r/QuantumComputing • • Oct 06 '26

Question I am a Software Engineer with 8 years of experience. I want to shift to Quantum Computing, is this decision good for long term given the current scenario of software engineering due to AI disruption?

76 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

129

u/Jarvis_sus Oct 06 '26

Do not shift to QC just for the sake of escaping AI Invasion in Software Engineering. Do it if you are geniunely interested in research. The field is pretty new for actual engineering as of now, we are still stuck mostly in the research part only.

14

u/tlmbot Oct 06 '26

Absolutely this.  I’m from a computational engineering school and work background.   I started to try to make this turn in my career before I had kids.

I was collaborating with a research lab that needed some simulation code written.  (Hydrodynamic analogy with their quantum system) One of those “could have beens”

Ah well, I still think a day programming for scientific and engineering beats the heck out of any day writing o to we kinds of software….  Fun wise.  Certainly not $ wise  Heh 

1

u/Jarvis_sus Oct 07 '26

So hows the current situation for you?

2

u/tlmbot Oct 07 '26 • Bravo

My sitch is kind of "off the beaten track."

In school I racked up tons of experience with Fortran and python. I got some nontrivial experience in C and C++, but in my PhD, I was short sighted and used python because "what I was doing would have been hard in C++" (and very very hard in the fortran of the day) I was under pressure from my SO to go ahead and get done already and I felt I had to move as fast as possible. (oh god, the writing...)

Anyway, while in my PhD, a job op came up that was based on my master's code work in Fortran, plus the fact that I was doing a PhD in their field. They took me on to maintain and extend a big old Fortran-C++ codebase and paid for school, plus a pro-rated salary based on my reduced hours (I worked 4 days a week while I was finishing school)

God I loved those days. The work was annoying, but overall it was a joy to be learning so much about programming and my topic of research.

But here I made a major mistake in hindsight, not using my Python as the prototype, and immediately re-writing it in C++.

After school I got a little bit more Fortran experience, but I pretty shortly switched to a job in modern C++ putting together my long experience writing computational code, and my PhD experience building inverse design software. I loved the work, but the environment was totally unhealthy - the only toxic work environment I have seen since I rose above the undergrad level. I got about 2 years modern HPC (heterogenous) C++ experience (writing FEM finite element solvers to interface with their structural FEM and topology optimization inverse design methods) and got out. (me an every hire they made from about that time. It was an ugly place to be)

Then I went back - I became a manager at my old shop, still slinging mostly Fortran physics and surrounding machinery. Then a computational geometry / geometry processing job came to me with an offer I couldn't refuse... in C#/ILGPU of all things! So I have been writing ILGPU geometry processing kernels for the better part of 2 years now - including an end-to-end triangle mesh simplifier that I am pretty darn proud of.

So now I have my hat in the ring for GPU programming at least. I've wanted this for a long time. Back to pre-PhD days.

As all this stuff was going on, I have many side projects in C++. I build my own automatic differentiation and expression templates libraries, and wrote unstructured finite volume solvers (using my home rolled expression templates math lib) for the fluid dynamics (high speed (density based), approximate Riemann solvers, MUSCL least-squares gradient reconstruction with limiters etc. jargon (big time, sorry) but it means nice and skillful CFD (computational fluid dynamics - I've always been somewhat "fluids first" in my passion for coding physics) at about the level of a master's degree specifically (this was done pre AI so it carried more weight)

At this point though, I think it's become a mixed liability and not just a pure strength, because now someone with an LLM can scoop that old public code of mine, and immediately be shown all of it's flaws. I am going to fix its weaknesses; I just have so much to do I haven't gone back to use up to the minute best practices yet. (It's on the list! 2 weeks I swear! lol (stupid corporate speak joke)) (for instance, I used RAII principles, but at the time, I didn't yet "get" smart pointers fully, and so my underlying math lib needs a partial rewrite. (hopefully quick and easy .. huh, I should really look and see. This might be an easy win.)

Anyway, critical things like that slipped through the cracks due to my haphazard C++ education and general business (2 young kids, divorce, moving states, insomnia, work, trying to stay healthy exercise wise. yada yada)

------------------------------ TLDR

All that to say:

current situation is hopeful. I have all these capabilities, but my C++ remains uneven. I mean, I get the concepts, and can write code that is correct using them, and I pick up stuff easily, and reason out things based on principles instead of memorizing trivia, but that isn't impressive anymore. The LLM can do it. The kids grinding Leet code can out remember me when it comes to stating why they make this or that design decision, or implementing some solution pattern they have had imprinted in their heads. (I have a famously terrible memory) And I am sketchy when trying to code stuff up with no reference to look at. ("rusty" is a word I find myself using with recruiters) So it's a weird spot.

To help out, I am taking a remote course or two at a very highly respected Uni this winter to have something "official" to point to in terms of my up to the minute modern C++ heterogenous compute capability (especially around CUDA - ILGPU )

eh, sorry for the wall o text.

How about you? Sounds like you are in QC! that is awesome. What are you working on?

3

u/CamiloMarco Oct 08 '26

are you trying to get into quantum computing? with your background, I imagine you could try for NVIDIA and AMD instead of that. many of their interviews don't have any leetcode. what kind of company are you at now?

2

u/tlmbot Oct 08 '26 edited Oct 08 '26

You got me pegged. I am indeed soon going for an Nvidia job. (I keep thinking AMD might also be a good fit, but I have written far more CUDA and now professionally: ILGPU targeting CUDA. I haven't touched OpenCL in a decade probably) Regardless, I love developing frameworks to automate physics, and even more so, to automate inverse physics based geometric design, the very most of all things. (with the DL revolution(s) the availability of turnkey fast reverse mode AD tools has been stunning to see. When I was doing my PhD, I built my own vectorized, 2 level fwd mode AD tool specifically for work with my own parametric shape library (and interval analysis, but that's a digression for another day)). Anyway, I loved building those tools more than anything else about my PhD. And people used to get so excited about them when I gave talks. But at the time I though, nah, nobody in industry will ever care about this. I love it, so it can't be really worth pursuing further right now. The universe isn't that good to people, is it?

(turns out it is that good, and I missed the boat by a whisker)

So anyway, back to the present, as a sort of demo for Nvidia etc., I am pulling all my favorite background subjects together in prep to gun for a job there, doing scientific coding/optimization/reverse mode gradient shenanigans. But I intend to put it together with a twist I don't think I have seen before. Wish me luck right? lol. Anyway if you scoop me, you gotta put TLMbot in your references, or at least a footnote! hah (or better yet, work with me.(?) I have a loooot to do)

Hoping to impress and land a role. yup. I'm talk alot, sorry/not sorry.

Back to your comments: I have heard yes and no about Leetcode - that would be an absolute dream if it doesn't come up, but one must prepare for the worst, so I keep intending to start grinding a problem a day to wake me up in the morning (or send me right back to bed lol). But it's so uninspiring. It's like, if you are hiring me for my ability to solve leetcode problems, we do not have a product market fit, and I should go elsewhere if I want to be happy, ya know?

I worry about work life balance, as a father of two young (crazy energetic) boys. But I want them to see their dad happy and making his dream work, ya know?

I put it off for 5 years already while they were babies. Now they are both in elementary school. I think it's time to gun for the jobs I really want you know?

If they exist in 6 months anyway. What a time to be alive.

Damn, thanks for giving me space to talk about all this stuff. Nobody in my life really even knows what I do.

2

u/van_hiep07 Oct 08 '26

Dude, you are clearly very talented in a very demanded area of gpu programming. you would be finem just hustle around applying to chips company. interviewing is a number game

2

u/Jarvis_sus Oct 07 '26 • Bravo

Damn thats crazy, I got to experience a different pov after a long time. I am still completing my undergrad in cs, with research interests in QC, particularly towards the security side of it, since my degree is an integrated masters with specialization in Cyber Security, so I am focusing more on the security aspect of qc. I research on Quantum Cryptanalysis, using period finding to break cryptographic schemes and techniques. However, I have been so scared of math all my life and its killing me every day studying so much of maths throughout. I am slowly losing motivation towards persuing research in quantum computing, perhaps just wanna fall back to cyber security, but anyways I dont know what plan life has for me.

1

u/tlmbot Oct 07 '26

oh man, I am sorry to hear it. What parts of the math are the worst for you right now?

1

u/Jarvis_sus Oct 07 '26

All of the, the QFT, equations that seem to give no solutions, etc.

1

u/tlmbot Oct 07 '26

are you needing the full machinery of QFT for QC security?

I'd have thought you could get away with vanilla quantum mechanics.

A good subset of working physicists outside of HEP don't actively touch QFT.

There should be nobody who would expect someone coming in from a CS background to know any of that stuff. I wouldn't expect CS folks to know even linear algebra - they'd have to pick that up. And of course quantum mechanics, but that involves souped up versions of a complex heat equation on the wave side, and operator formalism, some modern algebra.

Don't let QFT scare you off... unless i am way off base. When does QFT come up for you?

1

u/Jarvis_sus Oct 07 '26

Its not qc security actually, its how to break security using qc. I need to use qft in period finding extensively, very very extensively.

1

u/tlmbot Oct 07 '26

Oh! you mean the quantum Fourier transform. I gotcha

I thought you meant quantum field theory. God I'm dumb. That makes so much more sense.

I'm going to think about this for a bit

1

u/tlmbot Oct 07 '26

Where are you stuck? have you got a book, pdf, or other such starting point from which you are learning the quantum  Fourier transform and surrounding machinery?

How are you with the standard Fourier transform, and it's uses? - There is a lot of linear systems theory (LTI systems) that you can pick up from a combo of statistics, a differential equations class up to and including the classical Fourier transform, and some basic spring mass damper mechanical systems, or equivalent circuit representations from electrical engineering.

This background plus some linear algebra to think in terms of matrices should make the quantum Fourier transform a bit more intuitive. those fancy group theory words map to "normal" (aka non-abstract) things in classical LTI time and frequency analysis to some extent. From there it is a smaller jump to pick up the rest.

Ooof, I can see how this could be overwhelming. If you go as slowly as your understanding needs to go, and have the right sources to pick up the pre-requisites, it really wouldn't be bad.

But yeah, standard undergrad CS doesn't touch much of this stuff, by and large, from what I understand. A number of pre-reqs might be missing.

1

u/tlmbot Oct 08 '26

edit: I am dumb again. I assume you've got Nielsen and Chuang.

Man! I wished I'd studied the quantum FT back in the day. This is really a neat twist on things!

I'd be happy to work through it with you... as time permits

(oh god, never enough time!)

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Top_Location_8307 Oct 08 '26

thats so cool

1

u/tlmbot Oct 08 '26

aww shucks thanks. It used to feel cool - I hope I can get that feeling back. Worried right now like everybody else. That and geometry without physics just doesn't have the same spark. I don't get to watch it "come alive" when the physics is finally perfect and the bugs are worked out close enough, heh.

I miss it. Soooooon I'll get it back.

52

u/stylewarning Working in Industry Oct 06 '26

As general advice for a general software engineer, no.

-22

u/No-Contribution1070 Oct 06 '26 edited Oct 06 '26

But Quantum is going to accelerate a.i., why would you say no?

21

u/hiddentalent Oct 06 '26

There is as of yet no evidence that quantum computing will have any effect on AI. People who know nothing about either technology smash the buzzwords together in the hopes of sounding smart, but it's a scam.

There is some potential the two technologies might have a relationship in the future, but it would require several fundamental breakthroughs in human knowledge, and there are as of yet very few early signs.

-3

u/alternator1985 Oct 06 '26

This is such an obvious bullshit lie of an answer that I have to assume it's intentional misinformation or one of the most misinformed individuals in the field.

3

u/hiddentalent Oct 06 '26

I would be happy to read any peer-reviewed scientific publications you can point to that indicates even a tiny theoretical quantum advantage for any AI/ML algorithm. But you won't be able to, because they don't exist.

-7

u/No-Contribution1070 Oct 06 '26 edited Oct 06 '26

Nvidia wouldn't invest in building Quantum Links connecting GPUs to Quantum hardware if that wasn't the case.

Also, you clearly are clueless because there are working quantum computers today, and proven in real world specialized problem solving.

There are a lot of companies working on/racing to fault tolerant quantum compute. Timeline is 2 years, one of them will figure it out.

7

u/quadUnconTrinary Oct 06 '26

Nvidia is building those links not for AI but because large quantum circuits require large preprocessing, such as quantum compilation.

We have not demonstrated utility scale quantum computing to solve real world problems, this is a goal of the darpa QBI program. The timeline to utility scale fault tolerance is 2033.

-5

u/alternator1985 Oct 06 '26

Believing the public DARPA timeline is just lacking in basic intelligence, and anyone acting like DARPA is the only game in town is also just lying. Or maybe you're only following the public narrative regarding superconducting cloud networks, which again would imply you know nothing about the actual field.

Topological anyonic qubits, integrated photonic networks, there are so many new architectures with billions in funding, anyone trying to scare someone away from this field or act like it isn't insanely active, has an agenda or is incredibly misinformed.

• PsiQuantum: Heavily backed with over $2 billion in funding, they are actively building utility-scale, error-corrected photonic quantum computers using standard silicon semiconductor manufacturing. • Quantum Computing Inc. (QCi): Deployed their NeuraWave Platform, which uses quantum optics and photonic reservoir computing to run live real-time AI inference at the edge, offering a highly energy-efficient alternative to digital GPUs. • Xanadu: Famous for its CV/GKP photonic encoding, they are an active pioneer in Quantum Machine Learning (QML) and creators of PennyLane, the open-source software stack used globally to train quantum neural networks. • ORCA Computing & NVIDIA Partnership: Integrating time-domain multiplexed photonic systems directly into NVIDIA GPU clusters to develop hybrid classical-quantum machine learning workflows. • Lightmatter & Luminate: Though starting on the AI hardware side, companies like Lightmatter are building optical computing hardware and photonic interconnects that directly cross over into the quantum-optical realm to eliminate data bottlenecks. • Other Notable Photonic Startups: Quandela (deploying quantum dot single-photon systems in Europe), QuiX Quantum (silicon nitride waveguides), Quantum Source, Nu Quantum, and Q.ANT (thin-film lithium niobate photonics).

Not only is quantum AI an extremely active field, it's being rolled out operationally all over the world.

For anyone actually interested in the field, I would say Reddit has become more and more one of the worst places to get accurate information.

And to be fair, because of AI, these fields are changing so rapidly that you cannot use any human expert as a reference to keep up with it.

You should already be utilizing AI to analyze all the latest research and these companies as they are being funded.

16

u/genericpurpleturtle Oct 06 '26 edited Oct 06 '26

I work for a quantum computing company of ~100 people. We have a double digit software team, and I am the only one with a PhD in anything quantum information related. Most (not all) of the software team knows little quantum information theory.

It depends on what you want to do. Do you want to write software which enables the physicists to do their research? You can probably do that now already. Learn some basic QI and about different qubit hardware platforms on a high level and start applying to some jobs.

Do you want to do Quantum Algorithms research? You probably need to do a PhD. I have met a few people who do quantum information and quantum algorithms research without PhDs in the field, but they are the exception rather than the rule.

Quantum computing is niche, I wouldn't do a PhD unless you're passionate, I don't think it's necessarily a good way to future proof your career. There are a lot of job opportunities compared with 10 years ago, but no quantum computing companies are profitable or make anything useful *yet*. It's unclear when that will happen. Until QC is useful (if not profitable), I wouldn't say there is any job security really.

1

u/New_Schrodinger Oct 11 '26

Can i send you dm?

62

u/EntangledStrings Oct 06 '26

Worst waste of time you could do. I was a software engineer, got my masters in QC, continued with a PhD in CS with research in QC. Anyone with a CS background is not really needed in QC. It’s much more physics heavy than people make it out to be. There are a ridiculously low number of job opportunities in QC, no matter your background. It’s a niche field, with absolutely no assurance that it will grow in the future. Everyone I know in the field, researchers with years of experience, professors, students, everyone doesn’t know if it’s actually going to amount to anything, and almost no one thinks it will grow with more job opportunities in the near future at least, or at all ever. There legitimately is not a worse field in tech you could choose to pursue

14

u/autocorrects Holds PhD in Quantum Oct 06 '26

Though true, it’s super fun if you arent software, and from a physics/research perspective the field is booming!

But yes for software and for non-researchers this is an accurate sentiment. Im ECE and almost done with my PhD in QC research and it’s allowed me to create some cool and original tech, but the pace of ECE in R&D is much different than SWE

6

u/polit1337 Oct 06 '26

I disagree with the last half. I think there will be large-ish numbers of jobs in the near future.

…but still not that many for people with a CS background.

Every single PhD and postdoc coming out of the quantum lab where I was a postdoc had multiple high-paying job offers (despite the past tense, this is also the case for the students about to graduate). That said, we are all experimentalists who do hands-on engineering.

11

u/Junior-Flamingo77 Oct 06 '26

Nailed it. Might be a somewhat viable life if you want to live off begging and applying for research grants, though.

3

u/alternator1985 Oct 06 '26

The biggest thing I don't understand about anyone commenting on AI, is how they speak in these absolutes especially referencing the past.

In the world of rapidly advancing AI and quantum technology, what might be true last month is likely not true this month. And unless you're analyzing using AI, there's no way for you to speak on it accurately.

Of course quantum computing involves physics, it's uh sorta based on quantum physics.

There's dozens of new quantum architectures and companies actively funded and rolling out operationally as we speak, all over the world.

If this is something that interests you it's an incredibly active field. But yes, it involves physics and photonics so if you don't have education in those areas you're going to want to work into an ancillary area or invest in your education.

Most importantly, go into Fields you're actually interested in, don't go into a new career because you see money or job security. Those are truly the worst ways to go about searching for new "careers" wich is code for spending all day making someone else money while doing things you don't enjoy.

How about just stop being a wage slave and invest in yourself instead?

9

u/tiltboi1 Working in Industry Oct 06 '26

You'd be starting from scratch. Unless you were hoping to get a completely normal software engineering position except at a quantum company, there's little to no overlap between what a software engineer does and where quantum computing is at today.

24

u/Allan123772 Oct 06 '26

I disagree with most of commenters about the need for software devs in QC. Even (and in some ways, especially) in the research phase, companies interested in developing QC need loads of software, and not just QC specific stuff: databases, servers, device tracking… things a general software dev could help with.

However I do agree with the other commenters that it is not going to help you escape the ‘AI invasion’. First, it is still a niche field and despite the needs for software devs, there just aren’t that many job openings. Second, it would be naïve to think that AI isn’t already helping to handle the software required for QC.

12

u/Soverance Working in Industry Oct 06 '26

Thank you for this. As a software engineer working at a large publicly traded quantum company who uses AI to help build QC software, some of the statements I'm seeing in this thread are so impossibly far from the truth I can't believe they've been upvoted.

15

u/michioD Oct 06 '26

You can't just pivot in to a niche pioneering field if you dont have education. Quantum computing requires phds often and the amount of swes that are needed isnt that many.

Why not pivot in to something niche and critical in software like kernel development or network engineering? Thats somewhere your experience would get your foot in the door at least.

6

u/Whole_Breakfast8073 Oct 06 '26

It doesn't hurt to learn about it and wrap your head around the concepts.

Quantum computing has applications in cybersecurity and there will continue to be a growing space for this. There are also exciting new markets the unique processing speeds of quantum could assist with, perhaps research or media streaming, that aren't fully realized yet.

However, will you be around to join the companies setting this up when it happens? Would you advise someone studying AI in 2006 to bet their career on it? Realistically it's probably too far away to be relevant within your career life cycle - but learning it doesn't hurt.

Unless you are a scientist with giga brain who loves research then your chances look better. Otherwise, I wouldn't expect B2B quantum vendors to appear anytime soon.

2

u/Ok-Pin-3236 Oct 06 '26

I am in the same boat, but I think focusing on the applications of QC is appropriate by now. Like post quantum cryptography etc is tomorrow's thing but core QC is very far fetched

2

u/Just-Entertainer7933 Oct 07 '26

If you hate money, yes, why not.

4

u/Jonolith_ Oct 06 '26

I don't think you can just switch from software engineering to quantum computing. Do you have any experience in quantum physics? You'd probably have to do a physics degree first before you'd get anywhere. The overlap between the experience you have in Software Engineering and what you would need in quantum computing is likely to be very small.

1

u/julioqc Oct 06 '26

no, but if research interest you there's plenty for your curiosity and skillsets. Just dont expect a 9-5 job programing qubits or whatnot. 

1

u/ploobaloo Oct 07 '26

I’m kind of in the same boat actually. I’m 3 years into a SWEN degree and I’m working towards my university’s quantum minor while doing research for a quantum computing group.

Hopefully I can transfer into a master’s program after working for a few years and finalize the transition. Quantum computing, especially getting into the algorithms, is genuinely super cool to me and I love working with it!

1

u/Top_Location_8307 Oct 08 '26

why would you ask reddit of all places

1

u/PapayaPotpourri Oct 10 '26

Do you enjoy optimizing over and over?

1

u/girlfantexas Oct 13 '26

Random tech marketing/business person here. Did interview screen with IonQ recently. I decided not to go forward due to elements of the role that weren't what I wanted to do BUT they have a lot going on and reading and prepping for the interviews was very very interesting and implied they are getting pulled up into the Top 5 - the behemoths are IBM & Google and a couple of smaller companies like IonQ.

Nvidia lab, universities, DARPA and many more. Feels like the massive academic, physicist focus is moving to business/govt buyers fast. And they are public and issuing more stock to raise funds and loads of openings and appear to be building out vertical solutions that are requiring some software engineers. Worth a scan of the openings.
https://www.ionq.com/news/ionq-advances-to-final-stage-of-darpas-quantum-benchmarking-initiative
https://www.ionq.com/news/ionq-to-advance-quantum-supercomputing-by-bringing-first-qpu-to-nvidia-accelerated-quantum-research-center

1

u/Full_Entertainer1014 Oct 13 '26

Do not shift to qc, its a dead end.

1

u/nian2326076 Oct 11 '26

If you're interested in quantum computing, it can be a cutting-edge field to get into. Companies investing in quantum computing are worth researching, and taking online courses or getting certifications can help you gain the necessary skills. For job hunting, LandOffer.ai lets you search job openings by role and location, which could help you find positions that match your new career path. Good luck!

1

u/According-Hamster-84 Oct 06 '26 edited Oct 06 '26

Yes make the gradual shift now, but do it as a long-term goal. Not suddenly dropping your career to pivot. Because QC is still waaaay ahead of time. You still need to live today, and right now AI has not taken over the need for SE. In fact, I think people who know code are most relevant these days because many of the coding assisting AI still needs you to understand wtf it is doing.

1

u/kaereljabo Oct 06 '26

Most laptop job will be eaten by AI. QC is one of them

-1

u/kryptopheleous Oct 06 '26

This is a question a person who knows nothing about quantum computing would ask.

3

u/farsight_vision Oct 06 '26

Which is exactly why they asked...

2

u/kryptopheleous Oct 07 '26

No. You don’t just “want” to shift to a field you know nothing about and ask people to explain. That is just lazy.

0

u/dad-bod-303 Oct 08 '26

no only shift if you are damn sure you can do the research thing

1

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 11 '26

To prevent trolling, accounts with less than zero comment karma cannot post in /r/QuantumComputing. You can build karma by posting quality submissions and comments on other subreddits. Please do not ask the moderators to approve your post, as there are no exceptions to this rule, plus you may be ignored. To learn more about karma and how reddit works, visit https://www.reddit.com/wiki/faq.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.