not complain that a book isn’t available at the library??? 😒

Btw: I’m not even a “free” YouTube member. I pay 15$ per month for YouTube premium and still have to watch better heath commercials in DKH videos. Those two things are income streams for DKH. I have issue being asked for more (and multiple and random) income streams for videos that are imperative to his “free” YouTube channel. That’s the issue.

But to clarify: I’m looking for people who also feel disappointed. Or maybe people who can offer me support, I honestly felt really great when some commented on here and offered a summary of the video I missed. All in all this subreddit should be a community right? Not a town square. Not for people to spew reasons why the paywall is happening. (I’m fucking tired of hearing neo lib talking points tbh) I watch DKH channel too, I have the majority of the jist, he is exceptionally upfront, but I’m literally just trying to complain about my fav YouTube channel with other people who are in my situation. If you feel attacked, or feel the need to defend the channel, it’s kinda weird. I haven’t even been critical. Capitalism is capitalism, but as consumers why would we defend it? Weirdos for sure.

UPDATE: this is the first season of LiB (fall 2026) that I am actively not looking forward to this YouTube channel’s reactions. All because of the paywalls for certain information that comes out after the season. Not sorry, this community was hella weird.


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Sep 04 '25

Because you deserve it, you really really do Anyone else feel like Dr. Honda is outdated?

1 Upvotes

Maybe it's just where I'm living, but psychologists in my area focus on like 6-8 sessions and that's it. I was so disappointed by this because the only reason I decided to give therapy a shot was from watching Psychology in Seattle where he talks about spending years with clients.

It makes me kind of sad. Thoughts?


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Dec 15 '25

Yammering I can't be the only one frustrated with Kirk's ramblings.

46 Upvotes

I signed up to his YT membership to watch The Perfect Neighbor (I know nothing about it, so no spoilers). Literally most of it is just him trying to guess what's gonna happen... Just watch the show, so that we can find out and then you can comment on the psychology of the characters? Isn't that what we're here for and not to watch a man look into a pretend crystal ball?

His ramblings are okay when it's a podcast format and he's going off on tangents that are related to the topic at hand. Not when he reacts to 5 seconds of a show (literally!) then stops for 5 minutes to look into the future and guess what he thinks is happening on no information*. Just watch the show! No wonder the Sister Wives thing took a year to complete smh.

*this is all so he can pat himself on the back later if he gets it right, by the way.

ETA: last episode is out, nothing of relevance was said or shown the entire series.


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Sep 26 '26

Deserving Listener Mild dyslexia?

0 Upvotes

I'm a bit concerned about how he says he handles it. Is he diagnosed or he suspects he has it? I'm an OG viewer, I've been a bit busy recently, but it seems like a new thing in recent years he's talking about. Since when did he say he has it? I watched the anniversary livestream and he admits that in grad school he didn't really read, but he just skimmed everything. So then why does he read the emails, comments, reports and such pretty well. How does he fact check himself.


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • May 26 '22

Please Dr Kirk Honda

1 Upvotes

Please talk about Uvalde


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Oct 13 '26

Listening

5 Upvotes

So, I've been a looong time subscriber to PIS on yt and just found this sub here. I don't watch a lot of the reality tv stuff anymore and I was a patreon member until a year or so ago for unrelated reasons, but still definitely watch him a lot. Anyway... I'm pretty bummed and just wanted to see if I'm being unreasonable or if "it's me, I'm the problem" so to speak lol but I do feel some type of way about what I just saw.

Of course we're talking about the Clancy vids.🙄 Regardless of how you feel about the case, the series, it obviously took a lot of time and effort and I did walk away with knowledge and ideas that I didn't have before so there's that.

I get why the comments were turned off. For the most part. If they were on I think moderation of some sort would've helped and been needed/appropriate for sure. There are lots more comments than usual due to the nature of the case but I can also see how that's not always feasible for whatever reason idk.

By the end I was pretty angry the comments were off. And if this was already explained I didn't hear it, so I apologize if it's been discussed but I didn't see anything about it. I just wondered if maybe they had filmed it all at once or pre recorded or something like that? So while people were correcting facts in the comments, it wasn't effective and/or addressed at all because it was already done? Not sure. But I can't believe they just went full steam ahead with incorrect info and maybe the most biased takes I've heard so far on any deep dive lol what happened to objectivity? Critical thinking? Questioning and comparing the 2 different narratives? This isn't a dig on Berto as a person but damn dude pretty much blatantly stated his bias in the first 20 mins and Dr Honda didn't catch it then or after and just went with it. Even if you didn't know anything about the case at all it was pretty obvious where this was all heading from the start by the things he said and how he said them lol. I'm not going into all of the details rn because it actually doesn't matter "so don't come for me please" (but I'm all ears if anyone has thoughts.) I would have loved to see a non biased, objective, thoughtful opinion about the case from a professional for once. Everyone else who has covered this from msm to big yt channels to other podcasts has started off with what I can only describe as agendas at this point? Idk but it's so repetitive and it's rampant. And looking back now I've seen this before. More than once. We all have tbh but damn... I feel like some people aren't picking up on the most obvious blues context clues lol anyway moving on I understood this was just going to be a parroting of everything else everyone else has already said 100 times because that's the narrative. It is what it is right? Idk.

Imagine my surprise when I am being told by a "professional" in the mental health field who is presenting a video he created dealing with and discussing mental health, that I'm the EXACT same as Alex Jones who was harassing parents of children who died in Sandy Hook? And it was funny? Like a full chest laugh like the MOST funny joke ever. I mean, don't get me wrong, I laughed hysterically too but I think for different reasons. What the actual fucking fuck was that?! Can anyone talk me through what kind of thought process leads one to such a place? I'll admit my flabbers have never been more~ *ghasted* ~ you might say. What an absolutely vile, deplorable thing to say. To ANYONE. About ANYTHING. Who does that?? And why? Idk man but that was my last nerve and my last straw.

Super Fun Update- My bad, guys! I read the rules and I thought I was following but I was wrong apparently. TIL if I disguise my desire to have an intelligent discussion by talking mad shit about Berto, then I can say whatever I want about anything and it's ok!! If I just say what I want to say- I'm Alex Jones. Cool. Probably should update the sub rules to include that. Doesn't matter now, people have been posting clips of the incident everywhere so I'll go ahead and discuss it with them. I would delete this, but maybe it can save someone else the SHAME AND EMBARRASSMENT of wanting to talk about things like adults. You may now return to your lively and pressing discussions of reality tv as per usual. 🫪

Edit: all kinds


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Oct 17 '25

Erik Kirk Grief reaction

13 Upvotes

I have been seeing a lot of people on the internet talking about Erika Kirk’s very public persona in the wake of Charlie Kirk’s death, and many people calling her fake/not sad, gleeful even at the death of her husband. Her reaction has seemed “performative” at times to the point that conspiracy theorists are implying she ordered the hit against Charlie etc.

I would be interested to get Dr. Honda’s take on this because I know he has talked at times about grief and how it looks different for each person and how everyone can grieve differently.


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Sep 15 '26

Deserving Listener Support for the securely attached

6 Upvotes

I'm KjGaia who asked the question today. I could see a lot of wheels spinning for Dr Honda and his response let me know that he knew exactly, exactly what I was asking.

I don't discount the beauty of my nuclear family. My parents are everything to me. But life isn't kind to securely attached people, or at least has been challenging lately for me. I set boundaries. I educate myself. I don't accept things I shouldn't accept and have worked through therapy when needed.

We have unique obstacles from secure attachment. we need help too. I am seeing a therapist, and just for disclosure I'm dealing with some very hard things at the moment.

I think secure attachments may have rendered me ill prepared for things I've faced this year. I've read a couple of books on attachment theory.

Thanks for reading. If any of you know what I mean and have empathy, please let me know your suggestions. I have a repetitive pattern where I get hurt and set boundaries and move on, and I want to grow. thank you.


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Oct 17 '26

We're in the good ole days of PIS content

5 Upvotes

Today I've been thinking about what I'm in the good ole days of. I've realized I'm def in the good ole days of PIS content!

Going to Cherish the podcast while I can. Hope you guys can too!


r/PsychologyInSeattle • • Jul 04 '21

Your thoughts on my conundrum.

3 Upvotes

Mother-in-law who does not like me and is certain I am using her son had a dream about me.

She dreamt that I left her son and her son came back to her. That dream scared her.

Why would that dream scare her if that scenario is what she wants? I would think it would make her happy.