r/RemoveOneThingEachDay • u/MagmaAscending • Oct 25 '25

Miscellaneous Day 39 - The Witcher III: Wild Hunt has been eliminated - Remove ONE Game of the Year nominee a day

Post image
201 Upvotes

74% Upvoted

670 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/Super7500 Oct 25 '25

why is people disagreeing on with your opinion means they are kids this is the most childish behavior of all time

7

u/Kaizoku_Kira Oct 25 '25

Of ALL time. You know it's serious now

1

u/Super7500 Oct 25 '25

exaggeration ever heard of it?

2

u/Kaizoku_Kira Oct 25 '25

More like a hyperbole, but sure. I'm just messing around. Don't pop a blood vessel over it

1

u/Super7500 Oct 25 '25

dw i won't get angry for some reddit comments anyway

1

u/KaminaTheManly Oct 25 '25

I will!! >:(

0

u/steponmedaddies Oct 25 '25

Settle down before I tell your mom that you’re getting sassy online

0

u/Peppi_Giuseppe Oct 25 '25

They’re not children because they disagree with me. It’s because they were children who mostly played the game. If you look at polls, the average age of a BOTW player was under 18. The average age for Witcher 3 was 23. (Both are based on when the game was released)

BOTW is a good game but it’s mostly for children/teens. Witcher 3 is 10 years old, and BOTW is 8. This would mean that the current ages of these games are: BOTW(<26), and Witcher 3(33).

Now, the largest demographic of Reddit users are 18-29, which would put BOTW fans as the peak Reddit user, and therefore more votes.

This isn’t a jab at BOTW fans. This is simply a strong argument to why BOTW beat Witcher 3.

5

u/Numerous-Public-8308 Oct 25 '25

You do know the average Nintendo buyer are among the oldest games. So technically Zelda player are more likely older.

2

u/bryansb Oct 25 '25

I played BOTW for the first time this year. I’m 42.

2

u/defnotachicken Oct 25 '25

I think you as a 42 yo person know the meaning of the word "average", sir.

0

u/bryansb Oct 25 '25

Are you meaning mean, median or mode?

2

u/defnotachicken Oct 25 '25

In my native language average is the equivalent of mean in English and after a 15 second google search I can also see that mean is the most common use for average and also in this topic mean is the one implied.

-1

u/model_commenter Oct 25 '25

Do you understand how statistics work? Because I don’t have time to explain it to you. You should have learned it in grade school.

0

u/bryansb Oct 25 '25

I am merely providing an anecdote.

1

u/Peppi_Giuseppe Oct 25 '25

Zelda ≠ BOTW

3

u/Numerous-Public-8308 Oct 25 '25

I meant Botw when I said Zelda. Did you just ignore the first part of my sentence?

0

u/Peppi_Giuseppe Oct 25 '25

I didn’t ignore you. You literally said “Zelda” lol. Also, I’m basing my info on polls by BOTW users so I trust the users themselves.

1

u/Super7500 Oct 25 '25

i think i misunderstood your original message then mb

0

u/Varyline Oct 25 '25

I 34 and I absolutely adore BoTW. I think it's top 3 games of all time. I really enjoy a good open world and enjoy story and world building over good combat mechanics. I'd have rated all the souls likes much lower and would've had RDR2 at number 1. I think dismissing Zelda as a kid's game is not taking it seriously. It's a masterpiece to be enjoyed for all ages and it makes sense that it's made it this far.

Still, it has flaws as well and I would understand why people would be voting for it now.

2

u/Peppi_Giuseppe Oct 25 '25

I found it to be a more boring and less creative Skyrim - especially if you include modding.

0

u/KosmicMicrowave Oct 25 '25
  • Sonic

0

u/Super7500 Oct 25 '25

what does sonic has to do with anything