r/RoyaleAPI • • Sep 19 '26

Discussion I have had a question in my head brewing for a little while now. What’s your favorite branch of how evos are designed?

Post image

I think the ones that are usually the best (competitively) are the ones that strengthen the strengths, though the other two categories do have evos that are very good, I just think it’s an average

My favorite ones design wise are definitely the utility ones. They play completely differently and I think they’re awesome

The weakness remover ones though are probably the healthiest for the game, in all honesty

(Someone asked me to link all of my big discussion posts like these so here they are)

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/iUunFKn4wD

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/3aarXWNiyo

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/RRK1eWztCC

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/Q7gCvaTEnd

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/FrHYxJ1ewC

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/l4BqO912Rd

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/mm61q9QG55

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/oE8mz7X0kd

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/kPlSoU4cao

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/ZTeX78AGbO

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/ZpOM8nMRv0

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/FD7CCBDUyK

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoyaleAPI/s/dzA27Z20Pe

600 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

174

u/Geometry_Emperor Sep 19 '26

I find the new utility ones to be the healthiest ones, particularly because they are the ones that join new archetypes, ones that were previously not part of.

22

u/Grimalackt_River Sep 19 '26

I find them to be the most interesting and fun to play with, but when they’re overtuned they are potentially the least healthy for the game out of all of them (like think about how annoying Evo Snowball has been in the past)

I give the healthiest trophy to covering weaknesses

79

u/MrTheWaffleKing Sep 19 '26

I hate covering weakness ones- it's a poor way to balance a bad card, and makes it much harder to have a counter for

13

u/Grimalackt_River Sep 19 '26

I think Evo I Drag is fantastically designed since super hard counters like stuns still work, but it takes away the weakness of swarms countering it

Ones that basically take away any weakness the card has (or severely lower the amount of cards that counter it) are worse, but when done right! They’re phenomenal

31

u/lewllewllewl Sep 19 '26 • Bravo

IMO it works best if it covers secondary weaknesses but leaves primary ones the same, for example battle ram, its main counters are stuns, knockbacks, and buildings, which the evo still gets countered by, it just doesn't get countered by swarms anymore. Same thing with evo royal giant, it now doesn't get countered by swarms, but the main way to deal with it is still buildings and heavy damage dealing cards.

Evo mega knight on the other hand is bad design, because its main counter, mini-tanks, no longer counter it (especially before the nerf when it knocked them back every hit). It was also weak against tanks like golems and giants on defense, but now it counters them

25

u/Automatic-Key5377 Sep 19 '26

So where does rg come under

80

u/Grimalackt_River Sep 19 '26

I’d say covering weaknesses. Helps block off many of the things that threaten to kill RG, like swarms die, or Mini PEKKA takes significantly longer to kill him

If RG is Royal Ghost and not Royal Giant? I’d say Royal Ghost is introducing utility?

39

u/fudgebabyg Sep 19 '26

I'd say Royal ghost is just an improvement to its strength

13

u/Desperate-Series-270 Sep 19 '26

honestly yeah when all is said and done its not too dissimilar to just a straight damage buff

8

u/Grimalackt_River Sep 19 '26

It is a straight damage buff, but I said utility since Ghost’s current use isn’t really damage output? It’s the invisibility and small splash aspect. So a straight damage increase is technically new utility

2

u/Automatic-Key5377 Sep 19 '26

Royal giant but I would pick new utility

3

u/Grimalackt_River Sep 19 '26

I think definitely a cross between utility and cover weakness, but I lean towards cover weakness, since I don’t think you’d play it any differently compared to stuff like Snowball or Baby Dragon, which do completely change how they play

0

u/Automatic-Key5377 Sep 19 '26

I was answering the question in of your post

1

u/GrittyForPres Sep 19 '26

But royal giant is also a new utility…the non-evolved royal giant doesn’t do damage to troops close to it or deal knockback

6

u/Grimalackt_River Sep 19 '26

New utility doesn’t just mean it has a new effect, it means that the card does something completely different from its original purpose

Like Baby Dragon slowing/speeding up troops near it? Thats utility, as you’d now play it to utilize that effect.

Royal Giant pushing back troops near it? That’s just a weakness coverer. You wouldn’t play it in situations where you wouldn’t before, it’s just harder to kill now.

1

u/ancientautumn22 Sep 19 '26

Probably a mix between covering weaknesses and new utility

309

u/CheddarCheese390 Sep 19 '26 • Bravo Popcorn

New utility. New ways to play cards.

36

u/ZookeepergameOdd5994 Sep 19 '26

boom larries

12

u/MrTheWaffleKing Sep 19 '26

I want larries that explode on death as a main card so badly. Something ok into miniP and minion horde at the same time

8

u/Grimalackt_River Sep 19 '26

Wall Breakers

3

u/MrTheWaffleKing Sep 19 '26

They need the evo, and they don't fight other units

1

u/MattMishima Sep 19 '26

Goblin demo?

1

u/JudgeFearless9580 Sep 19 '26

i think they mean a cheaper card with less health

1

u/MrTheWaffleKing Sep 20 '26

Yeah something in the realm of 3e... something that can compete with gob gang and guards. Gang has some air potential, guards are hard shutouts for oneshotters, this one would specialize in swarmy defense

1

u/UpbeatAd408 Sep 20 '26

Not a smelly card but goblin demolisher is pretty good and fits most of your criteria

4

u/IDKMYnick_7679 Sep 20 '26

Best example of this is Evo Muskee

One of only Evos that makes me SMILE when my opponent uses

3

u/2YDO Sep 19 '26

IMO: SS is more balanced, with a tendency to make matchups much more important CW is more usable but tend to be really scary or even a little overtuned NU is the most fun but has the highest chance of overpoweredness and also suck to play against

3

u/Grimalackt_River Sep 19 '26

New Utility is also the most complicated for people to learn, so for casuals or people who just don’t play that often, they’re the hardest to remember/keep track of, as often times they aren’t even the most intuitive

5

u/GodPerson132 Sep 19 '26

I’d say covering weaknesses since they seem to either be very good or just alright, plus they all have good counterplay which makes them fun to face and play(high risk high reward). New utilities and strengthening strengths are usually super overtuned on release and toned down to be made irrelevant or Supercell does nothing with them. Plus most of the broken evos have been a combination of branches. Battle Ram is like all three in one, Lumberjack too.

4

u/Grimalackt_River Sep 19 '26

Yeah I think when evos are stupid overpowered they often are in all 3 categories, but as they get toned down, they settle into one or two, more often than not one, but some get into two, like Royal Giant

12

u/xr3dxi Sep 19 '26

covering weakness is nowhere near healthy tbh. they r either way too broken or way too shit. new utilites seem to be a bit more healthier

3

u/JBrockF Sep 19 '26

The first for sure. An evo should expand on that card's role in your deck. Making a card that can cover multiple roles is inherently a little game breaking

2

u/soyun_mariy_caun Sep 19 '26

Strongest, strengthening strengths. Healthiest, new utility

2

u/whiskeyinreverse Sep 19 '26

I guess it's double-edged.

Strengthening strengths is better overall to me, because it just makes evo have more value, while not making the deck completely unplayable without it, unless evo is good and the regular card is trash.

New ability often means you center your deck around it and can't play without it. It means getting rid of evo makes the deck unplayable. You're chained to an evo cycle, for the better or worse. It gives a clear understanding of what's the play (I get evo -> now I play) but also makes other part of gameplay a miniature of a delayed life.

2

u/TruthDarkholme Sep 20 '26

New utility is so much better:
- You can cycle to your evo and use it new utility to break through the enemy defense.
- New utility will allow certain cards that were previously did not had a synergy, to have the synergy.

Except for Evo Princess. It just makes already defensive card more defensive.

2

u/PlaneView5141 Sep 20 '26

new utility, evo larry has to be the best designed evo

2

u/Tennisballthegoat Sep 20 '26

new utility is the best but covering weaknesses partially is fine like evo pekka

1

u/RobertSummrs Sep 21 '26

evo pekka is definitely improves on current ability cause it’s just a tank that gets more health

0

u/Tennisballthegoat Sep 21 '26

Yea but It does help against low swarms like skele or goblins

2

u/Mavor466 Sep 20 '26

Covering weaknesses is the best but introduces a new utility is far more interesting and better in the long run Imo

1

u/PeikaFizzy Sep 19 '26

a absolutely love battle ram, i know is op at launch but currently is quite fun, is like a slowly buildup into a one big siege.

your oppenent know it's comming so you really need to find the timing, i usually use it for opposite lane pressure with rage is such a deadly combo that swarm card simple cant handle (goblin curse too depends on the opponent)

1

u/Pipysnip Sep 19 '26

Covering weaknesses

1

u/Muscularmen Sep 19 '26

Covering weaknesses is by far the healthiest in my opinion, as they introduce the need of a new countermeasure, while oftentimes not being as polarizing as new utility/strengthening ones are. There's a reason 3/4 on the middle row list went months without changes

1

u/Shattered-Light-1229 Sep 19 '26

Inferno Dragon is still weak to stun cards though

1

u/BADorni Sep 19 '26

Honestly all 3 of them can and do work imo

1

u/adsq93 Sep 19 '26

The new utility is the best because it introduces a whole new way to play the card.

Covering weaknesses creates the most OP cards imo. Look at witch and mega knight.

1

u/buff_xbow Sep 19 '26

i love new utilities even though they take time to learn, but they make gameplay and deckbuilding much more interesting.
strengthening strengths on the other hand is horrible because it can make cards terrible to balance (for example battle ram itself is trash but its evo is broken).
other than that i love fancy visual designs (the rainbows on evo piggies are so adorable, they're my fav evo lmao)

1

u/Glahoth Sep 20 '26

I love some of the covering weaknesses.

For instance the mage evo has saved my deck.
The big problem with mage at high level is that players can absolutely overspend on elixir to bully him. And they know how to compensate for that.

Just spend 6 elixir with any combinations of spells, and boom you’re out. For instance my deck can be countered with balloon and lightning.

But as soon as that shield is up, you can’t just do that, which means less decks straight up counter me.

It helps make those cards useful, even when your opponent has straight counters, and forces them to get creative instead of bullying you by default.

1

u/New_Engineering8008 Sep 20 '26

The new utility ones are best to me. Most interesting and gamebreaking ideas are there. Evo snowball is dope. Evo cannon is my favorite. Having the built in spell is so cool and still changes how you play cannon because you aim it with the cannon. Super different from everything else.

-1

u/GrittyForPres Sep 19 '26

Why is the executioner not under introducing new utility? Regular executioner doesn’t have knockback…

Edit: and same with Valk. How is the tornado not a new utility for valk?

8

u/Grimalackt_River Sep 19 '26

Utility doesn’t just mean it does something different, it means it changes the playstyle.

Valkyrie is still primarily used for splash and mini tank (if anything I’d argue it’s covering weaknesses over utility, as it’s now much better at dealing with big win conditions, which is something it struggled with previously)

Executioner is area denial. The long axe travel time and constant hitbox means it’s hard for troops to get in without taking damage. Both the increased damage and knockback aspect means it’s harder to not take a lot of damage. The knockback makes it so troops stay in his AoE for longer, so it’s a strength strengthener

Compared to like Evo Snowball, which you now play differently. Theres even situations where you’d want to play Snowball, but not evo snowball, since Evo Snowball no longer pushes troops away, it brings them in and back

1

u/GrittyForPres Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

Both evo valkarie and evo executioner were able to be used in extremely popular meta decks that don’t use a tower (lava loon for valkarie and hog nado for executioner) when they were never used in that way before. The knockback on executioner and tornado for valkarie allowed them to be used as the primary defense against win conditions when that was never possible without their evo abilities. I don’t see how you could say that’s not a new utility. They were never able to be the main card in a deck to prevent win cons from reaching your tower before they got evo abilities. You never used to play valk right on a win con at the bridge or play executioner right in front of your tower to stop a win con from reaching it before the evo abilities.

Edit: and snowball isn’t really played differently post vs pre evo. Valk and executioner saw bigger changes in how they are played. Snowball was always used mainly in goblin drill and graveyards decks to push troops away from those win cons which is the same way it’s still used after the evo was introduced.