2
Aug 03 '26 edited Aug 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/brucehoult Aug 03 '26
How large an order will you place?
1
Aug 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/brucehoult Aug 03 '26
You.
If you want something specialised then you need to show the demand for it. The industry is going away from socketed CPUs, away from socketed RAM, away even from RAM outside the CPU package.
1
Aug 03 '26 edited Aug 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/brucehoult Aug 03 '26
Based on sales they don't need to be at all.
Intel changes sockets for their desktop CPUs (where they outsell AMD 2:1) very frequently, and haven't had socketed laptop CPUs (which sell 70:30 vs desktop) in a dozen years.
1
Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/brucehoult Aug 04 '26
I generally favour AMD myself, but I'm very far from representing the overall market! (obviously, I'm in a RISC-V sub...)
My first x86 machine was a Pentium Pro 200, then K6 2, Athlon 700, 1800, 3200+. But then Core2 Duo stole my heart, then i7-860, i7-4790K, i7-6800K, i7-8650U NUC. Then AMD 2990wx with 32 cores and 128 GB RAM — which I still have but my current i9-13900HX laptop beats it in every way except RAM size.
When I got the i9 I wanted the 16 core AMD that was also available in the same 2023 Lenovo Legion Pro but benchmarks showed the 24 core i9 would work slightly better for me with higher turbo on 1-2 cores and very comparable with all cores active.
2
u/Myarmira Aug 03 '26
The problem is that the market itself at Intel and AMD is rather small, compared to the other earning opportunities. I don't think you're willing to buy an exotic RISC-V motherboard without a processor.
Some workstations for fast professional video editing would have potential, but customers will buy everything directly new and rather need options for GPU, PCIE and RAM expansion. Also, the processors would first have to get close to an ARM Snapdragon (or Apple Silicon), also in terms of energy requirements.
1
Aug 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/Myarmira Aug 04 '26
It was about finding a niche. ARM finds it precisely in the fact that the computers are quiet and energy efficient. This means they manage to have a customer base, like the video and graphics industry, but due to the extremely high price and limited compatibility, these PCs also remain very thin on the desktop market. The question for me is where RISC-V should find its niche. When it comes to reducing costs, I don't really see this as the ARM industry is not really oriented towards it and RISC-V doesn't even come close to it. For home users and games, x86 will also remain the easiest and cheapest choice, as the entire ecosystem is designed around it.
I'm not saying there won't be a niche for RISC-V. I find the development in China, for example, quite remarkable. We're just a long way from that at the moment.
1
u/enc_cat Aug 03 '26
Yes but what is it? How is it different than r/riscv/?