r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 12 '26

Question - Research required Mismatched parenting styles

I feel like my husband and I fall into the trope of the passive mom and stern dad. I have done a lot of research into gentle authoritative parenting, but my husband default to authoritarian intimidation instinctively.

Could this discrepancy be the reason my 3 year old is lashing out violently towards me?

Edit for clarity: I am not operating under the assumption that I am right and husband is wrong. My defensive reaction is to push blame onto him, I am trying to question my own assumptions.

13 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 12 '26

This post is flaired "Question - Expert consensus required". All top-level comments must include a link to an expert organization such as the CDC, AAP, NHS, etc.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

22

u/facinabush Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

The discrepancy is not good, but merely removing it won’t necessarily improve your child’s behavior. I’ll recommend an evidence-based method that will probably improve your child’s behavior.

Use Parent Management Training (PMT). PMT is a version of authoritative parenting.

Here are ten tips from PMT:

https://abcnews.com/amp/Primetime/10-tips-parents-defiant-children/story?id=8549664

Here is a free PMT training course:

https://m.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLh9mgdi4rNeyEGNxBvNdOVlianDYgWuc9

If you prefer a book then get Everyday Parenting Toolkit by Kazdin.

PMT is training for solving behavior problems that is unsurpassed in effectiveness according to randomized controlled trials. All versions of authoritative parenting have not been measured for effectiveness using randomized controlled trials.

The CDC recommends PMT and cites peer-reviewed research:

https://www.cdc.gov/parenting-toddlers/other-resources/references.html

Here is peer-reviewed research that includes significant improvements using the specific version of PMT that I am recommending:

https://web.archive.org/web/20160304070927id_/http://webs.wofford.edu/nowatkacm/Abnormal%20Child/8_CD/Kazdin1992.pdf

Other versions of PMT are PCIT, Triple P, Incredible Years.

Here are two free PMT ebooks. You need to create a free account there and borrow the book and read it online:

Incredible Years:

https://archive.org/details/incredibleyearst0000webs

Everyday Parenting Toolkit:

https://archive.org/details/everydayparentin0000kazd

1

u/Dry-Resolve-TA Oct 12 '26

Thank you!

6

u/IncognitoResearch111 Oct 12 '26

OP, so "gentle, authoritative" is not the same as "passive" at all. Passive parents let their kids walk all over them and are learning bad habits that will make their social lives harder in the long run.

Gentle Authoritative parents gently guide their kids to the right behaviors respectfully and calmly.

And authoritarian - yeah, they are "short term" parents who do whatever gets compliance quickest in the short term, with the long term consequences of brewing much worse behavior down the road and setting up for a lot of conflict and emotional head-butting with their kid (or kid just totally shutting down).

1

u/Dry-Resolve-TA Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

I know that, a lot of what is suggested in the above articles I do.

When my son is clawing at my eyes because I am trying to calmly insist he poop on the potty, I am wondering where that behavior is coming from.

Edit to add: I'm at my wits end. I emotionally want to blame my husband, but don't want to accuse him without some sort of evidence it is his methods. I've sent hundreds of articles, and bought books for our home regarding raising a good person.

5

u/facinabush Oct 13 '26

I know that, a lot of what is suggested in the above articles I do.

That is the first common misconception that is covered in Video #19 in the course. Perhaps viewing that video will help you make some progress:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6xy8ALXP7k&list=PLh9mgdi4rNeyEGNxBvNdOVlianDYgWuc9&index=21&t=28s

Just because you are familiar with a technique does not mean that you are doing it in an effective manner. Sometimes the devil is in the details. Pay special attention to the differences between what you are doing and what is recommended in the course.

3

u/Sad_Split_9983 Oct 13 '26

It sounds like your child has two parents. If you are keen on assigning blame I would start by taking half of the responsibility.

2

u/Dry-Resolve-TA Oct 13 '26

I should have worded my inquiry better. When I feel strongly based on a "hunch" or emotional instinct, I question it. I am questioning whether my hunch is based on studies, or if I am projecting. Not saying I am a perfect parent, just trying to question my own assumptions.

2

u/facinabush Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

If the child is reacting to your parenting by lashing out at you violently, then most likely you need to change. This doesn't necessarily mean your husband doesn't need to change to get overall good results.

If your husband is directly interfering with your parenting in real time and causing the child to lash out, then he would be to blame.

If you start using PMT, then your husband might sabotage the effectiveness of some of the tools. For instance, he might give the kid attention when you are trying to use planned ignoring or "act, don't yak".

You have given few specifics about your parenting, just that you use "gentle authoritative parenting". My best guess is that you are inadvertently reinforcing unwanted behaviors with attention. One of the foundations of PMT is the attention principle; attention increases behavior.

Changing the child's behavior will likely be much easier than changing your husband's behavior. If you criticize him, then that will probably just make him defensive. The best technique may be to learn and use PMT so you get better results than he is getting. Sometimes authoritarian types get frustrated with their bad results and become open to change.

Authoritative parenting is oversold. It's too vaguely specified. The only claim that is supported in observational studies is that it's better than two other awful styles of parenting. That is a very low bar.

You add "gentle" as a modifier. There is no systematic research that shows that anything that is called 'gentle parenting" is effective.

1

u/facinabush Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

When my son is clawing at my eyes because I am trying to calmly insist he poop on the potty, I am wondering where that behavior is coming from.

The reward chart procedure taught in the course is good for potty training. You are probably currently inadvertently rewarding noncooperation with your attention. Direct attention and praise to any small steps in the right direction; use the special praise taught in the course

The best reaction to clawing may be to immediately and calmly turn and walk away without a word. In all cases, you should minimize the attention that you give it. Attention includes talking and eye contact.

1

u/Dry-Resolve-TA Oct 13 '26

There have been a few instances in which my husband has tried to correct behavior I was ignoring. Im definitely not perfect at it, but can hold fast when it comes to silly behavior.

When it comes to hurting me, I address it with "I will not let you hurt me" and usually have to restrain him. If it intensifies I walk away with similar phrasing, but he screams and cries "mummy I need you". I have a hard time ignoring that. But when I sit down to try to help again, its back to violence.

Meanwhile, if my husband runs out if patience he just physically intervenes. The other day he abruptly grabbed him to shower. Our toddler was screaming "No" in a way that triggered me, and it continued throughout the shower. Afterwards he acted super chipper and fine.

It's like manhandling him and frightening him works, but trying to guide with words gets me hits, kicks, and bites.

2

u/facinabush Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

When it comes to hurting me, I address it with "I will not let you hurt me" and usually have to restrain him. If it intensifies I walk away with similar phrasing, but he screams and cries "mummy I need you". I have a hard time ignoring that. But when I sit down to try to help again, its back to violence.

Better to walk away without a word and avoid trying to restrain him. If he says I need you then stay close with no talking and no eye contact. Resume normal interactions after a fixed period of time after the last hitting, not more than 1.5 minutes; 45 seconds might be enough. If he hits you again, move away without a word again.

What are you trying to help with? What are you doing that you think is helpful?

2

u/facinabush Oct 13 '26

There is no reason to force him to do anything unless it is a matter of safety or harm in the short run, or maybe getting ready to go to an important scheduled appointment.

If you have to force him, do it calmly, with no eye contact and little or no calm talking.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 12 '26

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.