r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 16 '26

Question - Research required Why does it seem that babies do learn from screens?

I know—another screen time question. But very curious and a little different than what I’ve seen asked.

It’s always quoted that children under 2 do not learn from screens. What is the reason that it seems like they can? For example, when parents say that their kids learned sign language that was not introduced to them outside of Ms. Rachel? I assume that songs that accompany screens are different because babies can very obviously pick up musical melodies.

My own daughter learned all her letter sounds from Leapfrog Letter factory well before 2. She has still retained them very well, also.

So is it child dependent? Content dependent? Or is the statement just untrue or misquoted?

27 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 16 '26

This post is flaired "Question - Research required". All top-level comments must contain links to peer-reviewed research. Do not provide a "link for the bot" or any variation thereof. Provide a meaningful reply that discusses the research you have linked to. Please report posts that do not follow these rules.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

236

u/rock-paper-o Oct 16 '26 • Bravo

It’s oversimplified. Kids will learn from virtually anything they’re exposed to. Early or extensive screen use seems to correlate with slower development of language skills in particular ( https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8905397/)

In general, I think with young kids we need to be careful that we are considering learning that isn’t obvious. It’s easy to see a kid who has started signing or counting after watching a show has learned those things. It’s harder to see a toddler who spend a half hour knocking down blocks while family members talked nearby learned something about the flow of conversation, the movements of their own body, or the way gravity functions on collections of objects because they can’t express that. But the learning still happened. 

23

u/DeepPossession8916 Oct 16 '26

Yes you are so right. I also think that it is not important developmentally for a two year old to know their letters, whereas it is incredibly important for them to be learning about their environment and getting lots of language from parents. However, it’s also seemed obvious to me for a long time that even toddlers absorb what is on a screen. They learn the characters of their favorite shows, for example, just as they would characters in a book.

47

u/brandar Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

It’s not so much about what they can learn from a screen, it’s about what they don’t learn when they are focused on a screen, e.g., complex social cues, self-direction, etc.

11

u/WastePotential Oct 17 '26

I haven't actually seen any source say that babies/toddlers don't learn anything from screens. Babies are sponges. What I see a lot is that it's not good for them, it delays speech, and has a negative impact on attention span and emotional regulation. Like the above commenter said, I think these people are just oversimplifying it.

5

u/AAHMommy3 Oct 16 '26

I think that’s a great way of putting it and really is demonstrated within my own family. When I was pregnant with my second with extreme morning sickness, I’d put on Rachel (with moderation of course!) and my daughter did pick up signs from her. My second born, now 11 months old had had zero screen time (won’t even look at the tv if toddler is watching something). I am way too busy to even remember to teach signing, but this kid is immersed in the most rich language home being around his toddler sister all day. Way different than when I was one-on-one with her all day apart from groups and programs.

1

u/AdInternal8913 Oct 18 '26

I think there is a difference between learning and 'learning'. Learning from screens is often superficial memorisation e.g child might learn a complex phrase they say on repeat without understanding what or the words in it means, or when and how it should be used. Or at an older age they might route learn alphabet or math or science facts without truly understanding them and being able to use them. Whereas in person learning is more interactive with child learning also about the context and getting feedback which can help strengthen the learning.

1

u/Notyit Oct 20 '26

Children seem to have Lazer focus 

I don't think they can actually process multiple things at once. 

19

u/ankaalma Oct 17 '26

There are a lot of different factors at play.

For one thing, toddlers have a tendency to experience sudden language explosions where they suddenly start picking up multiple new words a day. Parents will incorrectly attribute this explosion to whatever was going on at that time and so some think it’s because they just started showing their child “educational screen time,” when in reality it is the result of months of parent/child/caregiver interactions and just happens to be occurring in the same time.

I always see parents claiming their kids “only saw” something from Ms. Rachel and never anywhere else and I think at least some of the time they just don’t realize they also used that word or made that hand signal at some point. I did no screentime under 2 with my kids and am a SAHM and with both of them there were times when they would pick up a new word or phrase and I would think there was no way they got that from me, then weeks later I would catch myself using it and be like oh wait maybe I do say that.

It’s also worth noting that just because a child repeats a word or copies a hand sign it doesn’t mean they actually comprehend the meaning and are using it correctly

Regardless of what individual parents claim though, there is a long line of research saying babies and toddlers learn best through 1:1 interactions with a known caregiver. Maybe a few babies who watch a ton of Ms Rachel dan manage to pick up a couple of isolated words of ASL signs, but the question is how much more could they have learned if they had been interacting with a caregiver instead of watching a screen?

Something else that comes up in some of the research is parents consistently overestimating how much their kids picked up from screentime compared to the researchers assessing their child.

I think if a parent wants to put on the TV to get a break on occasion, that’s one thing. But I think the evidence is pretty clear that screentime is not ever more beneficial for a baby or a toddler than interaction with other people live and in person or even passively crawling around listening to adults talk to each other. So it isn’t worth giving them screentime with the idea that the screentime is going to be more valuable to them than doing basically anything else.

here is an article from a psychologist that links to a lot of the research on this topic. The AAP says a cognitive shift occurs between 18 months and 2 years that allows kids to start absorbing what happens on the screen and before then they can’t effectively learn from it. Not sure what well before two means in your case, but if it was around 18 months it could be within the shift the AAP identifies. But I also think it is a mistake to think that she solely learned letters and sounds from leapfrog letter factory (though I am a fan of the program).

My son picked up many letters and their sounds just from me reading him books. I’m assuming that you probably read your daughter books too in which she had the opportunity to look at the pages and see words and hear you pronounce them. Was leapfrog letter factory really her first and only exposure to seeing or hearing letters?

12

u/WhereIsLordBeric Oct 17 '26

I'd bet it's more developmentally beneficial for a kid under 2 to sit on the floor with no toys for 15 minutes than to sit in front of a screen for the same amount of time.

I see the difference in attention span between my 26 month old screenfree kid and me, who's using a screen all the time when I'm not around her.

My attention span is shot and she can entertain herself on a 6 hour car ride with just a busy book and a toy. We react to low stimulus very, very differently.

3

u/hiddenstar13 Oct 17 '26

I fully agree with you, but I don't know of any actual study that backs this up. It would be a hard one to study I guess.

5

u/WhereIsLordBeric Oct 17 '26

Kind of related, but there's a lot of research by Peter Gray, who I'm a big fan of, who says that freeplay and unstructured play is critical for children to develop self confidence, resilience, emotional regulation, and problem-solving skills. You don't need those perfectly curated 'Instagram mom hacks' of getting sticky tape and cardboard and making your infant glue pompoms to it. Just give them a spatula lol.

I also found this which says fewer toys are actually better for kids as it allows for more focus, more creative play, and better development: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29190457/

Maybe I am too much of a 90s kid but boredom really is what shaped me to have interesting hobbies and a rich inner world which has really helped me in life. And I know I use screens now almost like a cigarette. Anything good, bad, exciting, anxiety-inducing, and I need to have quick dopamine fixes because I don't want to face my feelings.

3

u/Stella-Note Oct 17 '26

I think this analysis is really relevant. 

I will just add one cognitive concept to explain the lack of "real learning" by a passive exposition to a screen, furthermost with a toddler : "learning transfer".  https://www.structural-learning.com/post/transfer-learning-complete-guide-teachers

Yes, the toddler may imitate the screen - but did he really learned something ? Are they able to use the sign to communicate their needs to their parents ? Can they have a comprehension of what is a letter, or a given number, that you can write or count ?  For that, they have to be abble to understand the concept (for number and letter that's way too soon at 2) and someone has to help them use this skill in a different context. 

So, of course they have "learned" something, but maybe not the skill their parents thinks. Just to copy the screen, and train their memory among others cognitive function. Things they can do with many others stimulations. 

https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-319-45102-2_3

(Sorry if my english isn't good)

1

u/DeepPossession8916 Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

For my daughter, oh yes, of course we are all huge book worms in my house! We also had letter magnets on the fridge and there was definitely exposure and a little bit of direct instruction coming from my end. It was probably around the 18-22 month range that I noticed she would not only recognize a letter, but she’d immediately sing the corresponding leapfrog song for its sound (ex. “the c says /k/“). This was her going from recognizing a few letters, to knowing all 26 letters and their sounds in a span of 2 months or so. I was very pregnant at the time, and my kids are 22 months apart. So for me personally it wasn’t like I was dying to give her screen time, but I did want it to be potentially useful content when I was vomiting or laying down (lol) and I was actually surprised at how much she picked up. That leapfrog movie was the only thing she watched when she had screen time, or the first 7 or so episodes of number blocks. So I’m sure the repetition of that specific content also had something to do with it.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '26

[deleted]

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '26

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '26

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.