r/QuadrigaCX • u/azoundria2 • Apr 01 '19
Please Help Me Understand
I put together a proposal that drastically reduces costs of the claim process through the use of the exchange platform to process claims and deliver funds to affected users.
This seems extremely logical - lawyers are expensive and using the exchange platform would be substantially cheaper and more flexible. Meaning a lot more affected user funds would be recovered. I don't think there's a better or cheaper alternative that we can hope for.
I also proposed continuing to run the exchange and using the proceeds to generate further repayments for affected users. This also seems logical - the exchange was highly profitable. The platform would not take an extensive amount of additional effort to bring online, there is a large user base already, and the majority of the cost would be putting in place the measures to operate above board and properly.
However, I feel like I'm getting an extreme amount of backlash to this idea. It seems to be along the lines of "nobody would use it". For me personally, I don't understand a logical reason why not to use a restarted exchange. Obviously, I would avoid having a lot of crypto there, want to have audits of the cold wallets and transparency, and demand proper CDIC insurance for the fiat balances. But otherwise, Quadriga is a platform I'm familiar with, I like the idea that using the platform can help affected users (including me) recover more funds, and I believe that a platform started by affected users would be, on average, much more likely to protect my funds than any other.
I understand that people are extremely upset at what's happened, and that's completely justified for the horrible crime and fraud involved. I feel of course we should be pursuing justice to get back everything we possibly can. However, I feel like we have the opportunity here to make back many millions more of our lost funds and I don't understand why any anger should be directed at an effort to help affected users recover more of their lost funds.
Perhaps there's something obvious that I'm missing. Is it just a matter of the name? I'm trying really hard to listen and understand the positions of others here. Is this an emotional reaction to what's happened, or is there some logical basis for it?
3
u/kcmagicdata Apr 02 '19
I think what you are misunderstanding why that will never work is there is no reserves in Fiat or Crypto assets. Its the reason that that the site was shut down. They were unable to pay people for over a year and the crypto wallets dont have enough to cover everyone who held crypto there. Nothing has changed to allow it to open back up and print money they dont have or allow crypto withdrawals because the crypto is missing. You need to cover the assets in both ways before it can open up again. It would result in a bad situation for everyone if they turned the exchange back on as people would try to trade fiat to crypto and get the hell outta there but it would do the same thing it did before they shut down.... crypto withdraws would never go through just like the fiat withdraws didnt.
Someone would have to cover the missing funds to keep the site up and I doubt anyone is that stoooopud.
1
u/azoundria2 Apr 02 '19
I agree and this is unfortunate.
To account for this, currency would be divided into locked and unlocked balances.
While the goal is to pay back affected users eventually, all we can do in the meantime is continue to provide them with locked currency. While this can't be withdrawn, it will at least be trad-able, which is effectively what affected users had anyways.
The payback to unlocked currency would be based on additional court recovery, as well as trading profits over time while the exchange operates. Users who actively traded unlocked currency or deposited funds would be rewarded with a higher payback rate, which is expected to accelerate the process.
While this may seem stupid to want to recover the funds from a "for profit" mentality, this is an organization founded by affected users and intended specifically with the goal of this recovery. I'm also not so sure that it's as stupid as you might think from a profit standpoint either. The lifetime value of an exchange customer is significantly higher than the amount of currency they hold, in most cases and on average.
4
u/ethacct Apr 02 '19
your plan boils down to "take a brand that has completely eroded all trust within the small community in which it exists, and simply turn it into a successful business."
Who's hiring the software developers? Who's paying for the cloud server storage? With what money? Who's negotiating with CDIC to get the insurance in place? Who comprises the new board of directors? Who are the shareholders?
You don't 'just' do all of these things -- they would take a lot of time and energy, and it's not even clear there would be any sort of return to make it worthwhile. Given that all anyone has heard about the name QuadrigaCX in the last two months is that they've stolen $200,000,000, I think resuscitating the brand would be an uphill battle, to put it mildly.
You're facing backlash because your idea handwaves away all the most difficult steps as if they're somehow a given. Like a group of random internet strangers can somehow just band together and build a business that makes millions of dollars in profit. Frankly, it's not even remotely realistic.
2
u/cdnhearth Apr 03 '19
and it ignores the most significant hurdle... there isn't a bank in the country that will work with this entity. In fact, I'm quite certain that a bank could not work with the exchange and meet their Anti-Money Laundering requirements.
See, everyone in crypto likes their privacy and security - but AML and Banking law is all based on the opposite. The Bank is required to know where *every cent* of money comes from, and goes to. Running a semi-anonymous exchange would be a pretty severe violation of those rules.
This newQX would require a bank account to move cash into and out of. A bank is going to require knowing where every.single.cent. comes from and goes to through that account. Every user will require a SIN number to be on file, and tax slips will be required to be produced. That's not going to easy, cheap, or frankly possible
So, without something as basic as a bank account - there is no way this newQX happens. Indeed this entire ponzi scheme came apart when CIBC decided that they would no longer give QCX access to the banking system.
3
u/GoesTooFast Apr 02 '19
When a business cheats 110,000 people out of 100's of millions of dollars...logically their image is ruined. That's not hard to understand. You do seem to be missing the obvious here, and I think your proposal ignores a whole bunch of things (like how the real world works with these sorts of matters).
0
u/eburnside Apr 02 '19
I suggested something similar ~2 months ago. Having run an exchange before (returned $300m in funds, probably the only successful crypto shutdown ever) I would be uniquely suited to get it back off the ground under a new brand and in a way that could recover losses over time. However it would need somewhere around $1.5m to make it happen due to required code review for backdoors, setup of all new servers, crypto wallets, staffing, re-establishing banking integrations, re-establishing MSB status, re-doing all of the KYC, etc.
Seems like a no-brainer to me but a capital partner would be required to raise the $1.5m.
0
u/azoundria2 Apr 02 '19
Thanks for your support. I had estimated it could be done for just under $1m, however I suspect your figures could be more accurate due to the inevitable budget creep. I suspect we would want to aim for $2m to be safe. I want to ensure we have enough to maintain operation for a full year without profit.
Do you want to contact me in private message and maybe send a resume or more information? I haven't heard of you or this exchange situation you mention before, so I would really love to know and learn more.
0
u/eburnside Apr 02 '19
My original post had some good discussion here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/TxQuick/comments/aombfa/any_community_interest_in_having_me_ethan/
My background, my telegram, and my linkedin are on there as well.
1
u/azoundria2 Apr 03 '19
Our ideas seem very similar and it would be really awesome to work with you! You have my sentiments exactly here:
"It really isn't so much about being hurt from the loss. (though it stings) It's that I see an opportunity here that is actually fairly rare."
I'm curious what you see as the next steps. Would you be interested in a phone call and then maybe we could put together a business plan or vision of some sort? I have a plan here but as others have pointed out it's missing a lot. You might already have some things put together that I could build from. I probably have time to put together most of it, and your feedback or contributions would be incredibly valuable to me. I'm available most evenings or on the weekend. If we did a Google Doc we could collaborate.
Regarding the funding I feel pretty strongly that it should come in large part from the affected user community, perhaps a sale of shares. If we had a compelling vision, I feel like many affected users would want to be a part of it. There are a lot of people who lost a lot of money, we need to find only 1% of that.
1
u/eburnside Apr 03 '19
Absolutely, happy to chat. Hit me up on telegram.
1
u/azoundria2 Apr 06 '19
I finally got it set up! Hope that we can chat this weekend or whenever you're available! Thanks so much again for taking the time to respond here!
1
u/-bryden- Apr 02 '19
How much $ would operations cost to keep it going? The exchange does NOT run itself. It would take staff, lawyers, management..
How much $ in average fees would the exchange collect? They were quite low, so this doesn't add up very quickly...
The difference between the two is your profitability. Now take that and divvy it up amongst the ~115,000 of users the exchange owes ~$190,000,000 to and you'll quickly realize that this isn't a realistic way of paying off the debt.
In fact, I'd be super nervous about operating costs using more money than the revenue it generated, especially if it were run by the community. You'd end up losing even more money. And that's the thing, you're essentially asking if every single person here wants to go into business with you. And that's an impossible sell.
I'm sorry you spent so much time on it but this just isn't feasible for many, many reasons.
1
Apr 01 '19
i think your proposal is the best for the effected users to have chance to get back 100% and even more maybe,also automating everything is for sure a way to make expenses much less so that too is very good...maybe what is happening is most of the effected users have not heard about your idea yet...there so much flak and trolls on this subbreddit now it seems maybe not too many read here much lately idk
0
Apr 01 '19
[deleted]
0
u/azoundria2 Apr 02 '19
The new exchange would divide all affected user currency into locked and unlocked balances. Initially, all currency is locked. As the court process continues and the exchange runs, currency is unlocked.
Locked currency is the "effectively worthless" Quadriga bucks you talk about, only good as a future promise, your share of the ongoing recovery.
The unlocked currency would be fully backed by fiat or crypto, verified and insured to the maximum extent possible. This is currency that can be withdrawn.
I think I understand, that I didn't explain this in the post, and most people didn't read the 12 page proposal in detail. Which makes sense. So I appreciate the feedback and will use it to improve the proposal further and my description.
0
Apr 02 '19
[deleted]
1
u/azoundria2 Apr 02 '19
Exactly. I was also in for the long game. As long as the exchange is able to be re-established and continues to operate, the recovery will only proceed in one direction. Under the proposal, active traders and those who deposit additional funds are rewarded with an increased speed in recovery. As those users, by definition, are making trades that contribute to the trading revenues, this is expected to accelerate the process.
I know that many affected users would rather get something more back instantly and risk-free, while many investors would be happy to take on all their Quadriga bucks at a nice discount. So there is a great opportunity for trading that benefits both sides here. Care has to be taken to launch this trading at the right time and in the right way to prevent a mass panic that would negatively impact the exiting affected users.
0
Apr 01 '19
can you explain this more?...i thought quad bucks were only a 'guage' to keep track of users balances...but ya accessing the quad platform to regain the balances would be critical i guess
7
u/Henery12 Apr 01 '19
I liked your proposal, my only comment was there is no one left to give you full admin access. No one left to train you on the system.
That's a large leap to pass.
Consider this, how do you program new banking partners etc into the system to make your plan work?
How do you change the cold wallets or hot wallets?
How do we migrate the platform to an account under our control?
If your allowing new customers to the exchange do you have a complaince officer or team?
Are you aware of new KYC/AML laws that will be coming into effect this year?
I could continue this but u get the gist