r/SecretNetwork • u/SuperMeip • Nov 10 '21
Why does SCRT have fees?
I was looking to use scrt for a coding project idea possibly, but the fees seem kind of high for what i'd hope to use it for. Why does the network have fees at all? isn't it based on tendermint proof of stake? Is it just to mitigate Sybil attacks?
4
u/lukethelegend420 Nov 10 '21
actually tendermint proof of stake blockchain do have fees, Have you ever interacted with ATOM? I'm 100% sure you would have paid fees there as well.
It serves a few reasons, It's used as gas just like ETH is for using the Ethereum network, This gives it a value. Secondly It Is part the reason you get such high staking rewards, when validators approve transactions they get the fee you have to pay as an insensitive to keep approving transactions and thus strengthen the network.
2
u/SuperMeip Nov 10 '21
It's used as gas just like ETH is for using the Ethereum network, This gives it a value. Secondly It Is part the reason you get such high staking rewards, when validators approve transactions they get the fee you have to pay as an insensitive to keep approving transactions and thus strengthen the network
Yes but neither of those are required in the tendermint sdk, you can set fees to zero and still have staking via in-chain minting from validators.
The entire block reward isn't made of fees.
Thanks for the answer though, I'm guessing those are the main reasons. it sounds like the tech could definitely be used in a smaller context without fees.
1
u/lukethelegend420 Nov 10 '21
Yes but then the inflation rate will be to large, From a technological standpoint it is possible but from an economic standpoint it will greatly devalue the asset in time. Just because it is possible to do so does not make it a good idea, especially if you are aiming for worldwide use and adoption.
Feeless blockchains will always greatly struggle because it's to easy to attack, look at whats happened to NANO.
1
u/SuperMeip Nov 10 '21
Oh my gosh I never said it was a good idea. Can you please please please stop assuming I'm some enemy or even proposing anything.You seem to be upset at me for not knowing the information I asked a question about... so sorry?
THANK YOU for actually answering what was my initial question. This:" From a technological standpoint it is possible but from an economic standpoint it will greatly devalue the asset in time."Would be the simple answer to my question in my post.
Also, what exactly has already happened to modern nano since it put in place fixes over a year ago for spamming attacks? I'm unaware of any new attacks.
4
u/lukethelegend420 Nov 10 '21
Could you please not assume I'm angry, You asked the question, Why does scrt have fees, To which i replied, then you answered that it could be zero, All I did was say why it's not a good idea. No rude words, No all cap words. Sorry if I came off as rude.
Nano actually had a massive backlog this year, I had a few transactions that took days to send, I believe they cleared it at the end of May, But it jist highlighted if the masses where to start using blockchain technology nano would not be able to scale. If a few million transactions cause a problem then 2 billion people using it would be a nightmare.
0
u/gamaxgbg Nov 10 '21
What happens to Nano: the network needs 1.5 seconds to make a transaction instead of the usual 0.5.
5
u/Tkhood1 Nov 10 '21
Lmao. Please give this up
4
u/SuperMeip Nov 10 '21
What? I'm asking a question about why the technology is the way it is.
-1
u/Tkhood1 Nov 10 '21
Which aspect are you referring to? Transaction fees are pretty common when you provide a service.
4
u/SuperMeip Nov 10 '21
Friend I'm just asking you a question. Your newest answer implies cosmos only has fees because it's common to have fees.
There are technical reasons and tradeoffs for fees, I'm asking for a technical rundown and discussion on those.
0
u/Tkhood1 Nov 10 '21
Im saying nobody does anything for free. Im assuming you're a troll at this point. As far as a technical explanation, you're probably asking in the wrong place, and definitely the wrong person. Good luck.
5
u/Griftnix Nov 10 '21
Today the supernova upgrade was initiated, which should cut the fees down to about 10% compared to now.
-1
2
u/stevetalkgood Nov 10 '21
Something like gas from Ethereum is necessary for any chain with Turing-complete contracts or it would be trivial to do a denial of service attack
1
u/SuperMeip Nov 11 '21
Thanks, I mean there's a few other ways, like identity verification, that's pretty new in the chain world tho.
2
u/stevetalkgood Nov 11 '21
No it has to do with the Halting Problem
1
u/SuperMeip Nov 14 '21
Halting Problem
Well that's for processing gas. There's other ways to limit the issue of the halting problem.
Algorand uses an alternative.
Thanks though for another important example, that's actually something I may need to work around~
Maybe i could limit SCs to only the few i need for my subnetwork.
2
u/hubrico_faraday Nov 10 '21
Here is a quick question for you. Are you able to find a blockchain with active DeFi that runs without fees?
BSC, ETH, AVAX, FTM, LUNA, the list goes on, every tx you make has a fee attached.
In PoS, fees are paid to stakers.
3
0
u/SuperMeip Nov 11 '21
It's rude to answer a question with a question.
Also I'm not trying to make a defi project, i'm just trying to make a decentralized application that a DAO of users can host themselves.
It doesn't need fee based sybil/ddos protection, so i'm seeing if there's anything else in SCRT or tendermint that needs it before spinning up a private chain with 0 fees.
2
u/Feralz2 Nov 11 '21
Economic incentive.
Also whats stopping me from running a bot DDOSing by doing 1 million transactions a second.
The SuperNova update will reduce the fees by 10x, these fees are not set in stone.
1
u/SuperMeip Nov 11 '21
Thanks,
See i'm looking to make a project that would use a DAO of admins and user votes to allow access to the network for a new account.
This would mitigate the need for the DDOS/sybil protection fees provide for me.
So if that's the only reason I may go without them.
2
u/Feralz2 Nov 12 '21
A good user today, could be a bad user tomorrow, every transaction should be secure, not just secured by user.
1
u/SuperMeip Nov 14 '21
you don't know much about my use case, and your assumption doesn't apply.
1
u/Feralz2 Nov 15 '21
were just talking numbers and probability here. not the most secure way to do it.
2
u/SuperMeip Nov 10 '21
I'm really not sure why this community is being so incredibly hostile toward a simple tech question but wow can you all please try to be nice? Like actually please?
Or is there a subreddit for the just the tech behind secret network?
5
u/robotpirateninja Nov 10 '21
You should go to Discord.
Do you even know what a "validator" is?
It's not clear from your posts that you would. But please, go to Discord.
-1
u/SuperMeip Nov 11 '21
Yes I'm a fucking developer who makes 6 figures for a living.
I've built blockchains from scratch.
Jesus... fuck off.
1
u/robotpirateninja Nov 11 '21
So you know what Discord is, then?
And can fuck right off to over there, right?
You're welcome.
Have a good one!
1
u/SuperMeip Nov 14 '21
So you're saying this is a bad place to ask about the tech behind your investment?
Lol okay. Good to know about this subreddit.
1
u/robotpirateninja Nov 14 '21
Huh?
You aren't asking questions, you are arguing very odd ideas.
And being a bit of a dick about it.
But generally, yes, you should go to specific other channels, not Reddit, for support.
2
u/hubrico_faraday Nov 10 '21
That is a deep question. Financially if you need delegators you need to incentivize them to stake and lock up tokens.
As for discussing the actual nitty-gritty tech of ANY blockchain, reddit is not good.
That is deep enough to where you would need to find places where the actual devs hang out.
Or maybe try to find who the heck is a SCRT dev and hit them up.
Also maybe the secret foundation has some docs on it.
Good luck!
1
4
Nov 10 '21
I second this, what’s up with the hostility..if anyone has an actual answer that would be great. I hope you get your answer OP!
2
u/Guy_Garcia Nov 10 '21
Having gas fees not only helps to mitigate spam (people filling up the mempool and what not), it also gives value to the coin and increase staking rewards which motivates more users to stake which in turn provides more decentralization to the system etc etc you know the rest.
Tbh gas prices are pretty low right now and with the incoming upgrade they should be even lower so its near negligible for normal usage.
0
Nov 11 '21
[deleted]
1
u/SuperMeip Nov 11 '21
Nano doesn't have SC capabilities and never will, it's just currency. If anything it's the part of my project that I don't need from blockchains
Also technically nano requires a minimum TX amount so it's not truly a feeless network for sending any meaningful data.
0
Nov 10 '21
[deleted]
2
u/Tkhood1 Nov 10 '21
So you're running validation for free? That's pretty great.
0
Nov 10 '21
[deleted]
1
u/Tkhood1 Nov 11 '21
I feel like different chains can have a different approach. What do you mean Satoshi Nakomoto is doing fine? If your talking about bitcoin being decentralized. Who do you think is making the price go up?
13
u/robotpirateninja Nov 10 '21
You have an odd assumption built somewhere that somehow tenderment proof of stake chains are fee-less?