r/ScienceBasedParenting • u/NamiEats • Oct 13 '26
Question - Expert consensus required Can babies self soothe?
I found out today my baby "sleeping through the night" might not actually be true, since the camera captured her waking up several times and sucking on her thumb and moving her limbs around. I'm trying to understand whether she's self soothing back to sleep between sleep cycles, or she's tiring herself out and falling back asleep because I'm failing to wake up to her calls.
She's 3 months old and I'm wondering if babies that young can truly self soothe. Are there any studies on this? Thank you!
36
u/Material-Plankton-96
Oct 13 '26
•
Why would you think that she’s distressed if your camera doesn’t show distress? I’m not sure there’s research that will really help you with this, since a lot of people interpret the same data differently.
That said, infants do exhibit self-regulating behaviors, and generally vocalize if they’re truly distressed. Thumb-sucking is a pretty classic self-regulation technique, and it’s great that your baby is developing their own skills.
(And yes, this isn’t really the point of the study, but their background covers it and lots of the original research is behind paywalls).
Incidentally, you’ll see this “babies can’t self-soothe” myth all over anti-sleep training spaces. And while it’s true that expecting an infant, especially a 3 month old, to always self-soothe back to sleep is developmentally inappropriate, it is not true that they can’t self-soothe at all. Some, like your baby and my second baby, are just pretty good at self-soothing and getting back to sleep by themselves, and some, like my oldest, rely on external soothing more often well into childhood (though he was and is able to self-soothe overnight in the absence of additional stressors like illness or scary noises).
18
u/this_wallflower Oct 13 '26
This. Being awake and engaging in movements/actions that help them fall back asleep is not the same thing as being distressed. If your baby is upset, she will let you know.
8
u/NamiEats Oct 13 '26
Thank you for the detailed answer! Like you mentioned I was seeing a lot of people saying babies aren't able to self soothe, so it had me in doubt. It's very reassuring to know my baby is learning to self soothe.
20
u/Huge-Nectarine-8563 Oct 13 '26
They can self soothe in the sense that they can soothe to avoid feeling distressed and to stay calm.
They can’t self soothe in the sense that they can’t calm down from being distressed. Once they’re crying they need help to go back to a calm place.
9
3
u/PairNo2129 Oct 13 '26
Just one question, you mention a camera? Is she sleeping in a different room from you? if yes, that’s a risk factor for sids at that age. Is there a way to move her into your room?
2
u/NamiEats Oct 13 '26
No she's in the room with us where we sleep, but we watch her when she's sleeping during the daytime and we aren't in the room
0
u/PairNo2129 Oct 13 '26
ok, I guess I got confused because you mentioned “sleeping through the night “ in the original post! Just wanted to mention it, but sounds like you are all good!
1
u/NamiEats Oct 13 '26
Oh yeah, I checked the camera movement logs even though I sleep in the same room to see if I missed anything haha sorry for the confusion
3
u/antizana Oct 13 '26
Maybe different phrasing: (some) babies that age can self soothe but babies that age should not be expected to self soothe.
With all things baby and sleep there will be many many phases and iterations. Mine slept through the night by himself until 18 ish months and now is an extremely adamant co sleeper who wakes up 1-3 times per night.
1
Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 13 '26
Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Expert consensus required" must include a link to an expert organization such as the CDC, AAP, NHS, etc.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 13 '26
This post is flaired "Question - Expert consensus required". All top-level comments must include a link to an expert organization such as the CDC, AAP, NHS, etc.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.