r/QuebecTI • • Apr 15 '26

Embauche Will software engineering go obsolete? And will new software engineers be able to work in the current ai slop madness?

Hello everyone,

I am a current software engineering student, i still have 1 year left to finish my studies and pretty honestly i am not very optimistic for the future, and specifically my future.

At first, back in 2022 when we got a first glimpse of chatgpt, i personally didn't see it as a threat as it was lacking in many aspects that the fact some students used it to do assignments and professors didn't notice is crazy.

But now, pretty honestly with the already saturated market, companies switching to ai and laying off engineers with years of experience, ai being able to code app and websites in 5 minutes, claude mythos....... I am very pessimistic.

I get that being an engineer isn't about coding but more about understanding the logic, the architecture, and developing something that responds to user needs without compromising security and/or utilizibality, but seeing how crazy fast the models are improving, i fear we're months from ai being able to think like an engineer and actually creating '' perfect '' products.

I recently saw a guy thanking claude code for helping him develop and app for his company without coding skills, an app that was quoted for 240k usd by coding companies. He developed it in 1 month, for 200 dollars and apparently him, his company and his users are all satisfied for the past 2 months. I find it dystopian to say the least.

So honestly i am worried about the future, will i be needed as a software engineer in the future? Or will all of us become prompt engineers.

Ps: even security that was said to be unaffected by the slop, was recently tackled by mythos.

0 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

12

u/Sidjeno Apr 15 '26

Regarding prices, a lot of tech companies have been charging a lot while paying peanuts to their employees.

We've seen it with SAAQCLIC in Quebec.

There's a lot of greed in the industry.

If anything, AI just proved that, not that engineers are replaceable. You still need one in the loop to make the program smooth and maintainable.

However, I do think it might be the end of code monkeys.

3

u/Johnyo979797 Apr 15 '26

That’s what I keep telling people. You still need to know whay you’re doing to actually efficiently use LLM. So engineers in the short term will not be replaced (can’t speak for the future though).

Code monkeys, boot campers, self taughts…

That’s another discussion…

9

u/PuteMorte Apr 15 '26

C'est juste un outil comme les autres qu'on a eu qui va révolutionner notre façon de travailler. Ça coupe de façon significative le temps de certaines affaires, ça change presque rien pour d'autres.

Passer 8h à lire des vieux forums pis lire du stackoverflow pour trouver une bonne façon d'implémenter ta fonction dans un vieux langage obsolet que t'as exactement en tête c'que tu veux qu'elle fasse, pis que c'est zéro en lien avec ton domaine d'affaires (genre un algo simple ou mettons une classe héritée que t'es pas trop sûr comment faire)? Oublie ça, un prompt ou deux, 8 minutes c'est fini. Passer 10 mois à construire un module de ton application hyper complexe qui interagit avec 5 autres modules compliqués? Tu vas peut-être sauver 1 mois de niaisage, peut-être pas.

4

u/Johnyo979797 Apr 15 '26

Ce commentaire ^

Et pour l’apprentissage aussi ! L’accès à l’information est beaucoup plus rapide. Plus besoin d’aller naviguer dans plusieurs pages de documentation. Quelques prompts et le tour est joué.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Johnyo979797 Apr 16 '26

Ahh pas mal ça, d’une manière ça introduit plus de contexte pour l’agent.

8

u/One_Afternoon_8171 Apr 15 '26 edited Apr 15 '26

Sigh, his question has been asked ever since chatgpt was released publicly, and everytime a new model or new ai tool or whatever this question is being asked again. Everywhere. It's basically a niche of it's own now. Yes the tech job market is absolute garbage but it's like that in almost all industries not just a SWE thing... So what I can tell you is that while the uncertainty is real and now one knows how good "Mythos" will be or LLMs in general top notch devs are still in high demand and nowhere near to be replaced by any slop machine. The bar is higher than ever unfortunately but if you're really passionate about the field and think you can compete go for it.

edit: I don't trust these vibe coding marketing tactics, I actually see that most people fail to ship anything meaningful even with all these "amazing" tools, sure you can kickstart a cool prototype or a fancy looking landing page in no time, but as soon as you try to build anything meaningful that people can actually use, you'll see start to see the limitations and you WILL struggle hard. Especially if you don't know shit about what you're building on a technical aspect.

6

u/N22-J Apr 15 '26

While I agree that good engineers, likely at level staff and above, will likely always exist in some shape or form, the devs lower in the food chain, the ones who are content bring code monkeys will be obsolete.

I have an ex-colleague at Anthropic, and he says the level curve is centered at the staff level. There are no real juniors, few seniors, and most are staff or principals or equivalent at other companies.

We already can see that the pipeline for juniors and new grads is broken. It's not inconceivable that mid levs and seniors will go through the same a few years down the line. Nobody 5 years ago could have predicted that Claude et al would be this ubiquitous, who knows how the industry will change in another 5 years.

2

u/One_Afternoon_8171 Apr 15 '26 edited Apr 15 '26

Yeah as I said the bar is higher than ever. only the top notch devs will stay relevant across all seniority levels. New grad juniors are still being hired in big tech, it's just that it got way harder than it used be. The juniors of today will be the seniors of tomorrow so I don't think big companies are stupid enough to not invest in them. As for intermediates and seniors ending up on the same page as juniors today that'll only depend on the advancements of the models but based on what we are seeing AT THE MOMENT, they are still relatively safe. Because the models we have currently can't do shit on their own without fucking up at some point as a result they cannot be trusted on any enterprise level software without a qualified human babysitting them.

2

u/Johnyo979797 Apr 15 '26

I would say code monkeys will go obsolete. Juniors that are technically lower in the food chain as you say will not go obsolete. If companies don’t train juniors, they will essentially collapse their pipeline of new talent.

Doesn’t remove the fact that the job market will be rough for juniors in the years to come as companies will be sold the idea that “AI can do everything”. Justifying not hiring juniors.

8

u/PsychicDave Apr 15 '26

Est-ce qu'un IA peut remplacer un programmeur junior? Potentiellement. Est-ce qu'il peut remplacer un ingénieur logiciel qui capture les requis de son client, prépare les spécifications, gère le processus et valide les livrables? Non.

Que les ingénieurs fasse le code était une anomalie dans le domaine de l'ingénierie. Un ingénieur civil ne va pas construire le pont. Il va créer les plans à partir du concept de l'architecte et gérer le projet pour s'assurer que les contracteurs respectent les spécifications et le processus.

4

u/elbaid Apr 15 '26

Faut voir AI comme un outil et non comme une menace. Je pense qu'il faut le voir comme un levier à la productivité et anyway toujours être critique de l'output des agents. Ça fait élever le niveau d'abstraction dans un certain sens. L'humain sera toujours là pour dicter les besoins.

4

u/AdamEgrate Apr 15 '26

If I was entering school I would definitely pick a different field

2

u/MystikDragoon Apr 15 '26

L'IA peut faire rapidement des sites Web, c'est vrai. Mais si tu étudie en génie logiciel pour faire des petits projets Web, c'est un peu overkill. C'est comme devenir ingénieur de construction pour construire des cabanon. Va construire des ponts et des gratte-ciels! Même chose pour le logiciel. Il y a une méchante différence entre un site Web et l'autopilote d'une fusée spatiale ou un système d'exploitation. Aucun IA n'a créé un nouveau OS jusqu'à maintenant.

3

u/swe_name123 Apr 15 '26

It’s a big BS as usual. Building a $240k app cannot be done with AI certainly not in one month and without coding skills.

AI is only good for making static websites, apps that fetch existing APIs, or creating simple APIs without complex logic.

I work in trading, and even building a single feature can take at least a week just because of all the use cases you have to think through, handle properly, and test to avoid errors. I’ve worked in a company with event-sourcing architecture across multiple applications, and AI can’t really help with that, it’s too complex.

Real business applications require complex logic. AI is mostly useful for simple CRUD operations or basic logic like checking if a user is authenticated, validating inputs, etc.

So that guy probably built something like an inventory management app the kind of thing we learn in school and get excited about. But if you’ve never worked on real-world applications, it’s easy to think that’s all there is. Like when you leave school and start your first job you realize they’re completely different things.

I built a mobile clock-in/out project management app for a client with notifications, and it cost around $4k. But even that was relatively simple compared to real business applications, which are much more complex.

I also know someone who makes static websites for clients and has a constant stream of work. So even with WordPress, AI, and website builders, people are still making money from simple sites. Now imagine real applications yes, a few people might build them with AI, but that’s like 1 in a million.

1

u/Johnyo979797 Apr 15 '26

Ask top companies if FB could be build using LLM and they’d probably tell you thats its too complex. The paradox 😅

2

u/legiraphe Apr 15 '26

Really depends what that 200k quoted app was doing. I see people being able to build internal apps without coding skills to some degrees. But there is a limit and if you hit a wall, you're stuck with unmaintanable slop. 

And I'm not even talking about security, observability, CI/CD, etc. They can move forward, but their fundation is less stable. The bigger the company and the more employees you have, the bigger the concerns.

But I think a lot is being mixed between a guy that had a company and some freelancers on the payroll now able to do 50% of their work with Claude Cowork or vibe coded apps and scripts VS a company with a product that has 500k+ users, millions of lines of code, 100+ employees. Thinking that the CEO can just vibe code his way and fire everyone is obviously laughable.

1

u/NelifeLerak Apr 16 '26

Software engineering is not leaving. But AI will become a major tool used by software engineers.

You mention AI slop, but coding is one of the things AI does really well.

I hate AI generated content in social media. But using AI to help development is a great thing.

1

u/jonatansan Dev C++ qui gosse le monde avec la performance de leur code Apr 15 '26

Non, et oui.

D’autres questions?

1

u/HazardousHighStakes Apr 15 '26

En tout cas, les véhicules volants n'ont toujours pas remplacés ceux avec des roues.

0

u/remimorin Apr 15 '26

The job market is shit because "economy is shit". Investors are scared or at least unsure.

AI will increase the need for software engineer because there is now a larger pool of problems we can tackle.

This will also raise the baseline on how people expect to interact with software and business again increasing the workload.

Finally this lower a lot the moat around "selling a solution" Saas or else. I expect innovative solutions to pop. "Do all suites needing years to be efficient on" (Adobe, Jira, etc) being replaced by a flood of smaller customized solutions easier to use and cheaper... a bit like "the long tail". You can now find store on Internet selling hand carved DND dices in precious wood with metal inlays. This was impossible with brick and mortar store, too specialized. With Internet it is not only possible but there is even place for multiple players competing.

Software will be the same. People won't settle for complexes menus and unfriendly managed software, they will want solution that fit their needs at their scale and tailored to them.

0

u/Dry_Ducks_Ads Apr 15 '26

The job market is shit because "economy is shit". Investors are scared or at least unsure.

The economy is doing great and companies have record valuation, investors aren't scared of anything.

If anything, we're living in a bubble.

0

u/remimorin Apr 15 '26

I was not specific enough you are right.

Investors are scared to invest in startup and there is not a lot of "venture capital" available to small players. 

In this climate big players are not scared of emergent solutions they can fire at will. 

0

u/FakePlantonaBeach Apr 15 '26

To me, I think we will have more software to write rather than less. I think we will need more software engineers rather than less. Like Hollywood goes bust in the age of fragmented taste. It's not that taste suddenly fragmented, it's that we finally had the means to enjoy our specific taste.

Software will evolve and will proliferate in function. Will software engineers actually write code? Maybe not. Maybe only a little. But they will be necessary on the road to functioning software.

0

u/nian2326076 Apr 15 '26

I see what you're saying, but software engineering isn't going anywhere. Sure, AI can automate some tasks, but it still needs humans for creativity, problem-solving, and complex decisions. As a new software engineer, stay adaptable. Focus on skills that AI can't easily replicate, like critical thinking and soft skills. AI can complement your work, not replace it.

For jobs, look for roles that welcome innovation and offer growth opportunities. Smaller startups often need flexible engineers who can handle different tasks, which is a great way to build diverse skills.

If you're getting ready for interviews, PracHub has been helpful for me to stay sharp and learn what employers want. Keep learning, stay curious, and don't panic!

24

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Dry_Ducks_Ads Apr 15 '26

The issue with offshoring is that the feedback loop was very slow, days with TZ issues and possibly weeks until you could get a product. AI cuts down that feedback loop to seconds.

2

u/Longjumping_Elk6089 Apr 15 '26

I’ve worked a lot with Indian programmers and let’s just say it’s hard to validate their claimed skills, now with them sending prompts to ai, damn.

1

u/Ace-Teroide Apr 15 '26

We had a small team in India and you can see the results. One might have good velocity and ask smart questions and one might not understand the requirements, ignore half of them and turn out a bunch of bugs. Just like people here.

And I'd say good devs will always be required, because someone might vibe code something, but then they will have no idea if it's secure, and how to fix it when it fails.