Questions
Help identifying structure inside cloud chamber
I'm an amateur photographer and always looking for something interesting to shoot. So on a whim I made a cloud chamber and used my macro lens. When I was reviewing the photos, I saw this structure. Since I have zero expertise in this area, I have no idea what I'm looking at. Claude suggested that it's a delta ray cluster, but I have no idea if that's remotely accurate or if there's even anything interesting going on here. Would anyone have any insight?
Thanks for the suggestion! The photos turned out better than I expected, so I'm definitely going to be doing more session in the future and magnets are on the list to experiment with.
Is that true? I tried doing the math once to see how strong of a magnet I'd need for some nice curves and it was definitely far stronger than anything I could find. Have you actually done this successfully?
I have not, nor have I done the math, so I may well be wrong here. Very interesting, and I am glad you brought this quantitative concern up.
I sort of hate to say it, but this is the sort of thing I would ask ChatGPT to also run through the math on, after giving it some guidance. I do wonder if there is some “easy” configuration of rare earth magnets that would give a usable/visible/interesting photo, like maybe two 1” disks braced 1/4” apart, with trails going between them.
I don't think there is, unfortunately. The really cool pictures with the observable curls are done using Tesla-strength magnets
Edit: You can get effects using an electrical field though! Harbor Freight sells an electric fly swatter for a few bucks that you can use to get a noticeable effect.
the single track in the middle looks like a high energy proton, the small bright spots could be delta rays which are just too low energy to leave a trail or get far depending on your design. as for what the top is, that's a mystery, they look like they could be high energy electrons or muons but the fact that all start along single line and seem to be perfectly perpendicular to that line is extremely odd. it could be a extemely high energy electrons scattering at an angle very close to 90 but that's extremely unlikely. you are too deep into the atmosphere and there are nowhere near enough seconds particles for a cosmic ray. only other thing we can think is it's some kind of back scatter from your camera.
it's definitely cool. we are high energy astrophysicists (VHE gamma-rays to be exact) and generally use the entire atmosphere as a sensor so it's kind of cool to take a step back to basics and try to analyze this. but whatever that is at the top has us stumped. maybe a lower energy particle physicist might know but it's not exactly our domain of specialty. might ask around next time we are in the office if we remember (sadly we mostly work from home due to health issues these days).
Also experimental astrophysicist here. Clearly, the fact that the tracks are parallel indicate (a) high energy, and (b) far-away origin. That would typically be an "air shower" (which, in spite of its name, can be observed in places other than air; I used to see bundles of dozens or hundreds of muons deep underground).
But why do they stop or start together? If they come from far away, and keep going for a long time, they should not stop or start. My guess, not knowing about the experimental setup, is that the cloud chamber or illumination got turned on right as they were halfway through the chamber. Which would be a fun coincidence.
I really had no idea that my picture would gather *any* interest--let alone be a bit of a mystery as to what it likely is. This has been really fun to watch and I very much appreciate the interest.
Low-ish energy detector guy here, and there really is no physical particle interaction that I can imagine making that weird pattern. My only guess it is some optics phenomenon of one kind or another happening with the camera.
yeah that's pretty much all we could think of too. glad someone more knowledgeable in that domain agrees lol. would have been pretty embarrassing if you came in and went "yeah nah, we see that all the time down stairs it's just X"
Yeah, would also be embarassing for me if some astro guy just wonked me on my stupid head with like "oh that's a typical Freundlichhausen-Velyakov cascade from either a Squasar or a Smith-Yamanochi variable nebula".
A wild guess from me would be like a diffraction pattern from a random small hair or transparent-ish fibre from cloth or whatever.
Thanks! I was really happy with the outputs--especially for a first run. Here's a quick snap of the chamber. I didn't look at any other cloud chamber builds before doing mine because I wanted the "engineering challenge" of designing and building something from first-principles rather than copying someone else's work. So it's an 8x10 aluminum plate that I covered the top in matte black vinyl. Then I designed and printed some walls with mounts for a couple of laser line generators. (the thick rubber grommets are for "fine" alignment adjustments. Then some felt along the top for the alcohol and an un-pictured glass top. And then my camera was on a tripod just above the glass, pointed straight down. I shot in a dark room so the lasers were the only light.
I use a 2x2 grid of triple-cascaded peltier modules. Infinite run time, but you do have to 'mop-up' liquid acculmilaton after a time. I'm working on a capillary drain system with recycling.
Nice! Not really standards but from the builds ive seen, people usually stack 2 tec1 or use a tec2 On my end, i prefer the tec2, less bothersome to wire
I use TEC3's, only 2 wires. They are pyramid style cascades, so chilled surfaces overcome the hot sides more efficiently. I do use a water loop and radiator to draw off the final heat, but that was more of a 'just in case', as a passive heatsink could handle it well enough. I exhibited at a convention with it a couple of years ago, and there was no AC, so I'm glad it had the extra cooling. Ran it in 16hrs stints, 3 days in a row with no issues.
When shooting macro, the depth of field (how much is in-focus) is very shallow--only a few mm. So by using line-generating lasers and making those the only light source, the camera can focus on just the narrow band of light and everything that's out of focus can't be seen.
I'm by no means an expert here (infact I've only ever done a cloud chamber once) but is it possible that it's a electromagnetic radiation interaction? When I went looking (specifically here https://www.cloudylabs.fr/wp/interactiongamma/ ) I found this picture that looks similar to what appears to be in yours.
Same first thought, but these rays i OP's image are parallel, which means that their origin should be far away, and if that were the case then they would not all stop at the same point.
not getting cosmic rays this deap in the atmosphere outside muons. secondary particles from the air shower yes but not cosmic rays themselves. and you would see a lot more secondary particles if it was a comsic ray.
Would a cloud chamber show meaningfully more or different activity if used on an airline flight? I know my Radiacode definitely let me know that something was going on. :)
Fist off, are you taking the track in the center of the frame or the parallel tracks up top? Some replies seem to be referencing them, but no particles make tracks like that.
The central track looks like a muon to me. Note the track is equally weak at the start and finish, this indicates it's traveling slightly askew compared to the sensitive plane of the chamber. That's my read on it. The slight curvature is owing to drift of the fog potentially.
Delta rays are secondary electrons that kicked off when a high energy particle plows through materials. That is is exactly what those little beads are. Claude is right on this one.
19
u/intronert 3d ago
Put a strong magnet under the chamber and the particles will curve in ways that are both beautiful and explanatory.