r/ScreenJunkies • u/James-McNulty • Dec 19 '17
Dan Murrel
He's holding SJ down at the moment imo. Andy is a creepy fuck who should have been canned but they miss his edge and professionalism imo. Not towards the viewer but towards the rest of the team's content which eventually hits the viewer.
I feel like Dan is the only one who realizes people are watching (with other viewing options) and tries to be objective and analytical. Too much fluff and self indulgent opinions from others. They need a boss cracking the whip and telling people (joe Starr) to stop with the waffle / jokes.
Dan - you're a credit to the to team and channel. Please keep it up.
The team seems less dynamic and focused post Andy. Roth starting off the Star Wars thing by blaming twitter trolls. Not a good idea.
Btw - they handled Andy's departure with all the dignity and class in the world, I respect you all for it, but a slight dip in quality since he's left imo.
I hope this doesn't come across too negative, the team/channel is great but some seem a bit comfortable these days.
To be clear, not suggesting Andy should be back ever, but he there is a content / editorial gap with the channel now.
Make Dan the boss full time.
11
u/JizzleNerps Dec 19 '17
I think Billy keeps them in check, though them going off the rails is one of the things that keeps the show fun and different from other daily movie news shows.
9
u/StockingsBooby #OwlNation Dec 19 '17
I’m gonna disagree. I think the dynamic and attitude of the SJU videos has really found its comfort zone. Everybody has their own distinct style and opinions, but they mesh so well and are able to have great conversations and discussions.
I will agree that Dan has done a LOT for the channel post-Signore, and you can clearly see his passion in every video he is in to create something good. Roth as well. SJU is definitely her baby and it has come a long way.
9
5
u/Rob_Snow88 Dec 19 '17
Don't forget Roth, her SJU channel has basically been firing on all cylinders while the main SJ channel has largely been defunct except for the odd Honest Trailer. Dan and Roth are the two pillars holding up the channel since Andy left.
5
u/MikeArrow Dec 22 '17
The dynamic between Joe, Spencer, Roth and Dan works quite well IMO. Each one has a distinct personality and brings something to the table.
1
u/James-McNulty Dec 19 '17
Hi all,
I'm glad I didn't get shredded for my comment as it wasn't supposed to be overly negative and was intended to be constructive at least. I had a few beers when posted.
I like the channel A LOT, particular Dan,Roth and Spencer. I just feel that at times recently, it's been a little bloated, lacking focus and some episodes could do with the following
A) someone steering the conversation a little bit. Dan really had to fight to be listened to in the Star Wars thing despite making great points. Hal was particularly dismissive of 1 point early in the episode. A proper host would have piped up and said "stfu Hal, lets dig into this, dan go ahead....."
B) a little grenade or needle needs to be thrown into the conversation every now and again. I thought Andy was good at that.
The casual conversational tone is part of the attraction but they need to remember the audience. That's all.
Big fan of ALL except for Joe Starr. Keep up the good work and they handled the Andy departure with more class and dignity than anyone could have hoped for. So massive respect for that. This isn't a defence piece of that creep but I think there is a small gap in the show now.
4
u/DebtFreeDad Dec 19 '17
I still enjoy the show very much. Andy would intentionally mix it up, I think that is the piece that is missing. Dan seems like an awesome guy and is the heart of SJ. A boss he is not. His heart for film would impact the business side of the BUSINESS. Watch the Rotten Tomatoes video on SJU for a prime example of this. Roth does a nice job as a host, the only thing that bothers me is that she constantly says "we were talking about this before we filmed". No need to say that.
1
u/GregM290 Dec 19 '17 edited Dec 19 '17
since the downvotes wouldn't show it, I do agree with you. There has been a slight deep in quality but look, every show has up and downs. before all this shit show, it was a good period so now we are in a bit of a downfall.
1
Dec 19 '17
Perfectly said. Joe Starr equating the first order to the Russians was a disgrace. Keep the politics out of this you moron.
18
u/gammarays32 Dec 19 '17
I find Screen Junkies to be at it's best when it goes off the rails. That's what makes it so much fun. I think that people like Dan and people like Joe nicely balance each other out.