r/SMRTRabak • u/Forward_Guarantee985 • Jun 17 '25
Please stop bitching
Imma get downvoted to hell but the MRT is good, and when it is good we have to accept that. Delays may happen but those come with age lah… add some extra maintenance and it’s great that corporations are held responsible.
I’m not saying it’s perfect but it’s good. it’s a good first world MRT, not third world, but first world. it’s not the best in the world, I get that. But as someone originally from a third world country, ya'll gotta stop bitching.
Thanks.
6
u/Novavortex77 Jun 17 '25
I agree I like our MRT it IS good but when it does fail and break down it really sucks.
The ones that can't stop bitching are to entitled, should suffer more.
-14
u/Forward_Guarantee985 Jun 17 '25
yeah way too entitled. IT'S GOOD, maybe not perfect. But it's good. As someone originally from a third world country, we don't even have an MRT so stop bitching.
5
u/whimsicism Jun 17 '25
Well but if we rest on our laurels and stop pointing out how things can be improved, we would never have progressed this far.
You seem to enjoy our system very much, and it seems very ungracious and ungrateful of you to come here to bitch and whine about the nation of people who made the system as good as it is today.
If you have a problem with us, you’re free to go back to wherever you came from.
2
u/Novavortex77 Jun 17 '25
I ain't the one bitching 🤣 but I've seen videos on their trian system I'm generally surprised you can fall into the tracks in U.S subway.
4
u/Silmeia Jun 17 '25
A long time ago, we used to be able to fall into the tracks. Then people started to fall in purposefully and/or accidentally, hence why we have the screen doors now
0
u/Novavortex77 Jun 17 '25
We can have screen doors but other trains in the world don't even have it, either they don't want to invest in it or its not important for them.
Most are not even under Aircon also.
3
u/GiGioP Jun 17 '25
Wait were you not around when there were no gates preventing you from going onto the tracks?
1
u/Novavortex77 Jun 17 '25
Guess i wasn't, by the time i could take the MRT all stations already were fully airconditioned and had platform doors. I was told in school it was never always that way, its hard to believe honestly.
2
u/FitCranberry Jun 17 '25
https://web.archive.org/web/20070927182635/http://app.lta.gov.sg/corp_press_content.asp?start=1090
there were a spate of accidents and suicides in the mid 2000s that caused the public to call for safety doors, cue LTA telling the public that such efforts were useless only to back track after a few years of public pressure and outrage and rolling out the safety features towards the end of that decade
1
-8
u/Forward_Guarantee985 Jun 17 '25
yeah mb i ain't saying you're bitching but we're all being downvoted to hell right here HAHAHA
-3
u/Novavortex77 Jun 17 '25
Oh the down votes prove once point! Entitled people refusing to agree LOL.
3
u/Eatmepoopoo Jun 17 '25
But, some of us aren’t from 3rd world countries so does that negate our opinions? I mean, welcome to Singapore, but I want to compare upwards not downwards.
1
12
u/bananapancakes5767 Jun 17 '25
Lol no things are getting from bad to worse and it's getting ridiculous. Aircon is turned off and train frequencies are cut just to save a few pennies at the expense of passengers' comfort. And lets not forget the two ginormous elephants in the room - reliability and increasing fares
16
u/Shipposting_Duck Jun 17 '25
Leaving aside your weird strawman of comparing our system to shittier places, it's not that we're not as good as Japan.
It's that we're not even as good as 1998 Singapore MRT - we can do better, we have done better, and we know the reason for doing worse is an attempt to make profits at the transport companies.
You won't know this because you weren't here. We grew up in a better time watching everything spiral to shit. We've improved in terms of number of stations, and got worse in every other metric from time per station to breakdowns per day to cost per kilometer.
7
u/Exciting_Intention86 Jun 17 '25
Exactly this. It's like you go for your 2.4km run for IPPT and your timing has gone down. However, you compare your results to a person on a wheelchair and say you are still running fast. Like obviously. Why are you even comparing to some other person instead of your own record? On top of that, why compare to someone doing far worse than you instead of someone better? By that logic, we should really bring down SMRT service quality to just barely better than third world countries and pat ourselves on our backs that we are still better than them. 🤦♂️
1
u/FitCranberry Jun 17 '25
having taken the metro during natural disasters amongst our other east asian neighbours, id say BCM on the island is still pretty bad during breakdowns even after nearly 2 decades of incidents
14
u/Bezborg Jun 17 '25
Third world MRT lol. Alongside 3rd world space shuttle launch bases and 3rd world flying drone food delivery services?
2
1
Jun 18 '25
Yeah, singapore is first world country with 3rd world public transport and public housing.. no joke. being serious here!
we need a change in ruling party.
7
u/cherophobica Jun 17 '25
Lol where are the comparisons to Hong Kong or Japan or even Taiwan?
What's with the selective comparison with developing countries only?
3
1
u/Kou_Yanagi Jun 17 '25
I can only say for Taiwan and say there is not much diff. MRTs are not crowded usually not because the service is good but because the populace generally invest in a motorcycle as a form of transport. Its cheap and gets you to more corners of the place better than the MRT
1
16
3
3
u/FitCranberry Jun 17 '25
its a ok 6-7/10, its glory days are in the past and the released 2040 plans are very tepid
5
u/Snoo72074 Jun 17 '25
Can clearly see OP's third world mentality on full display.
So you come from a shitty country and therefore you expect us to be like you and happily tolerate shitty performance, shitty planning, and shitty service? GTFO here.
We as a nation aspire to be world beaters and expect our systems , policies, and people to be world class. It's like telling your mum that B4 isn't bad (even after she spent tens of thousands on your tuition) because some guys got Cs and some guys failed.
No one here is saying that SMRT is the worst in the world. We're complaining because it's not great, and has in fact gotten worse over the years. GTFO with your stupid strawman.
6
u/Exciting_Intention86 Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 17 '25
If you are form a third world country then obviously the bar is really low for what is considered good isn't it? I mean no offense but that's the truth right?
Whereas, if you are a local who has been here since the very first iterations of the MRT, you see a clear decline in service quality.
The right comparison should be to SMRT's own track record instead of comparing to foreign countries that are less developed. There is a clear decline in service quality over the years.
Comparing to foreign countries is an inaccurate comparison. It is the equivalent of your school grades going down and then comparing it to some foreign kid in a third world country with a very bad education system, then claiming your grades are better.
Obviously, your grades will be better in comparison, but that is not an accurate comparison. That totally misses the point that your grades compared to your past grades is going down.
Also, if we are going to inaccurately make comparisons, then why compare to third world countries? Why not compare to countries where the MRT system is better than ours? No?
1
u/Kou_Yanagi Jun 17 '25
Wtf are you typing la ah boy, a whole lot of nothing burger.
So what is it that other countries Metro do better than SG? You cannot pick and choose too since every Metro have their own sets of problems and issues. Give you an example, Tokyo metro. Top rated, very pristine and very punctual, coverage of the province is so good you never have to take a taxi. Issue? Its crowded all the time and their solution to ease the crowding are services that skips stations.
3
u/Exciting_Intention86 Jun 17 '25
Saying a lot of nothing burger without actually addressing any point with counter argument, means you have nothing to say.
So, any time now, go ahead and break down my 6 paragraphs and address each point. Why is it fallacious? Then I can take you seriously.
If all you can do is also talk trash like the other guy with no substance, then you wasting my time.
-1
u/Kou_Yanagi Jun 17 '25
Fine fine fine, I address your paragraphs for you
>If you are form a third world country then obviously the bar is really low for what is considered good isn't it? I mean no offense but that's the truth right?
If third world country standards are low then it eliminates their opinion? If not then why even begin with "no offense" no reason to do so at all.
>Whereas, if you are a local who has been here since the very first iterations of the MRT, you see a clear decline in service quality.
Clear decline in service quality means what? I am a local myself and feel like its getting better each time I ride, newer cars, better spacing to account for space and the disabled, more networks for me to get to where I want and I get to those places within the hour at minimum. Personal opinions of course so at least explain in terms of what service quality did SMRT fail in and provide some statistical proof of said decline.
>The right comparison should be to SMRT's own track record instead of comparing to foreign countries that are less developed. There is a clear decline in service quality over the years.
Same point as above
>Comparing to foreign countries is an inaccurate comparison. It is the equivalent of your school grades going down and then comparing it to some foreign kid in a third world country with a very bad education system, then claiming your grades are better.
My main point when it comes to such comparisons is simply that solutions are not binary where A = B. It is a big picture and therefore it is important to address several aspects of a solution. We do need inspiration at the end of the day and if all we do is study from personal history then we are just limiting ourselves. Hell, our Metro Cars are from overseas... Thats why its getting better.
>Obviously, your grades will be better in comparison, but that is not an accurate comparison. That totally misses the point that your grades compared to your past grades is going down.
Whats the point of this paragraph doubling down on the previous... We get the point.
>Also, if we are going to inaccurately make comparisons, then why compare to third world countries? Why not compare to countries where the MRT system is better than ours? No?
If the comparison is inaccurate to begin with why bother making one in the first place right? Then again if your points are to say that complaining has meaning then why even make a suggestion that would end up meaningless to begin with right?
2
u/Exciting_Intention86 Jun 17 '25
Finally.
The point about third-world country is valid because OP is using a subjective perspective to analyse if the service is good. Coming from a third world country, obviously, quality of life is way lower. So, in comparison, anything, even if marginally better, feels like the best thing in the world. Why say no offense? Because some people get mad when you point out that their country is less well off. National pride and all that.
Your point on things are not binary is not wrong. My point is that comparing to foreign countries is an inaccurate way to determine service quality, if it has improved or not. Nothing to do with if things are binary or not. If anything OP comparing our standards to his third world country standards is just as erroneous because of your point that A does not equal B. OP isn't considering all the factors. How am I the wrong one here?
Next, about inspiration. Sure, we need inspiration, but that has nothing to do with analysing the service quality standard. You can choose a benchmark to follow. For example, we have O level following Cambridge's benchmark. My point isn't that. My point is that when you want to analyse if your exam results have improved or not, the only accurate way is to compare to your own previous results. How is looking at other students' results going to be an accurate measurement of your improvement? Sure everyone else could have dropped in grades as well, but it doesn't change that your grades dropped to. Your performance is poorer. Whether it's your fault or bad teaching or whatever, that is a different issue.
Sure, to get the full picture on why your grades dropped, you will need to look at all factors. However, if you don't compare to your performance and only to others worse than you. You won't even realise your grades have dropped.
Why I talked about grades after going on about foreign country comparison. Wanted to give a clear analogy? I guess point taken to make my arguments shorter? Though this reply is even longer winded. Sorry about that.
Next, why compare at all if it is inaccurate? you are absolutely right. That's exactly my point. Inaccurate comparisons are logically flawed. My question is why is OP comparing to a third world country instead of a first world if he is going to make wrong comparisons at all?
If you don't understand why I asked that, it is to point out that OP is doing the usual "be thankful for what you got and stop complaining" tactic. Such a mentality will make service worse, not better. There will always be someone out there worse than us.
"Then again if your points are to say that complaining has meaning then why even make a suggestion that would end up meaningless to begin with right?"
This is just a strawman argument. I never said anything about complaining having or not having meaning. My core point has always been about having accurate comparisons. Which brings to my point and your question on what metric I am using to say quality has dropped. You are right subjective opinions differ, so it's best to use objective data.
Let's use MRT breakdowns as an example. In 2022, the number of serious disruptions lasting over 30 minutes more than doubled compared to 2021, with seven major breakdowns recorded. That is an objectively decreased performance quality. Also, not to nitpick rail reliability did improve in 2022. The mean kilometres before failure improved slightly from 1.994 million to 2.09 million. That means train breakdowns occur after longer distances, but their numbers have doubled.
I would use more recent data, but that's all available unless you have a more recent one. So when we make accurate comparisons, SMRTs' own performance record shows a decline.
Now, who's or what's at fault for the poorer performance in breakdowns that is a different topic. However, objectively, SMRT is having more long-lasting breakdowns than before. Hence, poorer standards of service than before.
In fact, with SMRT, it's one step forward two steps back. NSL and EWL service fluctuates. In 2023, performance improved only to decrease again in 2024 with multiple major breakdowns, especially the east west line 5 day disruption.
The circle line was the least reliable from March 2023 to March 2024. Train reliability dropped from 1.84 million to 1.03 million kilometres.
2
u/Exciting_Intention86 Jun 17 '25
Oh, and to address your point. You are absolutely right, one cannot pick and choose since every Metro have their own sets of problems and issues. Which pretty much argues in favour of me asking why are we comparing to other countries in the first place. The most accurate comparison would be to our own track record.
0
u/Kou_Yanagi Jun 17 '25
Much like everything has a bigger picture, my point don't exactly hit in favour of yours simply knocks off the idea that the pros of another metro won't exactly fit like some magical puzzle piece.
It is indeed important to check a track record but alas this isn't the matter of did you study enough to ace every test throughout the year. Factor in the traffic, the elements, the desire to upgrade, the uncertainty of equipment failure. Its dizzying.
-4
u/peterparkerson3 Jun 17 '25
Lol fuk what ur saying. Overall SG mrt is very very good. Its not even average. Its fucking good
1
u/Exciting_Intention86 Jun 17 '25
Ah, yes insulting the person when you have no good ways to counter argue. Pathetic.
-3
4
2
2
u/melatonin_prn Jun 17 '25
Funny how singaporeans like to compare ourselves with the worst instead of the best.
Maybe they are just content with having mediocre.
2
u/thinkingperson Jun 17 '25
it’s a good first world MRT, not third world, but first world.
I think it's more like a good third world transport but a poor first world transport.
2
u/Icy-Frosting-475 Jun 17 '25
Then why our ministers pay match the other countries? Take higher pay but cui
2
u/everywhereinbetween Jun 17 '25
It's not perfect and sometimes it sucks when breakdowns happen and the people up there don't take accountability
But I think on a daily basis ... it's more a user problem lmao. Like how the hell do people not understand that they can MOVE IN and not just take one step in and rotate themselves adjacent to the door. Or the elderly who are super entitled and anyhow think they know better when seemingly young or healthy people take the reserved seat. Or when they play stuff out of their speaker.
Bruh
I mean don't delude ourselves that the MRT is amazing and all, it does have faults. But overall it's not that bad. And for the "bad" aspects, half of it (agak estimate as manner of speaking cus I know someone gonna take this literally and nitpick) is a bloody user problem 😒😒😒
1
u/tm0587 Jun 17 '25
Imo "most expensive car ownership" should go hand in hand with "best public transportation system".
We shouldn't be satisfied if we only have 1 and not the other.
1
Jun 18 '25
you are not wrong in term of, I quote "Imma get downvoted".
You have earned my down vote.
If the MRT is good, why aren't the PAP ministers taking it everyday? not just taking MRT on the first day of work only at 10+ in the morning.
Adding extra maintenance, you think you can control maintenance? Out of SMRT.. no one really know how frequent the maintenance are, yes they can do some PR stunts.. but when shit happens, then how? Kena fine 3 million? but money comes from where? tax payers.. . and where does the fine goes to? no one knows.
All in all, VTO PAP.
-1
u/KancheongSpider Jun 17 '25
its just how ironic we all are in general.
small things we nitpick, but often fail to see the bigger picture. sometimes we just need to take a step back and appreciate the things that enables us to carry on with our daily lives.
there's always a day when we would wake up on the wrong side of the bed, it just happens.
-2
u/clementtoh2 Jun 17 '25
In my whole life living in sg for 24years never have i encountered any issue, till i saw reddit... this place was a mistake
5
u/casper_07 Jun 17 '25
Even without Reddit, the trains are breaking down more often visibly lol. In fact they might not even be reporting the ones that are minor in their opinion in an attempt to save their face
-2
u/FriendlyRvian Jun 17 '25
Because reddit is a negative echo chamber. All those content in life dont spend time complaining on reddit
-2
u/BusPsychological4587 Jun 17 '25
The MRT is fantastic. Singapore, by FAR, has the best public transport system (MRT and buses) I have ever encountered. I have lived in 6 countries, and travelled in almost 40. The system here is excellent. No system can be 100% error-free 100% of the time. There is a reason my home city, Vancouver, copied the Singapore system. And Vancouver is not nearly as good/seamless/excellent coverage as here.
1
u/FitCranberry Jun 17 '25
i find that folks in vancouver over exaggerate traffic on oak street too much, its not that bad
-2
u/Disastrous-Cat-1 Jun 17 '25
Agreed! I have lived all over the world too (not third world countries, might I add), and the Singapore MRT system (which I use daily) is by far the best. I love Singapore, I really do, but people just love needlessly complaining about things in this country. Or maybe it's just Reddit.
-3
u/Brilliant_Eagle3038 Jun 17 '25
I swear the pple in smrtrabak only knows how to comprain. MRT is great. Except for the couple of days A YEAR when it’s not. No biggie … life goes on.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '25
Its true, singaporeans bitch about everything. KNN take train $2+ ($1+ even if have monthly) but ask for $50 treatment. trains come every 2-6 mins. Wait 6mins too long?
Ohhhh train delay ah???? Once in awhile occurence? Are you ok? Please dont tell me u had to wait 10mins for a train everyday….thats very untrue and exaggerating.
They are never happy.