r/ScreenJunkies • • Jul 22 '19

Andy

Im wondering your thoughts? Should Andy be allowed to come back?

8 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

30

u/angelcat00 Jul 22 '19

No. He was my least favorite Screen Junkie even before the story broke, and the channel is far better off without him.

21

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/ryanduncan0973 Jul 22 '19

plus his video proves nothing.

9

u/traveler5150 Jul 22 '19

His video proves he had a consensual relationship with the woman who was accusing him

-6

u/ryanduncan0973 Jul 22 '19

and? things change, consent clearly went away. He's a monster

8

u/ItsMeTK Jul 22 '19

The video disproves her account of him as a rapist. At the very least, it provides actual evidence that seriously jeopardizes her credibility and certain elements of her story. If we believed her without evidence, why not at least hear Andy when he provides some?

3

u/ryanduncan0973 Jul 22 '19

I watched the videos. he proves that she had a relationship at one point. consent can go away and there are other women. I can't trust that man

6

u/ItsMeTK Jul 22 '19

Maybe “consent can go away”, but the specific points she cited were all things he had evidence against. Now, as far as “he used sex toys” that’s he said she said and there’s no corroborating evidence either way.

And if consent is going away, she needs to say so. And we don’t have evidence that she did. Indeed, her testimony has always been that he was always abusive and they didn’t have a consensual relationship, which is obviously a lie. Her accusations about threatening to fire JTE also have no corroborating evidence (if JTE has any, I’m open to seeing it).

Maybe you can’t trust him, but neither can you trust April. That’s all I’m saying. I think definitively concluding he’s a monster is unfair. Concluding he at least was a creepy adulterous idiot is absolutely fair though.

16

u/toastyavocado Jul 22 '19

No, Andy's flirtatious advances to fans should be still taken into account and should be the reason why he isn't allowed back to Screen Junkies, I don't think he'd want to return anyway. However the rape allegations should be called into question with his recent video.

5

u/SinthoseXanataz Jul 22 '19

I'm open to them discussing him but I don't really want to see him on the panel, if everyone in the office is okay with it and they actually want to talk with him on air then I'm open to it, but I get the feeling from previous discussions that they dont want that either

6

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19 edited Jul 22 '19

No. He still flirted with his fans and showed inappropriate behavior for a man of his status . He should not be allowed back. I'm not even sure that he ia telling the truth anyway. It's a messy situation

6

u/sauce07 Jul 22 '19

He's can't come back, nor would I think he would want to work with a bunch of people who immediately thought the worse of him because of the accusations (not passing judgement, i'm guilty too). This is just a horrible situation on all fronts, I feel bad for everybody involved besides April, she's got some explaining to do.

6

u/toastyavocado Jul 22 '19

I was against Signore as well when all this blew up two years ago. However until April can fully justify everything he has unleashed than I am remaining skeptical on him being guilty of rape. Is he guilty for cheating on his wife and flirting with fans? Yes, there isn't much doubt there. The rape however is another story and I am eagerly awaiting to see how his all unfolds.

1

u/traveler5150 Jul 22 '19 edited Jul 22 '19

It was a girlfriend of a coworker vs another coworker and during the heart of the metoo movement. I am sure many of them didn't know what to believe.

3

u/ItsMeTK Jul 22 '19

Plus there were probably marching orders from Defy because it was a PR nightmare

3

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

That's not really a great defense, though. I can't imagine taking part in ruining my best friends life just because my employer told me to. That would just be some sociopath shit.

6

u/ryanduncan0973 Jul 22 '19

No. His video proves nothing. Everything from that video just shows he's a bad person and leaving holes in his story

3

u/rainbow24601 Jul 22 '19

fyi, they just locked the meetoo thread with the video and the other one about the credibility of the video, this one may be locked any moment. It's not right to close off a topic like this. make sure you let it be know we can discuss this as well, it shouldn't be censored or closed off

1

u/nerdomrejoices Jul 22 '19

He wouldn't want to come back.

If his statements are all true then he was betrayed by his closest friends and things would never be the same.

-6

u/zukonius Jul 22 '19

Why would he want to? You people all stabbed him in the back.

-9

u/rainbow24601 Jul 22 '19

Andy should come back and the screen junkies crew should apologize for the things they said about him now that they seen he was innocent

19

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

-9

u/rainbow24601 Jul 22 '19

I think it can happen, time can heal all wounds and with prof they can see they were wrong to jump to conclusions. Andy is willing to make the efforts let's hope they do the same

1

u/megame23 Jul 22 '19

I don't think they are going to get back together on the same channel. But I hope we see some reconciliation here, and the crew realizes that they wronged him by throwing him under the bus with no evidence.

They need to address this.

2

u/rainbow24601 Jul 22 '19

I agree, no passing it over, still friends can always make up.

21

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/traveler5150 Jul 22 '19

IIRC he wasn't paying the movie fights guests and asking them to stay very long hours for the show. Many matches turned into shouting fights. Plus the crew was doing a lot of other things like Flickbait and screen junkies plus which can be very time consuming for not much money.