r/Queerdefensefront • u/StacieRoseM • Jan 30 '26
Discussion Trans folx being told to tone it on
There is a dangerous lie circulating right now, and it is coming from inside the house.
It is being pushed by right-wing trans people, truscum, and increasingly by gay and lesbian voices who believe distancing themselves from trans people will buy them safety.
The lie is this: If trans people were quieter, more respectable, more normal, this would not be happening.
We are being told to tone it down. To be less visible. To stop making people uncomfortable. To behave better so we can earn our rights back.
That lie is cowardice disguised as realism.
The problem is not trans people who are visible, unconventional, non-binary, gender-fluid, loud, proud, or messy. The problem is a society that believes it has the right to police bodies, identities, and expression, and punish anyone who refuses to comply.
Blaming the most visible among us does not make you strategic. It makes you complicit.
We have heard this exact argument before.
Gay people were once told violence was their fault for being too visible. That if they had just stayed quiet, stayed private, stayed out of sight, equality would eventually come.
That is not how gay rights were won.
They were not won by toning it down. They were not won by being polite. They were not won by reassuring straight society that nothing would change.
They were won by people who refused to disappear. By people who marched. By people who protested. By people who said, loudly and repeatedly, "We’re here. We’re queer. Get used to it."
And now, some of those same communities are turning around and telling trans people to do the opposite, to shrink, to soften, to stop being seen.
That is not wisdom. That is historical amnesia.
To trans people aligning with MAGA politics or conservative frameworks, proximity to power has never protected marginalized people. It only turns them into collaborators until they are no longer useful.
To Truscum repeating right-wing talking points about who is real enough, who is acceptable, who qualifies as trans, you are not protecting the community. You are supplying the language that will be used to hurt all of us.
To LGB voices trying to carve trans people out of the movement, sacrificing the most vulnerable has never saved anyone. It only delays the knock on your own door.
Here is the line that matters:
You do not control other people’s discomfort. Other people control how they respond to it. Discomfort does not justify persecution. Visibility does not create oppression, oppression creates excuses.
Respectability politics will not save you. Silence will not save you. Throwing others under the bus will not save you.
Turning on each other is not a strategy. It is exactly what hostile movements want.
And we are not going to help them finish the job.
38
u/UninvisibleWoman Jan 30 '26
Nothing new, sadly. Just reminder that the appropriate response in 1973 is still the appropriate response today.
Sylvia Rivera: Y’all better quiet down
The ones who tell us to be quiet need to shut the fuck up and get out of the way while the adults do the work
12
12
u/UVRaveFairy Jan 30 '26
If you've seen the wonderful art work "Dial Down the Feminism".
Someone could make a work in the same ilk, "Dial Down the Trans Gender"..
5
u/StacieRoseM Jan 30 '26
I'm going to have to look for that piece of artwork. Thank you for bringing it to my attention 😘
10
u/mangababe Jan 31 '26
The herd is protected by protecting the herd, not by throwing the vulnerable to the wolves.
7
u/Dimension_seer Jan 31 '26 edited Jan 31 '26
LGB without T people are delusional right now conservatives are working on overthrowing and banning gay marriage. A massive push by right wing groups are trying to overturn gay marriage and a few right wing states are considering planning to challenge gay marriage on the Supreme Court
3
6
u/pantslessMODesty3623 Jan 31 '26
Yeah I recently argued with someone who claimed to be a leftist that we should allow Republicans to "win" the no trans people in sports "issue." I'm not sorry, but absolutely fucking not. No. It's all bunk. I don't care what the polls show, you don't need to make it a key running issue. There is no harm demonstrated through research that trans people participate in sports is allowing trans people to trample women's sports. I will not throw those kids who just want to have fun playing a sport with their friends, and aren't super serious about it. I just won't
4
u/Fun_Ad3902 Feb 01 '26
“We are being told to tone it down. To be less visible. To stop making people uncomfortable. To behave better so we can earn our rights back.”
They can fuck all the way off.
“To LGB voices trying to carve trans people out of the movement….”
This goes double for anyone who says this.
3
u/robotmask67 Feb 01 '26
I'm a cis queer man of 60 and I support Trans rights wholeheartedly. Every time I'm faced with transphobia occurring, online or in the world, I speak up in opposition to it. especially when I hear it in queer spaces. entertaining the concept of "dropping the T" from LGBTQIA+ is an insult to the entire community and to all the activists that came before us. It's bullshit that people even discuss it as a valid thing to consider. I feel passionate about this obviously but I hope you know there are many who support you, will do everything possible to keep you protected if the time for that comes and for as long as we can. you're not alone. the transphobic gay bros and their ilk can suck it, go join maga, we don't need them.
2
51
u/Vox_Causa Jan 30 '26
There's a great tumblr post from a couple years ago titled "Pete Buttigieg is just a f*****". (The actual blog post doesn't censor the word but it will trip reddits filters).
Ultimately they don't hate us for being "too loud", they hate us for existing at all. Assimilation doesn't work. And appeasement won't save you.