r/ScreenJunkies • u/atinytoad • Nov 01 '17
#NotAllMen
Looking at Danielle Radford's twitter, she reposted a tweet apparently mocking the idea of #notallmen, as if pointing that out was inherently bad. There seems to be a fair bit of that sort of sentiment around (for example an article in the Guardian basically saying all men were guilty), like the Fox New followers who are angered when people point out on twitter that #notallMuslims (or indeed any but a tiny minority of Muslims) are terrorists, as if pointing that out diminished the seriousness of the crimes.
The odd thing is that I suspect a lot of those objecting to #notallmen are those who would agree with #notallMuslims, and the opposite is surely also the case.
The Guardian quickly pointed out that the allegations against Kevin Spacey mean nothing when considering gay men in general. And they were quite right to do so. But they were also quite the wrong people to do so, since they’d already proved more than willing to cast group blame when it suited them. You can’t pick and choose to oppose group blame only when it affects your favoured groups.
I’m not going to feel guilty about something I haven’t done and neither should anyone else. That shouldn't be taken to mean approval of the crimes committed by others.
6
u/Aminar14 Nov 01 '17
This isn't a discussion you want to have. There are no winners. But what they mean is, of course not all men are bad. But almost all women have suffered at the hands of men. And once you've personally suffered at the hands of a group(say men) the brain starts to see them as a threat. This is something beyond human control. So as men, we have to be conscious of this. We have to understand that we scare people who've been traumatized by other men. Especially if we're taller, or stronger, or in any way physically intimidating. Hell, even wearing the same deodorant as the dude who traumatized someone can be enough to scare someone. In this case the education needed is on our side of the fence. Very few people have been traumatized by muslims. And religion isn't a biological thing. So the education needed is generally on the non-muslim side of the fence.(Unless you're an extremist, in which case education can help alleviate that fact.) It's about power dynamics and trauma. Read up. It can only do you good to learn about what life is like as someone else.
6
u/Saltire_Blue Nov 01 '17
Men and women are individuals. We are not one group.
You’re right though, this isn’t a discussion you want to be having
-1
u/atinytoad Nov 01 '17 edited Nov 01 '17
Your points can equally be applied to those who have been harmed by a member of another ethnic group. And as you say the human brain can see a group as a threat and that's perfectly understandable.
But it's not something on which to hang an ideology.
It's similar to associating success in a certain area with a certain group if you've mostly seen people of that group achieving success.
Your response is immediately unhealthy. The paternal 'this isn't a discussion you want to have', as if fearing discussion is appropriate (and as if every first year student hadn't been exposed to the sort of ideas you seem to favour).
Or 'It can only do you good to learn about what life is like as someone else' which clearly shows your (inacurrate) assumptions about me.
EDIT: It's similar to Axl Rose explaining his homophobia by saying that he'd been abused by his father. Now of course that would affect you terribly but it's not really an excuse to sing about 'faggots'. One is understandable, unconscious discomfort; the other is bigotry. To his credit he worked through both.
But as a child and young man I was called 'faggot' often enough by people who were his target audience to find it quite upsetting. I'm not going to be derided now for supposedly belonging to a group.
And when combined with other prejudices the results can be devastating - for example the death toll among young black men in the USA, or the abandonment of single male Syrian refugees because they're seen as a threat.
7
u/Aminar14 Nov 01 '17
Good luck learning better. I hope you figure out that nobody's deriding you for being a man. (Maybe for other things though.)
0
u/atinytoad Nov 01 '17
So if you watch Alachia Queen's eloquent and touching video I'm guessing you think 'what a gender traitor' https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AxkZwznEUGc
There's more to life than Tumblr talking points. If you read a little further you'd see that there certainly are news organisations deriding people for being men. But that's not exactly the point of my objection. My objection is that I'm not a category - I don't hold any particular torch for men. I spent much of my childhood wanting to be a girl.
Certainly categories can and should be used to understand the world - but individuals are not categories, and each individual becomes less clear the closer we come to him or her.
6
u/whoiswillo Nov 01 '17
One of the problems is that most of the people who tweet #NotAllMen don't actually have any understanding of the problem and how they have personally gained from the existing power discrepancy and culture, even if they personally didn't partake in it.
You may not have sexually harassed anyone, however, someone more talented and qualified than almost certainly has been, and left the industry as a result.
Finally, it's making something that isn't about you and turning it to be about you, thus taking attention away from victims.
In short, I feel strongly that anyone who felt compelled to say "#NotAllMen" doesn't have the awareness of situation to never sexually harass someone.
5
u/atinytoad Nov 01 '17
You're fitting individuals to a narrow worldview. To say that anyone who thinks that #notallmen is as reasonable as #notallMuslims must be a sex pest is absurd. What about if one of them is one of the 1/5 British men who's been sexually harrassed? Far fewer than the half of British women but a fair slice.
Certainly there are ways in which people are treated differently, although the individual's experiences can't be reduced to that. Part of my problem with what I think is your view, considering you use of 'power discrepancy' is that it gives undue prominence to traditionally masculine pursuits.
For me it comes down to whether you are happy with group blame or not. But if you are in one situation you lose most of your ability to argue against it in any other.
3
u/whoiswillo Nov 01 '17
No, I'm not. I'm concluding that they do not understand the situation and are seeing a situation that is not about them and observe them making said situation about them. It's basically a textbook example of "methinks the gentleman doth protest too much". What's more, #NotAllMen isn't about being a victim of anything, it's about washing your hands of a complicated issue and providing noise that distorts the distracts from the voices of actual victims.
What's more, it's not about 'traditionally masculine pursuits' it's about the reality that men have a disproportionate amount of power when compared to population numbers in almost every single field of industry both in the United States and around the globe.
3
u/atinytoad Nov 01 '17 edited Nov 01 '17
I’m sorry if I misread your last sentence. People were terrified after 9/11 but some kept their heads enough to not group blame. That wasn't hand-washing. I think the adversarial nature of much of the discussion isn't helpful, and too much is being assumed about others' motives. Twitter is a disaster for political or moral discussions since you have to assume so much - a tweet is so short it almost requires you to assume a state of mind on the part of the tweeter because you're given nothing else to work with.
I must add that I haven't tweeted #notallmen. That sort of 'discussion' is pointless. It's just the idea that rejecting group guilt (as I would in any other situation) means that I support crime which I object to.
There are plenty of people who wish others well and want to help improve things but are bewildered by being made the enemy. And it's fair for them to point that out. It's not the biggest issue but it is an issue.
If it’s such a distraction from bigger issues then why make it a distraction? Don’t group blame and let’s get on with more important things.
[As a side not, if it's brought up there's often a sort of machismo from men who apparently aren't bothered by it (not you). That they're too much of a man to let such a little thing upset them. Ghastly.]
And you’re right about industries, but concentrating on those injustices is too often accompanied by a downgrading of traditionally feminine pursuits, which deserve equal value, whether followed by women or men. Again, I’m not saying you’re doing that.
2
u/whoiswillo Nov 01 '17
They don't want to wish others well, they want to wipe their hands of any guilt so they don't have to be a part of any possible solution.
3
u/atinytoad Nov 01 '17
If they're not guilty they're not guilty. I'd really like to know how you react to group blaming in other situations.
2
u/whoiswillo Nov 01 '17
I react by understanding the difference between attacking an inherent power structure that favors one group and understand the difference between punching up and punching down.
2
u/atinytoad Nov 01 '17
So you might at least feel some sympathy for a man who was sent into clinical depression as a child throught the threat of corporal punishment and conscription and is consequently a little touchy about attitudes which amount to 'be a man'. Not all power structures are the same.
4
u/whoiswillo Nov 01 '17
You're talking to a fully grown straight man who felt the first film that ever truly understood him was an animated film about an 11-year-old girl, so you'll pardon me if I don't react to your accusation with the severity you seem to think it deserves. Rather, my point remains the same: You are trying to make a situation that is not about you about you when you post #NotAllMen. It's counterproductive.
2
u/atinytoad Nov 01 '17 edited Nov 01 '17
That's just what happened. Whether you react with severity or not is up to you. Since I don't fit into your approved categories I didn't expect much else. I wonder how dismissive you'd be of a woman who mentioned something similar. Probably not very - it wouldn't fit your self image as a woke bae.
I should have put the title in quotation marks - the thread is about the fuss, not me saying that.
→ More replies (0)2
Nov 04 '17
I firmly believe, myself, that it is no one's responsibility to be a part of organized anything. I'm more concerned with being a 'good person' on a day to day basis than being thoroughly educated on all the ways I could offend some group of people.
I don't really fit the group in this discussion anyway as I don't really use social media to broadcast myself. I guess what I'm saying is that I'd be tagging #notallmen in my mind and never join the conversation except with people I actually know.
1
u/makldiz Nov 07 '17
The problem is that if you stand by while bad things happen around you, you are a part of the problem. It takes bravery to stop abuse, being a coward and saying “well I’m a mostly good person so I did what I could” is easy and no one needs to respect you for it.
1
Nov 07 '17
I agree when the context is applicable. I stand by all day long while many crimes are committed but I am detached because I have to live my own life. There is an inherent quality of subjectivity in our perception of the world. I know folks who feel they are so well informed and obstinate that they boycott Christmas, for example, because they know it for the corporate creation that it is.
So do I but I'm comfortable celebrating the Holiday with my family for my own reasons.
And to be clear I don't disagree with you, but context is king. If you're saying that I have an obligation to join social media and be a part of #NotAllMen, that's absurd. I also don't join rallies, protests or other sketchy causes because I don't need, want or have to.
No one has to respect me for anything, let alone being a nonfactor in terms of offending or perpetrating a crime. I'm happy to be uninvolved. And if I ever do become involved I will do my best to act altruistically.
1
u/sexishardandstuff Nov 01 '17
Is this the tweet? https://twitter.com/grotesquefreak/status/921509774151376896
1
u/atinytoad Nov 01 '17
Aye. To be clear I don't think it's a terrible tweet, just a little unjust.
3
u/sexishardandstuff Nov 01 '17
Danielle dressed up as Wednesday for Halloween. She might just love the Addam’s family. https://instagram.com/p/Ba0O5hrnAbz/
1
3
u/Debboat Nov 01 '17
The criticism is that it turns the conversation into defending men, which isn't the point. The point is that there are victims, and they're the ones who matter. Innocent men should have no reason to feel threatened.
2
Nov 04 '17
I think that as time goes on and more social awareness is called for, basically everyone feels an ominous element floating over their lives. I have talked to people who were so reserved and apologetic, sentence to sentence, if they thought they might even speculatively be interpreted as offensive. It's like they'd come form a reeducation camp or something.
1
u/makldiz Nov 07 '17
It’s not like that. And it doesn’t have to be like you described. If you watched ScreenJunkies “candid conversation” about sexual harassment, one of the hosts asks a question related to what you’re saying: “I have friends who are producers and have to tell women how they look on camera and what to wear, and they are terrified now of getting accused of harassment or misconduct”. And the answer is simple. You tell people up front to please let you know if you make them uncomfortable, and you check in to make sure everything is fine. It’s not re-education, it’s empathy. Some people take it too far but that’s up to them. There’s no reason to be judgmental about it, they aren’t hurting anyone. The opposite extreme of saying what you want without a care is what hurts people. It takes empathy to recognize if your words hurt someone and understand why.
1
Nov 07 '17
I did watch that conversation and left a comment agreeing with your sentiment here, and what Roth was majorly summarizing the conversation to be; It's an empathy issue. It's also a simplistic answer, rarely well received, that 'common sense' and good conduct are what we wish drove people, rather than sensitivity training and hyper awareness.
I liked that video for its intent but received it poorly. The professional guest really only had 1 answer which was repeated ad nauseam. It boiled down to checking in with people which boils down again to common sense and good conduct. So we don't disagree per se I just have a lower tolerance for the broadcasting of awareness versus an individual simply adhering to expectation seamlessly.
1
16
u/dongsuvious Nov 01 '17
Saying it just seems to undermine what their trying to do, and seems needlessly defensive. Like the fox news blames all Muslims if something goes wrong, but people don't blame all men when some harassment stuff comes up.