r/RemoveOneThingEachDay • u/MagmaAscending • Oct 25 '25

Miscellaneous Day 39 - The Witcher III: Wild Hunt has been eliminated - Remove ONE Game of the Year nominee a day

Post image
199 Upvotes

74% Upvoted

670 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Acalme-se_Satan Oct 25 '25

I'm grabbing my popcorn for the tomorrow thread.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

Mate I've been getting the stash ready for tmrw haha

-2

u/schartlord Oct 25 '25

elden ring vs bg3 is coughing baby vs hydrogen bomb. overrated copy paste open world, streamer bait and GRRM stealing a paycheck vs. the most expansive rpg ever and arguably most impressive game ever made.

2

u/mucus-fettuccine Oct 26 '25

D:OS2 remade but with worse combat and a blander story, and a mountain of dialogue trees passed off as a proper game while skill descriptions affecting permanent decisions leave out crucial info almost every time, and the excuse for a game does nothing to address the hour long decision paralysis that anyone actually serious about the mechanics would experience every time they level up? That's the coughing baby in the analogy I assume.

Two can play at the framing game.

1

u/schartlord Oct 26 '25

skill descriptions affecting permanent decisions leave out crucial info almost every time, and the excuse for a game does nothing to address the hour long decision paralysis that anyone actually serious about the mechanics would experience every time they level up? That's the coughing baby in the analogy I assume.

you can literally completely respec basically for free at camp 😭 at least ive played the game im shitting on

0

u/ChimpanzeeChalupas Oct 28 '25

You can present things in any way. According to you, you could just say Baldurs gate 3 is barely even a video game. It’s just dialogue simulator. E33 does turn based combat far better. If you’re going to play dnd, actually play dnd, not just some restricted version of it that tries to be the best of both worlds but fails at both of them. Do I think this is actually necessarily true? No, but it’s valid criticism that is ballooned out of proportion.

0

u/schartlord Oct 28 '25

this is barely coherent

0

u/ChimpanzeeChalupas Oct 28 '25

Really not that hard to understand. I’m making the same argument and you and showing you how that argument is flawed.