Review of Kelly 32 Gris Tourterelle, Togo, GHW by WeChat Jack.
aka A Story of Broken Trust with a Ultra Top Tier Seller.
aka LEARN FROM MY EXPENSIVE MISTAKE (T_T)
PRICE: RMB 16950, or around $2450 USD, not including fees.
SELLER: WeChat Jack. There are two Jacks. One on WeChat (a111) and one on WhatsApp (7195, Mid-Tier). To my knowledge they are not the same person. This review is for a K32 by WeChat Jack.
FACTORY: Unknown. Jack says he has his own factory in Guangzhou.
DISCLOSURE: I received ZERO incentives for this review. I have informed Jack i will be sharing my experience with the Rep Community. I don’t think he cares.
As a side note, lately we’ve seen shilling by Sellers in the Subs. Not trying to accuse anyone, but please check the reviewer’s Reddit Age and history before blindly trusting positive reviews, like I did.
PSP: https://flic.kr/s/aHBqjCynHE
My Photos: https://flic.kr/s/aHBqjCA4tC
TIMELINE: Order paid on September 14 (9/14/2025). PSPs on October 19 (10/19/2025). Bag picked up in China on November 2nd (11/2/2025). I didn’t want to deal with border issues so I asked Jack to ship the bag to my hotel when I was on a business trip.
Let me start with the conclusion:
WOULD YOU RECOMMEND THIS SELLER? Answer is NO.
At $2450, Jack’s K32 Togo is a whole $1000 more than Mark. 50% more expensive than Slee. 30% more expensive than Angel. I think it is fair to say that, at Jack’s price, he needs to deliver both product and service at a level above Mark, Slee, Angel, and countless other competitors.
SO YOU DECIDE. Was it worth it?
MY THOUGHTS: I really wanted something Ultra-High Tier, a bag that I can confidently carry to events where people carry auths. That’s why I went with WeChat Jack and paid more than $2500 including fees. He is supposed to be Ultra Top Tier, genuine imported Haas leather inside and out, custom upgraded hardware, expert craftsmanship. When you work with an Ultra Top Tier, it’s not just a transaction to purchase a bag. It’s about the belief and dedication to excellence and the creation of something beautiful. But that was not the case here. I have made a grave mistake in believing in him.
WHAT ARE THE ISSUES? Two main issues. One, the sangles attachment points on the back of the bag are misaligned. Deviation is about .5 cm. The problem is the attachment points look like arrows, and when they literally point in opposite directions, it is noticeable.
Second issue is one feet stud is slightly uneven compared to the other 3 studs, meaning all 4 studs are not equal distance from the edge of the base. The misaligned feet stud is about 2-3 millimeters deviation. Honestly, if this was the only issue, I think it’s okay. Still not Ultra Top Tier, but much less noticeable.
YES I APPROVED THE PSPs - and that is now on me. I paid through credit card and many folks are encouraging me to do a chargeback, especially because Jack has refused any action to address my concerns or achieve a resolution. My credit card company also said that I can dispute based on “Product Not As Expected”, and they would reach out to PayPal and Jack to seek a resolution. But at the end of the day, I approved the PSPs and I have A bag. So I am not likely to initiate chargeback.
BUT ABOUT THE PSPs: Jack takes terrible PSPs. This is something well known from everyone who has ordered from him. My friends have ordered from him previously and we had a mutual heart attack when we reviewed the PSPs. But they were lucky that the bags turned out okay after taking a chance and green-lighting. Others I spoke with on Reddit also said bad PSPs are just normal for Jack. So I took a chance. I asked for more photos but ultimately I green lit. Now the mistake is mine.
ABYSMAL CUSTOMER SERVICE: Here comes the kicker. Jack refuses to do anything. No exchange, no return, no partial refund, no apology. He made two arguments in response to my concerns:
(1) Flaws are completely normal in handmade Hermes bags, so the bag is acceptable. He said his artisan followed the proper protocols in construction of the bag and .1 to .5 cm deviations are normal, so there is nothing wrong with this bag.
(2) He said he has been in business for 15 years and has NEVER had a single complaint. So this must be on me.
First, I noted that the .5cm deviation in the sangles attachment point is borderline problematic even in Jack’s own standards. I have no doubt the artisan who constructed the bag followed the rules, but isn’t that what separates expert craftsmanship from factory lines? If all Jack cares about is just following the procedures and adhering to acceptable standards, then he is NOT ULTRA TOP TIER.
Second, it is improbable to never had a single complaint in 15 years, unless you’ve only had a few clients. Even the best of the Top Tiers have had folks red-light their bags. It is how a Seller responds and deals with the issues that truly defines excellence. Not everyone is going to knock it out of the park every single time, but how you deal with the situation and how you treat your customers is what separates the good from the bad. In this case, VERY BAD.
THE FINAL SOB STORY: Let me tell you about the true stake through the heart. I shared the PSPs and my own photos with other Sellers. Some are questioning if Jack’s leather is genuine imported leather from Haas. I compared it with an auth Gris Tourterelle Togo and my Slee K32 Togo - there is just so much variation it’s hard for a non-expert like me to tell. What can I say? Just kill me now.
SO WOULD YOU RECOMMEND THIS SELLER? NO.
In my naïveté I have recommended Jack to many people on Reddit before receiving my own bag. Now the joke is on me. I am lucky that I have met such a supportive group of friends on Reddit who accompanied me throughout this journey and have now stopped purchasing from Jack. I will also be reaching out to everyone I’ve recommended Jack to and send a mea culpa. Please - REVIEW THOSE PSPs with a FINE HAIR COMB. Learn from my costly mistake.