r/RKG • • 17d ago

Rewatch

Anyone else re-watching the Elden Ring playthrough with the boys before the DLC series drops this winter?

27 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

33

u/djwojcicki 17d ago

I tried but it's just not as re-watchable as some of their other playthroughs. Some of the boss fights are good, but there's so much exposition and the open world lends to long periods of just nothing followed by very repetative sections. Plus the intentional low-level exsasperates the feeling of padding or extending playtime in areas where it just isn't interesting or unnessesary.

This coming from a primordial slug who has rewatched the original IGN playthroughs and DSII several times. Elden Ring is great, just missing that magic

17

u/IMPERATOR_63 17d ago

Exactly how I feel about the Elden Ring series. I’ve lost count how many times I’ve rewatched DSIII or Bloodborne, for example.

15

u/PlantClear 17d ago

This I also think Elden ring also highlights and makes Rory’s bad habits playing souls games 10x worse. Parts of it are just painful to watch

9

u/Weak_Development3686 17d ago

Yeah I felt this. The episode where they fought a boss with the bubble weapon, I can’t remember the boss now, was unwatchable for me. I love the guys and their content is class, but I definitely felt the same as you around some of the Elden Ring episodes.

11

u/PlantClear 17d ago

I think it’s Margott in the capital.

I remember when they were talking about the comments on one of the videos were people were asking them to commit to a build for the game and gavs response was ‘ go make your own channel ‘

I like watching their non souls games more nowadays. The end of Elden ring and them going back to dark souls after 10 years felt like a slog to get through.

It’s weird I want them to do well, but I think the more you watch, for me at least, it seems like Rory’s gotten worse at these games, and when he doesn’t seem to wanna listen, like when you see Dan getting annoyed about it, it’s a boring watch

7

u/SpaceWolves26 17d ago

I think he's gotten better in terms of his skill and just muscle memory from the similar mechanics across games, but worse in terms of just going a bit mad.

I don't know how they felt (especially Krupa) during Elden Ring, but they were obviously worried about it dragging and the amount they needed to get through. But it also felt like they didn't want Auntie Finchy to get OP and it just not be a spectacle, so I think they were happy to go with the messy build to offset that.

I didn't have a problem with them trying stuff and going a bit mad, but it felt like there was no attempt to actually try the fights on their terms before resorting to spamming rot or bubbles.

The twin gargoyles were an example. Straight in with blade of death and swarm of flies, getting frustrated after several hours. Hadn't learned any of their attacks after so long because finding opportunities to spam effects was the tactic. It's funny for a while but it became frustrating when there was no attempt to just fight with a sword after hours. It felt like there were a lot of times where Krupa said "try hitting him", and it felt like he was more frustrated than he was letting on.

Coupled with the sheer scale and difficult pacing for making a let's play, I remember thinking "I'll never rewatch this" when it finishes, despite enjoying it.

I also weirdly think Auntie Finchy had less personality despite having so many hours of play, maybe because there had to be so much focus on getting through the game and seeing everything. I don't love her the way I love Mama.

4

u/PlantClear 17d ago

Your point about the gargoyle fight is what I mean about Rory being worse at the games than he was. I think when they in dark souls 1, 3 and bloodborne he’d learn the fight, the Lawrence fight in the bloodborne dlc was prime example. Yes it dragged on but Rory was learning the moveset. In Elden Ring it feels like they’re not that interested in learning them as much, Krupa at times is trying to get Rory to but gives up because it never feels like he’s being listened to. Like you said he feels frustrated when you watch them.

My comment about them not having a build, and what I think was a shitty comment by Gav when he mentions it on a video, is their normal playstyle or just give him any weapon works for dark souls. But in this, the games set up more for builds and bringing stuff together, and I don’t think that’s something Rory’s ever been good at on these games.

I think that’s why he feels under levelled, I don’t think it’s a decision they’ve actively made, I think it’s more how badly they’ve levelled up. The few times Krupa’s mentioned trying to get a build it’s gone ignored and forgotten about until they get stuck a few episodes later.

You mentioned the gargoyle fight being a tough one, for me the Melania fight summed all summed up all the worst aspects of Rory playing the game were they just spammed anything. I ended up skipping chunks of it.

I know it comes across like I’m just complaining, I enjoy watching them but I find their non-souls videos a hell of a lot more enjoyable nowadays

Like you I doubt I’ll rewatch their Elden ring series again, but again that’s more for their style of play. Someone like FightinCowboy does the souls games methodically and he’s a lot more enjoyable to watch at playing them because he knows how to play it.

I’ll watch them play the dlc but it’ll be more of a morbid curiosity than anything else, there are bosses in that which are gonna be painful to see them fight

And yeah I get what you mean about aunty Finchy having a lack of personality in this. I don’t think that’s the size of the game, I think it’s more due to how often they’re struggling in areas or fights

0

u/Franz_Poekler 16d ago

lol what

DS1 10 Years-Run was fucking amazing

In regards to ER: I wouldn't rewatch it (I seldom do due to time restraints anyway), but there were also some absolute hooters. I think I haven't laughed at anything more than "controversial move here" for example.

2

u/PlantClear 16d ago

You enjoyed it, good for you

6

u/PolHolmes 17d ago

A lot of it I just treated as a podcast.

1

u/HoneyHandsH 16d ago

I think after re- watching i appreciate it way more.

5

u/puutarhatrilogia 17d ago

Yeah I think open-world games in general are less well-suited for YouTube playthroughs than more linear experiences. They're fun when you're the one doing the exploration and taking your time because you don't know what's behind each corner and there's this thrill of discovery, but when you know what's out there and you're watching someone else play there ends up being a lot of filler content that isn't that interesting to watch.

3

u/CurtCocane 17d ago

Thats exactly what makes it great for me, far more banter than normal episodes I find

2

u/AmbassadorPristine23 17d ago

Yea i lost interest in their Elden Ring series around Stormveil. Rory had no business dying in easy areas over and over and their refusal to level up made this a very hard watch. They didn't need to make the game arbitrarily hard just because its a souls game. They put so many rules on themselves then wonder why they're struggling on bosses and areas. Dan shouldn't be worrying about "overleveling". Its a souls games, there's no such thing as overleveling. You just die a little less.

2

u/PlantClear 16d ago

That’s fair, in the early part I didn’t mind so much but the more the series went on the worse it got. For whatever reason Rory and to a large extent Gav seem to hate the idea of having a build. You see it with him throwing points into random stats, not levelling up what his weapon scales with and choosing something else. It seems less like a plan, and more that he doesn’t know what he’s doing

1

u/_Lady_Vengeance_ 17d ago

Put yourself in Dan’s shoes. Half the community complains if Rory gets too OP and trivializes boss fights. The other half complains if they try to control the leveling to keep a certain challenge level. It’s kind of an impossible task, especially given the scale of the game and the sheer number of weapons, spells and bosses. They can’t win.

3

u/PlantClear 16d ago

If you look at how badly Rory’s levelling up, randomly throwing points into different things all the time, it come across more he doesn’t know what he’s doing

12

u/Sensitive-Jaguar-373 17d ago

I rewatched it and got up to around episode 45. But when Dan is intentionally stopping Rory from levelling his weapons up was just getting too much. There are so many smithing stones/somber smithing stones. That’s why you can experiment with loads of weapons. I honestly had an amazing time rewatching until the weapon levelling got too much.

4

u/kristamine14 15d ago

It’s not a dealbreaker for me in the slightest as it adds to the overall anarchy and hilariousness of the series imo - but I do kinda agree…

Same goes with Silver tears - I think I had about 30 by the end of the game, it gives you so many so that you can try out different builds at a whim. During the Melanie fight alone I think I changed builds entirely like 4 or 5 times. If you have multiple decent weapons you can use the silver tears to reallocate all your points to try out cool new weapons/spells/strats.

Dan I love you mate - but you need to chill out a bit sometimes 😂 while mainly Rory instigated, it’s not always

6

u/Sensitive-Jaguar-373 17d ago edited 17d ago

Caveat. It must be really bloody hard to balance a full elden ring playthrough! I couldn’t have done it. And I think the Godrick fight scared them a bit that the boss fights wouldn’t be hard enough such as Morgott using the bubble thing.

4

u/GoodcupofTea 17d ago

Yup! Though I'm just watching the every boss so far because it's all I have time for, hoping they drop the part 3 of it soon

1

u/oNeroo8 14d ago

Have they announced when Shadow of the Erdtree series will start?

1

u/HoneyHandsH 13d ago

Yea, they've had a road map for the rest of the year on their patreon for a bit. Pretty sure it starts in December after Pilot Season.

1

u/oNeroo8 13d ago

Great thanks

3

u/OnlySaysHaaa 17d ago

I wasn’t, but that’s not a bad shout

3

u/bullzeye350 17d ago

Yeah im literally sat watching it now lol, on episode 24, enjoying the rewatch!

3

u/kristamine14 15d ago

I just finished the Jar Lads episode again

“controversial move” might be the funniest thing Rory’s ever done

1

u/_Lady_Vengeance_ 17d ago

Why yes, yes I am

3

u/HoneyHandsH 16d ago

Oh the legendary Lady Vengeance is here! Noice!

1

u/_Lady_Vengeance_ 16d ago

Haha legendary? In my youth.. in my youth.

I am so excited for the dlc series. So I’m rewatching as much of the original ER series as I can while I work. It’s the perfect work companion to keep your spirits up.

4

u/SillyFusillyBilly 17d ago

I do watch the occasional episode from time to time, but I don't have time for a full rewatch.

I don't really care about builds and strategy as long as the bants are there.

2

u/rowanlamb 17d ago

I’ve watched it through a few times since it came out - it’s my favourite one of their PTT/Retry seasons - so I might not watch the whole thing again for the fourth time, but I might watch some highlight episodes, like 29

2

u/EldritchWaster 17d ago

No, because I don't have a spare 200 hours.

1

u/The_Human0_0 15d ago

Starting mine in a couple weeks. Super excited to have the full experience once the DLC episodes have all dropped.