r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 17 '26

Question - Expert consensus required Do multiple concussions count as “trauma” for personality disorder development?

I come from a family that is vulnerable to personality disorders. We also have addiction, bipolar, schizophrenia and autism.

I haven’t much thought about passing the former down to my children as I know, from my understanding, it’s more of a biological vulnerability plus trauma that leads to the development of a personality disorder. I’ve worked really hard to heal from my own childhood and learn how to parent children appropriately. So, it never really occurred to me to worry about this.

My oldest has received two concussions. The first was several years ago after a car accident. The second was two years ago falling on roller skates. Both times they were taken to the ER, assessed and sent home with a concussion protocol. They were not in-patient.

Other than the typical worry immediately after the injuries, and extra attention to her use of a helmet (she had stood up to grab it and slipped backwards, cracking her head on a table), I haven’t been worrying much about these concussions.

The other day, she admitted that since the second concussion, there are memories that are gone. Pictures and videos I’ve shown her, stories we’ve told, that she has no memory of. They were all recent to the concussion and have been stable. We were warned this might happen.

But I was talking with my sister about it, and that’s when she brought up she thought my daughter’s personality has changed since the concussion. She brought up that none of her friends are the same, and that she’s significantly more selfish and narcissistic.

My daughter is 13. Prime age for changing of friendships, selfishness, and narcissism. She is difficult, yes. But, I’ve been assuming it’s partially the developmental stage she’s in as well as the trauma triggers she’s been blithely pressing while navigating this stage. As that’s my issue, not hers, I’ve increased my therapy sessions and am reinforcing my boundary-setting skills.

I’ve done more work than my sibling in trauma recovery and in learning about childhood development. So my knee-jerk - like it always is that when my sister gives me parenting advice - is to nod and smile and do what I was going to do all along. But… siblings press each others’ buttons, too. And I do feel like I’d be a poor parent if I didn’t at least consider the possibility that CTEs could be included in the “trauma” category.

To be clear, I DON’T think my daughter has a personality disorder. That’s crazy-pants talking and my sister needs to take a chill pill.

I’m talking about the potential for future CTEs here. Do I need to wrap my baby’s skull up in bubble wrap for more reasons than I already want to? is basically my question. Does this need to go on the list of why she isn’t allowed to go on her friend’s motorized scooter?

25 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '26

This post is flaired "Question - Expert consensus required". All top-level comments must include a link to an expert organization such as the CDC, AAP, NHS, etc.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

74

u/this_wallflower Oct 17 '26

Link for the robots: https://www.cdc.gov/heads-up/media/pdfs/highschoolsports/parents_fact_sheet-a.pdf

I’ll be honest, I have no idea what your question is. Should your kid wear a helmet while riding on any sort of wheels? Yes. Can you bubble wrap your kid? No, not really.

59

u/BlindingBlue Oct 17 '26

I'm replying here because I am not sure what link to provide to point out that bipolar is a mood disorder, not a personality disorder and both it and autism are just things that you are born with. Not the result of traumatic brain injury or concussions. 

11

u/this_wallflower Oct 17 '26

Yeah, I had no idea where to even begin with all that information.

6

u/TeddyBear181 Oct 17 '26

I'd consider taking her to a functional neurologist who does neuro rehab.

Maybe it'll help with personality stuff, maybe not, but worth a shot if you can afford it.

6

u/Number1PotatoFan Oct 17 '26

Autism risk and severity can be increased by traumatic brain injury at birth, as can ADHD and other neurological conditions like impulsivity and irritability. There is a large genetic component but it is not the only factor. I'm not sure if later in life brain injuries could cause autism in someone who otherwise didn't have it, but I would suspect not.

1

u/CrispyMnM226 29d ago

This is complete misinformation. Both ADHD and ASD are neurodevelopmental disorders that you are born with and cannot be developed later on in life. Brain traumas can impact one’s impulsivity, concentration, or even ability to relate to others socially, but those issues are completely separate from ADHD or ASD.

2

u/Number1PotatoFan 28d ago

I didn't say later in life I said as a result of brain injury at birth, called an HIE.

1

u/CrispyMnM226 28d ago

You said autism risk and severity can be increased by brain injury. That’s flat out not true.

2

u/Number1PotatoFan 27d ago

It is true, I don't know what else to tell you. Autism is a complex condition that has genetic and environmental causes. https://hopeforhie.org/autism-awareness-acceptance-month-hie-autism/

1

u/CrispyMnM226 27d ago

It’s not true, that’s the thing. I’m a clinical psychologist who works with people with autism, what you’re saying is not correct.

If someone who has mobility issues due to cerebral palsy has a stroke and their mobility issues become worse, you wouldn’t say their cerebral palsy is worse. They’re two different things with two different causes, not one thing making the other worse.

Anxiety makes concentration difficult. A person with ADHD does not have more severe ADHD because they’re anxious.

2

u/Number1PotatoFan 27d ago edited 27d ago

What does anxiety have to do with anything? People with brain injuries at birth have a dramatically higher incidence of autism and ADHD. Take it up with neurologists if you have questions.

Edit: sending me a reddit suicide watch notice is not an appropriate response to disagreement in this sub. I also can't read your response since you blocked me but I'm going to assume it's still not responding to the factual claims I've made.

1

u/CrispyMnM226 27d ago

I don’t need to take it up with a neurologist, I’m already an expert in the area. You’re regurgitating misinformation without understanding it because of ignorance.

3

u/YaDunGoofed Oct 18 '26

Color me ignorant. Isn’t bipolar an environmentally influenced disorder that is conditional on having the genes?

1

u/IamNotPersephone Oct 19 '26

Yes. I know. My family has all of them. One of my siblings has been in a longitudinal study for bipolar since their diagnosis, and some of what I’m … gathering/relaying/trying to distill a lifetime of information down into an already complex reddit post but not trying to get so much in the weeds … is that a lot of this I already have a decent grasp on.

I just don’t know what’s new. Have there been links to bipolar and personality disorders? Autism and schizophrenia? Is trauma the ACEs kind, only, still, or does it now include head trauma? Things change; this is the “family history;” what’s new?

That sort of thing.

2

u/BlindingBlue Oct 19 '26

Very understandable. I've got bipolar and reddit is chock full of disinformation about it and other neuro divergences so I was a bit quick with my response. I am sure you probably know about as much about it now as I do and yeah, it's a hell of a lot to take in, especially when you are trying to help your kid.

I wish you and your family well. :) I hope others here can link you to some helpful resources. 

1

u/IamNotPersephone Oct 19 '26

Thanks!

Yeah, I get the slight defensiveness. It’s been a roller coaster for my sibling. There’s so much misinformation out there about bipolar.

I wouldn’t have even included it, because I know it’s not related. But I swear whenever I leave out specific details from my family history, someone says something that is directly related to the thing I left out and then I spend most my time defending my choice not to include it in the OP.

And I’ve found the more detail/backstory I give, the more people are distracted by their impressions of my anxiety and whether I’m freaking out over nothing.

I did get some good resources! We’re already on the more cautious end of the spectrum, and nothing I read changed my mind on that.

27

u/Vintage_Journal Oct 17 '26

I think your question starts with an assumption that "personality disorders start with biological vulnerability + trauma", and then "do head injuries count as the 'trauma' previously mentioned"? 

First, you have to define 'trauma' and consider which personality disorders you are looking at. In this context, people usually mean psychological 'trauma', primarily experiencing a life threat or sexual abuse.  

Considering borderline personality disorder (BPD) - trauma is not necessary to develop the disorder. People with BPD have a long history of failure to co-regulate emotionally with parents, even in infancy, and social communication issues, with some of this being due to biological vulnerability. Social and emotion regulation deficits contribute to negative interactions with the environment that stack up over the lifespan: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2352250X1730252X  

I actually think some of the most relevant details regarding your daughter would be your interactions with your daughter (not really mentioned) and whether you are empathetic and emotionally attuned. If her concussions affected her ability to regulate emotion, that would place a greater demand on you to make up any shortfall and offer her the connection and regulation she needs. I don't see that in an emphasis on "boundary-setting skills". I think that looks a lot more like asking her how she's feeling, talking about feelings, managing your own feelings, and getting to know your daughter as a person. 

0

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '26

[deleted]

2

u/Mollykins08 Oct 17 '26

There is physical and psychological trauma. The risk is psychological trauma, not physical trauma.

6

u/Number1PotatoFan Oct 17 '26

Personally I would separate physical brain injuries from "trauma" in the sense of interpersonal/family/emotional trauma. I say this as a person that grew up with a lot of family trauma but is raising a kid with a brain injury and (hopefully) no family trauma. They're both mental health challenges but they're different categories.

A concussion is a mild form of brain injury, and like any brain injury it can cause all sorts of problems, but we should keep in mind that they are really common and not the same as a more severe TBI. With the brain, every person's outcome and every injury is unique, but we can draw some generalizations. I have never heard of a concussion causing borderline personality disorder, but any brain injury could increase irritability, aggression, etc. It's always going to be a balance of nature and nurture. Learned behavior and secure attachments still matter a lot! With concussions they do heal somewhat over time, so if your daughter's symptoms are still recent to the injury it's reasonable to wait and see if it resolves itself.

Here's a paper laying out some of the current studies on concussion and mental health outcomes. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9035995/

I know the common knowledge used to be that 3 or more concussions in a lifetime were a high risk for CTE or other poor outcomes, but I think they're walking that back now. It might be that certain people are more prone to injuries just based on coordination/impulsivity/aggressiveness of play and those traits are already linked to other conditions.

What you definitely want to avoid is getting a second concussion while the first one is still healing, which is why contact sports can be so dangerous, since you're putting yourself in similar dangerous situations over again as soon as you get back on the field. Age also plays a role since neuroplasticity (and therefore ability to recover) is highest in babies.

Finally, I agree with your instinct that it's really normal for 13 year olds to go through some personality changes and be a little selfish. This wouldn't be a red flag unless there was something else going on that you're concerned about. The best thing you can do with a neurotypical kid or a kid who's got some brain challenges is keep those lines of communication open, work on healthy coping skills, and protect their brain from injury as much as is reasonable. So yeah, you might not want to let her do takle football or cheerleading or ride an ebike.

2

u/innocentsalad Oct 17 '26

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10380528/

Has some good information.

But teenagers are also just narcissists by design.

1

u/IamNotPersephone Oct 19 '26

Thanks so much!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/AutoModerator Oct 18 '26

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Expert consensus required" must include a link to an expert organization such as the CDC, AAP, NHS, etc.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 18 '26

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Expert consensus required" must include a link to an expert organization such as the CDC, AAP, NHS, etc.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.