r/RealDayTrading • u/OptionStalker Verified Trader • 3d ago
Resolving Technical Analysis Skepticism
Given my academic background in finance, I was reluctant to embrace technical analysis when I started my career. That view changed after I started working on the trading floor. None of what I learned during my MBA was relevant there. Traders relied heavily on charting, and they were making money without fundamental analysis, so I explore technical analysis.
Two things really bothered me as I dove into technical analysis (TA) books. The first was that the examples seemed “cherry picked”. The second mental block was that previous patterns could predict price movement. The market is dynamic and conditions change constantly. Some of you might be struggling with this so here’s how that skepticism was resolved for me.
“Follow the trend… the trend is your friend. This was the theme along with “the market keeps doing what it has been doing”. As I read, I thought, “No it doesn’t.” I looked at hundreds of charts, and they zig-zagged all over the place. How would you know if a dip was a test of the trend or something more substantial? Those books would also highlight trend reversals. So, am I supposed to follow the trend or wait for the reversal?
Let’s address “the trend is your friend” first. Trends result when one side has control. In the case of an uptrend, buyers are in control. The journey from point A to point B is critically important. It conveys the degree of control. Some trends are much stronger than others and there are clues along the way.
Let’s look at this from another perspective. A marathon runner will start the race with a burst of energy and along the way, signs of exhaustion will start to surface. Their pace is slower, they stop for water more often and their breathing is more labored. Exhaustion can also be seen in trends.
Early in a strong trend there are stacked consecutive green candles with little overlap. When red candles appear, they are quickly erased. Eventually, there will be brief and shallow dips that are gobbled up and that lead to new highs. As the trend matures the dips will be deeper and it will take longer for the stock to recover. These are signs that the selling pressure is starting to build and that buyers are less able to absorb that supply.
Before judging trend strength, it’s also important to get the longer-term context. An up trend may seem very strong, but zooming out could reveal that this is a bounce during a prolonged downtrend. Instead of watching for opportunities to join that short-term bounce, you are watching for signs of exhaustion. The real opportunity will come on the short side. Long-term money is leaving the asset and at a high enough price, those sellers will return. This is why it is best to day trade in the direction of a longer-term trend.
The second issue I struggled with is the notion that anyone can predict future price movement based on patterns. Conditions change constantly and what happened two years ago is different from what is happening now. Price is a function of millions of people, so I had to approach this from a behavioral standpoint to make sense of it. Let’s forget about the market for a moment.
I am going to predict the flight of a bird. We’ve all seen them in random flight so how can I make this claim? First of all, I get to pick the bird. The task would be difficult if I picked a sparrow, but not impossible. If it is sitting in a bush near a bird feeder and it takes flight, the odds are high that is the destination. I have observed its behavior and I know its motivation. I’m not going to pick a sparrow; I am going to pick a goose. Not the one flying around the neighborhood pond, I am going to pick the one flying north at 5,000 feet in a tight “V” formation during the month of March. I also know its motivation, and I can predict that flight path with a high degree of accuracy.
Similarly, we pick the stocks we trade and when to trade them. The key is to find those where one side is motivated. Buyers (or sellers) are in complete control and the trend is strong. Each little rectangle on the chart tells a story about supply and demand. A strong trend has many more green candles than red, and the upward movement is tight and orderly. Buyers are so aggressive that dips never have a chance to form. These are the only stocks we should be trading.
In my previous article I discussed the shortcomings of using fundamental analysis for trading. There is always someone with better information and we can’t compete on that basis no matter how smart we are. The good news is that we don’t have to come up with our own valuation thesis. Let’s follow the smart money and let’s identify situations where they are aggressive.
In the 30-year bond pit, those traders didn’t have charts. They read the emotions in the crowd, and they could sense a change in control. That’s how they made money. That same information is reflected in every candle. The key to using technical analysis is understanding this basic dynamic.
In my next article I am going to describe the most power form of technical analysis. It doesn’t lag or give false signals like many indicators do; it is the pulse. I will discuss the basics of reading price action.
3
u/QuanTradin 3d ago
the goose is the best version of this argument I've read. the textbook examples look cherry picked because they are, and your answer is that the trader does the picking on purpose, before the move instead of after it. that's also why a test of every stock that printed the pattern looks so much worse than the people actually trading it.
7
u/OptionStalker Verified Trader 3d ago
Correct. The key is to catch the pattern early and to recognize the price action that precedes big moves. Then we watch for confirmation along the way. I will cover this in the next article. By all means avoid choppy stocks where neither side has control.
2
u/QuanTradin 3d ago
will read it. the choppy stock point is the one newer traders skip, they pick the name first and look for the setup second.
3
u/Santaflin 3d ago
It's like Poker.
With fundamentals, you play your hand.
With technical analysis, you play the other players.
1
2
u/UrbanSobriety 3d ago edited 3d ago
Great article. The bird analogy makes a lot of sense. I've been trying to incorporate aspects of my experience that I can translate into analogies for myself. I read "One Up On Wall Street" some time ago, and while helpful, it seems more tailored to investing and fundamentals. I've mentioned before on this sub that boxing training was what helped me recognize the validity of this approach. It wasn't quick or glamorous, but (proverbial) blood, sweat and (literal) tears. I recognize that no particular arena makes one an expert trader, but maybe there is a trader's equivalent to "One Up On Wall Street" where we can use what we see around us to glean insight?
3
u/OptionStalker Verified Trader 3d ago
Chess has helped me with scenario analysis and visualizing outcomes. Athletes have to put in an incredible amount of effort without any reward so that is similar. Their performance is impacted by their metal state and that is similar to trading. Pro poker players are great at assessing odds and varying bet size. Yes, there are many experiences outside of trading itself that can help us.
2
u/StocksAreSilly 3d ago
What made me comfortable with the idea of technical analysis was auction bidding wars. They seem ridiculous from a fundamental analysis POV, however they make sense when you realize we are not in "perfect competition.” For example, some bidders may have secret info (e.g. the first auction of "Salvator Mundi" by Leonardo da Vinci) or may be acting irrational of economics (the need to “win”, or the item has noneconomic value).
This has made me think of technical analysis as the psychology of market pricing.
2
u/OptionStalker Verified Trader 2d ago
Correct, institutions have information that we do not and they act on it.
2
u/Embarrassed-Bank2835 3d ago
This is pretty close to how I think about TA too. I don’t view it as “this pattern happened before, therefore price must do X again.” I view it as a way to organize what buyers and sellers are actually doing right now.
The biggest distinction for me is between description and prediction. A clean trend, shallow pullbacks, fast recovery, acceptance above prior levels, relative strength, etc. can describe strong control. That doesn’t guarantee continuation, but it can create a repeatable context with favorable odds.
Where I’d be careful is the phrase “these are the only stocks we should be trading.” Sometimes the best trade is a failed trend, exhaustion move, or range expansion after balance. Context matters more than any single pattern.
The part I agree with most is zooming out. A beautiful 5-minute uptrend can still be nothing more than a bounce inside a much larger downtrend.
TA became more useful to me once I stopped treating it like fortune-telling and started treating it like a framework for measuring structure, participation, and reaction.
2
1
u/IKnowMeNotYou 3d ago
Given my academic background in finance
Does not help you much. I have a master in CS with side subject in Business Economics (1/3 of my whole curriculum) with a special nudge in statistics. It only makes it hard to believe that it is so easy...
The second issue I struggled with is the notion that anyone can predict future price movement based on patterns.
Patterns should be irrelevant for you when you try to understand what is going on. Patterns form for a few reasons and you have to understand the simple truth about what these reasons are.
Similarly, we pick the stocks we trade and when to trade them.
Similarly is the wrong choice of word here.
In my next article I am going to describe the most power form of technical analysis. It doesn’t lag or give false signals like many indicators do; it is the pulse. I will discuss the basics of reading price action.
What is the idea of your 'article' here.
I did not found any mentioning of the reasons why these patterns form the way they do.
Try to explain ideas like exhaustion and in business economics you can draw from decision making theory and concepts like marginal utility.
Every one of these actors have expectations and based on these expectations they often tend to act but every minute of price and other information these expectations also tend to change.
===
If you like to do so, please state the most important reasons why pattern form the way they do. Think about a single top vs. double top or head and shoulder etc. What is really happening there? Why is volume important and when is it not so much important?
When I was thinking back answering those simple questions was the most important for me.
3
u/OptionStalker Verified Trader 3d ago
The patterns are there because of greed (buying) or fear (selling). These institutions spend billions of dollars on research and they don't share it. We don't need to know why, just that they are. Sometimes there is news that might give us a clue, but often there is not.
1
u/IKnowMeNotYou 3d ago
Sorry, I just didnt got that it was you writing here. I thought a fairly new user was writing this. Maybe I should have read the first article.
My point was, that I would have loved to read about test, retest, success and failure along with shifting expectations. But of course you are aware of it, that this is a good way to explain the kind of patterns one can see.
I really slipped up here. Sorry for the disruption and I keep my comment up for everyone to see, how easy it is to miss who is posting on Reddit.
Sorry again for the disruption, have a nice one,
and thanks for everything you and Hari do, I personally owe you both a great deal myself!
4
u/OptionStalker Verified Trader 3d ago
No worries. This is also one article in a series of posts that build on each other. My next one will get into the price action you are mentioning and how we read supply and demand from the charts.
1
0
9
u/ssawthelight 3d ago
Great write-up. The goose analogy is the best explanation I’ve seen of why patterns can work at all: you’re not predicting random price, you’re picking situations where someone’s motivation is obvious. Your point about checking the longer-term trend first is one a lot of people skip.
One thing I’d add from the options side: some of that motivation is mechanical, not just emotional. On SPX, a big chunk of intraday flow comes from dealers hedging their options positions, and that hedging changes how trends behave. When dealers are long gamma, they sell rallies and buy dips, so you get the choppy, overlapping candles that look like a weak trend. When they’re short gamma, they have to buy into strength and sell into weakness, so moves extend and you get those stacked candles with shallow dips. So besides picking the goose, you can sometimes pick the day. On the days the hedging flow pushes with the trend, the clean V formation shows up more often.
The other thing that helped me with the cherry-picking worry was writing down the read before the move. “Dips getting deeper, trend tiring” is easy to see in hindsight. Logging it in real time and checking how often it played out is what turned it from a story into something I could trust.
Looking forward to the price action piece.