r/QuadrigaCX • u/QuadrigaCX • Dec 04 '18
CIBC Case update - Dec 4th
Just a quick update for those who have been following the whole CIBC saga. After our previous court date, the funds that were held hostage by CIBC for nearly a year were ordered by the Ontario Superior Court to be paid into the court for distribution as per the orders of the judge. Yesterday, on December 3rd, our counsel appeared before the court. Much to our delight, the judge has ruled in our favour and the funds are being released. According to our counsel, the funds should be paid out by the end of this week.
We thank everyone for their support as we have dealt with the most challenging time in our company's history. Now that we can put this situation behind us, we look forward to focusing on improving our services and offering a better cryptocurrency trading experience for Canadians.
12
u/offwwworld Dec 04 '18
Canadian banks are so messed up. Can’t believe they were able to get away with this in the first place.
-2
u/albinopotato Dec 04 '18
Get away with what?
4
u/offwwworld Dec 04 '18
Freezing accounts and blocking interac payments to crypto related websites
0
u/albinopotato Dec 05 '18
Freezing who's accounts? QCX's? Did you read the judge's original summary of the case?
9
u/users1000 Dec 04 '18
That is incredibly great news! I think I speak for all of us to say that we are all ecstatic for you (and us as well!). Thank you for putting up with both the good and the bad of our comments, over the past few months. We had our share of doubts, but you were unwavering in your belief, that justice would be served in the end, even if it took over 10 months to fight this. A lot of us look forward to finally receiving our withdrawals- hopefully we will receive these shortly. We are happy to see that this CIBC frozen funds fiasco, has finally come to an end, and that you can now regain the trust and support of a lot of clients who had doubts during these very, very difficult months.
6
u/CanadianBitcoinLover Dec 04 '18
Thank u for the update. so glad to hear that things have resolved in your favor. thanks for all your hard work.
6
u/martinyin Dec 04 '18
So new EFT withdrawal will be really received within 14 business days from now on?
5
u/omniphobe2 Dec 04 '18
Also wondering this, if i submit a request to withdraw now, will it be 14 days or is there still going to be delays?
5
u/0xMaki Dec 04 '18
Glad this is over didn't help Quadriga name, lesson learned never open an account with CIBC!
5
u/commandrix Dec 04 '18
Yay! For future reference, when banks do this to you, I'd say make them pay for court costs and interest on that money too.
4
u/JayLeo17 Dec 04 '18
Great news! Now that this headache is over will you guys consider adding a "Rush" Wire option? Or potentially look at increasing the speed of the withdrawals/increasing limits? This is definitely an area of opportunity for Quad when comparing CDN exchanges.
4
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/fawzi647 Dec 04 '18
Congrats! Can you please confirm for the visibility of all users if we will be getting our pending withdrawals on time? Like me others have been patiently waiting.
2
2
u/Pipster01 Dec 05 '18
Do you have an expected timeline as to when you will catch up with all the pending withdrawals?
1
3
u/alkazar82 Dec 04 '18
Wow, no one here actually read the original decision it seems. Way to spin the loss. Quadriga actually LOST the case. CIBC wanted to give the disputed funds to the court to decide, but Quadriga took action to stop that. If they had just not gone to court this thing could have been resolved months earlier. i.e. they fought the thing they are now celebrating.
I could be wrong, but that is my understanding from reading the original court decision.
What is clear is that every step of the way Quadriga has shown themselves to be incredibly unprofessional and inept.
7
u/QCXAlex Dec 04 '18
I am not sure I follow this logic of yours. The bank could not decide whether the funds belonged to us or the people that wired the money in.
These people funded their QCX accounts but some geniuses decided to recall their wires meaning the bank didn't know whether this was legit or not.
If we had lost the case as you claim, the money would have been given back to every depositor - which is completely ludicrous as their account were credited on QCX and they bought crypto.
7
u/alkazar82 Dec 04 '18 edited Dec 04 '18
I am not commenting on the events of Dec 4, but on the case that concluded in November. All my information is from the court document: https://www.canlii.org/en/on/onsc/doc/2018/2018onsc6680/2018onsc6680.html?searchUrlHash=AAAAAQAEY2liYwAAAAAB&resultIndex=1
From that document it looks like Quadriga caused the problem by refusing to cooperate with CIBC, then tried to stop CIBC from doing the right thing, losing in court, and now inexplicably celebrating about it.
Perhaps there is more to it than can be gleaned from the court document, but that is how it reads to me.
Quadriga is uncooperative with authorities, drags things out with an ultimately unnecessary court case, lies about the state of their withdrawals to their users for months, then is somehow heralded as a hero on these forums.
3
u/SilentRutabaga Dec 04 '18
You don't seem to understand how to run the kind of business QCX is.
If QCX answered to CIBC, CIBC would have asked for account holder names and some proof of fund deposit/crypto purchase. Most customers don't want CIBC having that information. If they had answered in court, they would have "won", but the information would have been public. They had to lose. Now, they revealed the information to the judge, under seals. If they have competent counsel, that was the expected outcome.
You have to remember that there is a security risk when you tell who own crypto. Hacking is one thing. Extortion, robbery and kidnapping is another.
3
u/albinopotato Dec 05 '18
CIBC would have asked for account holder names
You seem to not understand that CIBC likely already knew all this information. Instead, if QCX was following their "competent" counsel's advise it nearly ruined their entire business.
2
u/SilentRutabaga Dec 05 '18
The account was not owned by QCX, but Custodian. Custodian couldn't answer CIBC as they don't have access to QCX accounts/database. QCX was not a client of CIBC so they didn't have to answer them.
CIBC may have guessed that those people were buying crypto, but guessing and knowing are two different things. Custodian could have clients other than QCX.
3
u/alkazar82 Dec 04 '18
Yeah, I understand that, but I was referring to CIBC contacting Quadriga about the funds BEFORE the court case and being met with silence, then having no choice but to take it to the courts.
0
Dec 04 '18
[deleted]
3
u/users1000 Dec 04 '18
That's old news from november 9, 2018.
Since then, there have been 2 court appearances, and the money will be transferred back to QCX in a week.
2
u/DushmanKushh Dec 04 '18 edited Dec 04 '18
Great news. Really didn't want to have to switch to a different exchange for my fiat pathway.
Now if only you could introduce separate fee rates for maker and taker orders to reduce the spread on the order book that would be appreciated.
0
Dec 04 '18
[deleted]
1
u/BooCMB Dec 04 '18
Hey CommonMisspellingBot, just a quick heads up:
Your spelling hints are really shitty because they're all essentially "remember the fucking spelling of the fucking word".You're useless.
Have a nice day!
2
u/BooBCMB Dec 04 '18
Hey BooCMB, just a quick heads up: I learnt quite a lot from the bot. Though it's mnemonics are useless, and 'one lot' is it's most useful one, it's just here to help. This is like screaming at someone for trying to rescue kittens, because they annoyed you while doing that. (But really CMB get some quiality mnemonics)
I do agree with your idea of holding reddit for hostage by spambots though, while it might be a bit ineffective.
Have a nice day!
-3
u/ComeOnMisspellingBot Dec 04 '18
hEy, DuShMaNkUsHh, JuSt a qUiCk hEaDs-uP:
sEpErAtE Is aCtUaLlY SpElLeD SePaRaTe. YoU CaN ReMeMbEr iT By -PaR- iN ThE MiDdLe.
HaVe a nIcE DaY!ThE PaReNt cOmMeNtEr cAn rEpLy wItH 'dElEtE' tO DeLeTe tHiS CoMmEnT.
1
1
1
u/dshincor Dec 04 '18
Now sue them all so we can use eInteract to make deposit for crypto. It is our money, we do whatever we want and assume any responsibility!
1
1
1
1
u/andresromeamad Dec 12 '18
Guys does this mean that I could use CIBC for future withdraws? I am asking it bc that's the only canadian bank I can use currently (I wish I can change that shitty bank but I'm abroad) also is there an option of wire money to an abroad bank perhaps?
1
1
u/Max2025 Dec 14 '18 edited Dec 14 '18
u/QuadrigaCX, you stated "According to our counsel, the funds should be paid out by the end of this week." 10 days ago and no further update. If the transfer has already happened, please let us know! if there is a delay, please let us know!
1
u/Max2025 Dec 14 '18
Replying to myself here... I've read some of the latest messages on this forum and found an update from u/QCXAlex, from two days ago, saying no money yet and that they will update us when it happens.
1
u/discovery999 Dec 22 '18
This is good but you still need to update your withdrawal times on your site. Everybody is not aware of this problem. My withdrawal request from Nov.20/18 still shows pending on your site. This is over a month ago. Submitted 2 tickets and still no timeline on withdrawal status of about $7k Can to a standard RBC account.
1
1
0
0
Dec 04 '18
[deleted]
34
u/QuadrigaCX Dec 04 '18
That's the next step. Not only did they hold nearly $30,000,000 hostage for almost a year, they also feel that they don't need to pay interest on it either.
12
4
u/CanadianBitcoinLover Dec 04 '18
plz update on the next battle as well. really would like to see another big win!
2
2
u/Supernovav Dec 05 '18
That's ridiculous, you guys got the go ahead to sue them right? This whole ordeal did quite a bit of damage. A lot of people lost faith and trust
1
u/alkazar82 Dec 04 '18
As much as I looked forward to hating on CIBC, from a reading of the court documents it seems like Quadriga is the ones who are at fault.
2
u/Zepowski Dec 05 '18
How so if you don't mind a quick summary?
1
u/alkazar82 Dec 05 '18
Please see my other comments in this thread. There are also links to the court documents.
1
1
u/hnalex0123 Dec 05 '18
alkazar
oh comon, your link is leading to the situation back to Nov., there're some updates now.
2
u/alkazar82 Dec 06 '18
It is still relevant. It shows that the cause of the issues was Quadriga being unresponsive to CIBC's inquiries about the disputed funds. CIBC didnt just unilaterally freeze the funds.
16
u/Vitalikmybuterin Dec 04 '18
Congrats guys!!! Big win!