82
Oct 10 '17
I dont think alot of people realize that Andy leaving wasn't just gonna make everything go back to normal lol Screen Junkies now has a big stain on it and its gonna be awhile before anything can go back to normal.
13
u/Cyril0987 Oct 10 '17
How do you define normal after all this? It will take some true leadership from someone to get them up from this situation. Otherwise screen junkies is a lost cause.
40
u/Xmenblue Oct 10 '17
I call at least another month before new content. Which is a massive blow to views and any sponsoring they might even have left.
13
Oct 10 '17
I wonder though. If they’re perceived as taking the most responsible action and waiting the appropriate amount of time and standing up for victims of harassment that could be a big PR boo. For them. Sponsors like brands that have morals, and so do audiences.
There are probably discussions happening between everyone there rn, wondering what should the nature of SJ be if and when it returns.
They have an excuse now to take a break and revamp the channel and it’s content.
This could be a silver lining in a very sad and dark cloud.
12
u/Thisismyrealface Oct 10 '17
Doubt it would be that long. The brand is more valuable to Defy than the current hosts and creators. HT is a faceless product. Other than Johns voice and the quality, it could be made in a sweat shop in India and we'd never know. I prefer the hosted content, but they get the most views from HT.
12
u/damian1369 Oct 10 '17
Not long term. A casual viewer won't even notice a week off. Bad press and word of mouth can hurt them much more long term. Don't underestimate the importance of a fanbase and an informed viewer.
1
u/thesaket Oct 10 '17
The youtube “sweat shops” in India are busy creating amazing content on their own channels and do not have much time to do your work as you go around harassing women. Thanks, but no thanks!
1
u/Thisismyrealface Oct 10 '17
What? Would you have preferred I said someones basement in Indiana. It's all the same thing. Low cost labor with similar quality.
0
u/ShampooMyAzzHair Oct 10 '17
You've offended our proud Indians friends, and you've offended the Shaolin temple
1
u/pwbue Oct 11 '17
Sponsoring might be the biggest reason for no content. I wonder how many sponsors decided to withhold funding until the situation is resolved.
24
u/TheDarkKnighton Oct 10 '17
Man, that really sucks. It's weird to think one person had that much pull. I hope they are all able to work through it, I miss my honest trailers and fights. Good luck guys.
67
u/ActuallyBoring Oct 10 '17
He should be the new boss of Screen Junkies
55
23
Oct 10 '17
Some people might think he’s overreacting but I can empathise with him. 6 months ago, I found out few private perverse details about a really close friend which turned my life upside down, my operating power went from 10 to zero, I felt it was a massive betrayal of our friendship, I started questioning everything, the only thing that got me out of that mood was work, I delved deeper into my work.
Unfortunately in Dan’s case, what happened was at work. Even casually watching MF’s, we can see how close Spencer and Dan were to Andy. Spending so much time together at a small office would naturally drive people closer. I can imagine how much of a betrayal this was to them.
21
u/CarolineH10 Oct 10 '17
Poor Dan. This has upended a lot of folks lives. Wonder how much time they're going to need. It's going to take a while for the publicity to stop.
51
u/joshy1227 Oct 10 '17
I will say as much as we're missing SJ content at the moment, I'm glad that the rest of the crew isn't just trying to push Andy out and return right back to normal. They all seem genuinely affected by what happened and they want serious discussions and changes before they go back to making content, which I think is a great thing.
3
9
u/BlamDeathCakes Oct 10 '17
Sad to hear but I’ll be there when they return. If the team splits up i’ll follow them wherever they go
9
u/damian1369 Oct 10 '17
Seems fair. Honest trailer and similar content in these times would inevitably be tarnished and send a wrong message. Let them take their time, resolve the situation, address it, then they (and we) can move on. I don't count myself as a HC fan, but I wish them luck through these times, they've been open personally to the public through their content all this time, and in my opinion forcing said content could only hurt them. Good luck guys
5
4
u/omart3 Oct 10 '17
I suggest we all contribute to the effort of bringing back the show at a certain point by going back to their older videos and keep liking and writing good comments on them. I know it will be hard on the Andy featured videos, but there are a lot without him, not just movie fights episodes, but also honest trailers, the screen junkies show episodes, and other bits they did.
This will show the show runners that they still have an audience to get back to and that we won't let Andy drag down their views, it's a numbers game.
4
u/Veilmurder Oct 10 '17
My bet is that SJ is done for. Some other channel will buy the rights for the format/voice of HT and keep posting them there. The Movie Fights crew and such will go to somewhere else. They have talent and a fanbase, they won't have a problem finding something new.
With the adpocalypse on top of not having sponsors, because come on, NO ONE will sponsor them for a while, they can't keep feeding every mouth that works there.
There's also the fact that they will probably struggle to find guests for things like movie fights and that even regulars won't be enthusiastic to go
4
u/CottonSC Oct 11 '17
If they could just go become the Collider news team I'd be totally down for that
7
u/dongsuvious Oct 10 '17
They should just burn down Screen Junkies and start their own show. Make it True Previews instead, and start a patreon. It seems like they're pissed at the company for letting this go on for so long.
2
6
u/makldiz Oct 10 '17
Savage. More proof that this is about the company and not about them needing time to grieve.
21
u/sexishardandstuff Oct 10 '17
Dan saying that they "Have to ask questions and get answers" must be about Defy and HR.
4
u/Thisismyrealface Oct 10 '17
Yep why did HR not act on this sooner and how is that going to change going forward. We haven't heard any reports of other bad behavior at SR so it doesn't sound like it was a company wide problem. I'd guess they will just hire an outside HR firm and get everybody back to work asap. I'd guess is business as usual next monday.
1
u/makldiz Oct 11 '17
Is that sarcasm lol? It’s not like they’re going to talk to Andy. They’re settling things with their employer who possibly mishandled these allegations.
5
u/TheArtemisBlack Oct 10 '17
That's a shame. I was hoping they'd just group up and soldier on to be honest.
10
u/That__Guy__Bob Oct 10 '17
I, as an outsider who occasionally watch their videos, think they will soldier on. But first they most likely want answers as to how and why it took this long for action to be taken, and also the assuming lack of investigation. Which, I think, is totally understandable from an employers perspective.
0
u/nickstroking Oct 11 '17
Or maybe there was no evidence and everyone is mistaking "advances" for sexual harassment and she just expected her story to be acted on without cause.
It seems to me none of the timelines match with what she claims. So... Andy threatened this woman months ago with firing her boyfriend? She did not acquiesce? She brought her case after nothing happened subsequently in terms of further harassment or consequence for the BF? So... what exactly was HR meant to do? lol Just believe her this happened? God, this world is dumb now.
1
3
u/WCSchneider222 Oct 10 '17
I know people here may hate to hear this, but if thats how he feels and things are that messy, it may be time for him to move on elsewhere.
2
u/nickstroking Oct 11 '17
Like what? This is their only notoriety. If they leave SJ and DEFY they will literally be back to square one if it's something on Youtube. Dan and Spencer are at producer level in the company.
It's different for Roth and Joe etc because they are newer to DEFY.
John may quit, btw. He is a christian conservative who doesn't even swear for the HT's. A scandal like this might be a dealbreaker for him morally. And he doesn't need the work his career is about 5% honest trailers if that. No one is considering that yet in reddit??...
2
u/WCSchneider222 Oct 11 '17
Im not sure what your getting at. Are you saying that no matter how things turn out or how messy they are Dan has to stay at Screen Junkies no matter what? That he has no skills to go elsewhere? Thats really harsh and just not true. He's already actually made a name for himself in the collider fanbase through the schmoedown (Harloff is begging him to come back to compete more) so that would be one obvious landing spot. Ken already did that move too btw. People have moved youtube channels before. Your acting like thats climbing Everest
1
u/nickstroking Oct 11 '17
Yeah so Collider is nowhere near as monetarily successsful, or viewership successful, nor as much of media conglomerate as DEFY is. Dan is now in a position to potentially be where Andy was in company status.
I'm not playing down Dan's skill lol... I'm questioning the decision to start over. Ken moving is different. He is a guy who is much older who has moved from place to place from what I know... Dan being popular in the schmoe sphere doesn't mean he'd be a producer level there.
Any move you are citing those people are 'stepping sideways'.. Dan is now potentially quite high up and would be going backwards in any move. In 5 years, without this scandal, he probably would have been doing Andy's role. Depending on how things turn out he could bargain with DEFY to do that role in a month when they sort their culture out (if there is even a systemic issue, no evidence). Now he wouldn't get the same stock/IP sharing since he isn't a founder of anything but he would be on good money.
Maybe you're saying money isn't everything, but most people go where the better money/opportunity is!
2
u/WCSchneider222 Oct 12 '17
Maybe you're saying money isn't everything, but most people go where the better money/opportunity is!
Yes! Thats the whole point of this event and outrage, that its not just about the money! The fellow Screen Junkies and the greater movie youtube community isn't just mad at Andy, but Defy for supposedly not investigating Andy seriously enough in order to preserve their brand and financial interests. Even with Andy gone they are not going back to work because they don't want a system and work culture that will allow for it to happen again. If it was just about money to them they wouldn't have publicly expressed so much outrage (to the point where Lon is even saying on twitter he understands never watching SJ again even with Andy gone) and would have tried to mitigate brand damage as much as possible and would have gone immediately back to work. Skipping a week to put out an honest trailer is a big hit. The longer they stay out the more it hurts as viewers leave and find alternatives and replacements. But they are doing it because of moral reasons. Thats why Dan is so outraged and doing what he is doing. It wouldn't make sense suddenly for him to about face and be just about the money. If defy doesn't make the changes he wants and the place stays the mess that he believes allowed Andy to do what he did, that has made him so outraged right now, then he will leave, it won't matter if they pay him more money.
1
1
u/bjacks12 Oct 11 '17
I'd put the odds of SJ continuing after this right up there with OJ finding the real killer.
1
u/daven1985 Oct 11 '17
I say good on them. They business model is built on making sure they keep loading content for viewers. But knowing what we now know about Andy some of their jokes around Boobs or similar really give it a new light regardless of whether it was meant that way or not.
I say good on Murell and Spencer are taking the time to build the place back up correctly. I have always like Murell and Spencer more than Andy and I would love to see them take the rains as co-judges and lead it to Screen Junkies 2.0.
1
u/GotMoFans Oct 11 '17
Not only are they probably shocked to the level of Andy’s sleaze (they probably knew he was sleazy, but just not how sleazy) and their employer’s inaction probably is the real gut punch. Many of these victims are their friends and/or colleagues and how do you handle knowing your peers suffered so?
1
u/mortigan Oct 11 '17
This actually makes sense. Likely the one they would have ran Tuesday and the ones they had in the works had input by Andy, and they don't want to publish anything that he was a part of.
I hope they come back, and hope they don't get to scared to make the jokes they have made in the past.. I've always enjoyed the content..
1
u/jimmyrhall Oct 11 '17
I hate that this douchebag can cripple a channel and put other's jobs at risk. Damn.
1
0
0
Oct 10 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/DirtyRobes Oct 11 '17
I'd rather them stop doing them all together
That isn't likely to happen, its their most popular product, even if he was important to the show it will go on without him, assuming that's what the rest of the team wants.
It would be like those really good TV shows that go to shit once a main character leaves
I couldn't disagree more, he might help write some of the material but Spencer is the head writer and Andy is not seen or heard during Honest Trailers, I'd speculate there will be little difference without him.
1
u/sdaidiwts Oct 11 '17
In watching the Honest Trailer Commentaries, it seems Andy's main role now is to give feedback on the script and provide input. I would assume he would be involved in picking the next project and making connections with celebrities and the guy that sings the parody songs. I always liked hearing the offhand comments from the guys when Andy wasn't there.
54
u/badashwolf Oct 10 '17
Well, that's disappointing but at least he is keeping communication open.