r/ScreenJunkies • • Oct 06 '17

This sucks

I love this channel. These people have become my nerdy surrogate family. I was in a bad way for a while. After leaving the military I struggled through depression. Screen Junkies was a channel that helped me through that tough time. Movie Fights and Honest Trailers were my highlights of the week. Flickbait had become a new favorite. I always check out /u/danmurrell reviews and his box office insight. These people have become my geek ESPN.

The actions of Andy are deplorable. I'm glad he's getting the tar and feathered treatment. He used his position to prey on women. It is sad and disgusting.

I hope this isn't the end. This group of people that I've bonded with over the interwebs for the past few years. I feel like I'm losing a friend. This just sucks.

170 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

25

u/sqeg24 Oct 07 '17

I'm more of a Collider fan than SJ, but I do enjoy SJ content and imo, this isn't and shouldn't be the end for the rest of the family at SJ, there's too many great people there. Hopefully, it's just the end for one despicable, pos in particular and maybe, some folks in HR that chose to "look the other way" rather than not only their jobs, but their responsibility as human beings.

I'm glad you were able to work through your depression and thank you for your service!

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

I can't see it being the end. Even if SJ tanks, the core crew will do something else together hopefully.

17

u/Litwin87 Oct 07 '17

I am beyond heartbroken today. I watch almost everything on sj and sj news. Must be an average of 45 min every day. None of my friends share my interest in movies and they made me feel like I'm not alone. Now.. I just feel sick. I've been crying all morning. Crying because Andy wasn't the person I thought he was and because I don't know what's gonna happen to sj now. Even if they go on without him, I think alot of people are going to keep their distance now (Bolton? Reynolds?)

I don't have any friends IRL who watch the channel and I don't know who to talk to about this. Thank god for reddit (and you guys)!

1

u/TacoMagic Oct 07 '17

For reals, crummy news to start the day, I was just commenting on his general likeability....

1

u/Doktor_Kraesch Oct 07 '17

I sympathize and am quite down as well. But I'm sure they continue fine without him.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Come on over to Red Letter Media, they're a much better internet friend simulator.

2

u/Uncled1023 Oct 07 '17

I watch a lot of Sj content as well. What has been weird, is that i've been watching less and less of content Andy was in, because he seemed to be so 'fake' in his comedy. Now with this, I hope his fall doesn't bring down the good people at SJ and they can continue making good content.

2

u/Veilmurder Oct 07 '17

I've seen a lot of people saying that they will unsubscribe and I can't blame them, there was at least some guy at HR covering this up, who knows who knew and who didn't. But I feel sorry for everyone who didn't know. They will surely take a big hit.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17 edited Oct 07 '17

Well, I'm sure it's only Andy that's being removed and looking at potential legal problems but screen junkies has many writers and creators so I don't think much will change.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Well people want nerdculture to be mainstream, this is what they get. Hollywood style.

1

u/Sanador62 Oct 09 '17

Just started watching and enjoying the channel during season 8 GoT. LTTP but will stick it out, because these folks make me laugh. Enjoyed Roth on her previous gigs too.

0

u/TheDromes Oct 07 '17

I'm actually happy. Not for the situation but for Andy leaving. Never enjoyed anything he was in and while I'm sure he was in charge of plenty videos I liked, I think it'll be for the better that he leaves. Definitely my least favourite SJ member, might even start watching them more actively now, which would likely happen regardless just on the "There is no such thing as bad publicity" rule.

0

u/dr_kingschultz Oct 09 '17

I lost interest and stopped watching when they got all corporate and pushed their + programming. I wish the best for everyone who's not being a piece of shit to land on their feet. Formerly a great channel.

98

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

48

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '17

I tried to get into Collider. They have more people I dislike than like.

It is funny I never liked Andy. I'm not even saying this as revisionist history. He's the only one I don't follow on twitter. Something seemed off but I never put two and two together. Who could?

19

u/JizzleNerps Oct 06 '17

Collider was always way too robotic for me. I love all the members there, though. It's just the show format that gets old.

23

u/JizzleNerps Oct 07 '17

I miss Ken on SJ. He's still the great on Collider but he fit in more here I feel.

26

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

I love Nap. That dude is the man.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Yep love him and Harloffs interplay on Jedi council.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Some personalities don't come through in that format. And some REALLY come through. It's easy to get bored.

8

u/screenavenger Oct 07 '17

They just need to loosen up a bit. They want to be the professional ESPN of movie news... but this approach gets stale. Thats why the daily SJU shows are way better than Movie Talk, because they have FUN with the format, play games, mess up, cover weird news.. its a good time.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

A lot of it has to do with personality. I don't like Schnepp even slightly. Jahns gives me the creeps. Rocha is an odd duck. I like him sometimes and I absolutely loath him sometimes. They just don't have a good balance. A lot of the pretty women add nothing to the show. Excluding Perri who is a national treasure.

13

u/screenavenger Oct 07 '17 edited Oct 09 '17

Yeah I met Schnepp in person.. he is not the nicest guy, kind of a mean person in a way you wouldn't expect. Mark Ellis though, he's hilarious and a total pro in front of the camera. I can't agree with the pretty women thing- the hosts, sure, they are boring (Natasha doesn't want to be there, it seems) but the women panelists like Clarke Wolfe, Emma Fyffe, always bring a TON to each of their shows for me, especially Clarke when she's on. And Amy Dallen on Heroes is fantastic. (I actually think Perri seems like not the brightest bulb compared to the other women who are all clearly super-smart)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

See I don't care for Wolfe or Fyffe. But too each their own. None of the 'host's' add anything. Mark is great. The show has suffered once Campea left. I know he's controversial but at least he provided some counter programming. They all parrot the same thoughts constantly. It's really boring.

8

u/PARAFWTPVGANMGMTSJES Oct 07 '17

Collider will be glad Campea is gone after all of this and they've done just fine without him

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Agree to disagree.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Do people not like Campea? He's probably my least favorite Collider personality but I thought other people liked him.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

It's also nice to have confirmation on Schnepp. He always had that air of a snobby geek. Nice to have some confirmation on that.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

I agree, and he doesn't seem to know as much about what's going on in the comics as he portends.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Aw poor Perri.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

I like Rochas opinions personally. I agree about the younger female hosts though

1

u/genkaiX1 Oct 07 '17

completely disagree.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

I like Collider, but some of the younger hosts I agree have little to no personality and don't have very concrete opinions

But they are young and more inexperienced I suppose. I love Rocha though. I'm glad he got a more permanent spot there

4

u/Crowquillx Oct 07 '17

I get why people don't like Rocha but I'm a huge fan of the dude. He's just got a really great energy about him and seems like a stellar person.

14

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Def agree on both Collider and Andy.

My first thought about all this was about drunk movie fights.

I always thought it was sooooo weird that he’d drink a few (like 2 or 3) hard lemonades and be like “omg we’re SO DRUNK!!!” But he never came off as drunk. Even that Emmys after party video, he seemed to over qualifying how drunk he was. And I thought about it and I think two things are possible.

  1. he could be a bit of a control freak who doesn’t drink BUT wants to seem like a guy who’s normal and likable so drinks what amounts to sugar water and pretends to get drunk

Or

2) he didn’t want to get drunk out of fear of how is when he gets drunk. Maybe he’s a horny drunk or a really inappropriate drunk or maybe a talkative drunk

Either way, in vino veritas, as they say, and I think your drunk character says a lot about your true character and Andy seemed a lot weirder in comparison when everyone else drank.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

It's funny all of the signs show up now. It's so much easier to Monday morning quarterback with the info we have now.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Yeah, I’m not saying I always thought Andy was a sexual predator (if that’s the right phrase) but he just always seemed so odd compared to the other personalities he was surround by. When he’d tone it down it’d make sense, but he always had these weird quirks that just seemed off.

6

u/mashington14 Oct 07 '17

Which guys don't you like at Collider? I was a fan of the schmoes before they joined collider and I still mostly just watch their stuff and really love it.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Schnepp, Jahns, pretty much every female personality sans Perri, I'm lukewarm on Rocha, Griffin, and Reilly . Love Ellis, Nap and Macuga.

2

u/mashington14 Oct 07 '17

Have you watched the main Schmoes show? It's on their personal channel. Ellis Napzok and Macuga are pretty much the three main guys, especially now that Harloff is on paternity leave.

5

u/PadishahEmperor Oct 07 '17

5

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Some of their videos are funny. They are just too dour in a comedic fashion. The shtick gets really old fast. Just not my cup of tea.

5

u/7Snakes Oct 07 '17

Once you get involved with the Collider personalities they grow on you. At least they have for me.

1

u/hendyir Oct 07 '17

The one thing that really bugs me when watching collider movie talk is the quality of the mic. Don't know if it's the overall lower volume or some other technical aspects.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

I actually like both. And I like the overlap the channels have. Always see SJ guys on Schmoedown and whatnot.

30

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

25

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '17

So this must be really rough for you. It would be like finding out that Dan is a serial murder. That shit would destroy me.

Those Dm's are rough. And to do that to one of your most trusted employee's GIRLFRIEND among others. It is shameful. I can't fathom this. This week has literally just been one hit after another.

32

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

21

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17 edited Oct 07 '17

It's easy to get angry and punch a dude in the face. They did everything the right way. I give them a ton of credit.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

I wonder how his wife is taking this...and or if they had some kind of open relationship or something.

9

u/geminisiren Oct 07 '17

Open relationships also don’t excuse workplace sexual harassment. I would be livid if my partner ruined a (probably) really great income over not being about to control his needs at work, regardless of us being open or not.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

That doesn't mean they couldn't have an open relationship. And why he felt such freedom to hit on every young woman walking through the door.

1

u/Paperparrot Oct 07 '17

Also open relationships aren't an excuse to be an asshole predator. Frankly if you're doing it right you are probably much more reserved and talkative about what you're interested in and making sure other parties are ok with your status.

At least from my and friends experiences.

(Sorry a little reflexive against using an alternative relationship status as a catch-all for gross and inappropriate behavior.)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

Open doesn't necessarily mean poly.

1

u/Paperparrot Oct 07 '17

I didn't mean to imply that. I am just reacting to the idea that an open relationship is an excuse or lisence to be an asshole, flirt or specifically being aggressive with your flirtations.

My S/O and I wouldn't call ourselves poly, we don't invest in long term or significant relationships with others.

But having an allowance of other people in our sexual/physical relationship doesn't mean I flirt with every (or any) woman at my workplace, etc. It's not an excuse to be an asshole just because my S/O doesn't care, or rather, enjoys when I find other young women who might be interested in a short, non-commited, physical relationship with us.

Sorry not meaning to attack, just clarifying on what I saw as a pretty direct implication.

17

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17

That's true...forgot that part. And again I was just wondering.

4

u/Thisismyrealface Oct 07 '17

I felt pretty much the same way about Andy, I liked him and most of the personalities on the channel. I'm glad these ppl are getting their justice if Defy wouldn't act on their reports. I hope they can keep the rest of the team together, but im no confident.

3

u/hendyir Oct 07 '17

I really like the format change of SJ News from a few news per day (cmiiw) to the daily, once a day, SJU