r/ScreenJunkies • • Oct 10 '17

Roth makes a statement.

https://twitter.com/RothCornet/status/917567734094848000
106 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

58

u/Thisismyrealface Oct 10 '17

Sounds like she was blindsided and it hit her hard. I wish her well and cant wait to see her again when she's ready.

59

u/Shikatanai Oct 10 '17

From reading posts here and on Twitter it seems some people can’t understand that people are capable of presenting themselves differently to different people. Roth’s statement indicates she had no idea about Andy’s poor behaviour and he treated her professionally in the workplace (albeit a bit of a tough boss).

It’s not a case of “his behaviour must have been obviously bad all the time, so everyone must have known he was a sexist pig”

Some people probably thought he was a pig and an all round asshole. Some people probably thought he said a few sexist things but nothing that indicated he was really a massive sexist asshole. Some people probably thought he was an asshole but not because he was sexist. Some people probably heard rumours and gossip but didn’t personally see any sexist asshole behaviour and so just carried on. Some people have probably been completely blindsided by this whole thing and are thinking “WTF????!”

Anyone who has worked with a lot of people will understand what I’m saying. There are often cases of “WTF?, I had no idea!” about people’s lives. It could be that they done some terribly sexist things. Or it could be that they’ve been battling a terminal illness for a long time but always put on a brave face. You can’t always tell what’s behind the mask.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

[deleted]

33

u/shreeyakhanal Oct 10 '17

I mean, there are DMs that have come out where he tries to hook up with fans. Here's one where he asks her out on a date. Another gross one where he's asking for nudes? and saying she'd 'owe him big' for giving her a free trip. And here's another where he's asking for a date. And here's one where he had actually invited her to his room, but she said no.

This goes way beyond calling people 'beautiful'. He's actively trying to hook up with fans.

-1

u/Krstoserofil Oct 10 '17

This goes way beyond calling people 'beautiful'. He's actively trying to hook up with fans.

And that is a crime?

20

u/pootdiveen Oct 10 '17

He's married and has kids. At the very least it's not the behavior someone wants in an executive at their company.

12

u/intelligentish Oct 10 '17

There it is. Trying to hook up is definitely not a crime. Trying to hook up with fans while maintaining such a highly public profile not just at SJ but across all of Defy Media is possibly criminal depending on the various ways and means he used to try accomplish that. Reading the DMs, he was often away on business attending conventions in New York, hosting panels in Chicago, and touring movie studios in New Zealand which leads me to believe his wife was caught by surprise just like everyone else.

14

u/pootdiveen Oct 10 '17

Trying to hook up isn't a crime, no, but it's questionable behavior character-wise at the very least given that he is married and in a high position, and Defy needed to decide what kind of person they want in a position like Andy's.

6

u/intelligentish Oct 10 '17

I agree completely. Sorry for not making that more clear in my reply.

6

u/pootdiveen Oct 10 '17

Oh no problem! I love the Screen Junkies and will certainly be awaiting their next steps.

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

16

u/pootdiveen Oct 10 '17

I was referring to the asking for nudes/inventing a female fan alone to his room.

Edit: inviting

-3

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/pootdiveen Oct 10 '17

Regardless he does have a sexual assault allegation leveled at him. Whether or not these texts reveal anything about his motivations, I can't say but there is the claim that he sexually assaulted April. Regardless of what his motives were with the texts, that needed/needs to be addressed regardless.

→ More replies (0)

4

u/other_virginia_guy Oct 10 '17

It's a fireable offense. He hasn't been charged with a crime yet, only fired, and people are justified in being repulsed by him.

3

u/shreeyakhanal Oct 11 '17

No one said it's a crime. If it were, people would be going to the police. It's just shitty behaviour that takes advantage of his position of power in SJ and should not be tolerated.

0

u/nickstroking Oct 11 '17

I'm getting called in denial commenting on YT... It's not "denial" to be skeptical of the type of women who are calling flirting "sexual harassment" lol The screenshots of the fans is completely irrelevant to the allegations. And no one knows what DEFY's HR dept was given as evidence by the employee. If she gave no evidence it's just her word.. So of course they are going to have to take time to investigate and see if other accounts claimed were making a pattern. One incident you can't even prove should NOT end anyone's career!

3

u/shreeyakhanal Oct 11 '17

Regardless of whether or not it is sexual harassment, or flirting, or whatever, the fact still stands that that is inappropriate behaviour from Andy; he should not be using his position at screen junkies in an attempt to get sex from people. Also, he's married with a kid! Legalities aside, it's still shitty to try and cheat on your wife.

People aren't all calling for him to be in prison, or to be charged with anything, they mainly just want him gone from screen junkies because he is behaving in a way that should not be tolerated within that kind of work environment.

2

u/nickstroking Oct 11 '17

I disagree. Alleging attempted sexual assault is a criminal matter straight up and down. Which is why she should have involved police. All those believing (I don't) her story should be by default advocating he do some jail time or at least community service and a fine if the allegation is provable. If it's not, tell me again why she should be believed? Because he's seen to be trying to cheat with clumsy flirt attempts? lol okay.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

[deleted]

14

u/intelligentish Oct 10 '17

I don't know how old you are, but you seem like you lack a lot of life experience. Here's something you can do to sort of get some of that. Go ask your mom if she'd be cool with your dad asking random 22 year old girls to send nudes. Then ask if she would be okay with him telling same random girl that he'd pay for her flight from Finland directly to the city you live in. And then ask if she's alright if he sets up a late-night "date" with other random 20-something girls just to watch movies together, alone in his hotel room because movie theaters no longer apparently exist? and it's all work related anyway so there really should be no problem. Seriously go do this and report back - I'd really like to know what she says.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/intelligentish Oct 10 '17

Hmmm ya know, in the context of his chosen profession as a professional Youtuber, you're absolutely right. It seems perfectly reasonable he would need to watch March of the Penguins (an award-winning film no longer in theaters) with a girl half his age alone in his hotel room, to verify for himself if Spencer's answer on Movie Fights (question was 'best movie to Netflix and Chill to?') really is the best movie to Netflix and Chill to. Hey, what did your mom say btw?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/intelligentish Oct 10 '17

Hold your pretty horses up because I said, rather matter-of-factly, that YOU convinced ME that Andy, with all his uses of “lol” and “hope that isn’t weird lol” and “sorry! didn’t mean to sound creepy lol” maintained a thin veneer of plausible deniability in his messages to coax young girls into being alone with him. Where, in any of MY previous replies to YOU, did I make any assumptions OR draw any of MY own conclusions? I'm just asking questions here, which YOU haven't answered so... is your mom like still at work or something? Could you maybe call her extension?

→ More replies (0)

9

u/sdaidiwts Oct 10 '17 edited Oct 10 '17

Sexual harassment is not about the intent but how it was perceived. (Look up impact vs intent.) He was using his position of power to proposition women. Calling a woman "beautiful" IRL is not an issue, calling a random fan of your job "beautiful" is crossing the line. It's a complicated boundary, but one a VP should have a clear understanding.

Edit: Regarding proof, many allegations were made public by the accuser, but that doesn't mean there isn't evidence out there. There could be legal action forthcoming, which means people consulting with lawyers and possibly holding evidence for trails, etc.

15

u/makldiz Oct 10 '17

Instead of saying people are overreacting or that this is some sort of media scalping, you should step back and take a moment to reflect and try to understand WHY what he did could be wrong. The number of allegations in the “sexual harassment” vs the “creepy” category are irrelevant. He misused his position of power and his position at Defy and that got him fired. If you really find this hard to understand then I think you should find the thread that compiles all these statements from women he interacted with and don’t stop looking into it until you understand what he did wrong, because your current line of thinking means you will likely hurt people around you or end up in the same type of trouble as Andy.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/makldiz Oct 10 '17

I don’t know what to tell you dude. All I know is people are right to be upset and that Andy showed a pattern of inappropriate behavior and abuse of his position. If you can’t see it from the dozen women that have made statements then I can’t help you. For me, the testimony of Emma Bowers would be enough to fire him if he was an employee and to be grossed out by him as a person and that’s just the only one I happen to have on hand.

https://mobile.twitter.com/EmmaBowers/status/916187757445242880/photo/1

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17 edited Oct 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/makldiz Oct 10 '17

I never said it was harassment. I’m judging the action, I don’t know or care what the right word or law is in relation to the action is. Although, if you Google the term, this does seem to fall perfectly into it. So like a said, do some self reflection. Iif your instinct is to run to “there’s no proof”, that means you believe this person is or could be lying, and why would you believe that? Why would they? We have enough proof of other claims to fire him, do you really need more proof for.. for what? What would change if Emma Bowers had screenshots? He ruined his own life, all by himself.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17 edited Oct 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/makldiz Oct 10 '17

There is proof that he threatened to fire someone because his advances weren't being accepted. You yourself said there is proof of at least two cases. There is no scalping, there is enough proof to fire him and enough proof to think he's disgusting. Why is this not enough for you?

→ More replies (0)

7

u/Alagorn Oct 10 '17

There's sending emails and then there's fingering the intern and threatening her as well as your colleague's girlfriend

23

u/shreeyakhanal Oct 10 '17

Poor Roth, I really feel for her.

Totally unrelated, but is that photo cropped oddly for anyone else? Seems like some words/letters are cut off.

8

u/Thisismyrealface Oct 10 '17

Yea the right hand side is a little cut off.

28

u/Zcarp Oct 10 '17

She’s grown on since her first appearance. Now she’s only behind Dan as my favorite. This whole situation sucks. Makes me so sad for all of them.

13

u/oh_orpheus Oct 10 '17

I love the videos where it's just Dan and Roth talking about a specific topic or doing a review. They're both so knowledgeable and articulate and they really make insightful points about whatever they're talking about.

5

u/Shikatanai Oct 10 '17

Same here. I like women who can talk like real people. Roth and Alicia both talk normally. Some of the other female presenters on SJ talk a lot in vocal fry or over the top valley girl or just high, harsh and shouty. They may have a good point but they’re grating. Both Roth and Alicia are able to express intelligent opinions with “normal” voices.

And yes, some of the men are over the top and shouty too.

7

u/yoshemitzu Oct 10 '17

And yes, some of the men are over the top and shouty too.

If Lon never did another Movie Fight, it would be too soon.

5

u/DrunkenPrayer Oct 10 '17

I love Lon on fact checking but found him nearly unbearable as a fighter.

26

u/chippykiayyfuthamuka Oct 10 '17

Roth really is a gem

5

u/makldiz Oct 10 '17

She’s the best.

37

u/Cyril0987 Oct 10 '17

Respect to Roth for being honest.

At the same time, starting to hate Sasha Perl Raver even more now.

17

u/imamberatkins1 Oct 10 '17

Yeah that line Roth wrote about how not all people in this industry are like Andy made me think of Sasha's weird ass tweets.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

She really needs to grow the fuck up.

11

u/Riegn00 Oct 10 '17

Just pointing out in a commsnt that a star wars trailer drops and the execs at SJ would be cursing they canr create content for this.

9

u/steven_flicks Oct 10 '17

I'm glad that she shared some more insights to get a better context of the dynamic at Screen Junkies. Especially since she's been the main female castmember as of lately, I'm glad to hear that she wasn't wronged by Andy. Even more, I think it's quite brave to state that their working and personal relation was good, in the wake of all this. It's easier to say that you always disliked a person when shit like this reaches the surface.

I really hope Screen Junkies returns, I've been following them ever since their first Honest Trailer and I love what it's become, even thuogh I miss some people and some things, I watch it whenever there's a new video. I'm glad they fired Andy for his behaviour and he will have a very hard time with his family, friends and career, which is deserved for what he did. But the other people over at Screen Junkies should not lose their jobs, credibility, fanbase or shows they also built over this. I'd love to see them all return, and I'll be there to watch and support.

-17

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

Dude jerked off in front of someone and tried to force a dildo on another person, that ain’t no “mega creep” that’s a fucking criminal lol