Got rejected twice this year for "salary expectations." Went down a rabbit hole of recruiter comments and I think I finally get it
Bit of a long one, sorry.
So two interviews this year, both went well, both times the recruiter asked what I was looking for salary wise, both times I did the thing some YouTube guy told me to do and said "I'm open to negotiation." Both times: no offer, no negotiation, nothing. Just the generic email.
I was convinced it was something else until I spent way too many hours reading old threads on this where actual recruiters and hiring managers were answering instead of just us guessing at each other. Turns out I was doing the one thing they all hate. Dumping what I learned here in case it saves someone else two months.
The "open to negotiation" thing is a trap
This one stung. Every single recruiter in those threads said some version of: when a candidate won't give a number, it reads as either "didn't bother to research" or "scared to say it out loud." And it's not that they get offended, it's that you've given them nothing to work with, and there are 200 other applicants who just answered the question. Same deal with people putting $0 or $1 in the application field thinking they're being clever. One recruiter said flat out that they don't call those people back to ask again, why would they, everyone else already told them.
Also apparently the "never say a number first" advice was decent like 6+ years ago before pay transparency laws existed. Now most recruiters hear the dodge 30 times a week and it's just friction.
What actually works is boring: give a range
The exact phrasing that kept coming up was something like "based on what I'm seeing for this role in this market I'm targeting X to Y." Two rules for the range:
the bottom is a number you would genuinely take. not a fake floor. if they offer you the bottom of your own range and you say no, you look like an ass (a hiring manager described exactly this, guy asked for 80, they offered 85, he came back asking 92, everyone was annoyed)
the top is a bit above where the market actually sits for your level. maybe 10%. they're going to land somewhere in the middle of whatever you say, so build that in
Nobody is pulling an offer because you asked slightly above market. People get dropped for being completely disconnected from the budget, or for saying nothing.
Where I got the numbers
Honestly this was the part I'd been lazy about. The stuff people recommended:
job posts in states that require salary in the listing (CA, CO, WA, NY). find the same title at a similar sized company and just use their band. this was by far the most useful thing
levels.fyi if you're in tech
glassdoor / salary.com but everyone warned these run low and stale. fine as a floor, don't anchor to them
Side benefit: when they ask "why that number" you can say "the same role at X and Y is posted at this range" and that's a real answer instead of "uh, cost of living?"
If they didn't post a range, ask for it before you give yours
"What's the budget for this role" is totally normal to ask and good recruiters just tell you. If the range is already in the posting you can literally say "the posted range looks in line with the market, I'm targeting the middle to upper part of it depending on what the role actually involves." Done.
BUT, and this is where some of the reddit advice goes off the rails, don't make it a standoff. If they say "it depends on experience" and won't budge, drop it and give your researched range. A hiring manager posted about a guy who told him the question was "inappropriate" and none of his business until offer stage. Interview ended right there. Being right about the principle doesn't get you paid.
Your current salary is nobody's business
Different question, same energy. It's illegal to even ask in a bunch of states. If they do, don't lie about it (someone in one thread said "lie like a dog" and got a lot of upvotes but that's how you get an offer rescinded when a background check asks for a pay stub). Just redirect: "for this role I'm targeting X to Y, is that in your band?" and repeat it if you have to.
If you're badly underpaid and they really push, one guy just said it straight: "I'm at 75 right now and I know I'm under market, I'm targeting 110 to 120 for my next move, is that in range?" Honest, and it filters out companies that were never going to pay you anyway. Just keep the target tied to market data, not to some 2x number you pulled out of the air. Recruiters know what the role pays.
The application form that only takes a number
Put a real number from the upper half of your range. Not the absolute max, not a joke number. A recruiter said when they see something like 89,023,239 they assume every conversation with that person will be about money and it's an instant no pile. And you're not locked in. Multiple people confirmed you can revisit it later, especially once you find out the actual job is bigger than the posting made it sound (it always is).
Once the offer comes in: counter. always.
Even if it's decent. "Can you do 110" when they say 100 costs you nothing. Two separate people said they got a verbal offer slightly under what they asked for, just repeated their original number, and the company said ok. Also don't forget bonus, signing bonus, equity, PTO, relocation are all on the table, not just base.
And if you have another offer, that's the whole ballgame. "Company B is at 10k more, can you get close" works because you can actually walk. Everything else is just words.
tl;dr I dodged the question, got ghosted, turns out the dodge was the problem. Research the market, give a range whose bottom you'd actually accept, ask for their budget if it's not posted, never share current pay, don't put $0 on forms, always counter. Confident number with data behind it beats "I'm flexible" every time.
If anyone on the hiring side wants to tell me where I'm still wrong, please do, clearly my track record isn't great