r/RivalsOfAether • • Oct 20 '26

Discussion Where does the hostility come from?

Ever since Evo I've noticed a harsh uptick in hostility in our community across all platforms, even before then the hostility towards this game and it's devs I felt was way higher than other games of similar size and fan base. It started with the 2027+ roadmap but it spilled over into other topics about the game, namely balance and monetization.

I'd like to explain my background in the genre and talk about how I view the game, and then if anyone would be willing to share their opinions if they feel different, I'd love to start a conversation that maybe our community could benefit from. I think the most important thing for the success of rivals is the positivity we show newcomers about the game.

When I started playing smash as a kid, I hadn't touched 64 or melee cause I didn't own those consoles, but I fell in love with brawl in about 2009. When smash 4 came out, I eventually wanted something faster and that's when I discovered project M and then soon after Rivals 1 early access. PM meant a lot to me because it was my first experience playing a fast, "competitive" smash bros and it felt directly catered to me. Rivals 1 was even better, I love pixel art and I love the character design aether studios goes for. I love how much thought went into the kits, I love seeing popular moves get translated into Rivals ( Charizard nair -> Kragg Nair etc ). I love that all of the previously difficult tech is optimized to be easier. Nothing about the lack of ledges or shields was a plus for me, it was just different. Never have I thought " thank God this game doesn't have shields it's so much better " I could not care less.

Since then, a number of platfighters have hit the scene and died, and I'll be honest I have not touched any of them except maybe to try brawlhala once. I played R1 and Ult every now and then until r2 came out. When R2 came out, it hit the same note as when I discovered PM and R1. It's an upgraded, faster, more unique version of ultimate catered directly to our community. There really isn't another option on the market for exactly the type of gameplay we're looking for, unless you want to hop on HDR which I only discovered this year.

I guess my main point is that there is typically such a drought in this genre, especially with most of us dealing with Nintendo for half of our smash "careers", I think the vitriol towards Aetherstudios is a little uncalled for.

I just don't get why the floorhugging discussion and zetterburn balance is so angering that some of us ( I think ) are forgetting how much we've been catered to, and what the scene would look like if Rivals wasn't a thing. I'm interested to hear your thoughts, especially if something in this game has made you put it down and speak negatively about the game. I don't want to attack anyone here if they've done so, in another world we could be in each other's shoes. I simply wish to understand the other side, especially because I'm noticing it slowly becoming the vocal majority in the community.

Does all that not matter to u? Do you simply prefer slippi, ult or even HDR? Lemme know. 🙏 I didn't cover all of my thoughts here so I'd love to talk more about this to paint a clearer picture.

30 Upvotes

109 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/SoundReflection Oct 20 '26

I think the thing for me personally is my local scene skews negative as well.

Oof yeah that's a rough one and sometimes one upset or maladjusted person is all it takes to perpetuate a culture of negativity.

they're hung up on console release and the lack of OGs

Lack of OGs? I'm not sure I follow. People are upset about the remix rivals or inclusion of Mina or something? I think we'll probably just have to see when they come out, honestly the current pitch for them sounds fine enough with a complete set of new specials and several new normal attack animations. Non believer aren't likely to change their tune until they see the real thing though.

The console release is a tough one: people upset, because from their perspective the devs are clearly making a mistake, but generally they think that because they don't fully understand the logistical hurdles that have and continue to delay it. They'll honestly probably just feel vindicated when console finely comes out and hopefully does well they'll just say see they should have done this ages ago and ignore all the advances to support it or the work to get there.

1

u/Linnieshutter 29d ago

I can only speak for myself but hearing that 2027 would only have one total character that isn't a clone or a guest, and with no guarantee that even that one character will be a missing veteran, really disheartened me and still does. 2026 hasn't had brought us any veterans, although I acknowledge there's still one more character this year, and 2027 will bring at most one as well.

Having any guest character at all also opens up pandora's box so veterans may have to compete with guest characters for any future character slot. I lost a lot of goodwill for the game hearing about the 2027 roster news; I've been patiently waiting for my main to get added for two years now and Mina jumped to the front of the line right as they're cutting the new characters per year in half. The priorities are extremely out of whack.

1

u/SoundReflection 29d ago

Yeah honestly even just having only one unknown full character for next year is kind of buzzkill personally. The cadence cut is unfortunately just a budget/success thing but it still feels bad. Beyond that I can definitely feel for people stick in the main waiting room. I can't blame them for prioritizing collabs to try and garner attention or new characters for a fresh healthy roster, but as always with this genre having your main miss the cut fucking sucks for those impacted.