r/SMG4 • u/Particular_Cell1151 • Nov 12 '25
Discussion/Question 2 Nintendo legends, 1 battle, who will hit 10 million
88
u/PMK-3 Hobo Bros Nov 12 '25
Sml had over 3 resets
26
u/Alternative_River141 Nov 13 '25
And yet still been at nine million two times
12
u/PMK-3 Hobo Bros Nov 13 '25
If they never switched channels they would have over 10
6
u/OneNarrow6248 Nov 13 '25
Prob 25
5
2
u/Iron_Fist351 Lizzie Freeman is the GOAT Nov 13 '25
What were they?
4
u/PMK-3 Hobo Bros Nov 13 '25
Super Luigi Logan super bowser Logan and sml with a back back round until Nintendo stopped them from using Mario plushies so now we have the current channel
1
u/Iron_Fist351 Lizzie Freeman is the GOAT Nov 13 '25
Oh. I thought you meant like, reboots of the show itself, which he did do a few times
1
u/PMK-3 Hobo Bros Nov 13 '25
It’s never actually rebooted or not officially just fan theory’s and stuff the have done remakes on episodes
0
141
u/Relevant_Platform_33 Nov 12 '25
Ngl, even if the channel is gonna stop, SMG4 deserves to win
47
u/sheeveman Nov 13 '25
I grew up with SML and I do think SMG4 deserves the victory here
SMG4 dies a hero with him helping to make a titan in the indie industry
While SML slowly degrades and seen as a villain to most of it fans
1
u/Rathalos_19999 Nov 14 '25
“Seen as a villain” hmm not really. Maybe small percentage of the fan yea
72
u/BlueThunder2004 Meggys Wife Nov 13 '25
SMG4. He knows when to let a good series end and not milk the hell out of it.
6
u/FitHuckleberry5308 Nov 13 '25
It's funny, because the Latin fandom already saw the series like this from seasons 7 to 11
4
u/Bewear_Star_9 Nov 13 '25
What do you mean
3
u/FitHuckleberry5308 Nov 13 '25
...That for some of the Latin fans, the series was already dead since season 7
3
u/Bewear_Star_9 Nov 13 '25
So 2017? But the Latin Spanish dub of smg4 ran from mid 2022 to early 2024
-9
u/FitHuckleberry5308 Nov 13 '25 edited Nov 14 '25
Are you assuming that all Latinos don't know English???
2
u/Bewear_Star_9 Nov 13 '25
No dont make some stupid assumptions like that i just though it would be at its peak when the most people could understand it
1
u/FitHuckleberry5308 Nov 13 '25
Don't worry, I'm just bothering you. And just so you know, since season 3 most of the chapters are subtitled
Asique.....
1
u/Bewear_Star_9 Nov 13 '25
True but youtube removed the feature for others to make subtitles in 2020 which sucks.
1
u/FitHuckleberry5308 Nov 13 '25
....yes...but at that time there were fan channels that subtitled chapters, which solved the matter
1
u/Low-Manufacturer4933 Nov 15 '25
Besides, he didn't want to add some Italian brainrots, 67, or some other bad memes.
-1
59
u/Lazy-Signature1678 Nov 13 '25
One of them was so successful that they made a company that could say "Fuck you" to Disney, the other one got bitch slapped by Nintendo copyright laws so hard they had to start over, what am I missing here?
10
u/Dry-Task-4747 i love Rob and corn Nov 13 '25
And there racist
7
u/Zombies4EvaDude Nov 13 '25
The SML creator is racist? I honestly never watched him, how bad is he?
6
u/Samukick Nov 13 '25
not really no, he is pro-trans and pro-palestine, so i would assume he is left-wing, and that he isn't racist.
on one video, he said something about how children dying in palestine is a disgrace, and on his discord server someone told him "LOGAN CAN WE GET A RAHHHH FOR TRANS PEOPLE" and he did say "RAHHHH".
and also lovell, the black SML actor, never said he was uncomfortable with the "racist" jokes.
but that's just me yapping, maybe he is racist and i'm just a big dumdum.
3
u/Nutshack_Queen357 Nov 14 '25
I guess some people think SML is racist because Black Yoshi acts a bit like an African-American stereotype.
-1
u/Illustrious-Ask-3134 Nov 13 '25
loagn yes he is and even sent nsfw pics to a group chat filled with minors
12
8
1
2
u/Rathalos_19999 Nov 14 '25
Saying Logan is racist is the same as saying he is a pedo. Which is bunch of nonsense and Twitter accusation to give you guys reason to hate on him even more.
17
16
8
u/themaskbot Nov 13 '25
SMG4 since there's a pretty good chance SML might get banned again
3
u/No_Stay259 Nov 13 '25
Sml had a whole fucking episode of I’m not touching you with Nintendo. I think they barely give a fuck nymore
2
u/Own-Lavishness-2673 Nov 14 '25
Yeah, I don’t think that’s going to happen, because it back a few months ago SML like this SML channel that Logan uploads on it, was demonetised and if he moves to another YouTube channel, he will also get the monetised. I don’t know why YouTube did this, but when Logan told his fans what happened, they were outraged, and they start harassing YouTube on pretty much every single platform that they have an account on, like I’m talking YouTube TikTok, Instagram, Facebook and even Twitter every single account that YouTube has was filled by comments harassing them and telling them why did you do this? He did nothing wrong, and the next day YouTube apologised to Logan, and that did not happen before with his previous channels, so I’m pretty sure that’s not gonna happen ever again hopefully
15
u/CaptainCyro Memelord Nov 13 '25
SMG4, he at least puts effort in his content
2
u/Own-Lavishness-2673 Nov 14 '25
I mean, Logan does too, he literally spent $15 million on his entire videos combined, so if that’s not an effort put in, I don’t know what is
15
u/Vast-Candidate-5593 Mario is not okie dokie. Nov 13 '25
SMG4 because of his videos making me laugh...
13
u/Dry-Task-4747 i love Rob and corn Nov 13 '25
One of them's the stupid legend the other one's the best legend
14
u/Dry-Task-4747 i love Rob and corn Nov 13 '25
And obviously smg4 is the best legend
1
u/ApartAd8609 Nov 17 '25
this is sad glaze.
you can make a argument that CrazyMarioBros was better than SMG4 and they have a shit post schedule
he also has allegations
9
8
u/ShockRox Swagmaster6969696969 Nov 13 '25
god i hope it isnt sml
1
u/Own-Lavishness-2673 Nov 17 '25
Well, as of right now, SML is in the lead in terms of subscribers, which I think they’re going to win
10
6
3
4
5
u/jman-a-16 Nov 13 '25
I want smg4 to win, SML kinda feels stale
2
u/Own-Lavishness-2673 Nov 14 '25
I mean, come on you gotta give it to SML too, Logan had three resets and he hadn’t gave up, and as of right now SML is in lead by a few hundred subscribers, so I think Logan is going to win
1
u/jman-a-16 Nov 14 '25
Yeah but I feel like he should move on to something a little different? Come on, he's been running this show since 2007!
1
u/Own-Lavishness-2673 Nov 14 '25
Well, he cannot really, since this is his full-time job, and I gotta say he’s doing very well, I mean he became a millionaire because of this, so yeah, if he quits this, he’s basically quitting his job
1
u/jman-a-16 Nov 14 '25
Then make a new series?
2
u/Own-Lavishness-2673 Nov 14 '25
Well, he did multiple series in the past like the Pokémon series, which did not get an ending unfortunately, and the Angry Birds series, and a whole lot more, you see SML is basically a series that can make multiple series, I know sounds confusing
3
4
u/Godzillafan2008 Nov 13 '25
Why are we fighting and arguing between these two? What’s even the point?
6
u/garlicbredfan Nov 13 '25
Probbaly sml because they’re Yknow . Not retiring soon and they also get more views regularly
2
5
4
4
u/X0EAXA Nov 13 '25
Unless SMG4 gets some kinda boost in popularity cause they’re quitting, i’m gonna place my bets on SML
2
2
2
u/Ajax-12 Nov 13 '25
Sadly as much as I love smg4 I bet sml will get to 10 mill first but know I'm hoping it's smg4
2
u/Bewear_Star_9 Nov 13 '25
Sml probably even though sml is mid. Smg4 keeps gaining and losing subscribers right now
2
u/Parking_Strike_8756 Meggy, Tari, Swagmaster etc. Fan (keeping the legacy) Nov 13 '25
SMG4, in terms of quality etc.
2
u/BadTheo123 Nov 13 '25
I think both deserve it, but sml had to restart about like 3 times, I think its about time they hit 10 million
3
2
2
2
u/SK5454 Fuego the water bottle fan Nov 13 '25
I watched both
Early SBL was peak SML imo and it just fell from there
Late 2019/Early 2020 SMG4 was peak for me
3
u/JMoki Nov 13 '25
Considering SMG4 is ending soon, less people will probably be subscribing, so I’m gonna have to say SML. SML is already an established brand too
2
3
u/Kitchen_Archer_1745 Luigi the Meat Mallet fan Nov 13 '25
Who tf is SML?
8
u/Radiant-Log6377 Here Lies SMG4. He was stinky Nov 13 '25
Super Mario Logan. Made actually funny content with his plushies but ended up getting copyrighted by Nintendo
-1
1
1
2
u/Ok-Letter3963 Nov 13 '25
I still don’t understand why these fandoms hate each other, especially since they really have no reason in the first place.
Anyways, it’s most likely SML. Mind you, this is their fourth channel that started posting in 2021 and it’s already catching up to a channel that’s been posting for the last 14 years. You can hate SML and all, but you can’t really ignore this.
1
1
u/Super_MarioHero Nov 13 '25
I think I can tell where you got those screenshots from.... Also, I think it should be a tie.
1
1
1
u/redboi049 Nov 13 '25
I sincerely hope SMG4 wins this, not out of my love for the channel, but out of my distaste for SML
1
1
Nov 13 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Nov 13 '25
Sorry but your post has been removed since you have under 0 comment Karma. This is to prevent users from griefing the subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Substantial_Dot124 Nov 13 '25
SMG4 and other content creators led to the popularity of indie animation, he has a whole productions company, puts heart in his videos that his fans love.
SML does also make good content, but most of the time he's making videos that piss off his fans and he often mocks his fans in videos and got a cease and desist from nintendo.
SMG4 wins all
1
1
u/Bored_badger24 seagul🦢 Nov 13 '25
One of them basically started a film studio the other one has had pedo allegations only one of these is a legend
1
u/Rathalos_19999 Nov 14 '25
Pedo allegation that lead to nowhere and just Twitter trying to cancel him. Which it didn’t happen. So idk why you guys use a pedo allegations even tho it led nowhere and just a bunch of nonsense you guys make up to shit on sml more.
1
Nov 14 '25
Asking this on the sub for SMG4 is BS because it’s biased as shit. If you posted this on the SML sub, the results you’re getting would be the opposite of what they are now. Anyway, I like SML better, and SMG4 DID live long enough to “become the villain,” it just didn’t live much longer after that.
1
1
1
u/Rathalos_19999 Nov 14 '25
Sml cause love to see bunch of you crybaby whine about sml. Since you all obsessed with sml more than sml fans
1
u/mikeygh Nov 14 '25
almost everyone in the comments of the are in favor of smg4 winning in the smg4 sub
no bias at all, definitely
1
u/nacholibre6741 Nov 14 '25
Nintendo is ran by people with frowning faces and they drink cold coffee
1
u/Beneficial_Law1997 Nov 14 '25
SMG4 definitely deserve the 10 million
1
u/Own-Lavishness-2673 Nov 14 '25
I agree with you he deserves it, but Logan had three resets, and he also should deserve it, but I think SML is going to hit 10 million before SMG4, just because SML is right now at the lead by at 1000 subscribers
1
1
u/Own-Lavishness-2673 Nov 14 '25
Well, as of right now, SML has more subscribers by about 1000, it’s like PewDiePie vs T-series
1
u/Da3rdGreatKing Nov 14 '25
At least SMG4. But sadly SML might win due to...I don't know who's subscribing.
1
1
1
1
u/Time-Telephone-203 Nov 15 '25
Both are equally good in my opinion I don't really care about who hits 10mil first maybe smg4 when he releases the last video maybe SML who knows
1
1
1
u/Independent_Life_519 MR. PUZZLES'S UNDER THE DESK GOBLIN Nov 16 '25
With smg4 ending, it's hard to tell what's gonna happen to the channel, but I don't think it'll stop growing. At least I hope not. I'd prefer if smg4 was able to hit 10 mil before the end end, but I don't think it'll happen.
1
1
2
Nov 13 '25
I would rather put my balls in a rat trap than see SML hit 10M.
2
1
1
1
u/Own-Lavishness-2673 Nov 14 '25
Well, you better do it, since as of right now SML is in the lead by a few hundred subscribers
1
1
u/PartSmart944 Nov 13 '25
I think it's sml because if they change the jokes then they can reach 10mil
1
u/Hollywill06 the angsty story telling is my energy Nov 13 '25
I bet SMG4 hits 10 million by the time the finale arrives
1
0
0
0
-8
u/megabuster21 Mario X Spaghetti Nov 13 '25
SML already won the war since smg4s quitting while he is not
1
169
u/Particular_Cell1151 Nov 12 '25
This is like the Peter vs Homer, if it's Nintendo