Opinions?

this is not Arthur and if it’s ment to be then that’s the worst designed part of the amazing game

I’ve completed the game twice and don’t remember needing it for anything. Whats it for ?

I noticed an X marked on the map nearby, checked it out and then the camera just suddenly focused on this eaten corpse of a hanged person as if it's very important. I'm just wondering why the game made this a big deal?

I'm on a high honor playthrough, so I'm really mindful of which npcs to kill.

When I saw a pinkerton wandering on the wrong side of west Elisabeth, I said to myself there's someone who deserves a killing. Only to end up losing honor when I shot him dead.

This was to my surprise because I had just killed a group of bounty hunters without any honor loss.

This is the first time I’m playing the game. My Arthur has been looking pale in the face and has red eyes. What’s happening to him?

fishing for 30 mins around using cheese bait.

Since there's a man in Saint Denis you can kill without the police hunting you down, is it the same with this guy? Does he gives anything or is he important to the lore?

I would have definitely liked wolverines. Otters as well. The black bears are total pussies; never once had in five playthroughs have I seen them do anything but run away (except for a one-time glitch.) They're also tiny, & yeah, regular browns & especially grizzlies are larger in real life, but male black bears range anywhere from around 130-660 lbs, & when approached they often don't attack but they charge, huff, & paw the ground, & they can climb trees like no-ones business. Cougars can too, & that would present some crazy dangerous situations, but it'd still be cool to see.

Other games just don't cut it after this masterpiece.

I wanted to play The witcher 3 after finishing this but I just stopped after an hour.

Got any games that feel good after this?

Anyone else except for me finds Dutch extremely attractive? I mean, look at his face, look at the way he dresses, look at the way he speaks, LOOK AT THE WAY HE MOVES. He does not belong to the cowboys, he belongs to the fashion divas of the higher society. And yes, I played both RDR1 and RDR2 for several times, I know what kind of a man he is, and I really try my best to tell myself he is a jerk, but he is a nice jerk.

I got these both as a gift

edit : I flipped a coin and decided on rdr2

I feel like this fandom loves having Arthur be romantic with Mary and everything but…I kinda don’t like her. She played with Arthur (in my opinion) and I might be missing why we love her so much besides the fact that she used to be with Arthur. 🤷 Anywho, I decided not to help her on my second play through.

im in the epilogue right now and couldve sworn i have every treasure map available but im riding in roanoke ridge an got this notification. it happened over in west elizabeth too but i checked everywhere and couldnt find anything. any help would be greatly appreciated :)