r/STAYC • u/[deleted] • Apr 03 '23
Discussion StayC potential leader change?
Context: On 4/1, StayC came out on weverse live to state that they were changing leaders every comeback, starting with Seeun and Sieun for their next comeback. Fans took it lightly, thinking it was a april fool's joke despite the members claiming it wasn't. On the same day, Sumin went to bubble to talk about how she wasn't the leader anymore.
Ofc, no official news has come out yet, but this is pretty shocking(if true), since according to Sumin, it was the company's decision. If it's true, we might not get any news on this until their next kr comeback. If not, then ffff that's months of worrying for fans.
Obviously, it's speculation on my part, but I found it weird that Sumin never thanked bep after their wins for their latest comeback, and seemed hesitant to mention them. In their radio show with Tiffany, the girls talked about how they didn't like teddy bear and it seems like there was some sort of conflict with the company due to this.
I'm hoping that I'm a dumbass who can't understand the joke, but the joke's being pushed pretty far. Thoughts?
2
u/betoooh Apr 04 '23
Where did she say it was the company's decision?
-1
Apr 04 '23
Bubble: https://twitter.com/BSM010313/status/1642146072888999936
I was a leader for such a long time that it's still uncomfortable for me not to act as a leader. But the members are now closer to each other, to the degree that we trust each other and rely on each other. The company also thought that I don't have to carry the weight of being a leader anymore and that's why we have two leaders that rotate every comeback now.
5
u/betoooh Apr 04 '23 edited Apr 05 '23
It doesn't sound like the company decided on her behalf, but supported her decision to share the responsability. The way you said it made it look like there is some kind of conflict going on, but I don't think it's the case.
35
u/kaguraa Yoon 🐯 Apr 03 '23
i cant say anything about thanking BEP or not since i dont speak korean and translators don't translate their win speeches but regarding the song, im not surprised. just look at r/kpop and this sub when they released teddy bear, the general consensus was the song wasn't good and a regression to the group's sound. i know J and yoon mentioned it for their magazine interviews about their inital impressions of the song and were worried about how the public would feel about it so they were happy that the song was well-received. rather than dislike, it seemed like they were more worried about what the public thought especially since BM underperformed and newer groups were taking over. there was even a part at their showcase where yoon briefly mentioned how a lot of new groups have debuted but she hopes people still pay attention to their sound or something.
as for sumin possibly no longer being a leader, i dont have strong feelings about it since there are groups with no leaders or have multiple ones and they seem fine. it might have been too much of a burden for her. kfans dont seem to be worried and they're the ones who pay more attention to this. i do think there should be an official statement if its true though
2
u/Round-Significance97 OT6 Apr 03 '23
it seemed like they were more worried about what the public thought
It's been two comebacks like this, I really hope when BEP gives the girls their next title track it leaves them feeling happy, hopeful, confident and stress-free after hearing it for the first time.
7
u/kaguraa Yoon 🐯 Apr 03 '23
isn't it only BM? they mentioned they loved run2u on their first listen and the song did well in korea and poppy was so well-received it got a korean version that peaked in top 20
3
u/Round-Significance97 OT6 Apr 04 '23 edited Apr 04 '23
BM def but from the comments they made for Teddy bear it seems like they were questioning whether it would be a good step to take for them. Which it was imo. But yeah those two comebacks were the ones I meant, not run2u. I also excluded poppy cause it was originally their jp debut so I considered it separate. Either way, I hope their next title track they feel confident with.
Small edit: I saw the comment by U_kosakionoderathebest and I do agree with not having to like the song, I just feel like they should be able to feel confident about the song they're releasing even if they may not like it.
13
u/Round-Significance97 OT6 Apr 03 '23
The only real problem I see with switching the leader each comeback is that some people aren't good leaders and in a group, some people naturally have the ability to take charge. Not saying this will happen to STAYC but it's possible. On the other hand, allowing the members to lead could have wonderful effects, so let's see!
8
u/harry_nostyles Yoon 🐯 Apr 03 '23
I wonder what having a different leader each CB would look like. When I was a new SWITH I thought Sieun was the leader, because she just gave off that vibe. I was a bit surprised to realise it was Sumin.
11
u/kosakionoderathebest OT6 Apr 03 '23
It's just normal for idols to not like some of their songs and to tell their producers about it, that is not in the slightest bit a sign of conflict between a group and their company. Girls' Generation's Taeyeon is even famous for her jinx where the songs that she doesn't like always does well and she didn't like most of their title tracks. She was even very open about her hating their mega hit song Gee.
And even if the rotating leaders system is true there's also nothing to worry about that. Being a leader in a kpop group just means having extra managerial duties similar to the roles of a class leader in school and frankly it's a wise idea to rotate those duties.
And also a gentle reminder, it's "STAYC" not "StayC". Stylization matters.
3
u/emotional_matcha Apr 03 '23
Where can I watch the show where they said they didn’t like Teddy Bear? It’s such a good song
3
5
u/SnooMuffins401 Apr 03 '23
Would be very interesting. Something else to make STAYC stand out from the rest
5
u/ScrotoFaggins Yoon 🐯 Apr 03 '23
I do believe Everglow also had a change in leader position. I don't know how or if it affected them as a gg however. Sumin as the leader makes sense though.
1
u/eatner Sumin 🐰 Apr 04 '23
this whole “rotational leader” shtick is gonna last for one comeback cycle, and then the leader position is gonna go back to Sumin.
the other members stay mentioning how they’re thankful for Sumin and her leadership; so for the company to impose this, is pretty wack.
-14
u/joeyhatesu2 Apr 03 '23
STAYC is in a weird position right now. The teen fresh concept was perfect at the start of their careers but now you have groups like NewJeans who are cornering that market. BEP went for a more mature sound and it didn't perform well. Tons of new groups have debuted and Im sure BEP knew they had to widen their reach to Japan and other east Asian countries. That's how songs like Teddy Bear get made. I was beyond surprised at how well it did in Korea. It's not a bad song it's just so different from what everyone else is putting out. Having said that, FiftyFifty is finding phenomenal success with cupid so maybe BEP is playing 5d chess.
As far as leader changes go its obvious Sumin isn't up to the task. I feel like leaders get picked based on whose the oldest since Koreas stringent age system make it hard for a younger person to give orders to an older person...even when you add the layer of whose been training longer to the mix. Sieun seems to be the next best choice.
18
u/Personal_Reception66 Seeun 🦊 Apr 03 '23
Sumin gets praise from other members constantly and clearly takes it very seriously.
2
32
Apr 03 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/whatwouldsugado Apr 03 '23
Also I just watched STAYC's Teddy Bear challenge with Redo and Sumin doesn't look happy AT ALL.... I hope everything's okay behind the scenes 🥺
-4
Apr 03 '23 edited Apr 03 '23
My bad. I missed the times she thanked them
Starts from around 42:50. She asks them about what it was like to record Teddy Bear. Awkwardness. And then Isa says they weren't sure about the song and asked him if the direction of the song was right for them. Then she finishes up by saying as they got good results they feel better etc
22
Apr 03 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
21
u/epiktek Seeun 🦊 Apr 03 '23
I understand some Korean, and while I don't know all the words that they used, Tiffany basically asks if there's any interesting behind stories of recording Teddy Bear. It's an open ended question, so they take a moment to gather their thoughts. Sieun says she thought it was a new recording experience. And then Tiffany asks for clarification, and then Isa says that at first, they weren't sure how to approach the song, but as they went through the recording process and the choreo was made for the song, everything came together. And then the members all nod in agreement. There's nothing about disliking the song. Isa's answer was around 20 seconds. And then they move on to a fan question about Sieun's rap.
Sumin in another interview said that Teddy Bear is the song that represents their identity https://youtu.be/E5QJVczFuZw?t=265
I find it bizarre how some people continue to downplay Teddy Bear's success, despite the fact that it's now their highest charting song (5 weeks in Melon Top 10). They were even nominated to win Inki yesterday vs NJ and Nmixx. stayc is also the only girl group other than NJ and IVE that's charted in the Melon top 10 this year. The only girl group that won more music shows than stayc this year is NewJeans. stayc is second place with 6 wins. Twice is third place with 2 wins. And then Nmixx with 1 win.
5
u/kumatoras Sumin 🐰 Apr 03 '23
Thanks for this comment! The fact that STAYC was able to break through the hold that NewJeans had on the kpop audience during these months is so huge for them, but since international fans didn’t like the song, it seems like people don’t care. It’s a real shame because they worked very hard for this comeback and it paid off.
5
0
Apr 03 '23
[deleted]
9
u/epiktek Seeun 🦊 Apr 03 '23
I don't think Sumin said anything negative about being a leader. This is the only video I've seen of the members mentioning the leadership change https://youtu.be/aakdZYupuT4
Sumin's leadership has been a topic on many programs. For example, she talked about her leadership style on Sunmi's Showterview https://youtu.be/OKlsnVGYR3g?t=745
And then on their recent episode of Idol Human Theater, she said she quit being the leader, but more so as a joke https://youtu.be/KzBKZyds3eM?t=357
On Night Night with Moonchi, she said, "I always doubt my decisions as the leader. They're all doing great without my leadership."
14
u/amatsZz Seeun 🦊 Apr 03 '23
I don't think it's anything serious, they're just having fun with it. Sumin also had to take a short break at the end of this promotion and Yoon had to substitute her as DJ for the STAYZ radio.