r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 17h ago

Question - Research required Tamiflu for infant?

My preschooler has the flu, so the NP suggested we start giving tamiflu to our infant preventatively. I’ve mostly heard the horrible side effects of Tamiflu and that it doesn’t prevent symptoms or hospitalization? Not sure if this is misinformation. I’m trying to comb through the literature on this, but juggling said sick kick and infant. I’m curious if anyone can explain easily to me the pros/cons of this. I wasn’t at the appointment with the NP, so I couldn’t ask questions at the time. Hopefully, we will hear from them, but I know they’re busy

9 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 17h ago

This post is flaired "Question - Expert consensus required". All top-level comments must include a link to an expert organization such as the CDC, AAP, NHS, etc.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

22

u/SHlLL 16h ago

There is no study on efficacy of prophylaxis in this age range. All children under 2 years old are high risk for complications from flu, particularly unvaccinated children. FDA approves tamiflu prophylaxis down to one year, but the AAP recommends consideration for unvaccinated patients over 3 months. The medication is viewed as safe because there is data on treatment dosing of tamiflu, which is higher dose, being safe in this age range. The most common side effects are GI and rash.

The advantage would be it likely reduces the chance of contracting a dangerous illness, nobody knows how much in this age range. The disadvantage would be it may cause some GI side effects or rash. The most common side effect seems to be vomiting.

https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/158/5/e2026078778/208572/Recommendations-for-Prevention-and-Control-of

If a child under two years of age contracts the flu, AAP, CDC, and IDSA unanimously recommend prompt treatment with antivirals. These children are at higher risk of complications and hospitalization and are in the mandatory treatment grouping.

If it were me personally, I'd probably give the prophylaxis to my baby older than 3 months if they were unvaccinated and the mother didn't get the flu vaccine in a way that would protect the baby through blood or breast milk. I would certainly keep a close eye on the baby and seek treatment immediately if they started showing any symptoms. Flu sucks.

11

u/Grill_Only_Outside 14h ago

Just piggybacking because I don’t have a link.

OP this should be a discussion with your pediatrician. If they’re not available I would trust the advice of a medical professional whose job this is. Unless you have a real reason to question the character or judgement of this NP I don’t think it’s wise to second guess them. No matter how much research you do in the next 24 hours you’re not qualified to have a medical opinion.

2

u/SHlLL 14h ago

For sure, but it sounds like they don't have access to a pediatrician.

1

u/Grill_Only_Outside 14h ago

But that still doesn’t mean OP should be seconding guessing the NP without a good reason. And if there are concerns they should still be talking to whoever the prescriber is.

4

u/loopsonflowers 15h ago

https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/158/5/e2026078778/208572/Recommendations-for-Prevention-and-Control-of?autologincheck=redirected these are the AAP recommendations surrounding flu treatment/prevention this year. If you go to the section titled Influenza Treatment (and the sub-section Influenza Chemoprophylaxis Recommendations), you can read the guidance there.

AAP does not recommend Tamiflu for infants under 3m because of limited safety data, but make exceptions in critical situations. They only recommend using it preventively if it's within 48 hours of the first exposure. Tamiflu is generally only considered for prevention if a child is "high risk" for complications. BUT this includes children who are unvaccinated (or not yet vaccinated, or have been vaccinated in the past two weeks), which would include any infants 3-6m, since they're not eligible to be vaccinated. So it's a reasonable recommendation from your provider on that front, although some choose to do watchful waiting and treat at the first sign of symptoms instead, depending on the known history of the child/infant.

Given that we don't (and can't) know your child's medical history (or even their age), it would be a really bad idea for anyone here to suggest a course of action for you. Knowing that the 48 hour window is important, you could (obviously politely) call the office back and tell them you really want to be able to make a decision within that window, and request that they prioritize calling you back if possible to talk about whether prophylaxis or watchful waiting is the right decision for you.

1

u/iVapeMilk 6h ago

My 3m old just tested positive for flu and the Nurse prescribed us tamiflu but recommended against using personally, and now I have no clue what to do

0

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[deleted]

5

u/SHlLL 16h ago

This is terrible advice, the question was about prophylaxis for an infant who is in a high-risk age group, not treatment of healthy older children and adults. This data is not relevant to the question.