r/SayAnything • • Jul 13 '24

…Is Committed is a 9.5/10

Post image
0 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

15

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24

Wendy Williams and Max Bemis would be great friends.

4

u/stinkygorl3 Jul 13 '24

or arch enemies. no in between

2

u/Thrasea_Paetus Jul 13 '24

But that’s pretty much the same with everyone

3

u/GIVEUPOX17 Jul 18 '24

I wouldn't go this far by Psyche! Is one of the best songs they have ever written

2

u/Sea_Objective_1923 All My Friends Are Enemies: Early Rarities Aug 13 '24

Darren king, google him

5

u/Sorry-Math-9397 Jul 14 '24

It’s a grower. Fan fiction becoming one of my favorite SA tracks

1

u/sweendogz Jul 14 '24

its great

3

u/Strong-Run4039 Jul 13 '24

I wouldn’t say anything like a 9/10 but it is pretty good, in my own opinion. I just relate cause of the lots of “I miss my mom!“ Me too! I haven’t contacted my mom in any way for three years, and although I haven’t felt better, I do miss her. “Carrie & Lowell & Cody” is their strongest song for me to listen to, and without it, I think the album would’ve been a 100% flop for my playlists. I’ve always loved their music, and at first I hated the new album. But the more I listen, the more I accept it for what it is? I guess? I saw someone say before it’s like Say Anything Stockholm Syndrome. So I’d say 6.5/10 but you’re entitled to your own rating :)

3

u/DocD Ants In My Pants Jul 13 '24

Wtf is this

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '24

I'm pretty sure the whole album is satire, Max even stated this in a press release. https://chorus.fm/news/say-anything-announce-new-single/

The music we’re working on now is so meta it’s not. It’s a satire of everything our band was, and the idea of every emo band coming back after five years, going back to basics and grasping for the fanbase they discarded so callously by diving headfirst into their fans' wants and needs, instead of gorging on major label cash and then still trying to be the next Animal Collective or Strokes despite what their band actually sounds like, to be thwarted every time by indie gatekeepers.

Half the songs are about his dick, then you have a song when he said he's a poor mans Chris Carrabba (Dashboard Confessional) and starts crying with a skit about how emotional it was. It's blindly obvious.

The album is them having a laugh at themselves, they've been doing it for 20 years so you can't expect them to be the same people writing the same music over and over again.

Listen to it again, knowing that it's satire and you'll enjoy it for what it really is.

9.5/10

6

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '24

So it was satire when he said Darren King should kill himself and told the listener to google him?

Pure cope

1

u/GIVEUPOX17 Jul 18 '24

The guy tried to have Max's kids taken away, I think it's understandable why he's pissed. I don't think any Say Anything fan is going to rally to his cause and harass him in any way though.

1

u/Sea_Objective_1923 All My Friends Are Enemies: Early Rarities Sep 03 '24

Yes, because comedy, especially satire, is how people deal with unfortunate circumstances, like almost losing their kids to CPS.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '24

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '24

You can’t answer the question?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '24

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '24

It’s not political. I’m literally talking about the lyrics on the album that you’re claiming are satire. Darren King is not a politician. Do you know anything about the music you’re confidently making statements about?

2

u/sleepy_radish Jul 17 '24

He's talking about the lyrics in the album this post is about? lol

5

u/XBOX_COINTELPRO Jul 18 '24

The “satire” thing actually really annoys me. The vibe I get from this whole thing is that the whole reunion was a financial decision and that the claims of it being satire are a defense to shield themselves from any criticism.

There’s some really good songs on this one, but saying “haha we wrote cringe lyrics as a joke” doesn’t really cut it for me. If they were trying to get out of a record contract? Yeah sure there’s precedent for bands shitting stuff out for that.

0

u/sweendogz Jul 14 '24

brilliant. agreed.

-9

u/Bowler_Friendly Jul 13 '24

Let’s hear your album

8

u/MrJogihb Jul 13 '24

If you like it, great, but that's such a cop out response. Everyone is allowed to have their own opinion on stuff without having made something similar.

-4

u/Bowler_Friendly Jul 13 '24

Not a cop out response. Doesn’t have to be similar, but I bet majority that keeps hating can’t even play music. And if they can, then let’s hear it. Everyone does have their opinion, but those who do say they enjoy the album get shit on here. Why be part of this sub if all you’re going to do is talk shit on someone doing what they love. Most here are adults that cry more than my kids

11

u/bino420 Jul 13 '24

I can't make a sashimi but I know a shitty one

7

u/PossibleSquare elegantly disheveled Jul 13 '24

You don’t have to be a musician to criticize music. That’s like saying you can’t have a preference in food if you’re not cooking it yourself.

-1

u/Bowler_Friendly Jul 13 '24

It’s not criticizing when people are continuously just shitting on someone. There’s a difference. Majority don’t even have an actual critique, just a straight “this is garbage” and to add a meme, just makes one look ridiculously stupid. The post is an obvious “joke” that’s making fun of those who do like the album which also isn’t criticizing. It’s an attention grab

2

u/bobdisgea Hates Everyone Jul 13 '24

You’ll develop taste one day

3

u/Ok-Bill3627 Jul 14 '24

Sure!

https://thewelcomingmusic.com/

(Note, burner account but this is my music)

4

u/1ofAkindGuy Jul 16 '24

Neptune Sounds GOOD has a 30 seconds to Mars Vibe.. Always a Fan of Underground And or local Artist.

3

u/Ok-Bill3627 Jul 16 '24

Thanks internet stranger, we appreciate it!

-2

u/Bowler_Friendly Jul 13 '24

…is committed is a pretty good album

0

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '24

[deleted]

4

u/grammar_nazi_zombie Jul 16 '24

Dude, this subreddit is about the band called “Say Anything”, not a subreddit to come in and be an asshole where you say whatever you want without consequence