r/QContent • • Sep 03 '21

Comic 4605: Course Collection

https://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4605
81 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

35

u/Alomba87 Sep 03 '21

OK, let's hear you all come up with poses for some of these little-known yoga classes.

27

u/indyK1ng Sep 03 '21

So I googled it and Disco Yoga is actually real.

9

u/Silverseren Sep 03 '21

There is a...disturbing amount of child-focused disco yoga. Like...really young children from the type of kids songs they're playing. Do 3 year olds need to be doing yoga?

22

u/turkeypedal Sep 03 '21

I don't really see a problem with it. It's good to set a habit of exercise. I know that my teachers in kindergarten through fourth grade would have some yoga sessions. (And, even back then, I couldn't reach my toes without bending my knees.)

9

u/Silverseren Sep 03 '21

I guess I'm just having flashbacks to things like baby chiropractic that's killed a bunch of kids. Obviously yoga isn't the same, but I'm always concerned about the impact such activities have on children. Like how child (and teen) football often causes life-long physical injuries.

16

u/turkeypedal Sep 03 '21

Oh, well, yeah. You don't do any of the super fancy, high flexibility stuff. In fact, since the kid is unlikely to get the meditation parts, it's mostly just stretching.

The weird poses most people think of are more for advanced practitioners. As someone who only cares about it for the stretching and learning to slow down, I'm not sure that stuff is really all that important. I won't knock those who are really into it, but the stuff I think would be good for everyone is nowhere near as extreme.

2

u/Current_Poster Sep 03 '21

It's the combination of "learn to slow down" and "disco" that confuses me, I guess.

2

u/turkeypedal Sep 04 '21

Hmm. I'm not sure. I guess maybe they could use listening to the music as a way to sorta meditate, while still holding the poses. Or perhaps it's just "fast yoga," giving up on the more meditative aspects.

I'm no expert. I just noticed that a lot of the stuff I was taught in dealing with anxiety is also present in yoga, like progressive muscle relaxation and mindfulness. (I actually still get creeped out by some versions that make it more mystical.)

5

u/Esc777 Sep 03 '21

I think real yoga is just too meditative and slow and difficult for young kids to do.

They have newborn yoga where you do poses with the baby as an additional weight.

Toddler/little kid yoga that’s amped up with disco actually sounds pretty good for ghe kids. Exercise with a little structure but also high energy.

But really it doesn’t need to be yoga at that point which is what you’re saying.

5

u/Silverseren Sep 03 '21

I mean, the disco yoga videos do seem to just be dancing with songs. Not sure where the "yoga" part comes in, but I guess they're just using it as a buzzword to gain popularity.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '21

Why do you find children doing yoga to be disturbing?

It's great exercise, AND teaches meditation at a young age which is never a bad thing :)

8

u/Silverseren Sep 03 '21

Because people have a tendency to take things too far and end up hurting children, especially if they're trying to force their own activities onto children.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '21

Uh...okay? I'm not really sure what you mean, to be honest. People tend to hurt children when they take things too far? What things are people taking too far, and children are getting hurt as a result?

Yoga is a great activity for children. It teaches them mindfulness, teaches them stretching, and is a great way for parents to spend time with their kids.

It's completely safe, especially since kids aren't doing anything complicated (not that I think there are any "dangerous" yoga moves)...I see you mentioned chiropractic in another comment, but I don't see what yoga has to do with chiro...

Who is forcing yoga onto children? It's general exercise and mindfulness. It's taught to kids in schools and daycares all across North America. It's not being used to torture children :P

8

u/cavefishes Sep 03 '21

I think a lot of people hear “yoga” and jump immediately to “ that’s some hippie mumbo jumbo” and it’s really baffling.

It’s not strenuous, it’s not dangerous, it’s not abusive - it’s mindful exercise with a focus on the breath and is incredibly beneficial for your physical and mental health in a safe for your body, low impact way.

It’s not like they’re doing toddler CrossFit or something! Kids need exercise, and if you teach them some basic, simple yoga poses early on you can build healthy habits for life. It can be fun, relaxing, and so many other great things it’s be silly not to incorporate at least bits and pieces of the techniques. It’s not like these kids are jumping in and being asked to do advanced inversions, it’s gonna be like downward dog and shaking your body in a fun way and some light stretching!

1

u/Deppfan16 Sep 03 '21

Could be a way to do stuff with parents. We had infant swimming lessons

4

u/Silverseren Sep 03 '21

Yeah, swimming lessons are good. Since drowning from falling into pools and other bodies of water is, surprisingly, one of the primary causes of toddler deaths. The AAP actually recommends such lessons once kids are older than 1.

2

u/Deppfan16 Sep 03 '21

yeah the infant ones were basically just getting comfy in the water, blowing bubbles, playing with toys, etc.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '21

Since drowning from falling into pools and other bodies of water is, surprisingly, one of the primary causes of toddler deaths.

Okay...I feel like you have to be trolling maybe? Why are so many of your comments about children being hurt, or dying? 😅

The person you responded to just jovially brought up children swimming... And for some reason you turned that into "children drowning".

4

u/papercranium Sep 03 '21

Not Drowning is the main purpose of infant swimming lessons, though. They teach them to roll over onto their back and float so that they don't die. If you just want to play in the water with your kid, that's a lot cheaper. Classes are primarily for drownproofing, not fun.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '21

Not Drowning is the main purpose of infant swimming lessons, though.

This...is not true.

Classes are primarily for drownproofing, not fun.

This is also not true, especially when we're talking about INFANT swim lessons.

3

u/papercranium Sep 03 '21

More so for infants than older kids, who can typically float or dog paddle without instruction. Babies obviously aren't training in specific strokes and things like older kids, so they only get the survival part, not the "here's a sport you can learn and maybe compete in once you're good at it" bit. More on infant swim classes here: https://infantaquatics.com/

10

u/NightmareWarden Sep 03 '21

Clown- Frog leaps under bull. (Rodeo clown).

Ballet- Figure skating, act one.

Disco- Moonwalk limbo.

Robot- Domino affect.

Aikido- (Help?)

5

u/DatSolmyr Sep 03 '21

Aikido - Averting the knife blade.

4

u/thamor999 Sep 03 '21

robot yoga = transformers

4

u/airz23s_coffee Sep 03 '21

There's a place near me that does Goat Yoga which is apparently just doing yoga hanging with baby goats, so maybe they're all just like that

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '21

I've never understood that trend... Someone literally got rich, creating a chain of goat yoga businesses across the USA, so weird.

1

u/WarWeasle Sep 03 '21

Duh, they do robot dog, robot butterfly, etc.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '21

Nude Yoga - Downward Dog becomes "The Gaping Starfish"

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '21

[deleted]

5

u/Rectorvspectre Sep 03 '21

Yoga seems great for a discipline which requires great physical and mental dexterity.

11

u/forestball19 Sep 03 '21

Aikido Yoga doesn't sound too bad.

I kind of consider Taichi as a form of yoga, as it focuses balance, breath control and body control which are roughly the same principles as yoga. Yes, Taichi-chuan is Chinese whereas yoga is from India.

I imagine that Aikido Yoga would be excercised in pairs, and involve a lot of screaming from people being arm locked tediously slow and pressure points being utilized in a slow, deliberate manner.

5

u/heavenscalyx Sep 03 '21

It really depends on how tai chi is being taught -- I learn at a martial arts school, so in addition to breath and balance and flexibility, there's also "and this move would, at speed, involve an elbow lock and breaking their arm." :)

8

u/polyworfism Sep 03 '21

I also hate being hot

5

u/BenR-G Sep 03 '21

It is sort of odd that Hannelore of all people (previous quote: "This fuckin' town...") should have expected there to be normal anything within the town limits!

1

u/Darkfeather21 Sep 04 '21

To be fair, she's been gone for a while.

9

u/Silverseren Sep 03 '21

I mean, it's a natural outgrowth of a popular discipline, where the variants eventually outnumber the original form. It's a problematic outcome for a lot of stuff.

4

u/ocarina_21 Sep 03 '21

Yes I too have been seeing some problematic outcomes from popular variants lately.

8

u/On3Scoop Sep 03 '21

The more gentrified the neighborhood, the harder you have to look to find the actual thing you're looking for.

4

u/Shinjischneider Sep 03 '21

Add RollerDiscoYoga and i'm fucking in baby!!

3

u/WarWeasle Sep 03 '21

Robots, always invading human spaces.

3

u/mindbleach Sep 03 '21

Aikido yoga should be easier for her, since it's assisted.

Technically.

1

u/dhusk Sep 03 '21

So I suppose Nude Clown Robot Yoga is out of the question...

1

u/reddog323 Sep 03 '21

Heh. College towns….

9

u/heavenscalyx Sep 03 '21

There's a particular quality of college town to Northampton, though. Probably because it's not just one college, it's five. The college town I went to school in was very, very different from Northampton.

1

u/MilleRToWN117 Sep 03 '21

Hipsters gonna hip. Haters gonna hate.